Re:also
Pam Niedermayer
Then you are effectively planing with a double bevel, a knife, and the back bevel becomes steeper with every sharpening. If it works, fine; but I prefer to keep the backs flat, except for the occasional carving chisel.
Pam
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re:also
Pam Niedermayer
Then you are effectively planing with a double bevel, a knife, and the back bevel becomes steeper with every sharpening. If it works, fine; but I prefer to keep the backs flat, except for the occasional carving chisel.
Pam
Re:also
craigd
>Then you are effectively planing with a double bevel, a knife, and the back bevel becomes steeper with every sharpening.
How so? I don't touch the flat (back) so there is no back bevel; if I [can] keep the bevel flat on the stone (I freehand) then the bevel angle doesn't change. Ideally, the blade just gets shorter, no angles change.
Re:also
Pam Niedermayer
I would agree that that's ideal, but the process of aiming so carefully to avoid the boundary of sharpened and not is highly fallible. Or to avoid the boundary, which would angle the "attack," one addresses only that area that's previously been sharpened, which would create yet another step in the blade back.
Pam
Re:also
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
How so? I don't touch the flat (back) so there is no back bevel; if I [can] keep the bevel flat on the stone (I freehand) then the bevel angle doesn't change. Ideally, the blade just gets shorter, no angles change.
Hi Craig
No matter what type of blade you use - paring or mortice chisel, BU or BD plane blade - the bevel will wear on both sides. It wears on the bevel face and on its back (sometimes these terms are used interchangeably, or the other way around - can be very confusing - but you know what I mean).
The photos that Steve posted (above), that Larry praised (quite rightly in my view), were some of the best I have seen of a wear bevel on the back of a blade. In this case it was of a BU plane blade. It was also interesting, with the longstanding BU vs BD debates in mind, that the simple use of the Ruler Trick to avert the affects of this backbevel is sufficient.
The thing is that a similar backbevel occurs on a chisel as well. Most chisels are used BU, hence one should expect wear on the back of the blade as well as wear on the bevel face. Honing only the bevel face is likely to leave the wear bevel intact. Honing the back of the blade must be done thoroughly to remove all vestiges of the wear bevel. On chisels it is not advisable to use the Ruler Trick (as this affects registration when needed). The danger of honing only the last 1/2" - 1" of a blade back is that you end up with a long and shallow backbevel (losing its coplanar flatness).
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re:also
TomD
Can't argue with what works Craig. My comment here was just to the effect that I can't always tell who is making what case since we can be talking about quite different processes. I prefer to sharpen both sides because it gets me the polish I want, but to the extent you are getting the edge you need for your work, who can argue. In fact, unless one is using a micro bevel on the back, or a japanese type hollow where the surface area is reduced, it is darn hard to make that much of an impression when polishing backs with very fine grits, given the acreage.
Re:also
craigd
Yes, Steve's micro graphs are great and really help me visualize the abrasive wear that Larry has talked about. I still don't have a grasp of the actual scope and wear rates - eg how much honing do I need to do to remove that wear on the back? (I have one of the fine loupes that David recommended, just need to start using it).
I just took a look at the #3 blade I've been using, there is a very visible wear strip on the back, if it actually changes the bevel angle, I really doubt I would be able to tell when using the plane (I regularly push 45º to 60º planes without noticing much difference in effort).
I probably should have emphasized that I only do this for double irons, if I have to pop out a single iron, the back side gets a swipe or two. I'll also admit to not caring that much about nicks, etc; no tearout and I'm happy.
Regarding the ruler trick & chisels, depends on the chisel and use - my gouges have a massive back bevel (as they are bevel down (can't remember which cannel that is)) and chisels are used bevel down.
Loss of Clearance
Steve Elliott
"I just took a look at the #3 blade I've been using, there is a very visible wear strip on the back, if it actually changes the bevel angle, I really doubt I would be able to tell when using the plane (I regularly push 45º to 60º planes without noticing much difference in effort)."
When a plane blade needs honing the main issue is loss of clearance behind the blade. The rounded wear surface behind the edge is being pressed down into the freshly planed surface of the wood. Honing only the bevel solves this problem even if it doesn't quite give as sharp an edge as a thorough honing of both surfaces.
Your description of the wear on the upper surface of the blade increasing the cutting angle is exactly right unless a cap iron is set very close to the edge. With a cap iron the wear can actually cause a decrease in cutting angle due to a hollow in the upper surface of the blade where the shaving is being bent sharply. Just this week I've been reading a study published in a Japanese technical journal that has scanning electron microscope images of worn blades showing the wear caused with cap irons set at different distances from the edge. Here's a diagram based on the SEM images showing a typical case:
The scooped-out area on the face of the cap iron edge is due to wear after planing 200 meters of birch. This cap iron had a microbevel of 50 degrees and was set 100 microns (.004") from the cutting edge. The study concludes that a microbevel of 50-60 degrees set 150 microns (.006") from the edge gives the best cap iron effect.
Returning to the issue of clearance, here's a diagram based on my own wear profile images that emphasizes the loss of clearance:

So honing only the bevel will help a great deal to freshen up a working edge because it restores clearance behind the blade edge.
Re: Loss of Clearance
wilbur
The biggest takeaway for me from Steve's great illustrations is that it really emphasizes one of the best pieces of advice that I've heard about sharpening: "The more you sharpen, the less you sharpen."
At 100 LF of planing, the edge still pretty much looks like the original bevel, which means that it would be trivial to establish the freshly sharpened edge. As you get past that, the geometry of the bevel starts changing in a pretty impressive manner, which means more work to bring the edge back to where it was when it was freshly sharpened. So it would seem that this is good evidence for sharpening frequently being best practice.
Re: Loss of Clearance
craigd
Thanks Steve for the lucid explanation!