Re: Up Yours!
David Weaver
Go to straightrazorplace and look through the literature to find old manual information on sharpening - literature intended for professional barbers.
Overhoning on a razor isn't applicable to woodworking tools, and generally tends to be an issue on harder razors with aggressive abrasives.
Working up to the point of only just not raising a wire edge will leave you short of a sharp edge in terms of practicality, and the wire edge can be raised before you've gotten all of the wear and damage out of an edge, so trying to keep a tiny wire edge isn't always productive.
It's just a matter of skill and experience, it differs by the condition of the edge and the type of steel. I.e., the wire edge on white #1 may never seem that large, but A2 of the same thing may raise a large wire edge.
You'll find in old literature that even 100 years ago, they considered some stones as being immune to overhoning, like eschers and japanese stones (yes, they were using japanese natural stones in the west on razors, even 100 years ago). That's purely due to the fineness of the hone. I'm convinced (as a straight razor shaver who has some stones that are "immune to overhoning") that the barbering method pdf that I read circa about 1900 is correct in implying that the method of trying to sneak up just to a stropped edge on a razor to avoid overhoning is something that doesn't exist when the edge is fine enough. I work my razors when I get them to the point that I have a harsh edge on them with a 1000 stone, and then work backwards from there with moderately heavy pressure (for a razor, at least) all the way up to a natural stone, running all the way to the edge with every stone, and finishing with an antique japanese barber hone or aggressive use of balsa and powder chromium oxide and I've never found any of those razors to be "overhoned", which is easy to tell when you have sensitive skin.
I have, at the same time, experienced the effect of overhoning with an inferior stone (something similar to a 6-8k stone), which for me is blazing razorburn that turns to white pimplets the next day - awful stuff.
All of that said, if the stones are fine enough, there is no harm in raising a stout wire edge on a worn blade. It's a waste of time on a paring chisel that's still shaving, but if you're prepping lumber by hand, you will probably have fairly dull worn edges pretty often.