New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Jointing off the wire edge?

Posts

Jointing off the wire edge?

#1

Jointing off the wire edge?

eliot d

Has anyone heard of "jointing" the wire edge? I believe it means to sharpen to the final grit and then, purposefully, point the edge straight down, perpendicular, to the surface of your final stone -- and then very gently drag the edge for a bit. So then, the edge is a tiny bit dull. So then resharpen, and repeat, etc. My understanding is that this method is distinctly different from the kind of honing, say on leather, that bends and breaks off the wire.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#2

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eliot

This is a technique that Harrelson Stanley (whose name came up earlier) discusses and demonstrates in his video on Side Sharpening. I have used it occasionally - can't say it makes the edge better or worse.

My usual method with the wire edge is to remove it (on the final polishing stone) at the each of each successive grit by lapping the back of the blade (which some call the face - we are divided by more than a common language :) ). I do this as the wire offers feedback on progress - it may be felt with fingertips even in the 10000+ range.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#3

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Pam Niedermayer

What you want to avoid is bending back the wire and breaking connection with the rest of the blade, which often causes gaps to form in your edges. So removal needs more gentle treatment. Interestingly, something I picked up from sharpening toothed blades, is that you can remove the wire by striking the chisel normally into some wood, harder than soft.

Another thing I do when removing wire on a stone is to make sure to swipe the blade in a forward direction, away from the bevel. You can try this and see the results with a 10X loop.

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#4

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Guillaume Dery

Pam interestingly enough, I was taught something similar, dragging the edge across end grain to get rid of the wire edge. I have since stopped doing that and basically just do like Derek (polish it off by lapping the back on my final stone)

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#5

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Pam Niedermayer

Hmmm, never heard that one; but the only way to drag it would be such that the wire would be stressed toward the edge, which is exactly what you (impersonal) don't want to do. I usually lap it, too, but I start the lap so the wire is stressed away from the edge or parallel to the edge.

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#6

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Brian Greene

I just learned something. I think that "jointing" or lapping the wire away from the bevel as Pam describes would be best, as opposed to a less careful approach. I'm going to try it as I think it may explain certain inconsistencies that plaque my technique.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#7

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Guillaume Dery

No no no, I didn't explain myself properly. You drag the blade sideways towards you. parallel stress. Hope I am making sense. If not, I'll try to post up a pic as I don't seem to be explaining myself well.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#8

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

TomD

The plunging of the edge into a balk of wood is a classic, you did well to rediscover it. I think some turners do that also.

On a separate point...

Ideally one does not produce a wire edge, there is no advantage to doing so. It may be necessary for beginners, or with certain processes, and will often happen with power equipment that is fairly enthusiastic. And it certainly happens to me in the ordinary course. What it signifies is that the given grit has overshot the edge, and is griding fruitlessly on, and also that the place on the edge is done and ready to move on. Overshooting like that is not necessary if one has a way of checking the edge progress, and that method can be something like testing the edge as barbers do, something that I have described at length several time here. There can also be process methods, like fairly frequent honing, or one can use steels and stones that are less likely to produce them. Anyway, wire edges are a fact of life, I just don't go out looking for them every time I sharpen.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#9

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ideally one does not produce a wire edge, there is no advantage to doing so. It may be necessary for beginners, or with certain processes, and will often happen with power equipment that is fairly enthusiastic. And it certainly happens to me in the ordinary course. What it signifies is that the given grit has overshot the edge, and is griding fruitlessly on, and also that the place on the edge is done and ready to move on.

Hi Tom

My view is very different. I believe the wire edge is a necessary and desirable feature of sharpening. It is confirmation that you are working fully across the bevel face. The wire edge does not have to be large. Indeed, keep it as small as possible since its size has no value.

Overshooting like that is not necessary if one has a way of checking the edge progress, and that method can be something like testing the edge as barbers do, something that I have described at length several time here.

Now I do not recall this technique. Would you kindly repeat it here? Thanks.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#10

David Barnett

I, too, was taught ...

David Barnett

... that if properly sharpened and polished, the wire edge should evaporate like the morning dew, should just vanish on those last strokes on a fine stone, and while I can't say I always succeed in doing so, it's my goal. The point is, the wire edge is evidence that the successively refined arris will be rough, and no matter how fine the burr, it will tear the edge. The more properly honed and polished edge should last longer.

I have seen this difference through the microscope but cannot say that my technique nor by ability to assess it in practice has proven a gain in edge sharpness and longevity to be the case. Perhaps my mentors possessed greater sensitivity and consistence to appreciate the difference. I could not.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#11

Wire Edges and Wear Profiles *LINK*

Steve Elliott

"What [the wire edge] signifies is that the given grit has overshot the edge . . ."

Overshooting the edge by a tiny bit is helpful because part of the wear is on the back of the blade. On extremely worn edges I've found that raising a small wire edge sometimes isn't enough to get past all the wear on the blade back. Under a microscope I could see a small wear surface that hadn't been removed and the edge just didn't feel quite as sharp as I expected.

Removing wear from the blade back can be done by honing steel off the back, but on a wide blade with a back that has been carefully flattened and polished I don't believe that's an efficient approach. Stropping tends to dub the edge a little and polish right at the cutting point, acting like a tiny back bevel. The ruler trick for plane blades reduces the size of the area that needs to be worked. Removing more steel from the bevel side (which produces a thicker wire edge) works too.

Here's a picture of the wear progression on the blade of a rabbet plane blade viewed at 540x:


For an indication of the size of the wear surfaces, here's a diagram from a similar test with a micron scale:


The micron scale shows 25 microns, which is about one thousandth of an inch.

There's a longer discussion of wear profiles at the link below.


Wear Profiles

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#12

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

TomD

Derek I think we are on the same page. The wire can indicate what you say, but should not be any larger than necessary. If you could just hit the point where sharpness occurred and not have to go further, why would one? The wire is not the goal but at best a marker on the road. So I wouldn't build much of my technique around it.

I will see if I can find the source for the barber method, it takes a long time for me to explain, and then is only second hand.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#13

Re: Up Yours!

TomD

OK, found some stuff online, but it wasn't my preferred method. So...T

ake your weak hand and hold it relaxed at your chin as one does simply by bending at the elbow. Extend the middle finger in the familiar jesture and moisten the end liberally. Touch that finger to the thumb as if testing for a medium rare steak. Now hold the razor horizontal and at the lowest angle you believe could catch the nail. If the edge is properly sharpened Wichita sharp it will hook the nail, when the razor is advanced in the direction of the face across the surface of the nail. This is done with a very light touch, and there is no damage to the nail. Unlike cutting hair, a barber can do this all day and not affect his nail.

For Arkansas sharp, you extend the middle finger... with the palm to the face. You moisten liberally, and leave it extended. You bring the razor across the surface of the finger, ona tangent path, and if it catches on the flesh, it is sharp in the spot tested. Again there is no damage done to the skin and the test can be repeated at will.

So, this method is described as for razors. Woodworking tools are far heavier on occasion, and dropping one in the position described, could cause serious damage to the supporting, weak appendage. So if you use this method use it at your own risk, and place your hands in a safe position fitting any tool you are then using. It will work so long as the angle of the approach is low and tangent to the dome of the tip of the digit. I love this method for 2 step finish sharpening, or one step if you are using something really aggressive that will do it in a single step. If you are refining through several stages of finishing, this method will not work, but in my experience often wire edges don't either since they are very slow to come up in some circumstances with the finest stones.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#14

Re: Wire Edges and Wear Profiles

Larry Williams

and the information at your link is some of the best sharpening information to ever appear on the web!

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#15

Thanks, Larry


Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#16

Re: Up Yours!

David Weaver

Go to straightrazorplace and look through the literature to find old manual information on sharpening - literature intended for professional barbers.

Overhoning on a razor isn't applicable to woodworking tools, and generally tends to be an issue on harder razors with aggressive abrasives.

Working up to the point of only just not raising a wire edge will leave you short of a sharp edge in terms of practicality, and the wire edge can be raised before you've gotten all of the wear and damage out of an edge, so trying to keep a tiny wire edge isn't always productive.

It's just a matter of skill and experience, it differs by the condition of the edge and the type of steel. I.e., the wire edge on white #1 may never seem that large, but A2 of the same thing may raise a large wire edge.

You'll find in old literature that even 100 years ago, they considered some stones as being immune to overhoning, like eschers and japanese stones (yes, they were using japanese natural stones in the west on razors, even 100 years ago). That's purely due to the fineness of the hone. I'm convinced (as a straight razor shaver who has some stones that are "immune to overhoning") that the barbering method pdf that I read circa about 1900 is correct in implying that the method of trying to sneak up just to a stropped edge on a razor to avoid overhoning is something that doesn't exist when the edge is fine enough. I work my razors when I get them to the point that I have a harsh edge on them with a 1000 stone, and then work backwards from there with moderately heavy pressure (for a razor, at least) all the way up to a natural stone, running all the way to the edge with every stone, and finishing with an antique japanese barber hone or aggressive use of balsa and powder chromium oxide and I've never found any of those razors to be "overhoned", which is easy to tell when you have sensitive skin.

I have, at the same time, experienced the effect of overhoning with an inferior stone (something similar to a 6-8k stone), which for me is blazing razorburn that turns to white pimplets the next day - awful stuff.

All of that said, if the stones are fine enough, there is no harm in raising a stout wire edge on a worn blade. It's a waste of time on a paring chisel that's still shaving, but if you're prepping lumber by hand, you will probably have fairly dull worn edges pretty often.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#17

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Pam Niedermayer

Please let us know if that solves any problem, always nice to have confirmation.

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#18

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Pam Niedermayer

I can envision this, assuming ends large enough to handle whatever blade is being worked. Thanks.

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#19

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

Pam Niedermayer

Oh, yeah, I didn't invent the method, just applied it outside sharpening a toothing blade. I've never gotten much of a wire edge, but my concern lessened when the edges turned out to be very sharp.

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#20

Re:also

TomD

Also, I think it makes a difference how evenly one works both sides of the edge. One rarely hears knife guys talk this way about how they can`t get a knife truly sharp unless they get a lot of foil off the edge. That is an edge that naturally gets worked evenly both sides. That is also more or less the Japanese way, and the way I handle many other tools. When I started out in the 70s many instructions suggested one only worked the bevel, the back would be set up, then basically not touched thereafter. I don`t know how much of that hangs in there. Whenever equally competent people are discussing something and one says you have to, the other says you don`t, the people who say you don`t have to are right.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#21

Re:also

Pam Niedermayer

I'm still surprised when somebody says you only have to flatten the backs for first setup, then you can forget them. I have to wonder in what world s/he lives, whether s/he ever sharpened anything. And then there's that nonsense about only flattening/sharpening the 1" closest to the edge. Jeesh, have those people ever seen a paring chisel after two months of such a regimen?

Pam

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#22

Jointing

david charlesworth

So no one here uses Harrelson's technique?

David

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#23

Glad I read your post, David

Hank Knight

I though you and TomD were getting ready to duke it out! :D

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#24

Re: Up Yours!

TomD

I'm a member over there, and that is where I got the manual, however the first few I looked at online described a different, and rather scary sounding, procedure. So I cut my losses and just described the process I use.

Re: Jointing off the wire edge?

#25

craigd

Re:also

craigd

> I'm still surprised when somebody says you only have to flatten the backs for first setup ...

I do this often with double iron setups (Stanley) - I pop the blade out, hone the bevel (with the chip breaker still on), maybe remove the burr by slicing it on the edge of the bench (like a tomato), pop the blade back in and back to planing. Quick and works for me.