New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Cutting gauges, Roger ...

Posts

Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#1

Cutting gauges, Roger ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I had the afternoon free and only just managed to get these done as Lynndy was threatening to shoot me if I did not come in for dinner! So the photos are not the best, but I did not want to leave this much longer, with the memory of yours still strong.

These cutting gauges are modelled on a Kinshiro mortice gauge. They are a little more compact since they have single cutters.

The Curly Myrtle gauge on the right was built for practice. This has a Jarrah wear strip. The photo does not do the timber justice. The other gauge is from Tasmanian Blackwood gauge with an Ebony wear strip. Its chatoyance is amazing.


Tasmanian Blackwood is almost identical to Koa. It is by far my favourite wood.



The beam is locked via a captive brass plate ...


The cutter is a knife shaped from a 3/16" diameter HSS rod ...


Here is the Kinshiro family, with the orginal on the right...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#2

Re: Cutting gauges, Derek....

roger lance

Derek....they are beautiful!!....I really like the captive brass plate for wear and applying pressure to the beam....nice job on the round knurled brass knobs as well....I find the Kinshiro shape to be very comfortable....it gives great registration to the work....it pays to listen to the masters!! This has been a fun, good exercise....and I learned a little something: 1.) I was a little shy about posting about such a "basic/simple" tool....thought I might be low balling the group....I didn't need to feel that way....2.) I should have asked better questions other than "How many cutting gauges do you use?".....to questions like which gauge do you use/prefer?....and why?....what characteristics make a great gauge?....I know you have tried in the past to get people to discuss design and I certainly see the merits in that and will contribute what I can in future....this was a great exchange!!....Thanks!!

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#3

Re: Cutting gauges, Derek....

James Watriss

Roger, this has been an interesting thread to follow. I've always been much more interested in threads that are ultimately goal-oriented. I stayed out of this one because I've been happy with just one tite-mark, but I'm tempted to build a couple of these myself... Quick projects are always fun.

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#4

Re: Cutting gauges, Derek....

Frank D. in Montreal

Another nice possible design feature that hasn't been discussed is one that I learned from Jeff Gorman (sp?): the captive wedge. Combined with the rounded beam, it positively locks the beam in place at an angle, eliminating swaying. I also like the fact that you don't need to move your hand to tighten the gauge: just set the beam, and tap the bottom of the pin (wedge) on the bench.

My examples are much less refined than Derek's but seem to be based on a similar mortising gauge:


Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#5

Re: Cutting gauges, Frank....

roger lance

Frank....I like your gauges....very attractive....I'm guessing that the pin has a taper on it in the center of the pin....small enough to allow the beam into the fence and then when pushed up from the bottom, the taper begins to close against the beam....locking it tight....that is clever!

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#6

Re: Cutting gauges, James....

roger lance

James....if you do make a couple....its show and tell....looking forward to the pics!

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#7

Re: Cutting gauges, Frank.... *LINK*

Frank D. in Montreal

Thanks. You got it for the wedge. Here's the link to Gorman's site (this is the marking gauge section). The round wedges really hold better than flat wedges...it doesn't take a lot of pressure to lock the arm tight. Andre Milette, an amazing plane maker from Quebec, once told me that nothing holds as tight as round wedges (he uses them on all of his wooden bench planes). I use the round wedges to hold pencils on pencil gauges too (the small ones in the puc below)

http://www.amgron.clara.net/markingoutindex10.html


Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#8

PS

Frank D. in Montreal

Just went back to the thread I missed...your gauges look really nice. I especially like the wear strip on the beam, and the blade setup (mine works OK, but the screw looks a little hokey), as well as the clean look.

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#9

Re: Cutting gauges, Derek....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I was a little shy about posting about such a "basic/simple" tool....thought I might be low balling the group....

Hi Roger

A cutting marking gauge - as with any tool - can be made as simply or as extravagantly as one chooses. It remains, nonetheless, on of the two most important tools that woodworkers can own and use. The other is a marking knife. It all starts with accurate marking.

I know you have tried in the past to get people to discuss design and I certainly see the merits in that and will contribute what I can in future...

The ergonomics is dear to my heart. It is no different from designing furniture - a good build is more than just putting parts together. Tool design deserves the same respect as furniture design. This is not about bling. Once one begins to use something, it becomes apparent which is the silk purse and which is the sow's ear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#10

Adjusting mechanisms

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Frank

Very nice gauges!

I noted your comment about how tightly you can get the connect with the wedge. The question I have is 'how easy is this to loosen by hand, how easy is it to make fine incremental adjustments, and how so with one hand?'. My experience here is with wooden plough fences, which tend to stick.

The reason I chose the screw/brass plate was that this is easy to use one-handed.

This is the mechanism I made ..


It is simply a brass plate that I drilled for a screw. The hole on the plate is chamfered, and the screw head fits fairly flush. Excess is filed off. The screw is left as a stub.

The stub fits into the hole for the adjusting screw (so it is now captive), and the adjusting screw presses down on the stub for pressure.

Clear as mud?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#11

Re: Adjusting mechanisms

TomD

I made a wedged one that was basically Japanese, from a plan in FWW. It work well enough, but it was harder for me to adjust that the screw/plate wood one I owned. It was a gift for my Dad, so that was too bad, but probably OK as he is not so picky as I am. I was easy enough to lock or loose, but not so easy to get at the precise point where it is squeezed a few thou, yet does not shift out of position. This middle ground is the most important place for me since it is the source of accuracy and the ability to quickly pick up lines, or transfer measurements from calipers, etc... But just because mine didn't work perfectly... I think it might be possible to play with the wedge angle. One way Frank's looks better is the wedge should stay in place when one moved the fence for or aft. On the FWW one, the wedge is parallel to the beam.

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#12

Blade position

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi again Frank

One of the important advances in the Kinshiro is that the blade is the arm. This places the cutting edge at the very end of the tool, as does the wheel gauges (such as Tite-Mark and LV).

There is a great advantage in this since you can more easily see what you are doing. Long beams obscure information. I like that you have incorporated this into your gauges.

I had wanted to place the cutter at the end of the beam as well. Other than your method or a wheel, the only way one can do this properly is to use a bent blade, as used in the Kinshiro. I was contemplating making my own (still thinking about this). I may also try a spare wheel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#13

Re: Cutting gauges, James.... *LINK*

James Watriss

Ha! Deal. :D

In the meantime, I humbly submit to you another worthy small project... Straight edge- winding sticks.


Winding sticks

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#14

Re: Cutting gauges, James....

roger lance

I just bookmarked your site :) .

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#15

Re: Adjusting mechanisms... Bigger wedge?

James Watriss

This thread is bringing up too many good ideas... You're all driving me to distraction.

Re: adjusting, you brought up an interesting solution. By using a large pressure plate, you effectively lessened the amount of pressure applied to the beam. Pressure= Force applied / surface area. Larger quantity in the denominator means less force applied... But over a larger area. So, in theory, using a larger wedge, thus providing more surface area, might solve that lockup problem.

Re: the blade at the end...

Back when I was using a crown gauge, one of the advantages was the ability to tap either end of the beam on the bench, to adjust in either direction. I gave away a very nicely made wheel gauge, because it lacked this feature... I wasn't comfortable banging on the blade to make adjustments. Sow's ear, for my purposes.

I'm gonna have to ponder this topic a bit.

You people with your ideas and your questions... I can never resist a process refinement question, you're going to be the death of productivity in my shop...

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#16

Re: Cutting gauges, James....

James Watriss

:D :D :D

Awesome... It's good to have an audience.

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#17

Re: Adjusting mechanisms

Frank D. in Montreal

Hi Derek,

Thanks. To loosen by hand, I just tap the top of the wedge (dowel) on the side or underside of my bench. I then adjust the beam as needed, often with my thumb and a finger as I hold the fence, then once the beam is in place, I tap the bottom of the wedge on the top of my bench and it's tight. If I'm holding a rule or a reference piece, I don't have to put it down to tighten the beam, so it is truly one-handed.

Another problem the wedge solves, one that I alluded to briefly to Roger about, is that the wedge pushes the beam against the mortise at an angle, effectively applying pressure to to two sides of the beam (or rather pushing two side of the beam against the mortise wall. This makes it impossible for the beam to sway (or swing), especially as the gauge gets older and things get a little looser. I don't know what it is about the round wedge, but it takes a surprisingly light tap to positively lock up the beam.

As Tom mentioned, the wedge is perpendicular to the beam, so no issues of a final tap moving the beam around like you have with a parallel wedge.

One thing I like about your platen is that it prevents the screw from wearing the beam at ommon settings and making the surface uneven, which can lead to things moving around when you tighten the screw.

Re: Cutting gauges, Roger ...

#18

Re: Blade position

Frank D. in Montreal

That was one feature which I wanted in my gauge. I also like the fact that the blade is easier to sharpen without removing it. I forget if I found my own solution on gorman's site or not, but I drilled a hole into the end of the beam and inserted a plug, so the screw that holds the blade wouldn't screw into end grain (which would not have lasted). I don't know if you can see it in my pic, but I also chiseled out a mortise so the blade wouldn't move around with just one screw.

I'm still not 100% satisfied with my solution. Mostly because I find the screw ugly but also because even if the blade won't have to be changed any time soon, that setup won't last forever...so to speak. I guess some kind of captured nut would be more durable. I also wanted to countersink the screw a little, but I used a hand scraper to make the blades, so it was tough going to machine them. I'd look into unhardened tool steel next time, easy to harden when it's so small, and easier to work with, as you know.

With the skills I possess now, I'd certainly think about using a bent blade too, and attach it to the beam from the top instead of the end.

Interesting discussion about a seemingly simple tool