Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Any comments or experiences?
Thanks much in advance.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Any comments or experiences?
Thanks much in advance.
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Hank Knight
David,
I have a pair of Veritas hold-downs that I use all the time . My bench has square dog holes along both edges and a row of round holes nearer the center of the top. I use the hold-downs in the round holes. I positioned the holes so the hold-downs reach within an inch of the edge of my bench. On rare occasions I use the hold-downs in the square holes, but I don't like to do that. The square holes are larger than the round shaft of the hold-down so there is a lot of "slop" in the square holes. You can get the hold-downs to grab in the square holes, but they exert a LOT of force and they deform the square dog holes a little each time I tighten them down. This is especially a problem with the Veritas hold-downs because the shaft has sharp serrations, which are great for keeping the hold down from slipping in round holes, but which tend to damage the edges of the square holes. Finally, my square dog holes are very close to the edge of my bench. Because the hold-downs exert so much force, I'm a little afraid they could blow out the sides of the dog holes or dislodge my dog-hole strip. They haven't done so, but I'm concerned about it; and, as I mentioned, I don't use them in the square holes often for the reasons I've discussed.
I love the Veritas hold-downs, but not in square dog holes.
Hope this helps.
Hank
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Hank...
The reason I'm asking is that in a couple weeks (it's already built!) I'm expecting delivery of the new Lie Nielsen workbench (the one Christopher Schwarz raves about), and as you probably know, it only has square dog holes. At this point I'm reluctant to drill round holes in a brand-new bench, but given what you've said, it looks like I'll have to if I want to use the Veritas hold-down.
I very much appreciate your response.
- David
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
TomD
I can't recall where or when, maybe in one of those FWW methods of work columns.. I seem to recall someone making square blocks drilled lengthwise with a hole, and using the hold down in that arrangement. Of course one would need to have square holes large enough to accommodate both the shaft and the insert. But that is probably possible with the veritas.
Personally, I would probably pay up for a veritas hold down based on a rectangular shank, and a pivoting head. Not sure what the hold-up is. There may be more than one size of square hole out there, but they sell the metal dogs for square holes, so there must be some standard. Making the shank a slip wedge would ensure that wear was kept to a minimum. Patent applied for, along with my double ended, double beam gauge. 
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Hank Knight
David,
Lucky you! The Lie-Nielsen bench is a beauty. If I hadn't already built my bench, I'd seriously consider buying that one.
I was VERY reluctant to drill hoiles in my bench top, having spent much time and many $$ on it. But I finally decided I needed one row of round holes for the hold-fasts. It was the right decision. I use them every day. I've just about decided (after five years) I need a second row nearer the back of the bench. I'll probably work up enough nerve to drill the second row soon; and, like the first row, I imagine I will find it very useful and only a minimal nuisance.
Good luck with your bench. I know you wil enjoy it.
Hank
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Paul M.
Drill Baby Drill! ;-)
You will want round holes for a holdfast. Just drill a couple to begin with and add more later as needed. After all, it's a bench and anything that adds to utility is much more important than keeping it pristine.
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Yes, yes, I know.
I've got a nice Festool plunge router, and with a 3/4 straight bit the process should be straightforward. The benchtop is 4" thick, so the router will only start the hole, which I'll have to finish by hand with a spade bit.
Even so...it will be awfully hard to make that first plunge.
- David
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes *LINK*
Hank Knight
I drilled my holes the same way: started them with a plunge router and a 3/4" bit and finished with a hand drill (an electric one). I have never been a big fan of spade bits. I ordered a 3/4" utility brad point bit from Lee Valley for my dog holes. It worked great and left a very smooh hole. Lee Valley sells much nicer HSS brad point bits, but the utility HCS one is half the price and worked fine. I finished by chamfering the top of the holes with a large single flute countersink, also from Lee Valley. I strongly recommend chamfering the holes. It prevents splintering your bench top with the hold-fasts - especially the serrated Veritas ones. Here is a photo of the large single flute countersink.

Here is a link to the utility brad point bits:
P.S. I forgot to mention that you should clamp a board to the under side of your bench top into which the drill bit will exit to prevent blowout splintering of your bench top.
Utility Brad Point Bits
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Hank...
Thanks for the invaluable advice. I'll do exactly as you suggest.
One more question...
How far from the table edge did you drill your holes, and how far apart did you drill them?
- David
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Hank Knight
I'll have to go home and measure (I'm at my office right now). I'll post later this evening with the measurements, and photos if that'll help.
Hank
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Hank Knight
David,
The holes for my hold-downs are 10" apart on center and 10" from the front edge of my bench. My dog holes are 5" apart and there is one hold-down hole for every other dog hole. My Veritas hold-downs reach to 1 1/2" from the front edge of my bench. I find that plenty close, and I don't recall wishing they were closer to the front edge. I have wished they were further back; hence my plan to drill another row further back, but I haven't decided exactly where to put them. I should mention that my bench top is 32"wide. I imagine your Lie-Nielsen top is not quite so wide. That might change whether you opt for one row or two.
Here are some photos of my bench:


Here's a photo of the chamfer I mentioned:

Hope this helps.
Hank
P.S.
Hank Knight
My shop is not really that dark. I'm just a poor photographer.
Change your mind set...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi David
You need to stop thinking about the round holes as something that you are perpetrating on a finished bench. Instead, think of the LN bench as unfinished, and that the positioning of the round holes has been left to you to do.
I drilled the holes in my new bench top without any distress. It is, after all, just a bench and worse will occur in the future (I am, however, enjoying the newness of it all). There was a great deal of concern during the build in getting the square dogs exactly right (and then I glued them in backwards and had to rip them out!!!). But those were for the tail vise, and placement of the round holes are a personal matter. LN cannot get that right for you. Now it is your turn.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi David
It is important that you decide on where the holes best meet your needs. Hank can show you his, and below is where I placed mine. In my article I explained why I did what I did. Still, your needs may differ.
Article: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/IDeclareThisBenchFinished.html
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
JDK
Thank you all for your advice and counsel.
Like many woodworkers, I've spend a number of years developing my skills on power tools. In the last few years or so I've been acquiring various hand tools for this-or-that project, and as a result have come to realize how wonderfully hand tools elevate the craft to a much higher realm indeed. With much practice, (and trial-and-error), I've become fairly adept at sharpening my plane irons and chisels (no effort yet on saws), and my skills have expanded to the point where I can comfortably join together pieces of wood using hand tool techniques. However, it is quite clear that I cannot possibly move forward without a quality bench (a realization I know I should have come to much earlier), and so after much research decided on the LN I described in the post.
At 61, I am still a few years from retirement, so I cannot devote full time to woodworking. Yet, even though my time in the workshop is limited, the satisfaction derived from building things for friends and family is profound, not only because that is what craftsmanship and creativity always bring to those so engaged, but also because each piece I build will, at least for a time, leave a little bit of myself behind for posterity.
Thanks again for your patience...
- David Katz
- Huntington, NY
Re: Veritas Hold-Down and Square Bench Holes
roger lance
Welcome to the discussions, David.
Absolutely
James Watriss
Most tools, however you receive them, are merely kits for making something better. Having something made to order, to your own spec, is cost prohibitive.
Some folks will strip as much dead weight as they can from their cars to lighten them up and get them to go faster. Attention to purpose is the difference between 'damaged' and 'customized.' To the hot rod set, they're not losing pieces, they're gaining speed. But they do choose what to scrap, and what to keep.
Holes drilled for a purpose add function. Holes drilled willy-nilly is damage.
Modify your tools to make them more useful for your own purpose. They are only the means, not the end.