New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

Posts

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#26

more "chewing the fat"

Bill Tindall

While the animal and vegetable oils, greases, tallows and waxes are, well, greasy , oily, and waxy, they are chemically worlds different from the petroleum oils, greases and waxes. Hence, it is not hard to imagine that they would perform differently in cases where chemistry could matter, rust prevention or finish and adhesive compatibility, for example. In these cases the practical experience with the materials is the best guide for choosing among them.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#27

Ellis Walentine

What about quenching with mutton fat?

Ellis Walentine

Years ago, I heard it from some assumed authority that lamb fat was the best quench for tool steel. I actually melted up a pot of it and quenched some chisels I was hardening and tempering. I have no way of knowing whether it made any difference, but I was willing to give it a try.

Not to hijack a thread on rust prevention, but what about quenching in the stuff?

Ellis

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#28

Stephen Shepherd

Real men [&women] use bear fat.


Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#29

Re: What about quenching with mutton fat?

R Payne

Quenching depends on heat extraction from the piece to be quenched. I ran across a paper on the speed of different quenchants one time in a galaxy far, far away. Seems that canola based quenchants has a better cooling curve than petroleum based quenchants. I don't recall there being anything on animal based fats/oils. But if it removes heat sufficiently fast then it would work.

Counter-intuitivly, warming the oil before hand actually removes heat faster. I believe that has to do with the lower viscosity of the oil at higher temperatures. When I quench in oil, I warm the oil to around 120-140 F beforehand.

ron

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#30

David Barnett

To quote from your blog, Stephen: *LINK*

David Barnett

"Tallow and bear fat have similar melting points, specific gravity, etc. to lard and work as a lubricant for metal and wood, a rust inhibitor for ferrous metals, for cooking, to protect leather, wood and other organic materials from moisture and as a lamp fuel for illumination."

I may be misinterpreting the linked study, but the melting point of black bear fat appears significantly lower than either beef or mutton tallow.

I will not, however, dispute the manliness of bear fat acquisition or use, nor pass judgment on its utility or what surely must be its unique aesthetic.


Composition of Fat From a No. American Black Bear

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#31

Who knows?

Bill Tindall

It is another chemistry question that involves the interaction of this or that chemical composition with the hot steel. There is little doubt that different stuff will be made when hot steel hits fat vs some petroleum product. So it would not be surprising if the results differed. The reactions would be so complex one could not reliably speculate on the outcome.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#32

Re: What about quenching with mutton fat?

Bill Tindall

Even if it is only heat removal, which I doubt, the details are boggling complicated. A layer of vapor will instantly form around the hot metal. In the case of water the vapor layer will be mostly generated by boiling water and some decomposition of the water(I think). ( I would not be surprised to find that water will decompose at 1100 degrees on a metal surface.) But in the case of organic liquids the vapor will more likely be largely a result of chemical decomposition to form a great variety of vaporized organic stuff, some of which will almost surely react with the surface of the steel to form carbides and what not. In the case of fat oxides could be formed.

Heat will be removed by vaporization, decomposition of the organic stuff, conduction through a vapor layer, convection of the bulk liquid, etc. No doubt someone has modeled it all and the results reside in some materials science book.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#33

What happened to Table 2?

Bill Tindall

That is where all the interesting results were recorded which might reveal its resistance to oxidation.

We had a bear hanging around and posing a risk to my sheep. Someone hit it with a truck before I had the opportunity to remove the risk otherwise. But if the opportunity presents itself I'll save the grease for those interested.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#34

David Barnett

I teased then gyped you, Bill.

David Barnett

But not intentionally. My bad.

I linked to the Verlag Springer preview instead of the less informative but complete (and free) study that I should've been able to find in my history. And I will, as soon as I find my computer glasses. Actually, a higher melting point was given in that study, though still not so high as beef or mutton tallow. Unfortunately, the free study says very little to nothing about rust prophylaxis, but as soon as I can find the link I'll post it. Sorry. Bear fat. Kinda like the idea of that. Anything but wussy camellia oil.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#35

A LV opportunity?

Bill Tindall

As I have read, the skins for those cool British military hats are bear that comes from Canada. Where there is bear skin there must be bear fat unless only anorexic bear are sacrificed for these hats. Instead of tiny tins of tame sheep, LV could sell the real stuff, Canada bear grease- for manly woodworkers.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#36

Waiting to hear from Dan'l Boone any time now