New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

Posts

Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

David Barnett

I see Lee Valley now sells McQueen's Pure Mutton Tallow. Bravo! If you've never tried mutton tallow, give it a shot.

Thanks to one benevolent WoodCentralian, I have a lifetime supply of lovely rendered lamb fat in my favorite consistency, but the softer McQueens should do fine, especially for woodworking tools. Mutton tallow really does make an incomparable saw and plane lubricant and rust preventative. I live fifty feet from saltwater and there's no rust on my tool steel.

I use it mostly on jeweler's sawframe blades and flexshart burrs for piercing, setting, carving cameos and so on, and mixed 50/50 with beeswax and damar, as a superb engraver's transfer wax. I went without mutton tallow for several long years and am loath to do so again. I treasure it. Buy several. Refrigerate your hoard and it'll last forever.

Great if you run out of Dapper Dan, too.

And it's made in the U.S. of A., by jingo!


McQueen's Mutton Tallow, 1 oz

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#2

good for shoes too

Bill Tindall

If you don't mind smelling vaguely like a sheep this stuff is a great shoe dressing. It lasts longer on work shoes than the typical commercial products for rendering shoes supple and water resistant.

It will soon be that time of year when lambs are sacrificed to provide lamb chops, leg o' lamb and the like. For little effort more lamb fat can be rendered to yield more of this product. For the price of a priority mail box and jar I can send some.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#3

I would love some...

John in NM

Hard to find good boot grease out here (or likely anywhere any more)... it's all this dryish silicone junk or wax and petroleum jelly.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#4

Re: I would love some...

Bill Tindall

my email is in the header

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#5

Re: I would love some...

Edward in Vancouver

Been curious about the stuff, in all my years in pro kitchens, I have never worked with mutton. Lamb, yes, tons of it, but not mutton.

I'm guessing that mutton tallow was used in the workshops because there was/is no culinary use for it. In other words it stinks. Good for plane soles, saws, and work boots, but disgusting in soups and sauces. Mind you, that's only my opinion...

OTOH I'm a big fan of chicken fat, I render it down a lot and use it in many cooking applications.

Now Bill, not wanting to pry or anything as to your "secret recipie", but do you just take as much mutton fat/gristle as possible, run it through a meat grinder, mix it with water and slow cook the whole mess until the fat bubbles clear and shining?

Even with all the water removed, will it not go eventually rancid?

Regards, Edward--who has been known to nip from the bottle of X virgin olive oil to grease his tools .....

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Tallow holder

Jack Guzman from Maine

Anyone interested in lamb fat should also note that St. Roy,in one episode made a small very neat container for holding just such a product. I remember seeing the episode but not sure how to find it. ---Jack

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

"Dovetailed Greasepot" episode #2901


Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#8

David Barnett

It keeps well, Edward

David Barnett

"Even with all the water removed, will it not go eventually rancid?"

Not if enough of the protein is removed.

EKO, Baar and other medicinal salves made from mutton tallow have longevity that runs into decades.

Also, mutton tallow is more solid and hard than most fats at room temperature. If you wipe an extremely thin film of mutton tallow on metal, you can draw on it with a pencil, which is another advantage for engraving, repousse, and so on. Mixed with beeswax and maybe a resin (I add damar), it'll stay nicely solid even in warm shops.

I keep my hoard in the refrigerator, but that's not really necessary. I do like Bill's lamb fat better for lubrication over the hard mutton tallow used by gunsmiths and black powder enthusiasts. Just a touch on setting burrs and sawblades to the wick in a tiny container of liquified lamb fat that lives on my jeweler's bench and they zip through stainless steel and titanium, not to mention gummy metals like fine silver and high karat golds. From Lee Valley's description: "smooth, butter-like consistency", I'd say McQueen's should be just right for woodworkers.

Another use for tallow - in this case beef tallow is just fine - it's a great lubricant for sawing even thick blocks of aircraft aluminum on woodworking bandsaws. There's a video on finewoodworking.com that shows Gary Knox Bennett doing just that. It works on my 16" Grizzly.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#9

David Barnett

Re: Tallow holder

David Barnett

I've made a wicking container for my jeweler's bench, Jack. It has a flared base to resist tipping and some mass to stay warm and liquid from an occasional pass of my torch to the base (turned aluminum). Way too small for the woodworking bench, of course. Really, though, just a touch on your finger will do it. It smears on easily.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#10

the secret family recipe

Bill Tindall

Put fat in pot. Heat slowly. Strain off the liquid portion. Add a few tenths percent BHT antioxidant. Pour into paint can.

Olive oil is chemically nearly identical to Camellia oil. It has less reactive sites so it doesn't react with oxygen to become rancid like the more unsaturated fats.

I don't think many would detect a significant difference in mutton fat vs lamb fat. Mutton (female) meat is tougher, and often fatter, but not particularly stronger. Ram meat is another story. I can notice a taste difference at about 1 year of age.

While we are on the topic, there are three classes of Ovine meat. Lamb (up to 1 year or the appearance of the 1st set of adult teeth). Hoggat( 1 to 2 years or the appearance of the second set of adult teeth). Mutton(greater than 2 years or the appearance of the third set of adult teeth.)

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#11

Re: Tallow holder

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for the replies gentlemen. The product is not available yet in CDN--at least it isn't on the CDN L.V. website yet, perhaps difficulties with shipping "food products" over the border?

If and when I do have time, I might trott down to a Halal butcher and get some lamb/mutton fat--it's worth a try.

Edward

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Yeah but...

Jack Guzman from Maine

The greasepot that St Roy shows has that neander charm that goes good with a hand tool bench.---Jack

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#13

Moses Yoder

Well yes, but I'm vegetarian

Moses Yoder

I guess that explains why I'm a mouth breathing sissie. I mean really, if we're going to go around insulting people here, I can think of some. I remember buying a bottle of camelia oil for about $12 I think, and being told it's too expensive. It has lasted me about 3 years now and is about 1/4 gone. Plus, I am about 5280 miles from the nearest salt water, so I don't think I need a nuclear blast proof rust protection. But thanks for the information anyway, when my camellia oil runs out in about 20 years I'll get some mutton tallow, in spite of the title of your post.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#14

The cheap person..

david weaver

... was probably me, but I use light mineral oil all over the place. A pint of it with a pound of beeswax (pesticide free beeswax is $6 a pound on ebay) makes a nice rub-on wax or sanding wax for the lathe (it's like spreadable butter....a little harder, but same premise).

Also works nicely on soft and hard arkansas stone (the oil, not the oil and wax) and is about $12-$14 a gallon.

For anything needing wax (sawplates, etc), either the beeswax plain or gulf wax ($4 a pound) seems a very good buy, esp. the gulf wax with as slowly as it gets consumed.

I can't imagine many craftsmen 150 years ago would've used mutton tallow at the equivalent of $3 an ounce. Certainly is a gentlemans wax and rust preventative at that price with as many things as are available cheap now.

I'd imagine nobody in the woodworking retail world tells folks to use mineral oil because it's 1/8th the cost of camelia oil, and you can get it anywhere (commercial kitchen supply, farriers supply, farm stores, ..). Instead, you use something similar that you can't cross shop so newbies won't catch on. At least that's what I gather of it.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#15

David Barnett

Bring it on!

David Barnett

"I guess that explains why I'm a mouth breathing sissie. I mean really, if we're going to go around insulting people here, I can think of some."

You probably know that was in jest, Moses, but go ahead, do your worst!

I've used Camellia, olive, other plant oils and petroleum derivatives for decades. However, mutton tallow works better for me as both a lubricant on hand and machine tools and as a rust preventative -- maybe even better than RenWax for hand tools. The point is, I've seen rust with the vaunted Camellia oil. Not so since I've switched to mutton tallow.

I can appreciate your vegetarian sensibilities, however, and was more so poking fun at woodworker Nipponophiles, but must opine that sheep aren't slaughtered for their tallow alone. As camellias go, Camellia oleifera is a useful and pleasant alternative (though not nearly so useful as Camellia sinensis), and (IMO) not nearly so effective as tallow. So for the unoffended blithely picking their teeth at the top of the food chain, I say man up with mutton.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#16

David Barnett

It's USP Heavy mineral oil...

David Barnett

...that keeps me regular, cheerful, and going strong, David. Or is that TMI?

"I can't imagine many craftsmen 150 years ago would've used mutton tallow at the equivalent of $3 an ounce. Certainly is a gentlemans wax and rust preventative at that price with as many things as are available cheap now."

I can't imagine 150 years ago that the average woodworker paid anything for it, but tallow was used for machine tools and cutters. Still is. The first I heard of mutton tallow was from gunsmiths at Smith & Wesson, then Lynton McKenzie, an Australian-born engraver, and experts at the American Precision Museum who helped indentify my antique short bed CT River Valley machine lathe.

Early in steam-driven industries, tallow (both mutton and beef) was discovered to have unique properties that avoided the deterioration and washout of other oils and so became an industrial product in widespread use. The higher melting point was also distinctly advantageous. In fact, tallow, both mutton and beef, was widely used on locomotives until the 1950s. Rapeseed began to be used as a substitute when tallow supplies ran short in WWII, however, but was never as effective as tallow.

Yeah, $3 might seem a little steep, but I think it's worth it. Even at that price, hardly a "gentleman's wax", though Geo. F. Trumper did use it in their superior shaving and grooming products before wussing out and reformulating. T&H and Taylor soon followed and now only The Art of Shaving offers tallow-based shaving products.

At least we still have mutton. Hard to find spermacetti nowadays.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#17

David Barnett

You can watch it here *LINK*

David Barnett

Of course, Roy shows the solid mutton tallow in a Twinings tin.


Dovetailed Greasepot

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#18

Re: It's USP Heavy mineral oil...

david weaver

I'm sure you can find rendered fat cheaper than $3 an ounce if you like to protect tools with it.

Makes little fiscal sense to me to buy gentleman's fat (at near $50 a pound), and i am pretty easily separated from my money. Ask my wife.

It could just be me, though, who knows? A couple of magazine articles and some blog posts and everyone will be smearing it all over their planes. That's all it takes these days to go from long-term machinst cutting tool protector to general cure-all.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#19

By the way..tallow shaving..

david weaver

I don't generally buy AOS products because they're overpriced and filled (at least the only tub I got) with parabens. Perhaps the hard soap isn't filled with parabens, it's still franchise store priced.

Mitchell's wool fat is tallow based, as is williams (though the new williams sucks, anyway), cella (which is a cheap soap that can be bought by the KG, but as good as any that I've used), tabac....I'm sure there are a ton of others, but those are just the ones that I actually have.

The flight from tallowate soaps probably has to do with squeaky vegans combined with cheap glycerine. They're still not hard to find, though.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#20

David Barnett

Mutton tallow, the "gentleman's fat" *LINK*

David Barnett

"I don't generally buy AOS products because they're overpriced and filled (at least the only tub I got) with parabens"

Yeah, I don't want anything to do with AOS, either. Absurd prices aside, I don't even consider them a passable product.

"The flight from tallowate soaps probably has to do with squeaky vegans combined with cheap glycerine. They're still not hard to find, though."

Hence my somewhat feigned derision.

"Makes little fiscal sense to me to buy gentleman's fat (at near $50 a pound), and i am pretty easily separated from my money."

Agreed, but Lee Valley makes it so easy to try next time you order (and we all do) at the click of a button for not an arm and a leg, and it does come in that cute little tin. If you need more, say up to a pound, you can get a block "approximately 12 to 16 oz.", from Dixie Gun Works for under $6.

"A couple of magazine articles and some blog posts and everyone will be smearing it all over their planes."

That's my plan. I'm headed into mutton tallow futures.

As for tallow soaps, home saponification of animal fats preserves the glycerin removed by commercial producers, and as I recently said about all-vegetable castile on the main board, "it's easy! - it's fun!"


Dixie Gun Works mutton tallow

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#21

I'm vegan

Frank D. in Montreal

And I wasn't offended. This said, a vagan alternative to mutton tallow is palm oil (also called vegetarian tallow). It has almost the same proportion of saturated and unsaturated fats and many of the same characteristics. I can't really compare from experience though.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#22

Re: DGW..

david weaver

..now you're talking my unit price range!! I have two quarts of beeswax mix to get through before I try anything, though. So far, despite using it on wooden tools and metal tools alike, as well as a dry skin and chapped lip salve, (and even a sanding wax on the lathe) I've used about 1/5th of the first container in a year.

(try the cella if you haven't before, it's lovely stuff, it lathers like a cream and I believe it's about $10 for a tub, I bought a kilo and when my MWF and Tabac run out, it will be cella only for me. I think the kilo of soap was about $35, and I've gotten my wife - who has become a chemophobe (or whatever you'd call someone afraid of lots of chemicals) - to go to a badger brush and cella soap.

My understanding is that it's also sold as razorock brand, also about $10, which folks who don't like the faint almond smell of the cella seem to like.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#23

David Barnett

It's all about the melting point for me

David Barnett

I've used palm oil in soaps a few times. It has a similar melting point range to beef tallow, although palm oil tends to melt at its lower end, whereas beef melts usually at 38"-40" C. For machining and cutting I much prefer the higher melting point of mutton tallow which usually melts from 46°-49° C.

Palm oil (vegetable tallow) 33-39° C.

Beef tallow 35-40° C.

Mutton tallow 45-49° C.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#24

Leo Cuellar

Sheepless In Seattle

Leo Cuellar

:b OK, near Seattle anyway.

What a wealth of information you serve us, David! I'd read about mutton tallow before, but after reading your praise of it, I'm going to have to pick some up & give it a try.

Re: Camellia oil's for mouthbreathing sissies *LINK*

#25

David Barnett

What's more, Sheepless in Seattle, ... *LINK*

David Barnett

...it clings mad hard to buffing wheels, supporting whatever abrasive you're currently jonesing, which, to the august Steampunk Lineshaft inventor, may be of some interest.


Leo's Whirling Circus of Grit