New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

New Lee Valley Chisels??

Posts

New Lee Valley Chisels??

#1

New Lee Valley Chisels??

tony roth

Wondering if anyone has any information on when Rob's new chisels will be available? Thanks, tony.

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#2

Rob Lee and The Shadow do.....

roger lance

but neither one is saying.

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#3

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

Rob Lee

Hi Tony -

The O1 chisels are ready.... it's the handles we're still futzing with. The caremelised maple has a bit of an unanticipated learning curve, and it's taken awhile to get the turning and finishing processes correct. We approved the first pre-production batch about a week ago.

Also last week, we received our first batch of PM-V11.... so work on those chisels (and plane blades) will start soon.

I'd like to be able to telegraph the price and availability date for the PM-V11 chisels at the same time we release the O1 (so customers can make an informed choice) so that may hold them back just a tad longer too.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#4

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

Howard Pollack

Rob- Can you say something about PM-V11 steel? It is one of the millions of steel I know nothing about. Thanks -Howard

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#5

Re: Maple causing trouble?

david weaver

Maple problems? No problem, just use olivewood instead :b

That'd put a bit of a wrinkle in material cost, though, huh?

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#6

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

Rob Lee

Hi Howard,

PM-V11 is a proprietary powder metallurgy steel, made in USA. It is the steel we chose for plane blades and some chisels after extensive testing - against dozens of other likely candidates. We evaluated all steels for a number of use and maintenance characteristics, and scored each - plotting a performance evelope of the steel characteristics.

We will be publishing much of what we found on the PM-V11 website (which has only a placeholder page at the moment).

In a nutshell - it's as easy to maintain as A2, holds an edge at least twice as long as A2 (and at lower bevel angles) - and affords excellent impact resistance.

It's a very impressive steel. Some of the other steel that were candidates were CPM-3V, CPM-9V, and a PM M4. We also looked at PM M2, A2, and D2 steels. PM-V11 outscored all of 'em.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#7

Re: Maple causing trouble?

Rob Lee

Yeah - it's the 0% moisture content that makes it tough to work with in a production envrionment.

We're trying to work to a cost target (after all - it's your (figuratively) money we're spending) and that means a degree of volume and automation. Hand processes really start to add up ...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#8

Caramelized maple?  Sounds tasty.


Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#9

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

Tony roth

Thanks Rob for the transparency!

I also appreciate the very thoughtful approach for releasing the information, especially since I am particularly interested in the pmv chisels. If you could kindly let us know on this thread when you determine release time for this info that would be much appreciated so we'd all be sure not to miss it!

Best,

Tony

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#10

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

wilbur

Do you need to use diamonds to sharpen PM-V11? Or will other methods work?

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#11

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

david weaver

Proprietary as in only Veritas? Or Proprietary as in only one maker can make it but anyone can get it (not that I'm trying to get raw stock of anything I can't harden in the back yard).

Is it similar to A11 steel?

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#12

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

Rob Lee

Hi David -

Proprietary as in only one maker can make it. That's as far as I'll go....!

No - it's not A11 (CPM-10V)...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#13

A Peek for Tony... *LINK*

Rob Lee

Hi Tony -

Here's a peek - got 'em yesterday afternoon....

Cheers -

Rob


O1 Chisels

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Can anyone else peek?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Rob,

Any bigger sizes in the makings? Those are beautiful chisels. It's hard to find a decent 2" chisel that isn't a foot long.---Jack

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#15

Re: Can anyone else peek?

Rob Lee

Hi Jack -

We'll be going wider with the Butt chisels... to 2".

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#16

Those look great!

John in NM

I've been holding off on replacing my Sandviks, cheapskate that I am... but I believe I'll try some of those when the fancy steel ones are available :D

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#17

Re: A Peek for Tony...

Tony Roth

Thanks Rob! Can we assume the m2's will look identical, perhaps a slightly different tone to the steel? Ill definitely be waiting for those...Tony

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#18

Re: A Peek for Tony...

Rob Lee

Hi Tony -

The PM-V11 steel chisels will have the same design....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Lee Valley Chisels??

#19

I appreciated the opportunity to peek

Bill Tindall

......with the expected result that I have mailed this link to many others that don't frequent WoodCentral.