New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Continuous arm Windsor

Posts

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#26

Re: Skews are cursed

TomD

Skews are great, etc... But this is not a skew as a skew, it is a skew as a scraper, and as promised it is easy, etc... EASY. SAFE. EFFECTIVE.

Now the devil skew, that's a different, and fun tool, but I would never suggest it is easier than sandpaper, except "so easy when you know how". Most of the problems, though, can be eliminated by trailing the handle, and cutting on the lower third of the edge, whether one is using the long or short end of it.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#27

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

Joseph Mulherin

Jack, I. am too making some rocking chairs for family members. Instead of carving put the seat using the adz and scorps, I found Charles Neil doing it with a daddo blade on his table saw. To see it go to

"In the Workshop@youtube.com. Anyway Charles thinks outside the regular woodworking methods and I did two of the seats using his method.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#28

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

Pam Niedermayer

I'd bet you don't even need a special dado blade to do this, as it's a standard table saw technique to cut out curved shapes by tilting and angling the blade and piece.

Pam

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#29

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

Jack Guzman from Maine

If I was going to power it I would probably get one of those chainsaw toothed wheels for an angle grinder. However,I really enjoy the carving process using hand tools. There's something satisfying about watching the seat take shape as you carefully remove slices of wood with a sharp blade. It was the hand work aspect that drew me to windsor chair making in the first place. The whole operation is fun. Besides carving the seat, using steam to bend and twist wood to whatever shape you need, shaping spindles with drawknife and spokeshave at a shavehorse.

I guess what I'm saying is that it's not about the end result for me. It's the process of getting there.

Don't get me wrong,I still like my tablesaw but that's for another forum.---Jack

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#30

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Skews are cursed-update

Jack Guzman from Maine

Tom,

I explored deeper into Peter Galbert's website"Chair Notes". He posted some good pointers and a couple short videos on the use of the skew. Very,very helpful. I turned a couple legs after and I think I'm getting it. My main issues were approach to the wood and blade geometry/sharpness. ---Jack

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#31

Curtis turning

Bill Tindall

Curtis has demonstrated spindle turning for our club. His blanks are green wood and it turns more easily than dry wood. The only way to get the crisp detail that Curtis achieves is with a skew and no sanding, but it will take a lot of practice to get there. This fact may be why in "days of old" that the turning was largely done by turners that only did spindle turning and sold the product to the furniture makers. If you take a class with Curtis the turnings are provided.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#32

Jack Guzman from Maine

Sharing knowledge(small rant and heading off topic

Jack Guzman from Maine

I am actually getting better. Thanks to Curtis,Peter Galbert, Elio and others who are generous with their knowledge and lots of practice on my part of course. Before I found Curtis' videos I was a very poor turner. The more I tried it seemed the worse I got.I have no access to a teacher or mentor so I have to learn by trial and error. Watching those videos got me off in the right direction.

There are a few pros I know of that are overly protective of their hard won knowledge and resources. I don't understand this mind set. I try to pass on any of my knowledge to any who are willing to learn. I feel the trade is improved by interest in it and the more tools these new people have the better they can perform. I guess they must think they earned the right to make money from their hard work,but withholding information and resources is counterproductive.

Rant over- back to work. :) ---Jack

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#33

Re: Sharing knowledge(small rant and heading off t

Bob Hackett

How close to South Portland are you Jack? If you`r within traveling distance of the Rockler store there then you ought to pay a visit on the night they hold the turning club meeting there.

I think you`ll find that turners are more than willing to share everything they know as well as freely giving one on one instruction to boot. Many of the turners I know are usually willing to loan you a couple of their spare tools to get a feel for what`ll really work for you as far as different grinds, widths and thicknesses in tools go. If I lived closer I`d loan you a few of my own tools. I am one of the founding members of the Maine Wooturners,the first chapter of the AAW to form in Maine.

I`d say I`d help you with your spindle turning and mastery of the skew but the truth is I`m a former bowl turner and do most everything with specially ground spindle gouges so I really couldn`t be much help for your quest in "taming the skew".

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#34

Tip from Alan Batty

Bill Tindall

To learn the skew start with a blunt bevel angle and a small tool. One made from a piece of 3/6 or 1/2" square metal lathe tool stock is ideal. Grasp the tool handle and extend the index finger along the axis of the tool. Rotate the tool about the axis of the pointing finger when rolling a bead.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#35

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Sharing knowledge(small rant and heading off t

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bob,

Actually I'm not very close. I don't drive. Can't do more than short trips.I'm on the New Hampshire border straight inland from Portland.I know bowl turning is a whole different thing. All I really need is to be able to create decent spindles and I am getting the hang of it. I have received help from turners here in Woodcentral and they are very generous and helpful. What I was saying was that these videos have gotten me to figure out what I needed to improve my technique.---Jack

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#36

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Tip from Alan Batty

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I don't understand what you're describing here. Could this test be done with a short ,worn down old 1/2" skew? I don't have any metal lathe stock but I do have a bucket of old flea market turning chisels.---Jack

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#37

Yeah, and is a "blunt" bevel 90°? A thick scraper


Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#38

Re: Curtis turning

TomD

Green wood also has the advantage that catches are a softer experience.

Skew turning along with a few other bedeviled woodturning techniques is one of those things that just comes down to very basic geometry of the tool, keep the bevel rubbing, and keep the shaft on the rest in a good place. As I say, there are a few of these tools/techiniques like the swirly endgrain hollowing cuts, where the lighbulb would go on as I realized, I just had to keep the bevel rubbing. Most of the catches,and other stuff are pretty obvious problems, after you figure them out.

While I like good old plain vanilla skews, the fact remains that there are some clever variations out there, like the sorby, that through minor variation make skews catchproof, or easier. That should tell one that there isn't much to taming the tool. As with many techniques in woodworking, you have to free yourself to play with the tool. Just do some fun stuff, do not get into the white knuckled project mentality, or progress will come much more slowly.

I somewhat doubt that the skew skills, that come pretty quickly, are the reason the turners did the turned parts. I think it had more to do with the fact that the source of the wood was in the forest, it could be split and turned on the spot with less loss of material. Productive specialization doubtless played an important role, but I doubt it was a skills issue. Maybe the fact one could take a lathe into the woods, and with hardly any other tool make some parts simply meant the chair shop could be undercut by the vagabond freelancers, if one can call them that.

It isn't accurate to say you can only cut those parts with a skew, you probably do need a long shearing action, and the skew is a great and simple tool. But there are many other ingenious tools, hook tools, long shallow gouges, triangle tools, the odd thing Oselnik used.

Another thing is that the

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#39

Re: Tip from Alan Batty

TomD

That would probably work, though I prefer regular tools, and I like to roll the bead by placing my thumb on the top of the tool, and I start with the thumb either to the left or the right, palm down or up. You want to have room for a big fluid motion. I also like to work the body, so I can carry a stable platform left or right. Big smooth motion. Mainly the catch occurs turning beads if the skew cuts too high on the edge, the bevel isn't rubbing, or the shaft isn't offset so the contact point is in line with the cut.

While beads can be cut with any skew, there is a special version for beads where the end is not skewed, but cut at 90 degrees. What that should tell you is to beware of skews with very long points.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#40

Training wheels for the skew chisel

Bob Hackett

Two excellent tricks I was shown to help me get started with the skew was to use a dead center (the ring type dead center) that you would usually use in the tailstock of the lathe as a drive center. Instead of those horrific catches that corkscrew up the spindle and ruin it the spindle just stops as the ring center loses it`s grip and spins. The dead center as dive center trick also helps teach you to use a light touch and not crowd a cut.

The second tip I found helpful was to take both a red and a black magick marker and color in the bevel of the skew.Black for the "sweet spot" and red (to let me know I was wandering off into trouble) everywhere else.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#41

Waiting with bated breath

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Tom,

You closed with, "Another thing is that the..." and then stopped.

Sitting here, just sitting here on the Group W bench, waiting for what you were going to say next.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#42

Re: Waiting with bated breath

TomD

I think I had a catch right there...

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#43

"Group W bench"...

Scott in Douglassville

...ya know, I wanted to name a kid Arlo. Got voted down, though. Relegated to dog naming, and even that hasn't happened yet.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#44

Re: "Group W bench"...

TomD

I'm not the most kid friendly dad, so when the third unplanned one came along, I made a really stiff campaign to name her Blanche Edna Pearl. Sadly, by then, I was so outvoted I couldn't carry the day.

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#45

Naming children

Bob Hackett

I wanted to name my youngest son Kenneth Ullysses Hackett. That way he`d be known as Ken U Hackett.

I was voted down as well. :(

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#46

Re: "Group W bench"...

Pam Niedermayer

My mother's name was Edna Vera H____; but she was born in 1925, don't know that she ever suffered for it.

Pam

Re: Continuous arm Windsor

#47

Re: "Group W bench"...

TomD

Those were the days! Blanche, Edna, and Pearl were classic names among the WWI generation. My grand mother was Edna Steel.