New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

British carving tools

Posts

British carving tools

#1

British carving tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I know Addis have a great reputation. Are the other 19th-/early 20th-century Sheffield carving tools considered generally good tools as well? Or is there a lot of variability?

I ask because I may have a line on some tools and am deciding whether to pull money out of the bank tomorrow a.m.

Re: British carving tools

#2

Re: British carving tools

joel moskowitz

I would say yes.

First of all the overall standard of quality was pretty high. Even brands that were considered downmarket at the time are probably pretty good by today's standards.

Addis's reputation was made fairly early on in their career and most of the tools stamped "Addis" were made for Ward & Payne and quality varied. So there is an excellent chance that considering the number of actual forging carving tool makers was pretty small, that the person who made your tools at some point in their career also made stuff that got stamped Addis.

The real question you have to ask is are the shapes and sizes appropriate for what you want to do?

Re: British carving tools

#3

Re: British carving tools

Pam Niedermayer

I've been happy with every Addis I've bought, probably something like 20-30 chisels total. However, I also enjoy those from several modern makers like Dastra, Pfeil, and Takahashi, all of which cost more than the Addises.

If the question is whether I'd cash in an IRA to buy any tools, probably not; but I'm comfortable delaying a contribution. :) There are too many satisfactory ways to get a task done to get real picky about using only a particular tool; so most all of my purchases are funded by new revenue. Once I decide I need a particular type of tool, I buy the best I can afford.

Pam

Re: British carving tools

#4

Re: British carving tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think any of the old British carving tools would be fine, but I would still be wary. I use Henry Taylor tools, the most like the older tools, and have never bought a used tool. Serious carvers who use old tools often look a large number of offerings just to buy one tool. When I look at older tools I often see tools that are either somewhat used up, or some kind of obscure tool. If I am going to spend $90 on tools, I would much rather buy three specific tools that are useful to me right now than buy nine that I may find a use for some day.

Re: British carving tools

#5

Re: British carving tools

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Sometime after J.B. Addis's death Ward and Payne aquired the Addis trademark so any Addis tools with the crossed stamp are actually Ward and Payne.

Either way I would not hesitate to buy any late 19th or even early 20th century Shefield tools, Addis or otherwise.

If you are not familiar with the numbering system used on London pattern tools you may want to read up on how it differs from modern tool numbering.

Robin