New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Gramercy Saw Kit

Posts

Gramercy Saw Kit

#1

Gramercy Saw Kit

Patrick Gibbons

Here is the saw handle I made for the kit I bought from Tools for Working Wood.



I had some European steamed beech that I used to make the handle. Letting in the blade was interesting to say the least. I wrapped a cloth around my hand and just held the blade like it had a handle already and cut the slot. Was quicker than making a jig and seemed to turn out alright. I had experimented with the saws I owned, including a coping saw. None of them were narrow enough to cut a useable kerf. In the future I won't be able to cut out waste easily with a coping saw because this saw has such a narrow kerf.

While the directions called for a 3/16" bit to drill for the shank of the bolts I found I needed to use a bit 1/64" larger. Also while letting in the brass back, I cut out too much wood and decided to fill it in with some JB Weld wood filler. It's not really noticeable and when I'm up to it, I might just make a new handle. I'll probably just live with the mistake. I finished it up with some Murdoch's hard sealer tung mixture. I need to wax it and then use it.

I've tried some test cuts and I'm pleased with it so far but I'm witholding final judgement until I can use it on a project. The handle feels great and was taken from the template provided. Once again, I wanted to show my work, worts and all. Thanks for looking.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#2

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

steve mackay

Very, very neat !

I'll bet its nice to just pick it up, let alone use.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#3

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Patrick,

Your DT saw kit post came two days after I ordered a Gramercy DT saw kit.

It arrived a couple days ago and I'm taking my first pass at a handle for it.

I say "first pass" in the hopes it will somehow mean that the first one will be perfect, and a second try will be unnecessary.

Any further tips or observations about the process of letting in the back?

I'll post a pic when It's done.

Bob in NJ

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#4

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

Patrick Gibbons

I found it was the most difficult part of the handle. Go very slowly with the drill bit and try to drill shallow. I used chisels to square up the sides. Sawing the slot was also a chore. The kit instructions have a suggestion for making a jig but it necessitated having the brass back unattached to the blade. Mine came already attached and I didn't want to disturb that. No saw in my kit cuts a kerf as thin as the Gramercy saw. I wrapped a cloth around the blade so it would not be so uncomfortable to hold and just used the saw two-handed to cut its own kerf. I went very slowly and followed the line I had marked on the wood. Sawing a straight line is so necessary and truly difficult to do this way. Handles I have made in the past for other saws demonstrated to me how easy it is to get off the line with a saw with a proper handle, let alone no handle. My original intention was to make the cut as well as I could and then use the first handle to make a better second handle. But the first one turned out well enough with only the mortise for the brass back being too deep. I could have left it as it was but instead I filled it with wood filler. It's not very visible and unless it starts to really bother me, I'm not making a second handle.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#5

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Patrick,

Thanks.

Well I jinxed myself with my post. I had everything laid out and was about to drill the first part of the mortise, when I was called away for a minute. When I got back to it I promptly drilled the first hole on the wrong side of the 'bottom' mark, oh well.

In spite of it being ruined, I figured I might as well continue to see how it would go. I used your method of wrapping the blade and using it to saw the slot, and I agree that that it is tricky to keep it straight.

Anyhow I cut out another blank last night and got it to the "ready to mortise" point. So I'll see how #2 goes.

I suppose it would be cheating to take it to work and cut the mortice on the Bridgeport.

Bob in NJ

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#6

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

Pam Niedermayer

If I planned to cut lots of western saw handles, I think I'd do my best to afford Economaki's upside down Japanese saw device, the one that looks like a contractor's saw without circular blade or motor. If you have a fence and stationary blade, it's lots easier to make such precise cuts.

Since I don't plan to make lots, I'd probably figure out a way to mount a dozuki upside down in my contractor's saw, or otherwise make such a jig with fence.

Pam

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#7

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

"mount a dozuki upside down in my contractor's saw, or otherwise make such a jig with fence"

Now why didn't I think of that!

Of course this will entail my getting a new saw to make my new saw. I need something to cut about a .025" kerf.

Thanks Pam,

(for providing a good excuse for another new saw)

Bob in nj

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#8

Don't know if this will work for these

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and I haven't tried it myself*, but: I've seen pictures of guys who clamped the saw blade down on a shim of appropriate thickness on a large flat surface - say, a table saw or the dining room table (probably best not to try this latter approach at home, unless you have no significant other or s/he is very tolerant) - then run the handle back and forth on the same flat surface. Or perhaps vice versa - clamp the handle down and run the sawblade back and forth while it (the blade) is resting on the appropriately-thick shim.

You've got very little depth of cut with those blades, so you might be able just to start the cut before the shim interferes, finishing it off using Patrick's method.

*...although I have used much the same approach (along with legions of remodelers) for undercutting existing door trim (casing, jamb) when putting in a new floor that's thicker than the old one: put a saw on a piece of the new flooring and use it to undercut the trim.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#9

Re: Re-Thinking the whole thing....

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Thanks Bill,

I'm seriously considering actually following the recommended instructions that came with the kit. Very early on, the instructions, stated "You might want to practice first by cutting a handle or two out of scrap. The "letting in" operations that cut the slot for the Saw-Back and Blade can be tricky if it's your first time."

Well so far i have proven the instructions to be true and accurate. So I'm going to continue down the path.....

They also have some more detailed info about cutting the slot and so on, that I have sort of ignored or "thought my way past" which i will expound upon later.

I'll report back in a day or two....

Bob in NJ

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#10

craigd

Re: Re-Thinking the whole thing....

craigd

You can also start with a over thick blank, cut the slot sorta in the right place/plane (which I seem to do no matter what), slot the saw plate, and, using that as a reference, square up the handle blank. Saved my buns on my last saw.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#11

My Japanese saw was not thin enough


Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#12

A tip for sawing the slot.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is extremely important that the slot is sawn straight and square. If not so, the plate will twist as it follows the kerf.

I start work with a blank that is parallel-sided and a touch over-thickness. Draw a reference line along the centre of the edges. Draw the plan of the saw on the blank. You can cut away the waste around the attachment area, and then replace the reference centre lines. You are now ready to cut the slot with the saw blade.

You need a block of wood that is half the thickness of the handle blank minus half the thickness of the saw blade (including the kerf).

The idea is to lay the handle blank on a flat surface (bench top). Now if you rest the blade flat on the block of wood, it should lie at slot level, and you should be able to saw a line that is parallel and square.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#13

How do the saw companies do it

Bill Tindall

The companies/people that make and sell saws must have some quick and reliable means of making this cut. Anybody know how "they" do it?

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#14

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit, any tips?

david weaver

You can either use a dovetail saw ( a thin plated one ) with most of the set run off of it (or if it's really thin, that might not be necessary)

Or a hardwood ryoba. I've used both.

I don't know if there's stock with the gramercy saw kit or what you've used, but I had pretty good luck cutting those mortises by hand. Just slow and careful and presumably the instructions tell you to mark center and stopping points for the cut.

The less set, the easier the cut will be. Imperfections in the cut will twist the saw plate a little bit, but if it's not perfectly straight only for the last 2 inches of the saw plate, no big deal as long as the rest of it is straight.

George Wilson mentioned to me that they cut their saw handles on a bandsaw with a blade that had the kerf they needed.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#15

Probably a milling machine

John in NM

Or a similar powered tool that can run thin saw blades. The limiting factor would be the desired kerf depth.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#16

Plastic handles.


Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#17

Re: Plastic handles.

les winter

I took a class with Mario Rodriguez many years ago where we made dovetail saw handles. He screwed the blank to a right angle wood fixture and ran it into a bandsaw blade. Worked fine.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#18

band saw

Bill Tindall

that's right. If one were to take the set out of the blade the thin blades should be just right. The operation would be no different than resawing against a fence.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#19

Re: band saw

Dean J in MN

Yep, that's a common method. Set a stop and "resaw" the slots on the handles.

For one/two saws in my shop I just use a backsaw and a gauge line, but if you have dozens to do it makes sense to set up the bandsaw.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#20

craigd

Re: How do the saw companies do it

craigd

To make a replica D8 handle (the slot doesn't exit the top), Mike Wenzloff ground down a table saw blade to 0.020" or so and used a tablesaw. I think he said Disston did something similar.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#21

Re: How do the saw companies do it

TomD

Has anyone taken a thin straight thing and probed the kerf to see whether the end of the cut is flat like a bandsaw, or concave like a circular saw blade.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#22

Re: How do the saw companies do it

TomD

Here is a 6" saw down to .023

http://www.lmii.com/CartTwo/thirdproducts.asp?CategoryName=Fretting&NameProdHeader=Power+Slotting+System

I quickly found a 4" saw at 20 thou, by searching on Slitting and Slotting saws. When considering these things one might consider the standoff of the saw one owns, it can suck up a lot of the kerf depth. Sometimes it is worth building up a jig to maximize depth of cut.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#23

Re: A tip for sawing the slot.

Charles

This is a good tip from Derek and what he is describing is basically a jig board for cutting end lap joints (rebates). Obviously, one can skip the shoulder cut and make only the slot cut which is what's needed here.

Reference Sam Allen's Joinery Basics (or maybe it's Sam's other joinery book) if anybody needs an imprimatur.

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#24

Re: My Japanese saw was not thin enough

Pam Niedermayer

Then I don't know what saw would be sufficiently thin. Western saws are thicker than Japanese saws.

Pam

Re: Gramercy Saw Kit

#25

Re: Thanks!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Thanks to all for your input.

I hope to get back to the "letting in" tomorrow evening, and will report my progress, (or lack there of :D )

Bob in NJ