New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

wax and dovetails

Posts

wax and dovetails

#1

wax and dovetails

les winter

I can cut a reasonably tight dovetail. Working in cherry, the wax that I like to finish with, over oil, gets into the smallest cracks in the joinery and sticks out like a sore thumb. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

thanks

Les

Re: wax and dovetails

#3

Re: wax and dovetails

roger lance

Les....this may not apply to you as you use oil to finish cherry.....but if you apply a coat of de-waxed shellac (often called a wash coat) on cherry to control/minimize blotching, then you might try filling the gaps in your dovetails with a mixture of cherry sanding dust and the same shellac. This mixture fills the gaps....when it drys can be sanded....and when the wash coat is applied, the shellac of the filler blends with the shellac of the wash coat to minimize the appearance of the filler.

Re: wax and dovetails

#5

Re: wax and dovetails

john Veerkamp

I use an old toothbrush to get wax out of cracks.

Re: wax and dovetails

#6

Re: wax and dovetails

Curt Putnam

Had never thought of using shellac although I have used hide glue and titebond. I'll try the shellac thing shortly. Thanks for the tip!

Re: wax and dovetails

#7

Re: wax and dovetails

Bill Tindall

Not clear what your situation is but I shellac and then wax all my drawer sides- light colored shellac, Carnuba wax, poplar wood. I don't see the problem of wax accentuating the joints.

Re: wax and dovetails

#8

Re: wax and dovetails

Guillaume Dery

I am assuming a clear wax which shows up white when it accumulates and dries. I would suggest switching to a coloured wax (you can make your own).

You can also actually peen the wood a very slight amount if you are just shy of a perfect fit. This is of course assuming that you cut them so they are a tad proud. Careful tapping spreads the wood fibers a touch to tighten the fit and then you plane off the evidence of the hammer.

Of course I have only heard of this as my dovetails are always perfect :D

Re: wax and dovetails

#9

Re: wax and dovetails

TomD

Doesn't sound that tight. Quite by accident I learned the krenov way of doing dovetails first, and even if you don't get them perfectly light, which presumably he was, the process of leveling the ends tightens them up. Because the wiggly side of the joint is at angles, how you dress that will either pull it together, or apart, it is kinda the same idea as with or against the grain.

The shellac idea sounds good but if you are actually using it as a filler you have gaps. It's like shooting everything is either a hit or a miss, you have to own the results. Another excellent filler is CA glue, you can polish it in, and get a finish, filler and glue, all in one. It is brilliant at hiding stuff, a lot of beginner guitars look like the work of expert thanks to that stuff. But you can also get these white marks so experiment with it. I'm thinking you might be able to use saw kerfs and veneer splines, a very quick technique to study some of these options without a lot of work.

Re: wax and dovetails

#10

Re: wax and dovetails

les winter

yes Warren, the wax shows up white in the joints here and there.

Re: wax and dovetails

#11

David Barnett

I was taught...

David Barnett

...that a man who bishops his dovetails would as soon pick another man's pocket, or at the very least, lacking those specialized skills, was nonetheless a scoundrel and reprobate.

Re: wax and dovetails

#12

Isn't it ironic...

John in NM

How the most condemned practices are admitted to by no one but somehow manage to be universally known :D :D :D

Re: wax and dovetails

#13

Huh? 


Re: wax and dovetails

#14

Heat Gun

James Watriss

The problem is optical in nature. The wax isn't in direct contact with the a layer of oil underneath it, so the light entering the wax bounces directly back out, instead of traveling into the wood.

Heat gun will melt the wax enough to put it in contact with the parts you want it to contact with.

Filling the gaps is, of course, a good idea also. But it's important to remember that the color and depth that comes from a good finish, comes from a good optical path that goes from the surface, and into the wood. Any air gaps in the path will reflect light back out... hence, white.

Re: wax and dovetails

#15

David Barnett

And for the few 'universal' practices...

David Barnett

...we may have missed, fortunately a von Krafft-Ebing comes along to catalog those that warrant addition to our repertoire. The trick to successful 'bishoping', of course, is to execute it so subtly as to avoid exposure.

Re: wax and dovetails

#16

Old wax

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Les, an antiques dealer told me years ago that if the wax gets too cold it crystalizes and then shows white like yours. He said to melt the wax in the can and the problem would disappear. I don't know if his explanation was right, but I melted my wax and after it cooled the whiteness problem had gone away. Usually wax should not be so noticeable.

Re: wax and dovetails

#17

Re: Heat Gun

les winter

Ok, I will give this a try. I'll repor back later.

thanks to all .

les

Re: wax and dovetails

#18

Re: And for the few 'universal' practices...

Guillaume Dery

...And perhaps not to admit to it in a public forum.

I guess no one bought my "or so I heard line" :)

Re: wax and dovetails

#20

Re: And for the few 'universal' practices...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't understand the fuss, although I know of the sentiment.

While I do not need to resort to peening much, I would have no hesitation in doing so if the situation was appropriate. Indeed, I wrote a short article on this:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/PeeningDovetailsinWood.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: wax and dovetails

#21

Re: I was taught...

TomD

Krenov did not peen... You can make a tight set open or an open set tight, depends on how you do it. It's like tear-out, avoiding tear-out is not the same thing as using putty. So easy when you know how.

Re: wax and dovetails

#22

Re: And for the few 'universal' practices...

Guillaume Dery

Sort of my point. I would rather do it right but the opening message stated that there were slight gaps which suffered from wax buildup. In this case, short of rebuilding, I think peening is the best solution to address the issue at hand.

Of course, it would be awesome if we all did perfect work all the time but some of us are mere mortals.

Nice little write-up BTW, I like the fact that you took the time to explain compression of wood when doing dovetails. That is a detail that is often entirely omitted or glossed over.

This brings me back to my business course. Specifically the definition of value.

as an oversimplification:

Value = Fit to use at lowest cost (effort in this case)

Since peening does not take away anything functionally or aesthetically from the joint and in this particular instance is the lowest effort, it has value.

All other solutions (coloured waxes, heating the wax, etc.) do not address the gap issue so fall short in the fit to use category (lower aesthetics).

Just my $0.02

Guillaume