New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

finished sandpaper cabinet

Posts

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#26

Re: Needlewoman

TomD

The thing for which she is knows is embroidery, but I call her a "needlewoman" because she can produce, and in a range of styles. This dress is an example of smocking, all done by hand, and each stitch is a little gather of dress material in a geometric pattern as well as part of a decorative pattern. She produces stuff like this all the time, and has four grand daughters. Of course while they love to open a package, this kind of thing is never as well appreciated as a set of Sponge Bob footie pajamas.

While building my wife's spinning wheel, I became aware of the degree to which women, of all classes, pretty much, were compelled to produce thread, and yarn, by law. This kind of deep tradition still finds expression today, to some extent, and I have known some blistering knitters, tatters, etc...


Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#27

That is unfortunate and maybe rare

Bill Tindall

I don't know how representative a sample of woodworkers I know, but......Every amateur woodworker I know, that actually makes stuff, got into it for the same reason, to make stuff they couldn't buy. These persons range from a recent Society for Period Furniture Makers Cartousch winner Fred Stanley (who lives up the way a piece) to some newer members of our club. The ones I know well enough to know have supportive families. Like McKay, their homes are filled with stuff they have made, if they have been in it long enough to have made much stuff. Their older children have requested stuff to be made, and typically they have made stuff for their children from an early age. In many cases their children have worked with them in the shop from an early age. These woodworkers have made stuff for neighbors, friends and acquaintances and maybe charities.

While they all seem more or less introverted they are extroverted when it comes to stuff they make, a fact I find interesting. In their shop I don't see much beyond the barest essentials. Shop "furniture" is not the place they express their skills. You all would be astonished by Fred Stanley's modest shop where he makes extraordinary Period pieces.

In my world there is a robust demand for the woodworking skills I have developed. I have not seen the lack of appreciation for the product of these skills that some of you have expressed. Many in our club sell stuff they make, a clear demonstration of demand. I have never lacked a "market" for things I make, or more globally, the skills to make them. Our house is filled with furniture and accessories , more than 75 at last count. My older children are now requesting stuff for their homes and children. I have made stuff for inlaws and relatives, friends, neighbors and acquaintances, and charity. For the past many years Christmas presents, and gifts in general, were stuff I made. I have lost count of how many cutting boards, paper towel holders, pens and pencils and toys I have given away-hundreds. Friends, neighbors and charities request stuff with regularity, but I now turn away most of these requests to focus on stuff for my children and grandchildren. Maybe I live in a strange world but the skills of a woodworker are appreciated and in demand here in E. TN.

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#28

Re: That is unfortunate and maybe rare

TomD

"I don't know how representative a sample of woodworkers I know, but......Every amateur woodworker I know, that actually makes stuff, got into it for the same reason, to make stuff they couldn't buy."

Right, like Mission sandpaper cabinets.

" These persons range from a recent Society for Period Furniture Makers Cartousch winner Fred Stanley (who lives up the way a piece) to some newer members of our club."

Yous seem to have a pretty awesome club membership...

"The ones I know well enough to know have supportive families."

Supportive is one thing, that is a long way from saying they get it. Though keep in mind if the chippies are that good, the brand, look and expensive thing everyone gets, kicks in. Keep in mind, you don't even get us, and are constantly questioning the way stuff is, which is great, that's what makes you so interesting, but it would be hard to get from it that everyone is on the same page.

" Like McKay, their homes are filled with stuff they have made, if they have been in it long enough to have made much stuff. Their older children have requested stuff to be made, and typically they have made stuff for their children from an early age. In many cases their children have worked with them in the shop from an early age. These woodworkers have made stuff for neighbors, friends and acquaintances and maybe charities."

Same thing, freebies are great, stuff made by dad is great, does not mean they get it. I made a trimaran, I'm sure in theory one of my kids would like it if it was a little more manageable, might even sail it. Basically though, there isn't a member of my family who knows the name of a single part of the boat, give or take. None of them get it, or are anywhere near where I am. Same thing with tools, you can leave your tools to your family, and they will spread them around, but tool collecting indicates that within a few years they all get used to open paint cans, or as impact tools.

"You all would be astonished by Fred Stanley's modest shop where he makes extraordinary Period pieces."

Well not really. I used to keep around the list of tools required to attend the College of the Redwoods. And Chris S. has a book one point of which is that you can do it all with 41 tools, if you believe that. There are a lot of things any of us can learn from pros, but one thing one doesn't learn is how to be an amateur. Amateurism can be at or above the level of pros, and in the wood field mostly is. But it isn't pro lite. It is a different activity. You have the freedom to do whatever you want to do, and if you take up on that, you are not chasing approval or conformity.

"In my world there is a robust demand for the woodworking skills I have developed. I have not seen the lack of appreciation for the product of these skills that some of you have expressed. Many in our club sell stuff they make, a clear demonstration of demand. I have never lacked a "market" for things I make, or more globally, the skills to make them."

Well there is a commercial demand for Rap music and crotch grabs. I know a lot of guys who sold their first piece in some cases before they made it. I'm thirty to forty years down the road, depending on the starting point one counts, and I really don't care that people can sell stuff.

"Our house is filled with furniture and accessories , more than 75 at last count. My older children are now requesting stuff for their homes and children. I have made stuff for inlaws and relatives, friends, neighbors and acquaintances, and charity. For the past many years Christmas presents, and gifts in general, were stuff I made. I have lost count of how many cutting boards, paper towel holders, pens and pencils and toys I have given away-hundreds. Friends, neighbors and charities request stuff with regularity, but I now turn away most of these requests to focus on stuff for my children and grandchildren. Maybe I live in a strange world but the skills of a woodworker are appreciated and in demand here in E. TN."

Your doing a good thing, right, but you see your value in your utility, which is reasonable enough. If you look at the culture, utility is a long way in the past. I remember talking to some connection to our family who was in cheerleading. At her level they don't do it for a team. It is her main activity, she has never cheered an actual other person. But when you think of it, what is football? Is it real, or what is it a stand in for? Is it fake battle, and cheerleaders, are fake women of Troy waiting for their men to stop fighting, and in the next generation the product is further abstraction to the point where the cheerleaders just cheer among themselves. At least they aren't playing video cheerleader. The average stock is held for 22 seconds, whole markets for stuff like commodities now have derivative trading volumes that are larger than the real market. Most "serious" sailors sail their boats around 3 markers. Now I'm with you, one of my favorite books is building a house full of furniture. If I had built that sandpaper cabinet (kinda odd in itself, I gotta use my molding planes to build a cabinet for my router bits), I would have thought it was practical...

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#29

Re: Why!?!

Pam Niedermayer

I suppose there is also the possibility that some people are doing that, but share shop related stuff due to relevance. But in general family doesn't get it. They don't have the background to like your work any more than a nail clipping you drop, "because it was yours". I'm lucky that my wife has built boats with me, and other stuff, and that she listens to me go on and on. My parents are both highly skilled, and my in-laws include an internationally known needlewoman. But it still comes down to the same point basically.

I don't know that this is a universal condition, Tom. For example, my maternal grandfather made lots of stuff, including a doll bed and child's chair for me. I always cherished the chair, still do but my thief of a sister stole it, so no photos; but the doll's bed wasn't as elegant (the chair really was) nor was I all that interested in doll playing. My paternal grandparents (grandfather was an interior house painter, his father an interior decorator, the Niedermayer Brothers in Richmond, VA) purchased a lot of hand made furniture, and convinced my parents to also purchase from the same place (Mr. Cee's in Charlottesville, VA). We'd often take the hour's drive there to pick out a piece or two. I loved these trips as well as the furniture. Loved short lessons from Mr. Cee on why he did some things the way he did.

In this process I learned by immersion to appreciate the attributes of good furniture, no major teaching efforts that I remember. So perhaps your kids have already picked up on your work without talking about it. IIRC, I never discussed this much with my parents; but I did undertake my first woodworking project at 11.

Pam

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#30

You said it better than I did

ron in kokomo

I completely understand what Bill said. It is a nice place to be.

I think Tom's trimaran example says it best.

Also his point about free stuff is good. I will just bet that there are some of your recipients who cannot tell why your stuff isd better than the termite puke they can buy at Village Furniture.

Amateur fine woodworking is a form of madness not readily understood by the unafflicted.

My wife and daughters eyes glaze over when I get excited about telling them I am going to cut down a tree and make a chair.

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#31

One has to be perceptive about craft gifts

Bill Tindall

One can go overboard in either direction. I gave my cousin a cutting board and they hung it on the wall as art. It was pretty but I intended them to use it as I noticed upon visiting that they didn't own a useful cutting board. I wouldn't give a child an 18th century high chest for their bedroom, even if I could make it. But I have no doubt that my granddaughter will enjoy the functionally simple chest of drawers I did make her. As she grows older I am confident she will increase her appreciation of its features. I have never failed to get an appropriate response from the gift of a hand turned pen or pencil. The bottom line is that the gift needs to be recipient appropriate. But it is a good bet that most anyone appreciates the look of beautiful wood, a beautiful design, or a smooth as silk drawer, or simply a gift from a loved one or a friend. There are enough of these people out there to keep my shop busy forever.

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#32

Re: One has to be perceptive about craft gifts

TomD

Then that is the right and generous hearted thing for you to do. I would also like to make the gifts you make, the question is whether I would want to do that kind of work. Making pens, just as an example is kinda boring. I have done a fair, bit. Shortly after I was smashed up, I bought a lot of pen sized projects because that was all I could even get a part of done, before I had to pack it in. But so far, I have not seen a single kit (and I am not up to date), that is interesting as woodworking, or as a writing instrument. Best quality pens are different in balance, and normally quite mechanically complex. I have given a few as gifts, but they embarrass me. I have a neighbour who was an Oprah book selection author, she is also an actress and presenter up here in Canada. A waving level acquaintance. I guess her book was really good, but from what I heard I'm not sure her family liked it (I didn't read it so I am well second hand here). Sometimes to really do something great one has to realize that one has to plow through a lot of people who are holding one back, shoot beyond the immediate surroundings. Or so I am told, though at the trimaran level I have been there. :)

Curtis Buchanan also?!?! It is possible that your neighbourhood is special in this regard. I would be curious to know what Fink thinks, he went through the Krenov thing. At one point K. was all about a very personal and unrestricted empathy with the stuff he was making, he seemed to drift off the mark when his concern shifted to the ability of his students to make a living.

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#33

Re: Why!?!

TomD

Yeah, I think they were artistically inspired crayon in hand so to speak. I think that living with people who do this kind of stuff can have a huge effect, I am hoping a 180 into a bought deal department on Bay Street... But it is funny, one day they will marry someone who can't even knot a shoe lace and wonder why it is that he can't make everything in the house from scratch. But they will still be happy.

My sister got her PHD in maths from Oxford and CMU. She once remarked that not all/any of her students seemed to really get math, like when they see a "5" they are thinking of 5 apples say, not even the number on a number line (I don't know) of rational numbers. I felt for her. :). My dad is a concert level pianist, I like Frank Zappa. It sounds nice when he plays the piano, but I am not sure it means exactly the same thing to him as it does to me...

I'm not bitter... (the kid in the dress was not the one who did this):


Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#34

Re: OT: TV Internet and Shopping...

TomD

Speaking of stuff like toy boxes... I was looking through Esquire at the Wal-mart the other day, and I noticed a list called something like "70 things we CAN agree on". One of them was Children, Country, Work, or some such. Children were first. I think that is the wrong way around. I'd take a bullet for any of my kids, and what is more I know that I would. But at the same time I sure don't rank them first. Of course it depends on the context. You make sure the horse is comfortable and fed before you feed yourself, but it isn't because the horse is more important than you. The court only cares about the welfare of the children in say a divorce, because they can't take care of themselves, not because they are more important than the parents (though in some cases that would be the best remaining hope).

So... maybe the kids need to learn that if you work throughout your life, and stay true to your soul, you get to have a sandpaper cabinet, that you made for yourself. Is the lesson there stronger than that magic boxes drop randomly into your play space?

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#35

Re: Why!?!

Pam Niedermayer

I am hoping a 180 into a bought deal department on Bay Street

I haven't a clue what this means. Parse it for me? Please.

As to math, I think maybe it's your sister who doesn't get it. I understand what she's saying, it's all about the abstraction and working in the abstraction; but really, a number is just a label that we put on line that makes it possible to manipulate mathematically, and it's reality is n apples.

Pam

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#36

Re: Why!?!

TomD

Bay Street is our Wall street. A bought deal is when you foolishly/brilliantly reduce the issuer's cost and snag all the fees by going long without fully marketing the deal. There is no preliminary prospectus. One alternative is the fully marketed deal where with PP in hand you market the deal to get some idea of price, and to lay off some of the financing risk if only at the level of collegiality. You need large institutions relative to issuers, you need them to be fairly transparent types of businesses, and you need to be willing to blow said proportionally large institutions out of the water if market conditions change. Various liability reducing devices have been added. It transfers financing risk to the underwriter. Sounds lucrative.

Well it is always possible she has was just messing with me on the math. But I doubt it, she is very serious. I know what she means at a certain level. I don't see boats as things a lot of people sit in that float. I see them in terms of the elements of service, flows, distribution of buoyancy, load paths, etc... These aren't just things I analyze and attach to boats, they are how I experience boats, which at times is a little unnerving. Scientists may not see solids they see little clouds of energetic particles (?). I'm not sure what she would say today.

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#37

Re: Why!?!

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks for the explanation of your market deals, very interesting how important the terminology.

As to math, I was a math major through 1st year of college, when I realized that I didn't begin to understand applied math. I didn't intend to say your sister was wrong about doing math, but that her students probably did get it better than she said. (Note: I don't consider pure mathematicians scientists.) But enough of this, way outside of woodworking.

Pam

Re: finished sandpaper cabinet

#38

Re: Why!?! The Real Woodworking campaign

TomD

Paul Sellers has this campaign. I think I would agree with all his stuff, I don't think it rules out excellence of personality in work, but it might have something to do with the stuff in this thread.

"The Real Woodworking campaign is:

Making really beautiful things from wood

Making really practical and functional things from wood

Making things from wood that people can really interact with and enjoy

The Real Woodworking Campaign is NOT:

Making shavings for the sake of it

Making furniture and objects that are made to look and not touch

Making isolated joints and doing procedures without a context"

I think one problem for a lot of beginners is insufficient practice of isolated joints or skins. The driving range, but I don't think that is probably what he is "against".