New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Next project....a sharpening station

Posts

Next project....a sharpening station

#1

Next project....a sharpening station

roger lance

I'm seeking your input on a sharpening station I will be making for my basement shop. I'll be using water stones and there will be a sink close by with hot and cold water. I'm proposing to make a cabinet about 24"w - 42" l - 36" h with a formica top to protect against water. There will be three drawers on full extension slides....5", 7", & 9" in height....and leg levelers (of course)....and poly to protect the wood. Any recommendations you have on design or features would be appreciated....do you favor shelves over drawers or some other covering....is 36" a good height for sharpening....etc....etc?? Thanks.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#2

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Pam Niedermayer

Rather than formica, why not make granite counters? Flat.

Pam

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#3

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Guillaume Dery

Hey Roger, I jsut checked it out. for me, 36" is bang on the money for my height (just shy of 6') and my body mechanics when sharpening. You may want to adjust accordingly depending on your specs.

As far as formica goes... yuck! I think you are over worrying about the effects of water. You aren't exactly sloshing it around even when using waterstones. A tray or waterproof liner will serve you fine.

As far as design, quite a few things can be cribbed from Tom Fidgen (unplugged workshop). His sharpening bench meets quite a few requirements and would be darn near ideal for a lot of people. It's worth looking at for inspiration if nothing else.

Drawers are goodness. I am a fan of fit srawers sized to accomodate all your parapharnelia.

Next question (which influences your design) is what type of sharpening you will be doing. I will again refer to Tom because I like his philosophy of a station for all sharpening activities. In my case that would mean all edge tools in addition to saws and accomodate the power side of things (AKA the grinder).

So I have a granite reference plate set into mine (flat to within a thou) sort of in the middle, on the right hand side, I have an insert cutout which accomodates the grinder (premounted to a plate which fits the insert cutout) or my waterstone tray (keeping the top mostly dry). The waterstone tray is fairly permanent and the grinder comes out from behind it's door only when needed (then you swap the 2 out).

Left hand side has the saw vise mounted in the front and a metalworking vise on the edge.

just my 2 cents, your actual mileage may vary.

guillaume

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#4

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I agree with the recommendation for granite over formica. Laminates will eventually come apart.

Three years ago, when we ripped apart the garage/shop to add on a consulting suite above for my practice, I took the opportunity to install running water for a sharpening centre. This is situated near the bench.

Along one wall, where cabinets need to be kept shallow to make room for one car (mine! :D ), under a window I built a centre that included space for waterstones, a Tormek and a half-speed dry grinder, and a granite shelf.


Inside that cabinet are drawers which house all sorts of sharpening paraphinalia: more stones, pastes, guides, etc.

Above is a space for the waterstones: Shaptons 1000, 5000 and 12000 (set up for side sharpening) ...


The dry grinder has the Tormek BGM-100 rest, which allows it to work together (swap over) with the Tormek.


Hope this helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#5

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a 36 inch cabinet for decades; I think it is a good height. Mine has an enamel top, but one I used before had Formica and Ian Kirby recommended Formica years ago. You might like the configuration of my cabinet. At the top are three drawers: two shallow drawers at the left and one deep drawer at the right (9 high, 10 wide, 16 back), a bin where I keep rags for wiping. Below is a cabinet door. In this space is a narrow shelf at the back.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#6

Banish the power grinder

Bill Tindall

Over time my grinder (the wheeled kind) had been banished ever more remote from woodworking activities. If a soft stone is used, which is recommended, it will shed particles of abrasive grit. These will eventually show up on some piece of wood if great care is not taken. A 60 grit aluminum oxide particle embedded in a board will mill a nice scratch down a plane bottom and right through the blade edge to boot. While I am a fan of hollow grinds this tool produces evil waste.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#7

Just put it in a corner somewhere...

david weaver

The dry grinder is the last power tool I'd give up. If I gave up every single other power tool in my shop (and there aren't that many), I'd probably give up the dry grinder last.

I have built-in closets in my shop that create a corner in the middle of the room. My grinder has dust chutes in the back, and nearly all of the stone bits and swarf go out the back. The area behind the grinder in the corner is dirty, but I have not had a piece of metal or abrasive dust from it ever show up on the surface at my bench, or on any of the wood in my shop. I don't have power dust collection, so there's no time that I have high volumes of air moving around - I don't think that'd make much of a difference on that heavy coarse dust, though. I'd guess that my grinder is probably 8 feet from the back end of my bench with the ports pointed the other way.

I wouldn't have it near my stones, which are on the other side of the bench. I can make the 15 foot walk to the grinder from the stones without a problem, much more easily than I can tolerate slopping water around in the tormek on a regular basis. I can't remember the last time I turned on the tormek, maybe the last time I turned something, who knows?

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#8

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

david weaver

Drawers and doors better than shelves.

Someone left me a machinist bench about 2 feet deep by 4 1/2 feet long when they moved out of my house. It had a small machinist vise on it on one end and a piece of railroad track on the other end. I replaced the vise with a bigger one.

It's all enclosed - three large drawers in the middle and one shallow drawer on the top of those 3. I keep my turning tools in the bottom drawer, some tormek and grinder parts in the next, and the other two are filled with stones.

There is a door on each side of the drawers that goes the full height of the bench (about 36" for the height of the bench, and the doors probably start within 3 inches of the floor). I keep grinding wheels, some rags and some bits of granite, etc in those.

Enclosed is nice, it means no matter how much wood dust, etc, is floating around the shop, or no matter how much saw filings come off when sharpening a saw, nothing gets on the surface of the stored stones.

I'm glad someone left the bench behind - it's heavy and stable, and I never would've gone to the trouble to make or buy something as comprehensive.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#9

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

wilbur

As far as height goes, it's good to be able to get over the top of your tool for sharpening. I'm 5'6", and my sharpening station is about 29" tall, which is the same as my workbench height using the "first knuckle of the pinky" rule.

I'm quite jealous that you have plumbing in your shop. I make do with a couple of gallon milk jugs and a small tray to deal with the water.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#10

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

I second the Tom Fidgen dedicated sharpening bench which I am building now. I will use water stones and also have a granite surface plate. Norm had a project during his New Yankee show that had lots of flexability built in i.e., a Tormek station and another station for stones, lots of drawers, on wheels, etc.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#11

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

James Watriss

Formica's one option. Coating the top with epoxy is another.

I have a long shop sink in our bathroom, so all I did was make a table that spans the sink. I bought a cheap set of plastic drawers to hold stones, and that works fine.

Sharpening itself is pretty simple. Having everything in the same place cuts down on time. Having immediate access to everything cuts down on time. Not having fitted inserts for everything makes it easier to bring in new stones or paraphernalia.

I'd start with a list of EVERYTHING you use. Stones. Flattening stuff for the stones. (sandpaper and granite plate? Diamond plate?) etc. If there's a grinder, bring that as near as is practical. (See Bill's advice.) sharpening jigs if you have em. Angle gauges if you have em. A small square to check that the edge is actually at 90. Rags for wiping tools down between grits. A basket for dirty rags. Rubber gloves if you use em. A GOOD source of light that's directly overhead, so you're not sharpening in your own shadow.

Go from there.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#12

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Pam Niedermayer

Formica's one option. Coating the top with epoxy is another.

That does work. I built a darkroom sink 30+ years ago, painted the interior with white marine paint, worked great. However, nothing sharp was ever dragged across it, don't know what would happen then.

Pam

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#13

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Guillaume Dery

+1 on the lighting. I Forgot to mention it. One of those magnifying lamps on the sharpening bench/station is a definite godsend. A well spend $30 if you ask me! Of course you may have superb vision and not need it but for my eyes, the light plus magnification is a definite boon for inspecting edges, finding stray particles of grit, etc.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#14

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I must qualify what I said about formica. It occurred to me that I have been using a section of a kitchen bench (for the waterstones) for several years without any issue. Obviously not made by me. It was glued (?) to a water-resistant core (chipboard), and it has been unaffected by numerous soakings. On the other hand, if I had laminated the formica to a ply core it probably would have lasted one day! :\

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#15

My opinion on the worrying about the surface..

david weaver

I know you guys are beating around which is better, polyurethaned wood or formica or whatever.

But I think there is a better thing to do, and that is to just put an MDF slip over the top of your sharpening bench. The last thing I want to do is have water spill on my bench and worry about it, or have swarf spill over the side of my stone and worry about whether or not I care that some black stuff has settled into the surface on the grains (i don't scrap swarf off the MDF until it's actually got a three dimensional texture).

I figured I would be replacing MDF once a year, but in 4 or 5 years, I've not done that. In the middle of my bench is one of those enco deal 12x18x3 granite plates, nothing has ever moved, the MDF is still flat (it's not all bubbled up from water like I was concerned it would be, etc).

Make the top whatever you want and then just put something over it that you don't care about, and that won't warp, and then you won't have to worry about fines or metal or grit getting on your sharpening station top.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#16

magnification

Bill Tindall

I could not sharpen without some sort of magnification. In my case it is a 10X hand lens of high quality. In the case of the person that brought the Dunlap plane that wouldn't, a quick 10X inspection revealed the problem instantly. Examining progress with a hand lens moves one up the learning curve as a result of the feed back of what is going on at the edge. I could go on and on about the value of this aid. Personally I find a hand lens more convenient than a large magnifier.

However one needs to know how to use a hand lens, which apparently many don't. The lens goes next to your eye and the object examined is adjusted to get focus.

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#17

Re: Just put it in a corner somewhere...

roger lance

thats where the dry grinder is....in a corner....and will not get close to the new wet sharpening station.


Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#18

Re: Just put it in a corner somewhere...

Guillaume Dery

Hey Roger, I notice the absence of a tool rest. Out of curiosity, do you freehand your grinding?

Re: Next project....a sharpening station

#19

Grinding platforms are in the drawers....

roger lance

no freehander here :D .