New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Paul Sellars

Posts

Paul Sellars

#1

Paul Sellars

Bruce Mack

Forgive me if this has been mentioned. In a recent video on his blog, Paul Sellars does a lightening fast hand sharpening of a chisel, dismissing the need for a flat bevel or micro bevel. I grabbed an old diamond plate and used 3 diamond pastes in succession, arriving at a wicked edge on a beat up Stanley after stropping. Not saying I'm tossing my rolling guides or water stones, but this is a revelation. Grab an old chisel and try it, after looking at the video a couple of times.

Re: Paul Sellars

#3

Observation.....

roger lance

he does not show how sharp or dull each chisel was before sharpening....therefore, it is difficult to know just how much of an improvement in sharpness was made....I suspect these chisels were not all that dull at the start of the demonstration (they both had flat polished backs).

Re: Paul Sellars

#4

Re: Observation.....

Stuart Johnson

I don't know how dull or sharp they were to start but I took some classes by him at Homestead Heritage and did see him use the same process on beat up ones used by students. Doing it though is not as easy as watching. It does take a fair amount of practice and experience.

Re: Paul Sellars

#5

Re: total time spent...

david weaver

..is at least as great as the time spent using a two stone setup and a hollow grind.

It's more time than I spend with two stones - one being a 1k ceramic stone and the second a 15k ceramic stone.

Time saved is in the stropping - if you feel the need to do it at all, the burr is so small that you can palm strop it off as you take 4 steps back to the bench.

Perhaps if I included hollow grinding once every three serious hones it would average out to the same amount.

I couldn't imagine taking a lot more time than that to sharpen a chisel.

Re: Paul Sellars

#6

Re: total time spent...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sellers uses very coarse stones for grinding material away. He calls his 1200 stone superfine. Then he uses his strop as a hone. That he takes an inordinate amount of time on his strop-hone suggests that he would be better off with an intermediate stone. On the other hand Toshio Odate uses a 1200 stone for for his rough removal and says if you need a coarser stone perhaps you waited too long to sharpen.

When I look at the picture of Seller's chisels, they appear to have a bevel considerably greater than 30 degrees at the edge. The picture at the beginning of the video looks like the chisel is held at 40 degrees. If he really does have 30 degrees at the edge and they angle back at progressively lower angles, one could use his same argument to claim that they are weaker than a 30 degree flat bevel. A flat bevel takes no more time to achieve, even using Seller's methods.

Re: Paul Sellars

#7

Re: total time spent...

david weaver

Warren, I agree entirely - especially in regard to odate's comments. I suppose he (sellers) wants that curved bevel so he can use his chisel like a hand skew upside down and moderate depth. I don't know.

The rounded bevel on those chisels looks pretty blunt.

Everyone can do stuff differently, I guess. But, I hope people don't watch these video and think that it's a revelation or long lost secret that should be followed 100%. There will be someone else advocating something different on another video by next year, but a simple bit of experience and economy in sharpening resulting from it should negate the need for any more of it.

Every new person who comes along and wants to rehash the basics just keeps sending the discussions sideways.

Re: Paul Sellars

#8

Marc Adams Story

roninkokomo

Marc Adams tells the story of seeking out Tage Frid when Marc was starting to make furnoiture. Marc was horrified when he saw fFrid take a chisel to a belt sander and then finish the job with a diamonf paste charged felt wheel.

Marc was horrified and asked Frid why. FRid asked do you want to work wood or play with tools?

Not sure I can go there... but I do think some of us can get a little too anal about our chisels.

Re: Paul Sellars

#9

Re: Marc Adams Story

TomD

I think he charged his felt wheel with honing compound like the green compound or jeweler's rouge.

Back a few years I claimed to be able to go from the 80 grit grinding wheel to the green compound which was generally scoffed at until someone tried it. It would be better starting from say a 120, or taking a swipe on 220 paper before going to the compound.

During the diamond wars I repeatedly came back to the point that if a person didn't care about the craft of hand sharpening, dubing edges etc... it would be faster to sharpen on the grinder with compound.

Knife makers have been sharpening on belt sander for decades, they even have cork belts that can be loaded with compound.

Tage Frid's view have been in print an on video for a long time, one didn't need to search him out.

Power sharpening gear is at least as generally available and cheap as fancy stones.

At some point, someone with enough of a bullhorn, like a CS, will write an article in just the right way, and people will get what others have been saying for decades.

Re: Paul Sellars

#10

Re: oil stones

david weaver

I think CS went back toward oil stones not long ago. I can't remember his reasons.

I do agree that if someone doesn't have some sort of way of grinding, they're missing out. All of my cambered blades are sharpened only on power tools, with the exception of a polishing stone on the back of the iron from time to time.

For chisels, though, it takes about the same amount of time for me to sharpen with stones as it does with two belts, and the edge is a little better with stones (so long as the second stone is fine enough) and I can be a bit more thrifty with the metal.

It takes me about, I would guess, 30 seconds to sharpen a dull chisel on stones, and less than a minute to refresh the hollow when it needs to be refreshed - perhaps 30 seconds.

Unless someone really likes to sharpen chisels as a way to pass time, or unless they are grinding by hand on a stone out of some sort of principle, if it takes longer than that, it's maybe time to think about why, because it'll be a deterrent to going back and making sure the chisel is sharp.

I don't, though, see anything wrong with sharpening woodworking tools with powered abrasives. I certainly would much rather do that than do routine chisel sharpening with a guide.

Just my opinion.

Re: Paul Sellars

#11

Re: oil stones

TomD

I don't normally look at CS's stuff, but I was doing Underhill yesterday, and you know how that goes. I think he said he had always used oil stones. He comes from a state where they are mined, so maybe it is partly a local thing. I retried them when Krenov wrote about them, but I found keeping my hands clean a little tedious, and I try to keep stuff like oily rags down. And there are better options. I mainly don't dry grind just to save steel, as you say chisels being small are relatively easy to get sharp, however.

I do like to formally sharpen my Japaneses chisels, I wouldn't say to pass time. It is a skill like dovetailing, with an aesthetic pay-off. I have been at it for 30 years, so it is one of those things that becomes a part of one. If the shop burned down, it would no longer be something I felt a need to replace out of a sense of identity. I overcame it by making tools. Some day I will have a set of tools that I have all made. Saws are the last thing I have to tackle. Have to be as god as anything one could buy.

Re: Paul Sellars

#12

Re: oil stones

david weaver

I agree on the japanese chisels, and they are the only thing that I don't put on a power grinder.

I think that I have put a couple of *new* ones that came with a convex face and a lot of lacquer on a tormek, but that's certainly not the norm, because they look so nice properly prepared.

Even they shouldn't take too long to sharpen if they are not abused. A couple of minutes, maybe, and for someone going only for the look, you can run them all the way up on synthetics and use a natural finishing stone to make them look better.

There certainly is a premium on protection of the edge (from stupidty, not from general use) when you know you'll work nicks out by hand.

Re: Paul Sellars

#13

Re: oil stones

wilbur

Interestingly, I've picked up a few really well-used Japanese chisels on eBay, and they all had convex bevels. Now these weren't Tasais or anything like that, but they were obviously user chisels, and they had enough of a convexity that they were clearly sharpened a lot to get that way, so the condition of the bevel was probably not an accident.

In Odate's book, he makes mention of feathering the edge of a blade in his discussion on sharpening as well.

I did wind up flattening the bevels of those chisels I mentioned above, and I like flat bevels as well. But it goes to show that there are different ways to skin a cat.

Re: Paul Sellars

#14

Re: oil stones

david weaver

I haven't gotten any used chisels like that, but I have gotten some new that appear to have been made that way on purpose, plus they have a layer of lacquer. The tormek makes a shallow hollows, so it has been my tool of choice.

I'm not sure I could guess why older japanese chisels were like that, unless they were really convex, and then I'd guess it's for depth control using the chisel bevel down. But that's just a guess.

I wouldn't be against it, other than it's really not necessary in a good quality chisel and keenness suffers a little. On the opposite side of that, though, for a chisel a little chippy, it would add extra strength to the edge and maybe help stay away from the stones.

How is the overall quality of the chisels you're getting (assuming they have some age) compared to the chisels that are offered to us over here recently?

Re: Paul Sellars

#15

Re: oil stones

wilbur

The quality of these chisels is nothing special. They're not any better than the Imai chisels that I have, but not particularly worse, either.

As far as the reason for the convex bevel, my best guess is that a sharpening technique much like what Paul Sellers is demonstrating caused the convexity. There's nothing about these chisels that makes me think that they were specially used for carving or anything else that would require depth control or a convex bevel to help get out of the cut.

I have a few old western wooden planes. When I got them, the plane blades also had convex bevels.

Re: Paul Sellars

#16

Re: oil stones

david weaver

I only have one old plane of that type, got it to practice tapping out.

The bevel on it was put there with no particular care at all - really none at all, it almost looks like it got its shape at random - it's not parallel to the edge, it's not even, and no part of it evenly meets another part.

It's clear that it's well used, but not for fine work.

The same is true for a plane that was given to me by a friend - the plane belonged to his father, a carpenter in england. It's clear his father used it a lot, but it was not kept in the shape that a cabinet maker would use (the iron or the plane) so I think it's important to not conclude the used tools on ebay are the product of fine woodworking.

When I view current craftspeople on youtube (in japan), their tools are well cared for, and the bevels appear to be flat. That includes when they're sharpening their tools - they are more meticulous than I am, and they are apparently making a living doing it.

Re: Paul Sellars

#17

Re: oil stones

TomD

I have only had two actual shots at real Japanese craftsmen, they really do say stuff like their tools would be ruined if they were ever sharpened on a King stone, etc... It may just be a superior pose. But I don't count on that. People all have their ideas. It is hard to see how a chisel can be ruined more than one sharpenings worth, though.

Re: Paul Sellars

#18

Re: oil stones

Charles

I'm pretty sure Odate only feathers(ered) blades early in their use to get past the really brittle part of the blade. I have an old American Woodworker magazine (black and white days) where he discusses this very technique.

Re: Paul Sellars

#19

Re: Paul Sellars

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thanks for this post. I am not familiar with Mr. Sellars but his method is basically the same as mine. For years I have wondered about getting things like Tormeks or guides etc....thinking I am missing something. But since my chisels are sharp I have never been motivated to spend the money. For me, this is like affirmation....if it ain't broken, don't fix it.

Tom

Re: Paul Sellars

#20

not borken

Bill Tindall

there sure isn't anything "broken" in your designs or execution of them.

Re: Paul Sellars

#21

Re: not borken

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Designing comes easy to me. Execution of those designs? Well, maybe I should start my own "swear jar" and put it to a Roth IRA. ;-)

Re: Paul Sellars

#22

Re: Paul Sellars

Ron Hock

I say if it works, use it! Don't be afraid to experiment. And I agree about getting it sharp and getting back to work. For chisels this is all fine but be careful if using a convex bevel on a bevel-down plane iron. Avoid creating a bevel that's too steep right at the cutting edge. A plane iron needs relief (clearance) behind the cutting edge or it won't cut (and it'll drive you nuts if you don't know to look for it.) For a standard Stanley-style 45 degree bed bench plane, the maximum bevel angle is about 33 degrees depending on the type of wood you're planing (dry hardwoods can be planed with less relief.) Just a cautionary public service announcement. We return now to our regularly scheduled program.

Re: Paul Sellars

#23

You're right

wilbur

You're right, Charles. Odate does discuss this in the context of using a new plane blade. He also mentions using this strategy if planing a piece of wood that is more abrasive than you first thought, using the example of pine that happens to have bits of silica in it.

"Dubbing over the edge makes the blade a little less sensitive, and so less prone to chipping, but you should do this only when you have to."

So probably not an absolute prohibition against this technique, but certainly highly discouraged.

Re: Paul Sellars

#24

Re: oil stones

Charles Stanford

Wouldn't it be practically exhiliarating to learn of an Asian woodworker who preferred oilstones, Sheffield steel, and Chippendale?

I always loved Iron Chef Sakai from the original series - specialized in French cuisine. Refreshingly unstereotypical.