Re: oil stones
david weaver
I think CS went back toward oil stones not long ago. I can't remember his reasons.
I do agree that if someone doesn't have some sort of way of grinding, they're missing out. All of my cambered blades are sharpened only on power tools, with the exception of a polishing stone on the back of the iron from time to time.
For chisels, though, it takes about the same amount of time for me to sharpen with stones as it does with two belts, and the edge is a little better with stones (so long as the second stone is fine enough) and I can be a bit more thrifty with the metal.
It takes me about, I would guess, 30 seconds to sharpen a dull chisel on stones, and less than a minute to refresh the hollow when it needs to be refreshed - perhaps 30 seconds.
Unless someone really likes to sharpen chisels as a way to pass time, or unless they are grinding by hand on a stone out of some sort of principle, if it takes longer than that, it's maybe time to think about why, because it'll be a deterrent to going back and making sure the chisel is sharp.
I don't, though, see anything wrong with sharpening woodworking tools with powered abrasives. I certainly would much rather do that than do routine chisel sharpening with a guide.
Just my opinion.