New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

M&T Glue Up Question

Posts

M&T Glue Up Question

#1

M&T Glue Up Question

Todd Nebel

I need some guidance on a project underway. The sides are solid cherry 3/4" thick and 13" wide. I'll be joining them to the posts with M&T. I've divided up the tenons into three. The tenons are 1" deep and 3/8" thick. There's a 1 1/4" gap between them. How should I glue (and peg) this up to allow for seasonal wood movement? Would you change anything you see in the photo? I've only cut this one joint.

Thanks,

Todd

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#2

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

TomD

AS far as I can see most quality furniture does not use pegs. And some pegged woodwork, I have seen in timbers or doors (wedges also) does not use glue. I don't peg, notwithstanding CS's need to make a deadline.

Glue wise The three tenons are supposed to deal with the issue. The only tenon I have had let-go was a 2 tenon job in a writing, desk, possibly some hide glue that had cooled a little too much. The other seven joints were fine.

One thing I wonder about is how tight the tops of these should be. Normally in glued joints we need to really tune the faces, but there can be a little in the sides. Whereas other traditions go the other way. I am starting to think we need good contact in the faces, slip fit, and tight fit on the tops so that if the joint experiences movement, it can't shear out the faces.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#3

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

roger lance

Todd....this situation has often been puzzling to me in the way some choose to handle it....it appears to me to be no different than a table top and a breadboard edge, in which case, you should glue the top tenon (keeping the top of the table level and allowing movement at the bottom of the case) and let the other two be pegged to move freely....you would have to make a little room in those two mortises for this movement (lengthen the mortise or reduce the width of the tenons)....lets see what is said.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#4

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Pam Niedermayer

The allowance for wood movement is built into the 3-smaller rather than 1-big tenon approach. The smaller tenons presumably won't change width enough to break out any of the mortises; whereas the one large tenon likely would. So I'd glue all three of them and enjoy. I don't see any particular reason to peg them, but you could if you want that look.

Pam

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#6

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Frank D. in Montreal

It seems to me that Todd could divide the joint up into any number of mortise-and-tenons, but he would still have 13" of moving wood to deal with, something which the post couldn't do if the board with the tenons is restrained by glue at both ends. Dividing the joint into 3 tenons saves the tenons from potential splitting, but it seems to me that this just transfers all the forces that could cause a split to the board itself.

Of course I could be missing something...

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#7

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Yes, but doesn't the whole board change width with the seasons? And, if so, wouldn't tenons that are tight on their mortises across the width of the board lead to cracks in the board?

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#8

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Pam Niedermayer

Depends on in which direction the grain is running. I'd expect the tenon board to expand but not the leg, and with not that much effect since it's almost independent of the leg. To insure that I'd probably make the two end tenons shorter, take some off the ends of each.

Pam

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#9

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Mark Salomon

As others have said, the wide board must be able to expand. How and where you allow it to do so is your choice. The easiest, and probably the best way for a table, is to glue (pinning isn't necessary unless you like the way it looks) the upper tenon and allow the bottom tenon to remain unglued. If this were a breadboard end you might want to glue the middle tenon only and let the outer ends expand/contract with the seasons. Also, since you used three rather than the usual two mortises/tenons you could also glue the top half of the middle tenon although I suspect that it won't make much of a difference. You will also need to reduce the width of the middle tenon a bit and the lower tenon a bit more to allow for expansion. It's not necessary to figure the shrinkage exactly to size the tenon for a board of this size, I just reduce the tenon width by a quarter of an inch or so and it seems to be fine. On the other hand, if you are fitting a wide table top you would want to be more exact in calculating the tenon and mortize size.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#10

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Tony - Memphis

I built a low boy a while back with a similar arramgement. I glued all of the tenons. No issues after a few seasons. No pegs and the material is walnut. I was concerned, but so far, so good!

Tony

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#11

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

TomD

Roger,

If I really felt that, and there is a point, I would probably try something totally different like a sliding dovetail with a large floating tenon. Where this situation is different is that the leg takes huge loads that try to rip one end of the joint off, that one does not see with the breadboard. In fact breadboard ends are kinda optional. They have an aesthetic, and they can be structurally essential as with some bench designs, but they can equally be left off without any hardship. Legs on a table being a whole other mater.

Another option would be rebated tenon, and hardware bonded studs, like if it was something that really took a load. Obviously table have been built without for a long time. But basically bed construction.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#12

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Phil

A quick check of the shrinkage calculator shows that delta from min to max width of that 13" cherry board due to low/high humidity could be about 3/16", +/- (going from 40% to 60% RH). If you wanted to do it according to Hoyle, I think you might:

1. Glue/peg the center tenon.

2. Trim the outside tenons to allow for wood movement (above)

3. Drill slot (instead of round hole) in outside tenons for pegs to allow tenons to move, with same allowance as was used in step 2.

Keep in mind I am a rank amateur, but I have done this, for a table breadboard end. It is possible that none of this is necessary, that is largely a function of the environment the table will be exposed to. My cherry table top moves about an eighth of an inch from spring/fall to summer/winter (heat in winter/ ac in summer, high humidity spring/fall), but the table top is about 30" wide. Based on my experience with the 30" wide table top, you might be able to get away with gluing the whole magilla, but then that would not be according to Hoyle.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#13

Hmmm, Hoyle was a bridge (cards) player.


Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#14

This is a card table, isn't it? 


Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#15

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Todd Nebel

Hi Tom,

Thanks for the feedback. Sounds consistant with what I remember reading in the past. Seems like there's a different approach when constucting a wide board and post joint verses a breadboard edge. In the former you can glue all the tenons, in the later you glue the middle and peg (in slots) the outer tenons.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#16

Frank, Bill, and Pam

Todd Nebel

Thanks for the feedback. I think I will make the lower two tenons a quarter inch smaller to give the board just a little more releaf.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#17

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Todd Nebel

Thanks Tony. Just what I wanted to hear :)

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#18

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Todd Nebel

Thanks Mark. I will reduce the middle and lower tenons by a quarter inch.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#19

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

Todd Nebel

Thanks Phil. Good to know the expansion is 3/16". I'll use that when trimming down the middle and lower tenons.

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#20

Re: Frank, Bill, and Pam

TomD

It is the bottom one that normally breaks. In the Watts desk I built the tenons were 2.5 inches wide, and separated by .5" So you may have gone far enough?

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#21

Re: M&T Glue Up Question *LINK*

Phil

Link to Bill Hylton's Power Tool Joinery: see his comments on mortise/tenon width

(middle column of pg. 94 second to last paragraph):


Bill Hylton's Power Tool Joinery

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#22

My Theory

Bob Lang

Another very good reason to split the tenon is to maintain the strength of the leg. While the general principle of allowing for wood movement is sound, the numbers in the charts are a worst-case scenario for a board that is exposed to the environment on all sides. You might see 3/16" seasonal movement on a 13" wide board, but I don't think you would see that when the wide apron is assembled to the leg. Why not? One thing never mentioned in charts of movement is how long the process takes. In my neighborhood we have humid summers, and dry indoor conditions in the winter. But it takes months to go from one extreme to the other and then back again.

When wood takes on (or loses) moisture it does so from the outside in. For the assembled tenons to change, the interior of the leg has to have already changed. And by the time the leg is done swelling from increased humidity, the leaves have started to fall and it starts to shrink back again. In short, the moisture content on the tenon doesn't change anywhere near as much as it would, if it were exposed to the air.

It might be prudent to glue one of the three tenons and pin the others if you were building a piece in Seattle and shipping it to Phoenix, but under most conditions gluing all three would work without causing problems.

Bob Lang

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#23

Antique experience with this construction

Bill Tindall

This following information is sourced from American Period Furniture, page141, Jeffrey Greene and Jeff Headley, personal communication.

The problem you present is common to various period pieces such as dressing tables and the bases of high chests. It is typical to see this piece split in period pieces, even when the wood is mahogany, the most stable wood we build with.

Greene offers an assembly technique(pre-compression) that is claimed to mitigate the problem. Headley just said such a piece will eventually split and don't fret it. In both shops, all the tenons (and three are typical to keep strength in the leg) are glued.

However, I have kept track of a piece of walnut this wide that is a combination of flat and quarter grain and it moves less then 1/16 over the course of years in my shop. In spite of claims otherwise, the humidity in climate controlled homes doesn't vary to extremes, so it follows that wood will be more stable in this environment. I don't need to humidify in the winter but I control the humidity to less than 60% in the summer, so my seasonal excursion for this test piece is only a 20% range. Certainly if the piece never experiences large variations in humidity it won't split. I would expect it to split regardless what you do if it does experience wide humidity swings. People that have bread boards ends to things know that response to humidity changes is weeks not months. As they say, "results may vary".

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#24

Re: My Theory

Pam Niedermayer

You are certainly correct; and this illustrates once again the principle of "storing" wood and/or metal in wood cases for protection from humidity. However, if the one long tenon fits the leg mortise perfectly and is anchored perfectly, it could almost replace the strength lost from the leg.

Pam

Re: M&T Glue Up Question

#25

Re: My Theory

Bob Lang

There is strong enough to sit in one place, and strong enough to survive an accidental kick to the leg or other such mishap. Yes, the glue bond is stronger than the wood itself, but when something does break it is almost always the weakest area of wood that is closest to the joint.

Bob Lang