New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

On the subject of benches - a vice question

Posts

On the subject of benches - a vice question

#1

On the subject of benches - a vice question

Guillaume Dery

Since Derek started the ball rolling with his bench build, I also will have an upcoming bench build (old one was left behind) as soon as my shop build is done.

So here is my question for discussion, and yes, it is a serious question.

Do I really need to incorporate vises at all? What benefit would they bring me?

A bit of background/explanation:

- I am a mostly hand woodworker

- I work the edges of boards by using a birdsmouth to secure them

- I am used to using wedges in double rows of parralel dogholes to secure panels for working on their faces or edge profiles

- I use holdfasts to secure parts for mortice and drilling operations

- I plane long boards against a planing stop

- I use a bench hook for x-cuts

- I use a shooting board

So apart from sawing the long edge of boards (dovetails, etc.), for which I intend to use a Moxon vice to bring the work up to a more comfortable height, I can't fathom what benefits/use either a face or tail vice will be to me.

I must be missing something but right now I am toying with the idea of omitting vices from my next bench entirely. Please chime in and tell me what I would be giving up.

Cheers,

Guillaume

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#2

potential....versatility....

roger lance

making a bench is an individual matter....make it to suit you....but I'd make it so that if I were to change my mind in the future, adding vises could be done....sounds a little like being asked by a younger worker why should I reduce my check by investing in the 401k program....I'm young....I want my money now....retirement is so far off....thats for old people....well, grasshopper....

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#3

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

James Watriss

You have perfectly described the bench that Ian Kirby worked on for many years. He used F-clamps and a pop-up plane stop. Nothing more. I think he added a vise later on, but he was able to work perfectly well up until that point.

Build the bench you've described. Adding a vise later isn't a crime. (Nor is it difficult.)

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#4

My experience ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Guillaume

So here I am building a bench that uses a Benchcraft tail vise .. a wagon vise. I explained why I chose this vise in an earlier post, but what I may add is why I have chosen to incorporate a tail vise at all.

Shocking admission - I have never used a tail vise. My current bench has a Record 52 1/2 as a face vise and, over the past 5 or 6 years, another in the tail vise position. It never functioned particularly well as a tail vise, partly because the bench was never flat enough in this section, and partly because that particular vise was in poor condition.

For most of my woodworking life I have simply used a bench stop, dogs, or hold downs on the bench top for faces. The face vise gets used for thick boards that will not bend.

My priority is a face vise for edges (I shall be using a leg vise on the new bench), and a bench stop for faces. So why now include a tail vise?

Well, I believe an end vise will add a great deal of utility. Just because I have got by without one does not mean that I want to continue doing so. The acrobatics I go through to accomplish simple work-holding tasks is no longer something I want to continue doing ... and unnecessary with a good tail vise.

It is quite possible to go without any vises, even a face vise, but they do make the job of work holding quicker and less stressful.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#5

I'm excited for you....

roger lance

Derek....you are going to love having a fully functional....fully effective tail vise....I must use my shoulder and tail vise almost equally....I think the square dogs slanted at 88 degrees was also a good move.

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#6

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

TomD

I thnk your current list of holding methods sounds great.

Assuming this isn't about cost, or time to make, and that all we want is to have the best possible bench, I think some version of the two vise bench is the best possible bench, but there is nothing saying the bench has to hold all the vises. That the bench has to be "it". I really don't see any problem with a tail vise of some kind. Should allow you to do everything you currently do, and then some.

The problem with the face vise, particularly on a short bench is that it stands you off the bench. I think a face vise is as useful as the rest of the bench put together, but whether it needs to be on the main bench is a fair question. There are lots of parts that I don't really see how a Roubo would hold them. Working on a handsaw grip using hand tools, I go at it alternating rasps, spokeshaves, and fitting my hand to the grip. The grip probably exits the vice a hundred times, particularly if it is the first of a type. I don't know how that works on a Roubo. I wouldn't want to make a guitar neck, and head, without some kind of vice. Or work inside a plane.

In the past we had the European bench, and that yelled "cabinetmaker". Times have changed and the Roubo bench, usually in some oddball form, originally designed for architectural work, is now becoming the standard. So people invent reasons why it is the best. It's like the Mountain Bike fad. Great type of bike, but 99% were never used in a mountain. Just as today 99% of the fixie bikes never see a racing oval. Stuff comes and goes. Make your own rules.

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#7

Re: My experience ...

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, I've never used a tail vise, either. Strange; but in contemplating a new bench, I think I would like one and I think the new LV tail vise would be perfect, maybe. I know it doesn't meet your needs; but on the off chance you've looked at it, do you know if it's possible to use it with a much deeper front, say 3-4" rather than what appears to be 1.5" from front to back?

Pam

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#8

Re: My experience ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I have no information about the LV vise. I looked at it - LV always have novel solutions - however it did not fit my requirements for space-saving, which you recognised.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#9

OK, thanks. Hey, Rob!!!

Pam Niedermayer

I repeat my question to Derek, is there any reason the LV sliding tail vise jaw and apron couldn't be 3-4" thick, front to back?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#10

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

Guillaume Dery

Thanks Tom, that is probably the most thought out response I got so far. I was asking members of our woodworking group as well. Truth is, I think people forget how easy and useful old methods of holding work are. I know quite a few people who were literally agog when I just tapped some wedges tight to hod a large panel on a bench. It's like I blew their minds, they had never even thought of it.

My issue had been working the edges of panels. I thought (and still do) that I could get away with the Moxon or a holdfast through the leg and a sliding deadman. However, your point about shaping exercises is one I cannot ignore and for which I haven't got an answer. For that reason more than anything else, I think a face vise goes back into my design.

Of course, I will keep pondering this because I was sort of hoping to have a highly efficient bench without any vises. It was a self-challenge but perhaps it was also subconsciously to show off and I should just concentrate on the best tool for the task instead...

Anyhow, all this to say thanks for opening my eyes to what I was overlooking.

Re: On the subject of benches - a vice question

#11

Re: On the subject of benches - the simple side

TomD

Cheers! It may no be much help, but one thing that I share with the Rouboites is that I feel a lot of these problems go away if you make a long enough bench. At some point you have enough real estate to do everything a simpler bench would do, and everything a a vised up bench will do. Pretty obvious if you had a 12 footer, since one would in effect have 1.5-2 benches, but my "experience" suggest the real sweat spot is around 8'. Enough real estate to both hold anything any way, ignore any vise, and build anything that is to fit under an 8' ceiling, or reach regardless of the ceiling height. unfortunately a lot of the repros are very short, but this may be one of their strengths in that some vises will shorten the board that can be held to less than the bench OAL. While some of the hold-down systems will even allow pieces to overhang. The face vise can also allow edge planed boards to overhang. Not all one sided.

I share your interest in simple benches. I always wanted a Roubo, but the one in the Landis book. Interestingly, those guys who built it but moved on to vised-up benches. Other people from that book, like Svenson who did a fancy article on body mechanics for FWW (back when it was good), and who is further covered in the Landis book. He was promoting a trestle system I have built. Svenson moved to a vised-up bench while remaining a Japanese system teacher for Country Workshops, etc... Last I heard.

There was also Kip's testle sytem I built from the Landis book, and I also built an architectural system from one of Underhill's books. I built a bench of my own to plane battens for sails, that was sorta japanese.

Here are a few thoughts:

- A lot of pros, ans semi pros who use these simple benches, end up vised-up

- Japanese workmen do not have one type of bench. some of the benches going back quite a while, for instance for chairs, use vises. Others use some clever trapping system but are highly specific to single product, like a plane.

- Further some of the benches eager Californian "apprentices" jumped on were just timber framing beams, that were sitting on trestles, around the shot. Not benches in the conventional sense. Though benches pretty much all start from that root.

- Same with our western model, the more you do some repetitive thing, that a sticking board would hold, the less one relies on vises. But a blacksmith who holds all kinds of oddball stuff uses a vise, same with woodworkers.

- This is not my first rodeo, all this stuff went around once already, with the Landis book, and many others in the 80s. Then vised-up benches, then CS and the Roubo (Underhill was in there also). I'm sure people who go back before the 70s have seen this also. Morse commented on it in the 19th century.

I guess the only agreement one is likely to get is that it is easier to hold stuff if one has sharp tools to cut with. :)