Re: On the subject of benches - the simple side
TomD
Cheers! It may no be much help, but one thing that I share with the Rouboites is that I feel a lot of these problems go away if you make a long enough bench. At some point you have enough real estate to do everything a simpler bench would do, and everything a a vised up bench will do. Pretty obvious if you had a 12 footer, since one would in effect have 1.5-2 benches, but my "experience" suggest the real sweat spot is around 8'. Enough real estate to both hold anything any way, ignore any vise, and build anything that is to fit under an 8' ceiling, or reach regardless of the ceiling height. unfortunately a lot of the repros are very short, but this may be one of their strengths in that some vises will shorten the board that can be held to less than the bench OAL. While some of the hold-down systems will even allow pieces to overhang. The face vise can also allow edge planed boards to overhang. Not all one sided.
I share your interest in simple benches. I always wanted a Roubo, but the one in the Landis book. Interestingly, those guys who built it but moved on to vised-up benches. Other people from that book, like Svenson who did a fancy article on body mechanics for FWW (back when it was good), and who is further covered in the Landis book. He was promoting a trestle system I have built. Svenson moved to a vised-up bench while remaining a Japanese system teacher for Country Workshops, etc... Last I heard.
There was also Kip's testle sytem I built from the Landis book, and I also built an architectural system from one of Underhill's books. I built a bench of my own to plane battens for sails, that was sorta japanese.
Here are a few thoughts:
- A lot of pros, ans semi pros who use these simple benches, end up vised-up
- Japanese workmen do not have one type of bench. some of the benches going back quite a while, for instance for chairs, use vises. Others use some clever trapping system but are highly specific to single product, like a plane.
- Further some of the benches eager Californian "apprentices" jumped on were just timber framing beams, that were sitting on trestles, around the shot. Not benches in the conventional sense. Though benches pretty much all start from that root.
- Same with our western model, the more you do some repetitive thing, that a sticking board would hold, the less one relies on vises. But a blacksmith who holds all kinds of oddball stuff uses a vise, same with woodworkers.
- This is not my first rodeo, all this stuff went around once already, with the Landis book, and many others in the 80s. Then vised-up benches, then CS and the Roubo (Underhill was in there also). I'm sure people who go back before the 70s have seen this also. Morse commented on it in the 19th century.
I guess the only agreement one is likely to get is that it is easier to hold stuff if one has sharp tools to cut with. 