New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Need your opinions

Posts

Need your opinions

#1

Need your opinions

Stuart Hough

About ready to drill for the bench-bolt (bed-bolt) system to attach the front and back stretchers to the legs of the workbench. Tenons are four inches in height, three-quarters thick and 1.75 inches long (deep). Would it be better to go with one or two bolts (threaded rod). Would three-eighths or half-inch rod be advisable? Thanks for the help.

Re: Need your opinions

#2

IMHO, one 1/2" rod and nut at each...

roger lance

mortise/tenon will do the job....thats a big bed bolt....make sure the bolt extends well into the rail (3 - 4 inches anyway)....show a photo or two as your bench build proceeds....everyone likes to see a nice bench getting made.

Re: Need your opinions

#3

Never a shortage of opinions....

Bill Tindall

The function of the bolt is to keep the mortise tight. There is little stress on the bolt so long as the mortise is pulled up tight by it. 3/8" is a traditional diameter. Two would be beyond reason overkill.

Measure twice cut once. Well, when it comes to locating bed bolts 4 or 5 measurement confirmations is not too many. There is little room for error.

I drill the hole (I use drill press)in the bed leg, install the rail and using the bed leg hole as a guide bushing, drill through the leg and into the rail to the calculated depth. The hole in the leg must be parallel to the mortise or you risk running out the side of the rail. That said I have never had any problem doing this operation.

Re: Need your opinions

#4

Re: Never a shortage of opinions....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The method you described, Bill, is exactly how I've done it on six beds. They are solid as a rock and only one bolt is necessary.

Re: Need your opinions

#6

Re: 6 beds!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Well, this wasn't just last week, but over the course of about 25 years. First, bunks for the kids that got cut apart when we got a bigger house. Then as adults, I made their beds (and night stands, couches, tables, chairs and desks) and a couple for our spare bedrooms. I should branch out, though, because they're all oak except for one that's ash.

Re: Need your opinions

#7

Thanks for the advice!

Stuart Hough

I'll go with one 1/2" rod on each leg. As for locating the hole for the washer and nut, I'm planning on using a jig I saw in a PWW mag from a few years ago (see honey, I really DO need to save those 150 magazines!) that has two long dowel rods stuck into a squared block of wood. One rod goes into the hole and the other rides on the outside of the stretcher. The mark on the rod shows where the hole stops, so you can chop or drill out the opening for the nut and washer to mate with the threaded rod. I'll have pics as I get closer to completion. Thanks again!

Re: Need your opinions

#8

Re: Need your opinions

TomD

Best method is one piece of 1/2 rod that is epoxied into the end of the beam, goes through the leg/motise/hole strucure, and is captured by a nut.

The way you do this is you get a 3/4 speedbore bit and drill about 4 inches into where you want the 1/2 rod. More is better 4 inches is enough. you make a jig on your drill press that has a 13 mm hole through it, or any hole somewhat larger 1/2" You screw this centered on the end of the stretcher. Remove the jig and put the rod you will mount in the end of the beam into the jig using enough tape and wax so that you can hold it there, but get the jig off later.

Pour enough west epoxy in the hole to fill when the bolt is inserted, about 1/2 full. You can spread any slight overflow over the endgrain where it will do no harm. Insert the bolt and screw the jig in place. The jig needs to have tape and wax on it's contact surface.

The end result is a bolt that grows out of the end of your beam. It is a lot faster to do than talk about. It is self-centering without any real skill to get a perfect result. If you had a choice between buying a bolt with a nut on the end, or a bolt with a bunch of loose expensive parts that were hard to line up, weak, and left a big hole in the side of your project, which would you choose? Not only is it stronger, better looking and easier to make up, but the real pay-off comes every time you actually assemble a base, it is a pleasure without a lot of fishing for parts.

Another few advantages to this method are that you can do it in the middle of a piece so large there is no place to get a nut in. I did it one the breadboard for my bench which was pretty massive to have done a captured nut set-up; it can also be done on discontinuous or squiggly pieces of wood since the parts do not need to be all that accurately cut, which I suppose is also true with the alternatives, but it is easy in this case. And it reduces moisture uptake, output of the pieces rather than making it worse.

The only downside is that it requires a place to upend your beam that is tall enough for the beam. When I did this with my workbench, I had to do it in a stairwell, but most stretchers are easy.

This is a picture of a 165 foot (diameter) wooden windmill blade that the Gougeons made for NASA and GE. These were mounted with 24 small epoxy bonded bolts at the root. The loads are massive, but the method works great.

http://blog.mlive.com/tricities/2008/04/large_turbine%20blade.jpg

And of course there is a youtube video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHtf4zu5Xgo

The section "advanced fastener bonding" is closest to the mark, however we do not need the added cost of buying the white filler, and the method I described does not require you to drill an accurate hole to get an accurate result. Or I suppose it requires an accurate hole in a scrap of wood, just not in the potentially hard to maneuver beam itself.

This method does require some reasonably competent epoxy, 5 minute will probably not work or be easy to handle in this use. One needs WEST, MAS, System 3, etc... Most of these companies have sample size packs distributed at marinas, and boat stores, etc...