New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Adventures in the handplane SIG

Posts

Adventures in the handplane SIG

#1

Adventures in the handplane SIG

Guillaume Dery

Adventures in the handplane SIG

Part II – Making Krenovian Woodies


Introduction



So last Tuesday was a special day for the some of the handplane SIG members, we made our own planes! Our moderator, Jack, had offered this to anyone who wanted to participate and he was going to lead the charge and provide adult supervision/talk us through the building our own planes.

Due to overwhelming response from the OWA membership, we had to split into two groups to do the build. Being a keener, I volunteered for the first group. The build took place at Glen's shop (our usual SIG hangout).

In attendance were the following:

- Glen – I wonder if my insurance covers this – B. (our gracious host)

- Charles – Where do I attach the power cord on this plane – A.

- Ken – I’m going to have to build a pegged box to hold this – D.

- Guillaume – I wonder how long I can milk this not having a shop – D.

- Jack – I’ll keep building tools until I need more furniture – S. (our benevolent SIG dictator)

So before I go any further in describing the actual process (as has probably been done countless time on the web), please allow me to provide a bit of background and to do some philosophizing.

Disclaimer: Making your own tools is addictive! If you hoard your shop time like a miser and want to devote it solely to making furniture, please abandon this post immediately! Disregard all the benefits you could reap from building your own tools and run away from the computer screen right away! Jack is a prime example of this. I believe he started off innocently enough at one of Lee Valley’s plane building seminars. However, it seems to have mutated in an incurable disease. He has made quite a few smoothers and last time I dropped in on his shop, he had a prototype grooving plane (I call it a prototype because, although it looked fully functional, he was already planning the next revision), was working on a new smoother with integrated Norris adjuster, had finished his own plane hammer (from brass rod) and I helped him and Terry (another OWA member) get their Moxon vise prototypes off the ground (they did the hard work, I provided sarcastic asides). Since then, he has made a production run of hammer heads for the OWA membership. So, as you can see, this tool building thing can be quite an addiction. You are right to be scared. Personally, I call this the slippery slope, Mark 2. Or perhaps we are just greasing the already slippery slope…

One of the reasons I jumped at the chance to participate in the build, although I already have a sufficient arsenal of handplanes (If I ever finish the shop and get them out of storage), is that I firmly believe that to get the most out of a tool, one has to become intimately familiar with it’s workings and the relationships between the parts which make the whole. To become a better sawyer, understand a saw and the function of every part and configuration. To become a better planer, understand the components of a plane and how it interacts with wood. I could go on in this vein but that is probably best left to another article at another time. Needless to say, one cannot become more intimately familiar with a tool than when building it oneself. This is the same reason for which I encourage people to add a few vintage Stanleys to their plane arsenal and to refurbish them. You understand the way a plane works much better than when you just get a LN or a Veritas which work great out of the box. What is wrong with working great out of the box you ask? Well, when your entire experience has been with properly functioning tools, you have no idea where to start to correct issues when they do arise for one.

Still with me? Good, obviously you tolerate my ramblings and I haven’t scared you off with my disclaimer. On to the good part, the actual build.

Let me preface this by stating that what we built was a very basic Krenovian woodie, sans fancy lever caps, laminated sole, etc. This was a plane in its most simple form. So here are the materials and tools which are needed for this, as procured and provided by Jack.

What you need


Plane Material:



- 1 plane blank (this took the form of hard maple baseball blanks, chopped to length by Jack)

- Retaining pin (although a lot of people use wooden ones which are perfectly acceptable, Jack managed to coerce someone into turning some nice ones out of brass for us)

- ¼” dowel (cheap home-center stuff. This is just used to pin the parts together and will be part of the cut-off waste)

- Blade ( we used the LV replacement blades for their Taiwanese planes)

Tools Needed:



- Low angle block plane

- Chisel(s)

- Smoother or jack plane

- Accurate square

- 6” rule

- Clamps

Consumables:



- Wax paper

- Masking tape

Power Tools Used In the Shop:



- Bandsaw

- Chop-saw

- Drill press

- Jointer and Planer (optional, this could be done with handplanes)

The Process



Prior to getting together, everyone was provided with their own blank with the objective of 4-squaring it. As an aside, once you figure out which face will be the sole, you only need to 3-square it (the sole and both sides).

So we all arrived at Glen’s shop with our hand tools and maple blocks in tow, ready to make some planes. Jack handed out retaining pins and blades to all and sundry and we were off to the races (or at least awaiting word from our wise master, Jack…)

Step 1: Par 4.

Drill ¼ inch through holes at each corner. Placement is not critical as this is to insert the dowels for alignment and will be cut off in final shaping. Off to the drill press we went.

Step 2: Shave your cheeks.

This is a real simple exercise, figure out the width of your blade, plus a bit of room for adjustment and another extra bit to clean up the cut and account for the kerf. Let’s just say that 1/8th of an inch on either side. This will be the width of your center block. Minus that from the width of your blank, divide by 2 and presto, you know at what distance you need to set your bandsaw blade to slice off the cheeks. As an example, let’s say your blade is 1 ½ inches and your blank is 3 inches. Blade plus ¼ inch (1/8th per side) is 1 ¾. Blank (3) – 1 ¾ = 1 ¼ inches. Divided by 2, the nominal cheek thickness is 5/8. Set the fence at this distance and slice off that cheek.

Step 3: Joint prep.

Since we had access to power tools and were in a bit of a rush, no one seemed inclined to clean up those bandsaw marks up with a handplane… Off to the planer (side note, you should re-joint one side of the center block prior to the planer to ensure perpendicular and flat reference faces or plane the first face prior to slicing off the second cheek). Start by cleaning up the center block, ensuring you remove the same amount from both sides and that the thickness remains slightly greater than the width of the blade. Now set this piece aside and clean up the sawn face on each cheek. It is good practice to run both pieces through together to ensure that both cheeks are the same thickness (unless you want a lopsided plane). Reassemble and check the fit to ensure you will have a good glue-line joint (you did mark the sole with a triangle prior to band-sawing so you’d know which order pieces went in, didn’t you?).

Step 4: Time for bed.

Now it gets nerve wracking, we are going to cut our bed for the iron (and also the rest of the mouth opening). Off to the chop-saw we line up, like little duckies in a row. I had visions of a York pitch but since the saw was already set for 45 and I didn’t feel like friggin (or should that be frogging… no, wait, that’s for Bailey planes…) around with angles or resetting the saw, I, like everyone else, settled for a standard 45 pitch. I won’t get into mouth placement as that is a matter of taste, plane size and function, alignment of the stars, etc. The first cut is the bed (the 45 degree cut in this case).

Step 5: Make your bed.

Yay, hand tool time! That 45 degree bed needs to be planed smooth, perfectly flat and exactly 90 degrees to the sides. Take your time and do it right as this ramp will support your blade in use and there is no part more critical to the proper operation of the plane. Check your progress with a square and straightedge regularly.

Step 6: Humpty Dumpty, mouthing off.

Once step 5 is done, reassemble all the parts, pin them together, insert your blade and mark where it intersects the toe block. Carry this line around to the sole and mark the sole. This would form a zero clearance mouth if you cut the toe block exactly to that line. The reality however is that the mouth will open up a tad when we back bevel the toe ramp and a bit more when we true the sole. Off to the chop-saw again to whack off the clearance ramp in the toe block at 60 degrees (as memory serves me, which it rarely does). This is the point where Jack has me dig my off-cut out of the scrap bin; turns out I will need it for the wedge.

Step 7: Pin-holes for pinheads.

Again, memory is failing me on exact measurements… However, this is where we laid out the hole for the retaining pin. As I recall, we mark a line 1 ¼ inch up from a cheek. Then align the toe block on the cheek (you can drive in the dowels to ensure alignment) rest your small rule on the angled ramp and mark the point where 13/32 intersects the line you drew on the cheek. This is your center point for the indexing pin. Off to the drill press and drill a ¼” hole (in our case as the brass pin was turned at ¼ inch on the ends). Reassemble the entire plane using the dowels and carry that hole through to the other cheek.

Step 8: Make Red Green proud.

Tape, tape and more tape… Mark where your cheeks intersect the middle blocks then take the entire thing apart one final time. Now mask off the inside cheeks (leaving clearance for the retaining pin) as well as both ramps. You do not want to have to cleanup squeeze-out inside the plane.

Step 9: Sniff some glue

Based on Jack’s recommendation, we used standard yellow glue. Let’s just say that Jack has had some spectacular delaminations using 5 minute epoxy and won’t recommend the stuff… paint your glue on, pin with your dowels to ensure alignment and clamp the snot out of it to ensure a good glue line. Set it aside to grab and have a beer…Wait, what’s that Jack? There is more still to do?

Step 10: Wedgie

This was so simple it wasn’t even funny. Grab your off-cut, go to the bandsaw and slice off a wedge. Mine ended up being about 1/8th of an inch wide at the bottom and ½ inch on the top. It rides low enough to support the blade fairly low and fits tightly across its entire face. The only pain is smoothing the face of the wedge that makes contact with the blade…

Conclusion



We actually took the planes out of the clamps after about 45 minutes. This is where we stopped for the night. Astoundingly, the entire process took less than 4 hours with only final shaping left to be done. That is our homework, to finish shaping the plane to our liking (bandsaws are your friend), true the sole and make fluffy shavings. Had I known how easy this was, I would have done this a long time ago. It is amazing how our minds tend to throw up imagined obstacles and complications which don’t really exist. My thanks to Jack for taking us through this and providing guidance…He’s kinda all right for a crusty curmudgeon!

I did finally get that beer :)

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#2

Retaining pin question

Bill Tindall

More details on the pin please. Largely overlooked, until you get into it, this pin affords an opportunity to build a plane that is annoying to own if its engaging surface is not perfectly parallel to the bed. I have tried various ways to make the traditional wooden pin and none are handy or fool proof.

I would add another reason to build a plane...frugal. There are some kinds of planes that would be handy to own but not regularly used and hence difficult to justify for the planing frugal. I have made high and low angle Krenov style planes and planes of custom length, and even a hollow of large radius.

What is SIG?

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#3

SIG - Special Interest Group


Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#4

Re: Retaining pin question

Guillaume Dery

Hi Bill,

The pin was brass as mentioned. I believe it was turned down from 1/2 or 5/8" rod (someone else machined this for us).

The ends are turned to 1/4" diameter and then a flat is ground across the larger diameter until it is just proud of the end diameter.

As your question infers, accuracy is the key. this part needs to be machined precisely and then the iron bed (the ramp) needs to be dead square to the sides of the center block as well as dead flat. We spent some time ensuring that the drill press table was also dead square to the bit. Then it was just a matter of re-pinning the plane together and drilling through both cheeks in one pass to get the holes for the pin perfectly aligned.

Maybe we got lucky but my pin is perfectly parallel to the iron bed. I can see how making the wood pins may be frustrating to get them dead accurate. Since I am not a turner (just one of the many skills I lack, I am afraid), I can't really offer suggestions. Were I doing it, I probably would do it in my drill press and advance a file in a sliding vise so I could get dead accurate repeatability for reducing the ends. The flat is easily planed.

Yeah, my inner cheap ba@#%#d, appreciated this too. total cash outlay, $20. Also great for experimentation such as placing the mouth back etc.

BTW, damn you for mentioning a hollow. I am now pondering how difficult it would be to make myself a set of hollows and rounds as it is beyond my budget to actually purchase.

SIG is Special Interest Group. Since the Ottawa Woodworkers Association is a diverse group, in addition to our monthly meetings and special OWA activities, we also have a number of voluntary sub-groups who self-organize under the umbrella of the OWA. The handplane SIG seems to be where the galoots and galoots in training congregate.

Cheers from Ottawa,

Guillaume

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#5

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

Pam Niedermayer

In drilling for the pins (available at Hida, btw), it's easy enough to build a jig to hold a powered hand drill in the right spot, don't really need a drill press.

On smoothing the wedge, probably easier to do if you do it before you cut the wedge.

In general, sounds like lots of fun for a group build.

Pam

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#6

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

roger lance

Guillaume....having just caught the bug to hand cut my half blind dovetails, I now realize how poorly made my Crown marking/cutting gauge is and I also see a need to have more than one of these for convenience....so I'm assembling a little hardware to make my own....I'm confident I can do better....at least I've got to give it a go....tool making = another slippery slope.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#7

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

TomD

"- Glen – I wonder if my insurance covers this – B. (our gracious host) "

That was why I ended up giving up teaching. There was no insurance for the teacher, just the venue. I'm asset rich and income poor, relatively, so I could be wiped out.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#8

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

TomD

"In drilling for the pins (available at Hida, btw), it's easy enough to build a jig to hold a powered hand drill in the right spot, don't really need a drill press."

That drill Harrisson made was really neat. But.... I recently got a drill press off KIJIJI for $35 Can. There was one available, literally at every exit along the 401 for about that price. I have a huge drill but needed another one as the base for a CNC project. So it is cheaper to buy a drill press than even the cheapest new hand held drill or egg beater, and they are all over the place. That is actually a "problem" right now. You can buy all the milling machines and lathes to make your own Hotley, cheaper than you can buy a Hotley.

When I started out one reason to use hand tools was economy. A planer cost about 65% of a Buick Skylark. Today, between re-engineered consumer tools, far east production, and de-industrialization, and the always new keen stuff hand tool market, it is cheaper to buy stationary tools than hand tools.

"On smoothing the wedge, probably easier to do if you do it before you cut the wedge. "

One way I do it is make up the block, then saw off the cheek, and I like to flip them and if the saw marks come out nicely I sometimes leave them for grip. Then I retrue the center block. When I get around to cutting out the waste for the wedge block, the piece will come out with the sides and the op all true. The top side of this block become the bottom of the wedge, so it is true to start with. Some hand work needs doing to get the top surface of the wedge cleaned up, but it really can't be done before the wedge is sawn out. If that makes any sense.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#9

simple solution in the US

Bill Tindall

If anyone in US has this issue, form an LLC (limited liability corporation). They were created just for this kind of situation. I was an S-Corp but the paperwork is onerous. One day I called IRS to clarify some issue and the person directed me to form an LLC because they were created just for simple small business situations.

They are blessed by the IRS (income passes through to the owner(s), but are chartered by the states. One can set them up in any state so choose a state where the fees are low. At least in TN the paperwork to set one up is trivial and the necessary forms can be obtained from the state office for revenue. Legal Zoom may also aid in establishing an LLC. I hired an attorney to set one up but the process was so trivial he handed me the computer printed forms and told me to do it myself. A friend got charged $500 but his attorney went to the same church and some churches rely on brethren to provide services.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#10

"tool making = another slippery slope"

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Amen! This might be the slipperiest slope of all. :D Guilty as charged.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#11

Re: Retaining pin question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The pin's necked down to 1/4"; the holes are 1/4". I didn't see any explicit reference to gluing the pin in place. Won't it self-align the first time the wedge is tightened up?

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#12

Here is the problem

Bill Tindall

The way Finck suggests making these pins is to fashion a 1/4" diameter projection on each end of the rectangular pin piece. The challenge is to get the axis of both these projections parallel to the flat on the pin proper. If not coaxial the wedge will have to be tapered and a tapered wedge is a nuisance to adjust.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#13

Plane making pin question

Bill Tindall

Has anyone tried using just a cylindrical metal pin...no flat spot? I need to make another custom sized plane and I could easily fashion a cylindrical pin on the metal lathe if it would be serviceable.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#14

craigd

Re: Here is the problem

craigd

What I've done, with metal pins, is to use two concentric pins: a pin/axle through the cheeks and an outer pin with a flat. The outer pin is free to rotate (on the inner pin) and thus does align with the wedge.

The alignment doesn't have to perfectly parallel with the bed as the wedge can be shaped to condensate.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#15

craigd

Re: Plane making pin question

craigd

I've used a single metal pin but it works too well - setting the wedge causes the pin to put a [mild] dent in the wedge. Which is then a b**ch to remove. The flat has more bearing surface and doesn't dent.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#16

Re: Plane making pin question

Guillaume Dery

Using a larger pin and creating a flat in the middle section rather than reducing the ends would probably work well for you Bill and would take care of both your issue of maintaining the axis and of the issue of denting the wedge with a round pin. Haven't tried it but my gut instinct is this would work quite well. I'll actually try it on my next plane

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#17

craigd

Re: Plane making pin question

craigd

I just remembered - there is a wooden plane maker (I don't recall who, maybe Canadian?) who makes his pins out of an (I believe) aluminum rod with the middle (ie the part that contacts the wedge) filled flat, to about the center of the rod. The pin is not glued to the cheeks and so can self align with the wedge.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#18

Re: Plane making pin question

Pam Niedermayer

Again, I use brass pins sold by Japanese plane vendors like Hida in San Francisco. They don't dent, they don't touch wood except on the ends (they're really for holding a subblade in place, the main blade being braced in abutments). They aren't glued in place, but placed run through a hole in one side and then into a depression in the other side, the hole then plugged.


In fact, as I recall my western woodies, none of them have pins of any sort. There are wide abutments designed to hold both blade and wedge, and the fronts hold the driven wedge with no problems.

Pam

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#19

Thanks to all.....

Bill Tindall

for all the pin experience and ideas. I was saved the failure of making a plane with a straight metal pin.

What I will try is to make is a round wood pin on the lathe with a smaller diameter spigot(as the turners call it) on each end. Making this arrangement on the lathe will ensure the cylinder and spigots are coaxial. Then I will file a flat on the inner cylinder. I realized that it should be possible to "eyeball" the flat and get it the same depth across the cylinder.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#20

Re: Here is the problem

TomD

I once asked someone at Redwoods why they did that crazy hand whittling pins and freehand drilling on a horizontal drill. They apparently just enjoy it! I do it on a lathe most of the time.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#21

Re: Thanks to all.....

TomD

One of the problems with the Krenov style is that no mater how well you make the wooden wedge they tend to trap shavings. One sees this in the hands of all the experts in the Krenov video tape. They take one pass, and then hand remove the shaving, they never get to two passes. One can certainly get effortless use for some planes, like my favorite scrub planes, but fine shavings may get caught.

My best suggestion for all the possible problems would be a metal rod about 3/16" and then a wooden shoe with a groove in it under the rod. IN esense a profile a bit like the lower half of the Krenov wooden pin. No dent, sufficient friction for the wedge, and very low profile, maybe 6MM total.

That said, over the years of extreme emotional resistance in favour of the Krenov style I started with, I have been forced to consider that the various abutment methods are better.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#22

that gives me an idea

Bill Tindall

Metal rod through a square cross section that was centered drilled with a 4 jaw chuck. For clarity, chuck up 3/8 x 3/8" piece of wood and drill a 3/16" or 1/4" hole on axis through its center. Slip this piece over the metal pin. Result- everything is coaxial and there is a large flat friction surface for the wedge to engage.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#23

Re: Retaining pin question

Ron Hock

For our Krenov-style plane kits we just use a 1/2" dowel for the cross-pin. No pivoting, no flat, works just fine for thousands of planes. Krenov's pivoting cross-pin is by far the most difficult part of plane-making. And having a glued-in dowel strengthens the side instead of weakening it. Like I said, works fine.

Re: Adventures in the handplane SIG

#24

Re: that gives me an idea

TomD

Every part that is above the mid point of the pin isn't doing anything.

If you have a 4 jaw, how come you don't just turn them?

I like to have the flat on the base of the Krenov style pin pretty much level with underside of the pin, which if you have a 4 jaw means you can mill that cut also.

Have fun.