New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Wood 'defect' *LINK*

Posts

Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Wood 'defect' *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

Here is a picture of a back of a violin. The description is that of root markings on the top and bottom of the one piece back with a knot in between. I think the knot may be a bark inclusion. I admit I have never heard of root markings before, I know and have worked some root and seen the grain in the butt swell.

What do you think?

Stephen


Violin back

Re: Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#2

Re: Wood 'defect'

wilbur

It's pretty similar to markings from when I've turned projects from root stock, although the projects that I've made have had more markings than that violin. Then again, I'm not sure that the back plate of a violin is where you would want a lot of those markings, as the wood probably wouldn't be very stable over time and under the tension of the strings.

Re: Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#3

Re: Wood 'defect'

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is no knot. The grain is kind of wild at the lower end so it is possible it was near the bottom of the tree, but then definitely not "roots" at the top also. It could be that root markings are what violin dealers call defects in maple. I don't think the person who wrote the description actually knew what they were looking at.

Re: Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#4

Re: Wood 'defect'

roger lance

It's difficult to understand how the best string instrument maker of all time would have included a 'defect' in any instrument....is this instrument given a special name?....is it known for a special sound?....was this violin early in his career?

Re: Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#5

Re: Wood 'defect'

David Weaver

I don't know what's on that violin, but if the date is correct, it precedes antonio stradivari's well known period by quite a lot of time. He was only 23 when it was made, and may have been newly married according to wiki. His standards may have changed for wood selection, as he may have just been making violins to eat at that point.

I wonder how it sounds.

Re: Wood 'defect' *LINK*

#6

Re: Wood 'defect'

James Watriss

Having talked to various of the violin makers at North Bennet, they all said that it takes about 25 years for a violin to really and truly settle out into what it will sound like.

At 23, regardless of how great he was to become, he was still a beginner, and probably using whatever he could get his hands on... or what he was given by whoever he was working for.