New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Are your planes this sharp?

Posts

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#2

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Boy, he's sure working to get that shaving.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#3

Every last one of them are

Bob Hackett

Fortunately none of them are that wide or I`d have at least a double hernia.

All my chisels,spokeshaves and drawknives are that sharp too as well as my axes,adzes and knives.

In my dreams. :)

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#4

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

Pam Niedermayer

You bet they are. The first Japanese plane I made helped me cut a 3" wide 6' long read through shaving, several of them actually. Note that it's not all a factor of sharpness.

Pam

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#5

Nope...

John in NM

But neither have I found the need for them to be :D

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#7

Re: Of course they are ...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Friends of mine came back from a trip through Europe years ago, and commented that the toilet paper in their hotel rooms appeared to have wood chips in it. Now we know: they were right.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#8

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

TomD

That is a nice wide plane, but not a particularly thin shaving. So tough to know exactly how sharp it is. My finishing planes would be sharp enough to get 4/10000", but not much wood needs a finishing plane finish.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#9

WHOA !

steve mackay

I can manage dusted knuckles and cut fingers with my tools. I'd probably take off a whole leg with THAT thing !

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#10

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

roger lance

For good showmanship, part of the secret of the illusion lies in what is not so apparent....in this case, in the wood used for this demonstration....the species....grain....moisture content....etc....where all carefully controlled to get this to work....very impressive all the same....I would like to see them sharpen that bad boy....I wonder if they used a Veritas Mk II ?????

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#11

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

david weaver

My smoothers probably are.

The rest of them... probably sometimes, but they only hit the stones (or rather, the belt and powered strop) when you can tell they need sharpening, anyway.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#12

It would appear...

david weaver

Judging from the video, it may be that the toilet paper in japan doesn't just come with wood chips in it, but it may be the wood chip itself.

All the thing in the video needs is a machine to put perforations and floral patterns in it.

:b

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#13

Question for the Japanese tool folks *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Is the plane he's using there a workaday plane - that is, one a woodworker might actually use? Or is this the handplane equivalent of a racing belt sander?


One belt sander race - lots on Google

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#14

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

Pam Niedermayer

Believe it or not, the temple renovation business employs a fair number of woodworkers. They use wide planes to avoid breaks in the surface of large posts and beams, the breaks most woodworkers here avoid via chamfering blade edges.

Pam

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#15

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

Schtoo

Yes, kind of.

The idea is to finish something in one pass, if possible, in some cases.

A fellow building nice houses might find one and use it on posts and beams that are exposed, as they'll be unfinished and a smooth, track free finish that can put in on site might be handy. Otherwise they'll buy the timber pre-surfaced and be very careful.

A fellow building temples might have one for the same task, but they'll be more likely to buy one new, to specification.

They're less common now than they were many years ago, but they're not something conceived for the sake of an established contest, but perhaps more "Keeping up with the Jonses'".

I spent an hour with an old fellow discussing how stupid his grandson was who'd just ordered a 150mm wide plane for a job. We went through all the details of making sure it was set up every time, the blade was right (sharp, straight, in good order), the cost, how much trouble it was to pull it through a cut, etc.

They're fairly pointless, especially since you can buy the stuff run through a supersurfacer that does an equal job, and will do it all day, every day at the press of a button, and the smaller supersurfacers cost about the same as the plane do if you needed that kind of surface treatment often enough to justify the expense.

But, there's also the credibility of skill that goes with buying, owning and using one. Pulling one out, and making it work properly in short order shows that the guy driving it knows his beans, and that most other aspects of his work are likely to be top notch as well.

Because the blades are so wide, and need some special effort to make, sharpen and maintain, some folks stuffed several smaller blades into a wide body to get the same effect, for a lower initial cost and less trouble keeping the blades in good shape, but trading that effort saved (?) into more trouble setting up several blades all the same in the body.

It's very much like having bunch of professional photographers taking their pictures with their top end DSLR cameras, and one of them using a Hasselblad.

It's overkill, and the other folks might think it pretentious and not really needed to take simple pictures, but the guy using it also has a few Pulitzer prizes to their credit too.

Stu.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#16

Thanks, folks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was aware of the super-surfacers that Schtoo mentioned*, and so thought those planes might be real tools people actually used.

As always, everywhere approaches the craft slightly differently.

*that never took off in the U.S. market. I remember Foine Wouldworking raving about them back in the 70s, when Makita (?) and others were trying them out here.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#17

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

TomD

It is real as others have said, but I spent about 20 years trying to get one, including from people who had them themselves, to no avail. I finally gave up and am no longer interested. I first saw one at the Masterpiece tools seminar. Later I crossed paths with the same blade after Harrelson bought it, which pretty much confirmed my sense that there might only be one in the world. With the internet, many folks are dealing direct, and getting stuff I couldn't have imagined, so I am not convinced it is all that common.

Should be noted that very wide planes that do crown molding in one pass were available in the West. In most cases what seems extraordinary about Japanese woodworking had a parallel of sorts in the west, it just wasn't in phase.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#18

Re: Thanks, folks

TomD

There is this guy who happens to be locallish, but trades all over NA, who sells Japanese tools of monstrous proportions. He sells super surfacers that make those Hitachi/Makita models look like VW beetles to a Hummer. They must have some support for him to sell them at the prices he charges. I remember the article in FWW which mentioned that one of the guys who had bought one used it for making shavings, he wasn't a cabinetmaker or temple maker, he was turning out animal bedding or something.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#19

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

Pam Niedermayer

You can get the blades fairly easily for $2-3,000; but the real problem is finding hunks of wood for the dai. I'm sure Inomoto-san has them laying about in his attic, but they're for him.

Pam

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#20

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

wilbur

That's a great point, Pam. I never thought about it that way.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#21

Re: Question for the Japanese tool folks

Paul M.

I got to try out one of those wide planes when I was in Japan several years ago. It wasn't as wide as the monster in the video in this thread, but it was probably 6" wide. It was surprisingly easier to pull than I expected and didn't have much trouble getting the full-width shaving out of the plane.

Somewhere I have a picture of me doing this, but this was before I had a digital camera so it's stuffed in some album somewhere. I may have to dig that out.

Re: Are your planes this sharp?

#22

Re: Of course they are ...

Philip Duffy

Derek, Perfect answer! Phil