New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Posts

Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#1

Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Bill Tindall


Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

There are some tips that apply to any complex glue up, as illustrated by the assembly of this back panel for a chest of drawers. It involves assembling 14 mortise and tenon joints. In this example the frame is ½” poplar and the raised panels are 3/8” poplar. The panels are the remains of resawing thicker lumber for the drawer sides. I hate wasting wood and try to use whatever I can somewhere.

I like to use a paneled back for a fine piece of furniture. One can’t tell where or how it will be used in future generations and a finished back could make the piece more useful in the future.

Tip 1 Don’t make the joints so tight that they are difficult to assemble. If they don’t go together easily by hand before applying glue they will be a problem during assembly when the wet glue swells the parts.

Tip 2 Dry fit the assembly . This step achieves several important objectives. 1. A test that everything fits and aligns 2. A rehearsal for the order of the assembly steps. This particular assembly only goes together in one order. 3. Clamps and pads are selected and adjusted.

Tip 3 Number each joint so there is no mistake what part goes where. Mark alignment points for each joint. I have darkened some of these marks so they would show in the picture, for example in the center cross pieces.

Tip 4 Use liquid hide glue. It has a long assembly time and it is “greasy” such that the joints act like they are lubricated during assembly.

Tip 5 If the final assembly needs to be some predictable shape assemble the whole structure at one time. After assembly the glue is fluid enough that the shape can be adjusted to perfection by altering clamp positions.

Tip 6 Prepare the glue in some handy container. I use disposable cups set in a block of wood so that the cup doesn’t move around. I like the small thin “lab” spatula for spreading glue. I pick up a dab of glue on its end and swish it around on both surfaces of the mating parts. Glue must wet the wood to bond. The best insurance for a good bond is to spread a thin layer of glue on both mating surfaces, especially in a mortise and tenon joint.

Tip 7 Don’t spread glue on a part too far ahead of assembling the joint. With hide glue the joint stays flexible for many minutes after assembly. But if the air is dry and warm the glue on an unassembled joint will form a dry skin that interferes with bonding. During dry fitting make a mental note of the optimum way to combine glue spreading and assembly. In the example at hand I spread glue on the mortise and tenons for the center divider and assembled it, added the panels, then applied glue and assembled each end, and finally the sides.

These tips will aid rapid, and reliable, assembly necessary for a complex part like this frame and panel assembly.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#2

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

roger lance

My complements, Bill....that is more than a great back panel....I like how you also paid attention to having corresponding panels match grain pattern including the two outside stiles....good tip on the hide glue....wonderful use of "scrap"....well done.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#3

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Those are beautiful panels. Boy, you take details to a whole new level!

The panels are the remains of resawing thicker lumber for the drawer sides. I hate wasting wood and try to use whatever I can somewhere.

I had the same decision to make on the recently-completed military chests. In my defense I hoard cutoffs and just use them at the appropriate time. So I went with Jarrah (thinking all the time that the back panels shall likely not be seen in my lifetime ... but who can tell - that is the thing).

I like to use a paneled back for a fine piece of furniture. One can’t tell where or how it will be used in future generations and a finished back could make the piece more useful in the future.

Exactly.

Anyway, I had fun using a new tool (LN #48) to create the panels. Not nearly as nice and detailed as yours, but I left this project feeling it was complete and without any cut corners. I am sure you thought the same ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#4

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks, Bill. Sharing your experience this way is most helpful. I've yet to tackle an assembly that complex, and your post was well worth printing out.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#5

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

TomD

I don't dry fit. I stopped doing it when I noticed that it could damage pieces, and it it is not really necessary anyway. If one is making parts loose enough there is zero risk of damage they may be too loose, and it is hard to see how they need dry fitting either. The parts that need to be fit, are too tight to fit. The key to not having to dry fit is to make quality parts and develop procedures to check areas that stop joints fitting. I use a small keyhole saw as a straight edge, and it not only identifies parts that are not true, but can dress them in one step.

I agree that parts need to be just so for the fit, but I believe they ought to be tight fitting. It is hard to say exactly how tight. There should be some resistance, and that means a risk of disaster with grabby glues. Gap holding of most glues other than epoxy is exaggerated over the long haul, as is the durability (epoxy is not generally desirable for furniture, but you can have a gap of up to 1/4" or more). How great the furniture is for the first 20 years is little measure, and this maters if one is actually building with the intention that furniture will last for generations. I build with long term use in mind, but do not expect to encounter many long term owners. That kind of patience is gone for ever.

Another measure of how tight parts should fit is that dovetails should not require clamps and then some. The same fit applies to tenons, though the outcome will normally require clamps due to the nature of that joint.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#6

Gee, Derek...

James Watriss

You spend all that time working on the assumption that your back side won't be seen by anyone... And then you show it off online?

I knew there was more to you than met the eye.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#7

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

James Watriss

Awesome, Bill... I really like the symmetry of the dark lines in the top of outer rails. And I'm glad you're having such good luck with resawing. I tried resawing some 12/4 poplar once to make sides for a bookcase. I hadn't given it enough time to acclimate, and it all warped really badly, and trying to force the issue only lead to further heartache. I've had better luck with cherry, though.

I also really dig the big, clear pencil marks you made across the joints during the dry fit. That's such a help to me when I'm in the 'oh, crap, go time' stage of gluing up. Is it just me, or is there a corollary of Murphy's law that dictates that the phone will always ring once you're in the middle of gluing up?

Last point... I wanted to add in, it's allowable to glue up such a large assembly in stages, gluing up inner joints, and dry-assembling outer ones (like the outer rails, on this panel) to hold everything in alignment. That gives you more time to work carefully, because you're not gluing everything up at once. Once the assembly is dry, glue stage 2.. or even glue one outer rail at a time, if you're in no hurry that day.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#8

resaw cupping

Bill Tindall

The more common resaw problem is from drying stress, which gets more likely the thicker the lumber is that is resawed. If the cup occurs in a few minutes it is a result of stress that was not relieved at the end of the KD process. Additionally, some trees will develop stress because of their growth environment.

While it is easy to establish a moisture gradient across a piece of lumber during the relatively rapid KD process, significant gradients are unlikely to be developed during typical storage and movement of KD lumber. Cupping from differential absorption or loss of water is more likely a result of unequal side to side exposure to air after resawing.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#9

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Bill Tindall

I can imagine these attractive pieces being used as a room divider situation some time in their life. The unified back will enable this application.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#10

Re: resaw cupping

James Watriss

I usually start by taking 1/4" or so off of the skin to relieve drying stress. That board typically goes wild for a few months a flattens again. Not on the poplar though. Pretty sure it was stickered, but if the core of the beam was wetter, there would be no way to prevent unequal drying.

In the end, I should have stuck with 4/4 for bookcase sides. Or plywood. That's what I get for trying to get fancy.

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#11

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

Pam Niedermayer

Is it just me, or is there a corollary of Murphy's law that dictates that the phone will always ring once you're in the middle of gluing up?

And that's why there are voice mail and ringer off switches. :)

Pam

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#12

Re: Gee, Derek...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi James

I racked my little brain for a come-back, but your comment was so good, that I just cannot top it. Damn! :D

Best wishes for the New Year.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Assembly of complex parts with multiple joints

#13

Re: resaw cupping

TomD

I haven't had much problem with that, and most of the material I chainsaw mill I do in large sections then resaw, so I do have a fair exposure. But it does happen, and one tip I read was to throw it dry side down on the lawn. Got to be careful but it does work.