New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

Posts

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#26

Cast Iron Dishes a Little

Steve Elliott

I found my original 3” wide lapping plate from Harris Tools had dished a little after quite a bit of use. I flattened it on waterstones and then found that my blades weren’t reaching the same high degree of sharpness as before, probably because of embedded grit. After a few sharpenings the results were better.

The problem for me with a 3” plate and narrower blades (most were 2”) was that each stroke would pass over the center of the plate but at least one edge was not used. Naturally the center wore more. I’m now using a 2-1/2” plate and have just started experimenting with a 2-1/4” plate for blades that are 2-1/8 or 2-1/4” wide. The narrower plate dimension means that each stroke uses most of the plate width.

Most of the problems from dished stones or lapping plates are related to honing the back (flat) side of the blade. Using either the ruler trick or a small back bevel helps avoid these problems and saves wear on the stone. It also speeds things up.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#27

Exactly..

david weaver

The wear I described as seeing was the same as you describe, due to flattening guides (or rather iron holders) that allow/force me to plant the end of the iron right around the middle of a 3" lapping plate. Consequently, that's where the wear is.

But the appreciable wear was only on things that get used in very heavy lapping. On anything that's been subject to regular honing use, the wear must be extremely slow, and someone who was freehanding an iron could negate most of it with technique, even working the back of the iron.

Of the two substrates I like to use (mild steel and cast iron) cast is much easier for a home user to use because good sandpaper will condition and level the surface fairly easily. A very heavily used lap that I have of mild steel is not the same - it is a bear to flatten. It works great with diamonds, but I will make heavy laps (which hopefully i will rarely use going forward) with cast.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#28

Disclaimer- coarse diamond

Bill Tindall

I have never done any significant amount of coarse grinding with a diamond format of any sort. It was a surprise that some of you all do, and apparently to good effect. I am curious what is being ground and why by hand with diamond? We have shopped out our coarse grinding to surface grinders- cheap, painless.

Anything I have ever said about using diamonds is confined to the scope of edge refinement only. It may not apply to coarser grinding/material removal situations.

From a very brief exploration of coarse diamond particles it seemed they worked well on acrylic(plexiglas) with a glycol lubricant. No experience on how well the combination will hold up but it cut fast, the diamond embedded well and the steel slid easily, unlike the fine diamond situation. But I had no application so it was not further evaluated.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#29

Re: Disclaimer- coarse diamond

david weaver

Only old tools and new tools that were poorly made and need a lot of lapping to bring a section of a back into plane.

Old pitted irons that are throw-away on stones, or that would cause a lot of sticking and unsticking of norton 3x can be done well with 100 grit diamonds and either mild steel or cast iron, and there is no limitation (other than your own body weight) to the pressure you can put on the iron being lapped.

It is at least a 10 to 1 speed difference vs. something like a 1000 grit stone, and still leaves a very flat back without worrying about things like "should I change this sandpaper yet, it's such a pain to unstick it", or "did I get all of the dirt out from under the sandpaper before I stuck it down", or "crap, I just cut the sandpaper by accident".

At any rate, something like grinding to a line to remove metal, etc, that stuff is all still done with belt sanders and grinders.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#30

Lapping with Coarse Diamond

Steve Elliott

"I am curious what is being ground and why by hand with diamond? We have shopped out our coarse grinding to surface grinders- cheap, painless."

When I fit a 3V blade to an infill plane body I need a very accurate thickness because the mouth dimension of the plane depends on it. My blades are lapped before heat treatment leaving enough extra thickness to allow for the degraded surface layer to be removed, which is very easy. Then the good steel shows up and progress practically stops on waterstones. I’m using 60 micron diamond paste on a 5 x 24” cast iron lap to get the blade to its final thickness.

Since 60 micron grit is equivalent to 220 grit sandpaper I guess I’m not really using coarse diamond, but it cuts quickly enough. Coarser diamond might leave subsurface damage to the steel so I think 60 micron is a reasonable compromise for speed and surface quality.

Machine shops can surface grind to exacting tolerances but the tighter the tolerance the higher the cost. When I had my cast iron Blanchard ground I asked for the lowest price, thinking I could do final lapping if I needed to. It turned out no further lapping was necessary and the cost for Blanchard grinding was $60 for the stock that produced six lapping plates 2-1/2 x 8 inches. Finding a machine shop I liked was a bit of a chore, though.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#31

Re: Beyond Feather Sharp - .05 micron

bugbear

I'd consider a properly done .5 micron hand american chromium oxide (not the lee valley stuff, but a true 0.5 micron only powder)

Could you expand on that distinction? - I'm not sniping, just curious.

BugBear

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#32

Re: Beyond Feather Sharp - .05 micron

david weaver

When you examine the edge from the veritas green stuff under a microscope, you'll see small scratches. You can also read the history of the back and forth from razor forums trying to find out what's in it. There is stuff other than 0.5 micron chromium oxide in it (the lee valley crayon).

When you get the 0.5 micron powder from hand american or a lapidary supply, the first thought its "this doesn't cut as fast as the LV stick", and I think the reason for that is the powder is just that - 0.5 micron chromium oxide powder. No wax, nothing else, etc.

The razor forum folks have gone to preferring chromium oxide sprays and powders where they are only 0.5 micron chromium oxide (you can shave off of any of it just fine, though - LV, hand american, whatever) because they prefer the edge finish (cosmetically or otherwise, I don't know) from the pure stuff.

Now, calling it the Lee Valley green stick is a bit misleading (but a lot of people call it that), it's as if Rob's being accused of spiking the green stuff to make it cut faster, and really all they're doing is passing along a stick of stuff made in the states that's sold in several other places, too. It's not like it's Rob's bad doings or something.

As far as the comfort (I think you were asking about the green powder vs. the stick, but.. ), one needs only to shave off of a nice natural stone of some sort to feel the difference in a bare leather stropped edge off of a nice stone vs. an edge dragged across powder. Despite not being quite as fine maybe, the natural stone edge is less irritating to the skin, and in my experience thus far, feels the same longer than a razor dragged across a strop with compound on it.

For woodworking, I'd rather have the LV green stick (there, I just called it that, too). It cuts faster, it's more convenient than powder, and if there are 1 micron or whatever bits of other abrasive in it, it makes no difference for woodworking.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#33

Re: Beyond Feather Sharp - .05 micron

bugbear

There is stuff other than 0.5 micron chromium oxide in it (the lee valley crayon).

(from the LV site);

The average size of scratch pattern it leaves behind is 0.5 microns or .00002 inches.

Now you point it out, I think that LV are stating that (fairly) explicitly; Key word "average"

Thanks for your detailed and informative reply to my question.

BugBear