New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

Posts

I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#1

I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

These seem like they could be an affordable alternative to diamond stones, for those who want to try diamond sharpening but can't justify the relatively high up front cost for diamond-coated plates.


New Lee Valley offering

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#2

I have some

Bill Tindall

I was given some for evaluation but I have not used it for straight edged tools (plane, chisel). As far as I can see they behave about like abrasive coated paper, with the advantage of the more aggressive diamond abrasive. The fact that the sheets can be wrapped around dowel rods and the like makes this stuff handy for grinding curvy cutters. Don't apply a lot of pressure; let the diamond do the work. The short length is a major disadvantage for chisels and plane irons, in my opinion.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#3

About like sandpaper maybe?

John in NM

I've used similar stuff in lapidary work. The thin film will help, but I'd still expect some dubbing of the face just like with paper. Of course those of us who hollow grind won't have that problem :D

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#4

Re: I wonder how these would work?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I helped evaluate these films, working through a wad of different grits to narrow down the micron progression, and trying to get a fix on their longevity.

Keep in mind that these should not be considered a replacement of oil/waterstones in a permanent set up, but are ideal for working with PM steels or as part of a travelling kit.

That said, the films are amazing in their ability to hone steel, and their longevity. I have some that have been through several hundred cycles (per piece). Just be careful that you do not inadvertantly slice the film (with a rough edge). I use a little camilla oil for a lubricant. This works very well.

I pushed for the current sizing. Firstly, it is available in this sizing from the manufacturer I believe, which makes it cheaper I imagine. Secondly, I had the idea that one could (as I have) stuck all meshes on one 12" x 6" substratum (glass or whatever), which makes it convenient to store and use. A 6"x3" mesh is large enough for either freehanding or a guide (note: these meshes act like diamond plates - there is no cross contamination). The mesh requires very little "movement" to do its job. I did not experience an issue with dubbing. The mesh is unlike sandpaper - it is very flat and on a hard backing. Be sure that you clean the substratum well - dust below will create a bump, which will end up being sliced.

The meshes chosen (15/3/.5/.1u) allow for the least extra wear on each successive mesh ... in other words, the most efficient use of each mesh. You could forgo the 0.1u if you wish, but I must say that the addition of this takes the sharpening level to something well beyond "scary" ... frightening sharp.

In summary, these meshes are a must-try. Prepare to be amazed. You may not stop smiling! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#5

Re: I wonder how these would work?

TomD

Looks like a good thing. Does raise the issue of what else is out there. Every five minute we hear about a new product that is essential in some other craft. Drip, drip. Could we just get them all at once.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#6

Correction

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

To say " been through several hundred cycles (per piece)" is an overstatement - call it enthusiasm. It is, however, truer to say a few hundred cycles. The fact is I lost count after about a 100 cycles.

The film seems to be an excellent carrier for the diamond grit, so my next thought is how well (and if) if will be possible to "recharge" it with diamond paste? I have not worn out the original set yet, so have not explored this area (yet).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#7

Recharging with Diamond Paste

Steve Elliott

When I was testing abrasives to see how sharp an edge they would produce I found the self-adhesive chromium oxide film 3M used to make was equal to the equivalent diamond (0.5 micron) although it cut more slowly. When the film was worn out it some fine diamond paste seemed to renew it, with the advantage of leaving fewer rogue scratches than any other substrate I tried.

Now that I’m back to more practical sharpening pursuits I’m much less concerned about rogue scratches. They’re visible through a microscope and it’s probable that they slightly increase the chance an acute cutting edge will experience microchipping, but a sharp edge with a few scratches is still a great edge.

Recently Brian Greene, who demonstrates sharpening for Lee Valley, said in a post, “I should also note that I'm not looking to chase away every last scratch. I want a good polish, not necessarily a perfect polish. . . . Any more than that, in my opinion, is counterproductive in a practical sense.”

I agree completely with Brian on this issue.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#8

Re: Recharging with Diamond Paste

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I agree with Brian and yourself about the rogue scratches - shiny is an end to identifying a sharp edge for working wood, not an end in itself.

Your experiences in re-charging the film is good news. Now we need to convince LV to stock the same micron pastes as the films for later use.

Incidentally, with the use of diamond paste, my method has been to smear it on and around the substratum, press it in with the back of a chisel, then wipe off the residue. I never read of others doing this last step, but I only consider the medium ready for use at this stage.

How do you prepare your substratum/diamond paste combination? Hopefully Bill and others will post on this as well.

Best wishes for the new Year.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#9

on the what else is out there

Bill Tindall

A call to the tech. service department of the major abrasive companies revealed this and the other diamond formats as well as a boron material, whose name temporarily escapes me, that could be used for tool steels. This revelation occurred back when we were investigating tool steels which was back when Badger Pond was alive, however many years ago. It wasn't my brilliance that discovered diamond abrasives but rather it was the recommendation of every abrasive company I contacted. However, advice from companies on these matters was not widely accepted at the time and remains so in some cases. These companies provided samples of the diamond film and boron material for evaluation and recommendations for using them for tool steel abrasion.

The limitation of the coated products for us was, at the time, format and availability. Products were not available in less than many sheet quantities ($$$$) and the sheet sizes and shapes available were not ideal. I don't consider a 6" long strip of abrasive useful for a plane or chisel, and a disk is even less so.

The recommendation to use loose diamond on cast iron proved so superior to coated sheets that I never pursued using them except for wrapping around curved substrates. The combination of power grinder, fine diamond plate and loose diamond on cast iron made obsolete the need for a careful progression of diamond grit sizes for routine sharpening.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#10

A better use of loose diamond

Bill Tindall

It astonishes me the effort that is expended to avoid what has been accepted for centuries the best substrate for loose diamonds- cast iron. Considering "recharging" these dinky sized films it would make more sense to add the loose diamond to a plastic substrate more appropriately sized. The films are Mylar but that is not the most ideal plastic for the task. Pick the hardest (most rigid) plastic one can find for the task, and one available in flat sheets. Plexiglas is a good choice. Mylar and polycarbonate are not bad choices. None will perform like cast iron because none have the self lubrication of cast iron.

However, coarse grits embed better in plastic. They tend to roll around on cast iron. Since I employed a grinding wheel for coarse grinding I have not further evaluated the diamond "rocks" on plastic but initial results were favorable and reported here.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#11

charging the plate

Bill Tindall

The topic has been discussed before . The gem polishers were the best source for this information since they have been doing it for centuries. I don't charge effectively because I am still awaiting my friendly lapidariest to provide a proper shaped rock. However, my 25 gram vial of powder looks like it will last a decade so I have not been overly concerned with wasting a few milligrams here and there. I dust on a very few milligrams and smear it around with some WD40 lub. A piece of thin grocery bag plastic "condom" over a finger works effectively for distribution about the plate and then I rely on the tool to embed it(not the best).

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#12

The New Ultimate Term - Feather Sharp?

david weaver

As in those blades that come from Feather brand, that nobody ever seems to be able to match with a hone - who knows what they do to finish their edges - probably slurry of the 0.1 micron flavor.

I wonder how long it will take these papers to show up on the shaving board.

There are a lot of edge chasers there, who love a razor that will pretty much slice off any undulation on a person's face, and punish the shaver who doesn't pay attention 100% to what they're doing.

It's a lot like this board, as there's an alternate crowd of "comfortable" shavers, who shoot not for super sharpness, but for good enough sharpness and a comfortable edge (oilstones, coticules, barber hones, ....).

The edge chaser crowd is down to 0.1 micron CBN spray now, and those who would affix the film here to a piece of glass would be able to use it without slicing it with a razor - it may be that people can now finally hone a razor straight up to the level of a feather DE blade.

Maybe I'll start a thread over there. It's hard to complain about spending $12 or so for the last two grits if someone has cut glass available, especially when you compare that to the cost of an escher or some other stone that edge chasers will buy.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#13

Cubic boron nitride probably...

John in NM

Next hardest to diamond

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#14

Re: Cubic boron nitride probably...

david weaver

Yes, CBN. Popular with the razor sharpeners. Can't see a practical use for .1 micron CBN in woodworking.

The edge would wear immediately past that level with woodworking and a 1 micron edge will allow shavings full width less than 1/2 thousandth, and even on bare wood, nobody would see the difference in shine on a planed surface.

Actually, don't see a practical use for it in shaving, either, it makes a razor that is far beyond the sharpness needed to remove hair easily, and it's a threat to skin.

There are apparently lots of people who send their straight razors out to be honed, though, and many people seem to be in love with razors that come back not practically sharp, but blindingly sharp (which only lasts a shave or two, anyway).

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#15

Iron plates

John in NM

I think the trouble with acceptance has more to do with the lack of readily available iron plates. I looked at making some, and found it cost prohibitive, though scale would help with the materials cost. As most of us haven't the time to search scrap yards for old cast iron machine tables, the project tends to be quickly abandoned.

Years ago I knew a guy who made petrographic thin sections, using diamond grit in a couple sizes on 24" cast iron laps. Diamond was in big salt shaker looking things, probably held a pound of grit. I was amazed he didn't have contamination problems, but I can only conclude diamond rinses off cast iron quite readily (not the case with copper laps :D )

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#16

Memory is foggy....

Bill Tindall

...But this stuff was recommended for some tool steel abrasion applications where it was better than diamond. I never tried it for anything. I still have the sheets though if something comes up.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#17

Charging a Cast Iron Plate

Steve Elliott

Hi Derek,

My method is the same as Bill Tindall's--spreading the diamond paste to a very thin layer on the plate--except I've stopped using a layer of plastic over my finger. If I use two grits I use different fingers.

I tried using a hardened steel roller to embed the diamond but didn't see any improvement in how the plate worked. The roller was messy and wasted paste, plus I'd need a different roller for each grit if I was concerned about cross-contamination.

After covering the plate with paste I add a couple of drops of mineral spirits (paint thinner) and start my honing stroke in the center of the plate so the thinner gets pushed out over the whole plate. By the time I'm done the thinner has just about evaporated and there's a little bit of thick black slurry on the plate that I clean off with a small piece of paper towel moistened with thinner.

I want my sharpening to be fairly simple and not some kind of mysterious art, more like frying an egg than making a perfect soufflé. I'm so satisfied with my present simple method that I hesitate to complicate it.

Last week I cut some new cast iron plates to width and started using one of them. The new plate had a different feel, not as smooth as the one I’ve used for years. They’re from the same chunk of cast iron and were Blanchard ground at the same time so the difference must be due to the older plate being broken in somehow. I’m not sure I’d like diamond sharpening if the plate stayed like the new one. I mention this in case anyone tries diamond on cast iron and doesn’t like the feel of it.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#18

Re: Beyond Feather Sharp - .05 micron

david weaver

I noticed today that someone mentioned that CBN (and diamonds?) are available to razor users in .05 micron size now.

maybe there exists a select few lab professionals who could find that kind of sharpness worth having...but isn't there some point where the substrate will cause greater wear than the abrasive?

I'd consider a properly done .5 micron hand american chromium oxide (not the lee valley stuff, but a true 0.5 micron only powder) to be borderline uncomfortable. I can't imagine the lashing someone's skin would get if you could even get the effect of .05 micron CBN. That's to the level of sharpening becoming a circus act.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#19

Worn Film v. Plastic as Substrate

Steve Elliott

My experience with using diamond paste on worn chromium oxide abrasive sheets was different from using diamond on plastic. The plastic (polycarbonate if I remember right) was grabby and not nearly as good as cast iron. The worn film still had a layer of green on top and was not grabby.

I sometimes use coarse diamond (60 micron) on a 5 x 24" cast iron plate to flatten the backs of plane blades. The grits do seem to roll around some but the cutting action is still faster than any coarse waterstone I've used. The big advantage is that the cast iron stays flat.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#20

Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

Tom Colligan

I seem to remember a poster from the Arkansas area who commented a year or two ago why he didn't stay with diamond on cast iron. He observed that it eventually dishes, if I remember correctly.

I thought it made sense as our steel is harder than the iron substrate, no? TIA, Tom.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#21

Re: Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

David Weaver

It eventually dishes some. I wouldn't worry about it with a large piece of cast, though, and the surface can be re-lapped (cast laps easily on fresh psa roll sandpaper on glass or any other flat surface), and the wear can be mitigated some by being conscious of where to lap.

Diamonds aren't a consideration to lapping if a coarse grit is used for a first step - they are lapped right off with the substrate.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#22

Re: Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

Bob Hackett

I`ll let some of the more learned folks here corrected if I`m wrong as they`ve been at this longer but it`s my understanding that cast iron plates don`t dish significantly when used correctly and with the finer grit diamonds because the diamonds imbed it the plate and don`t roll around abrading the CI away. On a properly charged plate with minimum diamonds rolling around the steel never touches the CI, it touches and is abraded by the points of the diamonds imbedded in the CI.

The only way for the CI to be abraded would be if the diamond were loose and rolling around.Then they would be free to abrade both CI below and the steel being dragged across. If you let the swarf build up or the CI plate get beyond the point where it needs to be recharged with diamond then you might get steel to CI contact and dishing could result. I haven`t seen any evidence of significant (meaning measurable) dishing on any of my plates but I keep them reasonably clean of swarf while I`m using them and properly charged with diamonds and be sure most of the diamonds are imbedded so that may be why they aren`t dishing.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#23

Re: Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

Bill Tindall

I have seen no wear on my cast iron plate. I believe Steve has seen some wear but he has used the plate in his studies more than most of us will in a life time. I don't expect I will ever have to flatten my plate. It is a cheap job at a machine shop with a surface grinder if it ever does.

The deal is that the diamonds embed and don't move against the cast iron. The steel does but cast iron has good wear properties. Think how many times the gears and trunions on a table saw rub one one another.

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#24

Re: Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bob

That's my understanding and expectation - that loose diamonds will roll around and create wear on the CI, while embedded diamonds will only abrade blades run across them. I do not have enough experience with my CI plates to say that this is actually so.

I suppose that one of the arguments to be made for wiping off excess diamond paste (after grinding it in as evenly as possible with a blade) is that this will reduce potential "loose diamond" effects and, thereby, surface wear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I wonder how these would work? *LINK*

#25

Re: Doesn't Cast Iron Eventually Dish?

David Weaver

They will wear with heavy duty high pressure use pretty readily (like if you have a specialized lap for flattening blades in bad shape with fairly coarse diamonds and something to hold the blades so you can get high pressure).

The tradeoff is no problem, though, given how much work you can do before you see appreciable wear. Lapping a plate on sandpaper to fix that once every couple of years for 10 minutes is a twaddle given how much work they do.

I haven't used any fine loose diamond cutting surfaces enough to know what they do, but I'd bet not much, because the nature of the work that causes heavy work to create wear (high pressure, bigger grit and more often charging) doesn't exist with routine honing work.

I still like a stone better for fine work, and only use fine diamonds when I am too lazy to put a polishing belt on the belt grinder for the very few HSS tools I use with any regularity (and even then, they are handled well by a grinder and cut fine with a microbevel by somewhat pedestrian stones).