New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

Posts

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#26

Re: Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here are some pictures of chisels. Note: square tang with long uniform taper to a point, octagonal bolster. hefty square shank at bolster tapering to bevel, long enough to get two hands on (10-11 inches), laminated a plus. But most important is the steel.These chisels have extremely fine texture so they take a fine edge. They have very low abrasion resistance so they sharpen like a dream. And they hold their fine edge a long time even in harder woods like Osage, Jarrah, Persimmon, White Oak, etc.


Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#27

Carving tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I once was standing with a tool vendor and a carver at a show. The vendor wanted a nice endorsement of his carving tools selection. The carver was trying to be diplomatic and would say things like "we like them a little more delicate" or "they would need a lot of work". The vendor said "yes but they are really great tools aren't they?" The carver finally said "they are unusable".

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#28

Ooops

Larry Williams

When working with carving gouges, you're working with the inside sweep. If the sweep of the outside arc doesn't have a radius smaller than the radius of the inside arc you'll end up having steel from the body of the tool in your way. You can angle the gouge to avoid this but that changes the effective sweep of the tool and you end up fighting your work.

Before you grind some gouges for carving you really need to know the difference between firmer gouges and carving gouges. Most dealers don't know the difference. Firmer gouges are shaped more like they're making carving gouges today and firmer gouges have a different purpose. Firmer gouges are pretty remarkable in they're own right and shouldn't be wasted by trying to turn them into carving gouges.

Here's a photo of a carving gouge next to a firmer gouge. The firmer gouge is on top.


Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#29

Useable vs profitable (long)

Bob Hackett

I believe you`ve nailed it once again Wilbur.

What the tool makers are really saying if you read between the lines is more like "We know the shapes you are talking about are more useful than what we offer but the stamping dies would cost more and wouldn`t last as long, the heat treating would be more difficult and the reject rate after stamping and heat treating would be too high. Besides that,the shape is too complex to be reliably ground by the machines we`ve been using for the past several decades and then we`d have to go back to hiring more employees to hand grind the profile when what we really want to do is automate and lay off workers to improve our bottom line."

There are a few (dare I say "cutting edge"?) individuals out there now who understand both WWing and toolmaking ( Larry is one stellar example) and some of these folks are offering classes and instruction on how to recognize the "tool within the tool" .

The class teaches how to take the tools manufactured today and use them as a start point. You base your purchase of a tool,a chisel in this case, not because it will do everything you want right out of the box but because it has good steel in sufficent quantity to allow reforming and reshaping into what you really need.

I am also active of a couple of metalworking forums as well as a blacksmith site and it`s common knowledge there that ANY tool is a merely a point of departure. Even if you`ve finally got your buddy to part with that hand made scrolling wrench you like working with so much when you go over to his shop it`s a given that one of the first things you`ll do after you get it thru your door is to tweak it so it`ll be even better and fit you,rather than your buddy, more closely.

I don`t have a single hammer (other than a claw hammer I loan out) that hasn`t been modified in one way or another and I own several dozen different hammers. I also have a couple of 5 gallon buckets of old hammer heads stashed in the corner. When someone needing a hammer (or coveting one of mine) asks about buying one of my favorite users they are directed to the buckets of hammer heads and told to " pick one that comes close".

We then go thru distilling what it is about the hammer they want to buy that made it so attractive that they wanted me to part with it. How does it differ from the ones they have at home that they are disappointed with? From there we talk about things like, how the way I approach the work may be a bit different from the way they`d like to do it. What changes would you make in your new hammer to make it even better than my hammer?

Once we have distilled things down to the basic requirements then the grinding, polishing, etc begins combined with advice at each step in the process. It continues with a rough length of riven Ash, Hornbeam or other appropriate local wood that has been drying in my shop for at least a year and the drawknife, rasps, sandpaper etc used to make a handle that closely fits their own hand and the way they actually want to work. It ends with mating the head to the handle with a handmade wedge. Now they have a very real understanding of why I`d have to ask in excess of $200 for any of my favorite hammers that have been made or modified to fit me.

It`s all about shifting your mind from "better" to 'best" and understanding that "best" is a transient thing, it`s bound to change as you evolve as a craftsman. The only way to get what is "best" for you is to make it or modify it yourself.

In the end it`s not so much about making someone a hammer (or chisel) as it is about getting them to look at how they work and what direction they want to go. Once you get them to see the difference between what they think they want and what they really need all you need is a big enough chunk of the right steel and someone to guide them thru the process. Yes,it takes time and effort, but the good news is if you make the commitment and devote the time and effort to transferring the understanding that allows someone to beak free of settling, compromising, or accepting only what is offered you`ll only have to do it once. Once they embrace this line of thinking they`ll never modify the way they work to accommodate simple tools again, Instead they`ll make whatever is required or modify what is at hand and move thru whatever they choose. They will only be limited by their own skills,materials and motivation, powerful stuff.

You`ll know you`ve been successful if the person you talked thru making that hammer doesn`t come back looking to have you make another hammer yet you begin to see more "customized" ones popping up in your travels around town. From now on the only thing that person will need from you is advise or the occasional bit of shop time using machines or tools they don`t have (yet). Don`t be surprised if they keep showing up to drop off things they "thought you might find useful" though. :)

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#30

Correct me if I`m wrong here

Bob Hackett

But it`s my understanding that if you are looking at what I know as the flute of a gouge (the part of the body that defines the cutting edge of an out cannel ground gouge) then the flute of a firmer most often forms a cylinder while the flute of the more useful carving gouges most often forms a cone.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#31

"Horses for courses"

Bob Hackett

It once again comes down to matching the tool to the job.

If you want to get a really good feel for the angle you want a precision cut to be made at then a long chisel will help you see that angle . Likewise if you are paring a rather large surface then a longer or wider chisel will have more registration surface to help guide your cut. The drawback of a long bladed chisel,or a long handled chisel for that matter, is when you need to choke up in the edge now you`re fighting the weight of all that unused length waving around and you`ll be fighting gravity to keep your cut straight.

Likewise most people will tell you a paring chisel MUST have a back that is dead flat for most of the leading portion (Asian chisels are still dead flat even with a hollow back) and a cutting edge that is dead straight across (even if the cutting edge is on a skew chisel).

A "slick" is probably the largest paring chisel most people will ever see and a proper boat builder`s slick is up to 4+ inches across. Every slick I have used with success has had a cambered edge and a convex back. The cambered edge helps ease and steer the cut and the convex back allows you to climb out of a cut. If you`ve ever worked fitting timbers on a wooden boat or in timber framing you could see these are important things to consider.

One of my English blacksmith friends uses the phrase "horses for courses" quite often and when asked what exactly that was supposed to mean he replied " You wouldn`t bet on a cowboy`s roping horse to win your Kentucky Derby now would you?"

I thought John B`s saying was a pretty good fit here.

Wish one of my sons were here to help me take and post pics. I have a pretty wide array of modified and refurbished chisels and gouges(to include slicks) that span a couple of centuries. Most of them have sockets rather than tangs though. I`m a fool for socket chisels, as the buckets, boxes and several drawers of old rusty chisels in the shop waiting patiently for rehab will attest to. :)

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#32

okay

Larry Williams

No, a carving gouge is more of a tapered section of a cylinder. It will have the same radius along its whole length. Where ever you truncate a cone you'll find a different radius. Take a piece of index card or business card and cut the corner off with a gouge then check it and you'll find the radius of the arc remains constant through the length of the gouge.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#33

Thanks Larry

Bob Hackett

I was misinformed.

So the body the gouge is a cylinder in either tool . In a firmer that cylinder is cut parallel to the length and in a carving gouge that it`s cut at an angle to the length. Is that a correct way of explaining it?

Apparently the person who offered that explanation to me was thinking visually and not geometrically. We were talking about the type of gouges Weygers recommended making in his books when he offered up that explanation as those gouges look distinctly cone shaped. I asked him about commercial carving gouges and he said it applied there too then pulled one out of the rack to show me what looked like a cone shaped flute. He was a carver so I took his words as gospel.

If he was still with us I`d love to point this out to him over a cup of coffee in the shop. It would be a fine way to start out the New Year, with a new and better perspective on how things really work. He`d have liked that.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#34

Chinese Laminated Carving Chisels

Tom Colligan

So sorry for being slightly off topic but for a while now I've tried to find a seller of these that had gotten fine reviews by Chris Pye and others.

Does anyone know of their being still available? I cannot find hide nor hare of 'Dick Fine Tools' that used to have them. These were unhandled, pretty delicate looking, gouges. Tia, Tom.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#35

Re: Chinese Laminated Carving Chisels

David Weaver

I don't know exactly which one dick tools had, but look up the seller "songtieling" on ebay.

Never bought anything like that, but I remember seeing that stuff when I was looking for gouges on ebay.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#36

Re: Chinese Laminated Carving Chisels

Pam Niedermayer

I had planned on photographing a couple of these for Larry, but then I looked to see if Dick still had them. They don't. They are not so delicate as they look, really tough little sticks, I just know they want to cut me. :)

Maybe Dave Barnett knows who would have them. He's the one who put me on to them.

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#37

David Barnett

They're still to be had

David Barnett

"They are not so delicate as they look, really tough little sticks, I just know they want to cut me."

Indeed.

Here are the links.

http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/product/700970/Carving-Blades-18-piece-set.htm

http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/product/700971/Sculptors-Gouge-Blades-18-piece-set.htm

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#38

Re: They're still to be had

Pam Niedermayer

That's very good news. The problem isn't Dick/Dictum, it is that when you choose "Chinese" from the "Chisels" page, the carving and sculpture carbon chisels aren't displayed. You really have to muck about. The only good way to get there is to do a search on "carving chisel."

But they're worth the effort.

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#39

Re: make them? more images

TomD

You need to be a "skilled expert" to get hired by someone. One doesn't need to be a skilled expert merely to make one's own stuff.

http://www.mountainhollow.net/abs_test_knives.htm

This was just the first Journeyman Smith set I came across. It takes 2 years to become a JS, and it is by no means a full time job. Some of these people discover knife making, and may never even have sliced bread before developing an interest. Let alone having 40 years of grinding stuff around the shop for dozens of different tools, for which there was probably a "skilled expert" in each respective industry. In the last while with internet, and video, it is even faster to learn stuff. I think once one has a grounding in something one can pick up a new trade in 3-6 months of hobby time.

Whether woodworking or toolmaking, a point of developing skill at this kind of level is to have complete freedom to make whatever one likes. To satisfy whatever distinctions one develops. Some of the folks around here come at this stuff as though they were designing products for GUM department stores in the old USSR. It isn't about the one way to do stuff, it is about meeting highly fragmented preferences. One can run all kinds of tests as to the superiority of Tupperware, but the person who prefers the Faberge egg as a container is not going to be swayed.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#40

David Barnett

In that case...

David Barnett

...I'll remove my snarky comments on their name change, which I still don't like.

At any rate, those evil little gouges are to be admired. And used.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#41

Carving tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For the usable portion of a straight carving gouge (first 3 inches or so) the width is constant and the curvature is constant. For some reason, what are called "sculptor's gouges" are different. On the outside profile they taper from tip to bolster, no constant width. I have two of this type that I rarely use. For the flutes, they both have slightly tighter radii as they go towards the bolster. More dramatic, though is the back side of the tool which is roughly conical. Spoon gouges can taper on the outside profile; I would not want to describe the geometry of gouges like this.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#42

So...

Bob Hackett

It appears there is no neat pigeonhole I can stuff gouges into then. No surprise there.

Like the people I tend to hang out with, it`s safe to say they are all over the map when it comes to description, usefulness and proper application of their best attributes. :D

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#43

A comment for the lurking "beginner"

Bill Tindall

Suppose you need some chisels. or a plane iron, to make furniture. As Tom D points out it does not take years of experience to make a tool you will be satisfied with. Countless knife makers and some woodworking tool makers (for example Blue Spruce) demonstrate this fact. Chisels and plane irons can be sawed and ground to shape rather than forged. With the recommendations of the metal companies metal can be selected to suit your application. Heat treating can be done cheaply, and locally in many locations, at shops that use sophisticated furnaces to yield a product with predictable properties. Will this process pursued by amateurs yield the best or most optimum tool ever made? Likely not. Will the difference be significant to you while making stuff? Probably not.

The fact that modern technology is a practical substitute for a shade tree and a forge greatly annoys some traditionalists and they will disparage tools made this modern way. Even if their claims are correct that a tool made 100 years ago or a modern tool forged in a boutique shop performs better, the amount that it may be better will not be noticeable to all but the most experienced user, if that. If you are at the stage where chopping a dovetail to perfection is not trivial you don't need to be worrying about a 10% difference in steel performance.

A $100+ price tag can go a long way to convincing one that a chisel must be better. Beware of this fact when evaluating claims.

If you don't need a chisel or carving tool you can have the luxury of searching for that vintage tool of your dreams, forever. In my example, I needed a set of chisels to use, now, not after 10 years of searching. I made them in a shape to my liking. I could have had one of the tool makers make them and they would have been prettier, and more expensive, and delivered quicker with less effort. Performance would have been equal. And most important, I have learned to use them for my needs. Experience, combined with the tool at hand, can be just as effective as an alternative "perfect" tool for the job.

The shape of the tool is significant. This or that shape will be more comfortable and/or effective. Shape is easy to copy from a previously made tool, vintage or not. You can rely on modern metallurgy to deliver a heat treated steel that will perform as good as you need it to.

Mass produced modern tools are another matter. The manufacturers don't provide the technical details to enable one to judge the performance of the steel. And, the customer is clueless as to what factors were most important when selecting the steel and heat treating- cost, ease of sharpening, ability to pry open paint cans, etc. Without reliable reviews these tools are "pigs in a poke" and certainly not optimized for a personal preference.

Bottom line....more data to guide your tool selection process to a satisfactory conclusion so you can get on with making stuff.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#44

Re: A comment for the lurking "beginner"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a suggestion for you, Bill. Make yourself a nice straight razor out of D2 steel. Razors made by experienced craftsmen with traditional steels often cost $100 or more. Don't bother to learn traditional sharpening methods (even the Japanese use strops on straight razors), just grind and refine with diamonds. Put your technology to the test and let us know how it works out. My guess is your face won't like it.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#45

An epiphany

Bill Tindall

Our tool recommendations should include how we shave (for the males only). A chisel recommendation from someone that shaves with an old Gillette adjustable razor and stainless steel blades would provide immediate perspective to what they held in value, which might be assumed to carry over to their choice in tools. Such a person would immediately be judged frugal to a fault and interested in getting a acceptable job done with the least inconvenience and bother, if they chose to shave at all some days. No doubt the 5 edged high alloy polymer coated blades would only be used by a person where cost was subordinate to have the latest and best and it would follow that they would be a Bridge City kind of person.

I suppose the electric razor crowd belongs on the main message board and we would only consider them for router suggestions.

I am stymied as to how to fit the bearded ones into the scheme. If I am any indication they have a high tolerance for itchiness, and hence maybe discomfort. They would find LV shoulder planes acceptably comfortable, or a Stanley 5 for a shooting board, or even a top heavy Sorby chisel for dovetailing.

Of course all this leaves women out of the picture and most will not tolerate discrimination. So in the end what seemed like a good idea is flawed.

May everyone have a prosperous New Year of making stuff and/or collecting tools and offering advice and perspective to those climbing the woodworking learning curve.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#46

What was that sound?

Bob Hackett

Is the neighbor slamming and locking his door again? :D

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#47

Clearing up a misconception

Steve Elliott

"I am stymied as to how to fit the bearded ones into the scheme. If I am any indication they have a high tolerance for itchiness, and hence maybe discomfort."

I've worn a full beard for the last 40 years and a beard is NOT itchy or uncomfortable. Stubble is itchy, a partially grown beard is itchy, but a fully grown one is not.

As to using "shaving sharpness" as a test for woodworking tools, I've found that the last little bit of extra sharpness disappears as soon as the tool is used. The amount of time it takes to achieve that extra sharpness is worth it for shaving but in my opinion not for woodworking. Speed of sharpening and edge life are much more important to me for woodworking applications.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#48

Re: A comment for the lurking "beginner"

TomD

"Heat treating can be done cheaply, and locally in many locations, at shops that use sophisticated furnaces to yield a product with predictable properties. Will this process pursued by amateurs yield the best or most optimum tool ever made? Likely not. Will the difference be significant to you while making stuff? Probably not.

A lot of these materials are designed to allow people to make tools and tooling in their own shops. In industry most tooling is not made, then pro hardened, then used. It uses inserts that are bought then tossed, or sold on ebay. Then you have the stuff that is made in shop for fixtures and short term use tools. I would guess that there is more of these two categories, than there are tools that are custom made sent out, and got back. Whatever the case, there are products that are designed to be successfully used in the small shop.

You are right about how well some of this might work. I have HTd stuff in really bad conditions, and failed to actually harden it. But for the most part it comes out pretty good. I know for a fact it comes out as good or better than some of the stuff in magazines. The most perplexing tool was a blade I had for a while in a Jack plane. It was from a batch I did out of doors during winter, and I got some bad results in that desperate situation. I also got some good blades. This one seemed to be good, and I used it for a while. Did not appear to be soft, or require a lot of sharpening, then at one point it bent at the edge. Possibly it just didn't harden deep on the back, like a Japanese composite, blade, but by accident. Pretty weird though.

Some of you may recall that I did a minor gloat about a rockwell hardness tester I bought. Unfortunately, that never got put into use. I think the guy who sold it to me knew it was a lemon. And I didn't get it sorted out. Wish I had, because I would have enjoyed really being able to accurately test my tools.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#49

Do not forget...

John in NM

There is also the bic crowd, disposables ranging anywhere from the cheapest single or dual blade (Kunz or Groz plane :D ) to the triple bladed thingy with some kind of funny little lube strip (ECE Primus?)

Happy New Year Bill :D