New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

Posts

On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#1

On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

Bill Tindall

Some dismissed the information provided by Crucible Products. I will summarize where I think the information is relevant. The format will be my understanding of a CP statement followed my opinion of its relevance.

1. Hardness does not correlate with abrasion resistance. The context here is hardness of tool steels heat treated in their range of typical usage. Broadly true for woodworking tools. In the series of typical carbon steel, A2, 3V, M2 and M4 I find my sharpening experience correlates exactly with the CPM abrasion data. Stu pointed out an exception for a particular carbon steel.

2. Hardness correlates with resistance to deformation. Again broadly true. Chisels can fail by the edge deforming(crumbling or folding), as observed under some magnification. The harder chisels don't exhibit this failure, for example M2 and carbon steel taken to high hardness such as in a typical Japanese chisel.

3. Toughness correlates with resistance to chipping Broadly true. Another chisel failure mode for chisels is edge chipping, again observable under some magnification. The hard carbons steel chisels can and do exhibit this failure mode. So does M2 chisels taken to high hardness.

4. Typically there is a trade off between hardness and toughness. True We used the CPM data to harden our 3V chisels to Rc 58. Turned out that this was not optimum for chisels as discovered by us and at least one other chisel maker. Heat treated harder the chisels were more robust to edge deformation without chipping failure.

5.Abrasion resistance correlates with wear Generally true. I will let Steve Elliot provide data here, or go to his web site. The conclusions are that the more abrasion resistant steels, according to CPM data, are more difficult to sharpen and they last longer in planing tests. Data from a Japanese lab in actual Japanese style planing tests also confirms this correlation.

The bottom line of all this is that one can predict, with useful reliability, how a steel will perform in a plane iron or chisel from the data provided by steel makers. One would predict that a carbon steel like O1 could make an excellent chisel. Experience confirms this prediction. The data predicts that M4 would make good lathe tools and it does. The data also predicts that M4 would make a good plane iron.

Are the predictions perfect or are these 3 factors of hardness, toughness and abrasion resistance sufficient to predict anything more than trends in tool performance? Of course not. But the data have been shown to be useful for woodworking tool manufacturing and selection.

If you don't want to deal with the technical details of the topic it is fine by me. However, there are many lurkers that follow these discussion, some intimidated no doubt by the responses one can receive, who are wanting to learn from the discussion. If you have facts or experience to contribute, do so. It is not helpful to be simply dismissive without offering some reason or data why you are dismissive.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#2

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

This all is a little like deja vu ..

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/30982CXsPwYdXYm2eoEP1325080948/spage/6/sanc/155338/sbid/3000/md/read/id/155338/sbj/chisel-blade-testing-5-steels/

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=30982CXsPwYdXYm2eoEP1325080948;spage=5;sanc=155535;sbid=3000;md=read;id=155535#m_155535

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#3

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Pam Niedermayer

The discussion does seem to recapitulate past discussions on the same topic, but I think this current discussion is a bit different. For example, several have added data and qualifications on the ultimate importance of testing and Stu has tested stones that sharpen/form powdered metal tools; and they're not diamond although there are several diamond plates that have come to attention since the older discussion. You, Derek, have revealed that you now rely on diamond paste to function as lower grit water stones.

And Warren, Larry, and Steve have discussed various reasons for paying attention or not to what Crucible has to say. And so forth.

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#4

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Larry Williams

While I haven't done the research to judge your results, I'm curious how you know Stanley 750's were made from O-1 and not W-1 or 1095?

I have spent some time researching what chisels I would like to have. I find nothing in the contemporary market that's properly shaped. One shouldn't need special "dovetail chisels" if their chisels are properly made. I look at your selection of chisels and there isn't one that looks well balanced or even invites me to pick it up. Given the results you show, I would prefer what were standard British chisels made between about 1870 (when bevel back chisels first show up in the catalogs) and World War I.

My problem is that I can't buy them without being able to personally look at them. The flat on the sides of these chisels is so minimal that any pitting means you'll have to change the width of the chisel when the pitting is lapped out. It's pretty highly skilled work to freehand grind with the precision they seem to have done as a matter of routine in Sheffield for a few generations.

Give me some good tanged bevel back chisels made when Sheffield's skilled blacksmiths, heat treaters, and grinders were working at their peak any day. I don't need any magic bullet steels or hassles sharpening. It's pretty hard to beat the edge retention of the chisels I've used from that time period. Those chisels are well designed, comfortable, agile and the steel is as good as it gets.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#5

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

While I haven't done the research to judge your results, I'm curious how you know Stanley 750's were made from O-1 and not W-1 or 1095?

I have spent some time researching what chisels I would like to have. I find nothing in the contemporary market that's properly shaped. One shouldn't need special "dovetail chisels" if their chisels are properly made. I look at your selection of chisels and there isn't one that looks well balanced or even invites me to pick it up. Given the results you show, I would prefer what were standard British chisels made between about 1870 (when bevel back chisels first show up in the catalogs) and World War I.

My problem is that I can't buy them without being able to personally look at them. The flat on the sides of these chisels is so minimal that any pitting means you'll have to change the width of the chisel when the pitting is lapped out. It's pretty highly skilled work to freehand grind with the precision they seem to have done as a matter of routine in Sheffield for a few generations.

Give me some good tanged bevel back chisels made when Sheffield's skilled blacksmiths, heat treaters, and grinders were working at their peak any day. I don't need any magic bullet steels or hassles sharpening. It's pretty hard to beat the edge retention of the chisels I've used from that time period. Those chisels are well designed, comfortable, agile and the steel is as good as it gets.

Well now Larry, let's see ... firstly, the chisels were chosen for their steel as this was an experiment. Secondly, those chisels with PM steel were made just to test the impact resistance of these steels, and were designed accordingly. Thirdly, I wanted a blade of older steel, and the closest I could come to one that had not been mangled beyond recognition was to use old #750s (which I initially thought may be W1 but later changed this to "probably O1" following discussion here ... it's all in the threads). I recall Warren why I did not include a few 18th Century chisels ... but since this is Perth and I do not have access to your fleamarkets with their abundant and pristine 18th Century chisels ...

There was good discussion at the time, and it struck me how similar it was then to now.

You probably would not like my paring chisels, which are Kiyohisa slicks (very fine blades) ...


My favourite dovetail chisels are the Blue Spruce.

That is to answer your question.

Of more importance, I am tired of your constant sniping. I do not know what burr you have in your shorts, but I am going to suggest that you bury it, and I will bury my sword. It is the end of 2011. Let's start afresh now for 2012. What do you say?

Best wishes for the New Year.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#6

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Pam Niedermayer

One shouldn't need special "dovetail chisels" if their chisels are properly made.

I certainly agree with you there; but would also note that most chisels called dovetail chisels aren't made for making dovetails, but they are shaped like doves' tails, thus the label. I think this confusion is a result of translation issues. To be precise, they're called "shinoji," for which I don't know the English equivalent.

As to buying old chisels long distance, picking the right one is extremely difficult, but it's possible to make some good guesses and get more of the right ones than not. Also, there are some vendors to be trusted out there, whether in the UK or Deutschland or US or ....

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#7

With the appropriate grinder...

Bob Hackett

and proper technique you pick just about any thick chisel that`s bigger than what you need,use it as a start point and go from there. The world is your oyster with the right gear.

Add a decent torch to the mix ( I`m assuming we all own hammers and an appropriate metal surface for beating hot metal on) and you now have the capability to forge to shape and with simple steels to heat treat to the hardness you choose rather than what the factory chooses for you.

I just don`t understand why anyone would make the correlation that different from what they personally use or do automatically = wrong.

I prefer to open as many doors in my head as I can (I like to think of them as "the doors of perception") and enjoy having the ability walk thru them, take a look around and deciding thru my own experiences if what`s on the other side is useful or not.

Apparently some are determined to slam and lock as many doors as we will let them. While they are free to do whatever they want within the confines of their own brain pan I take exception when they say I, or anyone else who`s interested, shouldn`t (or can`t) walk thru a door just because they personally feel what`s on the other side of that door is worthless to them.

Different just = different. It`s up to each of us to decide for ourselves if an application is harmonious or discordant for what we intend to do at the moment. I have also found that what`s discordant for me at this point in time may very well turn out to be just the ticket for tomorrow`s bit of work. It`s during times like that I am most glad I left doors open rather than slam them, lock them and nail them shut on myself and others.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#8

Re: I agree with Derek...............

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

there are too many semi rude comments posted that are counter productive to learning.

My feeling is, if what is being discussed/commented on doesn't fall in line with your needs then start a thread that does.

There is enough ill will in the world. Why increase it?

Hoping for a nicer 2012,

"Can't we just get along?"

George Allchin

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#9

Re: With the appropriate grinder...

Pam Niedermayer

Funny, I've recently bought several very small mortising chisels, 1.5-5 mm, for mods for specific tasks. I say bought, but on ebay, really can't see grinding a $70 chisel. But no torch yet, have yet to decide on how I'll address heat or whether I need to.

As to perception, I say there's a little room in everyone's life for Aldus. Easier with medication, but possible without. :)

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#10

Re: I agree with Derek...............

Pam Niedermayer

Can I safely assume you intended this post as a thread response? Because I certainly don't see that anything I said was rude, crude, or generally unattractive. And in the spirit, I'll add another cliche: you get more flies with honey .... Now the question becomes why anyone would want more flies. :)

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#11

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Do you have specific examples of the kinds of chisels you would recommend, Larry? Pics would help, so would brands. I've not had my hands on any classic English chisels and so wouldn't recognize them if they bit me.

I prefer tanged chisels, myself, but my favorites are all Berg.

Thanks.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#12

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

david weaver

I'm not larry, but I've hogged out on some of the chisels of that type - including tanged.

The bucks have been very good (all a bit softer than some other chisels, but very sharp and holding up fine in use), as have just about anything pre-1940 english with delicate beveled edges. The older socket chisels are also nice because they're not monstrous and have nice delicate edges. Marples, ward, sorby all come to mind for good pre WWII era chisels, I'm not sure if butcher did bevel edge chisels (not sure out of ignorance, i've got some butcher chisels, but they are not bevel edge), but I'm sure they would be very nice if they did.

All, including the bucks, have nice tastefully made bolsters on them and not too much weight, even when they're on the longer side.

Have a look at item 370571195616 on ebay. (no relation to the seller, the chisels just have the characteristics that are nice in a set of all-around chisels).

Ebay has pretty much killed the idea of getting anything like that local here, I've never seen any such thing in antique shops - not even at tool dealers benches. If the backs of a chisel or set are in question, the seller can always be asked to take extra picture or vouch in writing that they are good. I have not had any bad experiences on ebay (with chisels) yet.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#13

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is releva

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Dave. I have a good idea about what constitutes good US-made chisels, but I was specifically interested in Larry's list of English pre-war models just for my own information. Maybe my luck will change and I'll run across one at an MWTCA meet coming up in February (Feb 11, 2012, Medina, MN, for those who are interested).

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#14

Chisels

Larry Williams

Bruce,

There were a lot of makers working in Sheffield during the period. They all worked to the same specifications and at the same price. They also traded among themselves and there's really no way to tell who might have made a specific tool regardless of how it is marked.

Here's an example of what I'm looking for, it's marked James Howarth and is the center chisel. Those in the photo are just a sample of what we have available in the shop, we have a lot of chisels. There's also a Ward and Paine that's from about 1840 before they made bevel back chisels and it's next to the Howarth.


Here are the same chisels from the side showing the flats.


I have used the Buck Brothers chisels in the photos for nearly every day for years and they're pretty good but ever so slightly soft. They're the first and sixth from the left.

There's a bunch more I intend to write about this but it's a busy evening here. I'll see if I can get back to it later. BTW; regardless of what Derek thinks, this isn't about him. I've been trying for some time to get the chisels and carving gouges that would work best for Don and I in the shop. It's been a very frustrating search and it just shouldn't be.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#15

Why not make them?

Bill Tindall

Functionally the chisel of your dreams is what I made. Tanged, and edges ground to nearly a sharp edge. I use them for everything. I made them for the same reason you have encountered. The collectors have removed many of the good tools from circulation. It is vastly less effort to make a chisel than deal with one that has pits. I had no metal working experience and I hack sawed and ground them out of annealed bar stock with complete success. Pick the metal of your choice. In what way are the Blue Spruce chisels lacking? They certainly don't lack price. Mine were made for about $5 each and they are much more homely than the Blue Spruce. .

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#16

IIRC, the Blue Spruce are all A2.


Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#17

Bevel-edged Tang Chisels

Steve Elliott

I completely agree on liking this older style of bevel-edged chisel. I live in an area with relatively few older tools (maybe a little better than Perth). I took a quick picture before the sun set of my favorites.

When I bought the one on the left about 25 years ago it made me dissatisfied with all the other chisels I owned. Its edge retention was WAY better, probably because the steel was harder.

The second from the left is a recent acquisition that needed a new handle. I still need to flatten the back.

Second from the right is an old Buck, not quite as hard as I really like but a great user.

On the right is a Victorian chisel by I. Sorby that I bought to be a user, but when it arrived it was in such great "collector" condition that I didn't have the heart to sharpen it.

I wish more current manufacturers would use this pattern, including the very narrow flats on the sides. Except for mortising they are great for all the other uses I put a chisel to, and they feel great in the hand.


Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#18

Second from the left...

John in NM

Looks like an Ashley Iles, seems like they're one manufacturer who is following the trend you're looking for. So I'm wondering if they fit your needs or not?

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#19

Re: Chisels

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Larry.

I see what you mean by the side flats. Those really are fine. I have a nearly complete set of Bergs (and like them very much), but tanged unlike your socket example, and they have a fairly thick side by comparison. I wasn't aware of that - I always thought mine were narrower compared to much of what I've seen. It seems to me that Derek had a really nice set of Bergs that he had rehandled and sold off to buy his nice Japanese paring chisels, but that had customized them by grinding down the sides, but I'm probably wrong about that.

I have a preference for shorter chisels. My dad was a carpenter, and I grew up with a Stanley 60-1/2 block plane in one hand and a Stanley 60 butt chisel (1-1/4") in the other. Well, kinda :D Maybe the preference for short chisels is learned in my case. At any rate, I don't find myself reaching for longer chisels, even though I have them.

One of the Bergs I got on eBay has a handle exactly like the Buck Bros, and I never knew where that style came from. Now I know. Thanks.

I'll take a look for these examples at the Cabin Fever Meet.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#20

I like short chisels too

Bill Tindall

And I didn't grow up with any chisel. It would have been risky to arm me with a chisel. My grandfather remarked to someone one day that I could break an anvil.

I made my chisels about the length of a modern Japanese chisel. I made them to dovetail but wound up using them for everything. I have some long handled chisels and never use them. I have not encountered any preferred use for the long blade.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#21

Re: I like short chisels too

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I just took a look at your chisel making article Bill, but it doesn't include a shot of how steep the side bevel is or how sharp an edge it makes. Would you mind?

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#22

Chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This thread's wandered in a direction I find really interesting. I have leaned toward longer chisels for bench use for years, but am now realizing that this may be so because the first decent chisels I had were long, and I associated short chisels with the paint can openers from Sears that were my first chisels (bought new back in the early 1970s, before Fine Woodworking was around to open my eyes to other possibilities*).

I do have some short chisels in the "possibles box," and this conversation is convincing me that I need to add "fix up short chisels" to my round tuit list, and try them out.

I use the same yellow-handled Stanley carpenter's chisels that Bruce grew up holding in one of his hands all the time**, but had never thought about how a chisel that size might work on bench work.

*and, well, the Craftsman mechanic's tools, wrenches and all, were reliable tools, and I somehow thought this translated to their woodworking tools, only to find I was wrong.

**A note to beginners: if your woodworking includes carpentry, watch for these chisels at yard sales. The older ones have really quite good steel for carpentry, tough for prying but with durable edge-holding capability too. Just don't open paint cans with them; your paint store gives away really good paint can openers.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#23

make them? more images

Larry Williams

It looks like I will try to make the chisels we need. We have the steel on hand and I was explaining to Don that it's a little arrogant to think we can make chisels as good as skilled experts in three trades could turn out. His take on it was we are just acknowledging how high they set the bar and seeing how close we could get. It's a long process though. We've been rethinking our heat treating for example. We think we'll use our furnace for stress relieving and for preheating for hardening but use a torch to get the steel to uniform critical temperature. I've been filtering ash from our wood stove for a couple weeks and I'm working toward getting two five gallon metal buckets of it to be able to handle the slow cool after stress relieving.

This all started several years ago when Don approached one of the carving tool makers about getting some gouges ground the way they used to be. I talked to another maker recently. We got no where. The old gouges were ground so that while working on one detail you could work up next to another detail without fouling the second. They don't seem to have been ground this way since WWII at least. The old gouges have a radius on the outside arc that's slightly smaller than the radius of the inside arc. New gouges have an outside arc that has a larger radius than that of the inside. Here's a sketch with the better old style cross-section on the right:


New gouges also generally lack the taper in the blade that the old gouges have. A lot of carvers know the difference and old gouges in reasonable shape sell for two or three times the price of new gouges. Old ones in real good shape seem to go for four or five times the price of new gouges.

I wasn't having any luck coming up with the gouges I need. I've been making do with what I have but avoiding unwanted facets was taking a lot of time. While I preferred London pattern gouges, Stubai's continental pattern gouges were the closest to properly ground I could find and I ordered those that would work.

It's counter-intuitive but it's easier to regrind a gouge than a flat chisel. Here's the worst of the Stubai gouges before grinding:


And after, I also re-sized the handle:


The makers we had talked to said the fine tips at the wings were too weak. Really? I don't see them broken on old ones and I've reshaped a number of gouges without problem. Don spent years carving architectural details, mostly for geometric stairs, without problem using old properly shaped gouges. Don mostly worked in white oak but sometimes in woods like hard maple or Brazilian cherry. Carvers generally work in woods like basswood or white pine.

That Howarth chisel in the photos in the first post should be pretty delicate if these makers were right. When we got it there were about half a dozen small pin-prick sized pits near the edge and the last time it was sharpened it had been ground and honed at about 25º. I cleaned it up a little and sharpened it at that same geometry then drove it into poplar pretty hard. I wailed on it with a 27 oz dead-blow mallet like it was a mortise chisel quite a few times and it was fine. The edge showed no damage from the abuse. I've since ground nearly 1/8" off the length of the chisel to remove the very small pits and reground a bevel.

Getting back to chisel design, I want blades that are thin but taper to a greater thickness near a properly shaped bolster. I want the blades less than 1/8" thick 2 1/4" back from the edge. I think a slow curve on the back of the chisel is important for resilience and good feed-back. I often depend on feel when using chisels and I want a chisel that tells me what's happening at the cutting edge. A-2 steel feels dead in comparison to HC steel. There's simply a lively resilience to HC steel. The Ashley Iles don't have properly sized handles and the big bolster spoils the balance and feed-back of the tool. It's too bad, they're close but have some fatal flaws as far as I'm concerned.

Sizing a handle or a bolster isn't an easy thing but they need to be right and they need to be sized in relation to the other and to the size of the chisel. They're closely related and I'll be depending on old ones as a guide. Many of not most of the early chisels were sold unhandled and when you get an old one with an owner-made handle it's likely not going to be right. That Ward and Paine in the first photos is a good example of this and has a pretty clumsy old handle.

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#24

Re: make them? more images

Pam Niedermayer

I'm with you on your chisel preferences, although my knowledge about bolster sizing isn't nearly so refined as yours. I do know when a chisel feels right. Before I got into Japan land, I bought piles of old steel chisels, mostly from the UK. For carving chisels, I still mostly have Addis, Dastra, Herring Bros, and the like. The Dastra are still made, so they're fairly easy to get. I've also got a couple of boxes of Bucks that may satisfy, but I'm pretty sure they're pattern makers, may be totally inappropriate. Most of my carving chisels are western, but I've recently purchased several Japanese versions, mostly Takahashi. The designs are very different, but they work very nicely.

Tell you what, I'll photograph samples for you and upload them tomorrow or Sunday.

Pam

Re: On how the Crucible Products article is relevant

#25

Re: make them? more images

wilbur

The makers we had talked to said the fine tips at the wings were too weak. Really? I don't see them broken on old ones and I've reshaped a number of gouges without problem.

Do you think that the "weak tips at the wings" issue might not be a user problem, but a manufacturing problem? This is purely a guess, but if back in the day gouges were made primarily by a forging process, getting those fine wings might be relatively easy to do.

On the other hand, if the inside curve of the gouge is made by starting with a blank of steel and milling out the inside curve, I can see how the tips might present a quality control problem.

All of this is just a guess, but when manufacturers say that a part of a tool won't hold up, my bet is that they are thinking of how they would make it more than how the user is using the tool.