On how the Crucible Products article is relevant
Bill Tindall
Some dismissed the information provided by Crucible Products. I will summarize where I think the information is relevant. The format will be my understanding of a CP statement followed my opinion of its relevance.
1. Hardness does not correlate with abrasion resistance. The context here is hardness of tool steels heat treated in their range of typical usage. Broadly true for woodworking tools. In the series of typical carbon steel, A2, 3V, M2 and M4 I find my sharpening experience correlates exactly with the CPM abrasion data. Stu pointed out an exception for a particular carbon steel.
2. Hardness correlates with resistance to deformation. Again broadly true. Chisels can fail by the edge deforming(crumbling or folding), as observed under some magnification. The harder chisels don't exhibit this failure, for example M2 and carbon steel taken to high hardness such as in a typical Japanese chisel.
3. Toughness correlates with resistance to chipping Broadly true. Another chisel failure mode for chisels is edge chipping, again observable under some magnification. The hard carbons steel chisels can and do exhibit this failure mode. So does M2 chisels taken to high hardness.
4. Typically there is a trade off between hardness and toughness. True We used the CPM data to harden our 3V chisels to Rc 58. Turned out that this was not optimum for chisels as discovered by us and at least one other chisel maker. Heat treated harder the chisels were more robust to edge deformation without chipping failure.
5.Abrasion resistance correlates with wear Generally true. I will let Steve Elliot provide data here, or go to his web site. The conclusions are that the more abrasion resistant steels, according to CPM data, are more difficult to sharpen and they last longer in planing tests. Data from a Japanese lab in actual Japanese style planing tests also confirms this correlation.
The bottom line of all this is that one can predict, with useful reliability, how a steel will perform in a plane iron or chisel from the data provided by steel makers. One would predict that a carbon steel like O1 could make an excellent chisel. Experience confirms this prediction. The data predicts that M4 would make good lathe tools and it does. The data also predicts that M4 would make a good plane iron.
Are the predictions perfect or are these 3 factors of hardness, toughness and abrasion resistance sufficient to predict anything more than trends in tool performance? Of course not. But the data have been shown to be useful for woodworking tool manufacturing and selection.
If you don't want to deal with the technical details of the topic it is fine by me. However, there are many lurkers that follow these discussion, some intimidated no doubt by the responses one can receive, who are wanting to learn from the discussion. If you have facts or experience to contribute, do so. It is not helpful to be simply dismissive without offering some reason or data why you are dismissive.





Maybe the preference for short chisels is learned in my case. At any rate, I don't find myself reaching for longer chisels, even though I have them.





