We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Did you read the whole article, Steve? It's a marketing piece aimed specifically at those producing "metal forming tools." You expected them to mention wood forming tools?
From their list of desirable properties: "• Wear resistance
— resistance to abrasion & erosion"
You expected them to give more than a nod to adhesive wear?
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I don't believe I said the article said, "it's adhesive wear that dulls blades used for woodworking." Is it in my post?
Here's the whole paragraph from their marketing piece:
Wear resistance is the ability of material to resist being abraded or eroded by contact with work material, other tools, or outside influences (scale, grit, etc.) Wear resistance is provided by both the hardness level and the chemistry of the tool. Wear tests are quite specific to the circumstances creating the wear and the application of the tool. Most wear tests involve creating a moving contact between the surface of a sample and some destructive medium. There are 2 basic types of wear damage in tools, abrasive and adhesive. Wear involving erosion or rounding of edges, as from scale or oxide, is called abrasive wear. Abrasive wear does not require high pressures. Abrasive wear testing may involve sand, sandpaper, or various slurries or powders. Wear from intimate contact between two relatively smooth surfaces, such as steel on steel, carbide on steel, etc., is called adhesive wear. Adhesive wear may involve actual tearing of the material at points of high pressure contact due to friction.
Let's see, "Wear from intimate contact between two relatively smooth surfaces, such as steel on steel, carbide on steel, etc., is called adhesive wear." You don't suppose they're talking about a steel tool or a carbide tool contacting steel it's intended to cut do you? I think of a cutting edge contacting what one wants to cut as "intimate contact," don't you?
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
If this discussion is to have any value it must be because the difference between abrasive wear and adhesive wear is significant for edges cutting wood. Until we can establish that, any further discussion of the Crucible article has no point.
In a recent post you referred to "all the sharpening nonsense we see in print and on the Internet every day." It looks like you and I disagree about whether the issue of adhesive wear is useful to discussions of woodworking tools.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I pretty much agree with Warren on this one. Discussions of sharpening are more useful when they stay close to the practical stuff we experience in the workshop. I like understanding the theory too, and trying out different things, but if it doesn't help me do better at putting an edge on a blade or finding a better kind of blade, it doesn't matter that much to me.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
Once again the knife people are way ahead of woodworkers when it comes to metal. I would be using a belt if I knew how to replace the disintegrated plastic wheel parts on my Delta belt grinder. Delta wanted the price of a grinder to replace them.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
"I am questioning how it may be useful and applicable to most WWers."
Hardness is commonly provided for woodworking tools. Some people incorrectly believe that hardness correlates to steel abrasion resistance(ability to sharpen). It doesn't. These misguided people will be in for a big surprise when they try to sharpen plane irons that will be introduced soon made from steel with abrasion resistant carbides and hardened to a hardness similar to the carbon and A2 steels they are used to. Try sharpening a particle steel M2 jointer knife with the materials commonly used for an O1 plane iron and the applicability of my discussion will become apparent. Its hardness will not begin to prepare one for the abrasion resistance that will be encountered.
Hint. If a company was going to introduce blades with abrasion resistant carbides( or fairy dust if that explanation is more tolerable) this company would be starting a discussion of sharpening media and its applicability to handle metals like M2 to prepare the customers for a paradigm shift.
Additionally I attempted to explain why the hardness of a single material does correlate with abrasion resistance (correlates, not explains every detail) and make the comparison to a composite (steel) where the correlation fails for a reason I thought I made clear.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I would be more interested in an analysis of why the article in question has nothing to offer a woodworker interested in sharpening fancy tool steels. I find it to be quite relavent and wonder upon what you have based your statement. The pointing out of your vastly superior woodworking experience isn't enough - and that is not meant to be sarcastic. I will freely admit you know a lot more about woodworking than do I, but I do not find it to be a substitute for rational debate.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I don't really have the time to debate the specifics here, but I do find it quite interesting all the replies and whatnot.
Thanks to all for a lively discussion.
No, I'll not be taking any further part in it. Like I said, I'm not eloquent or intelligent enough, and don't have documentation to support anything. Even if the documentation existed, I doubt it'd be accepted and it doesn't really matter anyway.
Now I'll get back to playing with my nice, new 'fairy dust' (PM CoHSS) bladed plane.
Stu.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
You are a talented and intelligent guy Bill. Go to You-Tube and have a look around at some videos then make your own.
Do a web search for "no weld belt grinder" or "grinder in a box". That should get you started.
The tools we make for ourselves are always far more useful to us than the ones we settle on that are made to accommodate all the people we`ve never even met.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
You`re talking to a guy who has taken what others considered a "junk" chisel and using only a torch and some oil magically transformed that very same underachieving chisel into a favorite and trusted tool that would even cut metal.
OK, I used a grinder to reconfigure the entire blade into a far more useful shape, then also removed the plastic handle and turned a new oversized Hornbeam handle too, but you get the picture.
These are usually the same folks who refuse to understand that you can`t take that antique laminated chisel, stuff it into that glazed and loaded,concave grey wheel on that high speed 6" bench grinder till the first half inch of it turns blue and expect it to perform like any of the chisels in my shop. It may look the same (except for the blue end) and carry the same brand name but the one very different variable is the "loose nut behind the controls".
That very human factor makes all the difference between someone who turns useful tools into "junk" and someone who can take "junk" and turn it into useful tools.
There`s a thread a ways up this board where a fellow WWer asked what was the first thing he needed to do with his new LN plane. The answers were usually something like; "take the iron out,remove the chip breaker,flatten and polish the back", and on and on...
Living less than an hour away from where these are made and knowing how to get to their website I know these things are "Ready to go to work right out of the box". Yet I was the only one to say that the first thing I`d do would be to make some chips.
I think it may have chapped some of the other poster`s butts that the first thing I suggested the guy do was follow the manufacturer`s directions and get a feel for his new premium quality tool before making any changes and cranking the dreaded "human factor" into the mix.
I hate to be cynical here but we are talking WWers here. Any of the guys who are interested in this metal working stuff have all done the research on their own.
Most of the guys reading this with their eyes rolling back in their heads and making funny sounds are the same folks who won`t even take the time to check out the archives or articles before they come into the room, take seats, and began asking the same questions that have been answered at least 100 times in the past.
Besides,you know perfectly well that there is absolutely no earthly need for anything more advanced than O1 steel sharpened on oilstones when it comes to WWing.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
Seems like we`ve had this metalworking vs woodworking cutting edges discussion a number of times yet it just keeps being brought up by folks who hold themselves up as being extremely well versed in the differences between metal and wood and the consequences of the interaction of these two very different materials.
"Apples and oranges" ring a bell for anybody here?
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
By my quote I was summarizing what Stu had written. You don't have to worry about whether I am disagreeing with you or not, because if I do, I will say so, and why. (Recall the waterstone discussion where you had said that you could not tell how waterstones would perform without knowing what the abrasive component was.)
My point remains that at the end of the day, tool performance and sharpening effectiveness really comes down to performance in actual use tests, and that component knowledge is nice, but not a necessary nor sufficient indicator of actual sharpening performance.
You can make predictions as to performance with that knowledge, but those are only predictions. If it hasn't been established what sharpening methods should be used with the whiz-bang metals that are going to be showing up in chisels and plane blades, there are a few different strategies to deal with that situation:
1. Talk to the knife users, who have been using these steels. They should have figured out effective methods of sharpening.
2. Don't be an early adopter. Wait for other woodworkers to figure out sharpening methods and techniques and then see what works in a woodworking environment.
3. Become your own test lab. Try out various methods yourself, and tell us all about it.
4. Take a pass on buying tools made with these steels altogether.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
compiled from Home Shop Machinist and a couple other places. Plus, I am working on one from FWW back in 1989 or so. The first one lasted 22 years, and the most complicated part of that one was the pillow block bearings.
I got here too late for that LN thing, but I was so glad to read your post. I remember years ago when I first got the LN LAJ and posted that it worked right out of the box; and yet, several cognoscenti replied that it couldn't be true, that I needed to at least hone the edge.
Pam
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I kind of collect info on belt grinders and power hammers.
It`s a fun semi-hobby and I find the info very useful when it comes time to taunt my older brother who went out and spent several thousand dollars on a top of the line belt grinder with many attachments yet still wants me to make specialized tools for him so he can actually do the things he bought the grinder for.
He`s gonna love that roller tensioned, multi wheeled platten idea. He`s a sucker when it comes to the gizmosity factor.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
I turned new wheels for my little 1"x42" Delta from 6061 aluminum bar stock. The top wheel can be changed to a slightly larger diameter urethane covered wheel that I use as a contact wheel for some grinding/carving work (briar pipes, punch making, etc.). I have a small rollerskate wheel I use now and then. If you make a different spring tension adjuster, you can use even more diameters. Caster wheels work, too, btw and are good replacements for any of the wheels.
My 2" belt grinder is a square-wheel system with variable speed and different contact wheels, but it hardly gets used these days. Nice when you need it, though.
These little 1" belt grinders are ideal for so many toolmaking tasks: grinding, sharpening, carving, shaping, finishing and polishing. Not just for metal, but wood, too. Just the other day I used it to improve the contour on four new fan blades resawn from an old Cuban mahogany instrument billet I never got around to using. Heresy? Maybe. But those are some gorgeous fan blades for the old lanai Hunter ceiling fan we just refurbished. Nice match for the brushed nickel finish.
Just to clarify. Most of the work was done with hand tools, foremost among them my #7C that thinks it's a smoother. Most fun: planing to balance the blades within 1 gram of one another as suggested by Hunter Tech Support (Ohaus old-school scales, btw). Honed the early O1 Hock blade with an oilstone and a strop, in fact. Too challenging to fetch my diamond stones with both legs in compression casts. Yeah, forget the presents -- this year I got wrapped for Christmas.
Yes, Virginia... there is woodworking without joinery. And diamond.
Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
Did. Also checked my gmail address and it seems to work, but maybe only I can mail myself. I have my theories, of course. Which reminds me... the foil I've been lining my WoodCentral hat with these last few years? Let's just say I'm using another brand lately, heh.