New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

Posts

A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#1

A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

Bill Tindall

Hardness is measured by poking a point into the test material and measuring depth of penetration. In the case of Rockwell hardness the poker is a diamond point, the hardest material known.

Abrasion resistance is measured by rubbing something against the test material and measuring how much material is removed. To be abraded the abrading material has to penetrate the test material so to a first approximation hard material is more abrasion resistant than soft material.

The correlation of hardness to abrasion resistance is good for a pure material. The correlation can fail when the abrasion resistance of a mixture of hard and soft material is measured. If the concentration of hard material is modest, the hardness of the mixture will be largely determined by the hardness of the softer material. In contrast, the abrasion resistance will largely be determined by the abrasion resistance of the hardest material present.

Steel used for woodworking tools is a mixture of iron of various crystal forms and tiny particles of carbides dispersed throughout. The carbon concentration of these steels is small, at most a few percent. Hence, the concentration of carbides is at most modest.

The carbides formed from iron and the alloying elements-vanadium, chromium, tungsten, etc- are harder than the various crystal forms of iron. Chromium carbides are about hardness 65/70 , molybdenum and tungsten carbides are about 75 , and vanadium carbides are 80/85.

When the hardness of the steel is measured by poking the point into it these carbides have little effect on resisting penetration because they are there in small concentration. Hence the hardness of the test specimen will be most dependent on the properties of the iron and not the alloying elements.

However, when tested for abrasion, the hard carbides are present in sufficient concentration to resist abrasion. The harder the carbide and the higher its concentration, the more abrasion resistant the metal will be. Given the hardness of the carbides listed above and their concentration in the steel you will be able to predict how hard it will be to sharpen carbon steel, A2, M2 and M4 with no more information than I have provided.

To be able to abrade these carbides the abrasive needs to be harder than the carbide. Diamond, at hardness 100, abrades anything. But there are other factors than hardness that determines abrasive performance. That is a topic for another day.

If you have any disagreement with this discussion read the following first before replying. If I have summarized it unreliably I would like to know. It contains a nice summary of steel properties relevant to woodworking tools. http://www.crucible.com/eselector/general/generalpart1.html

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#2

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistan

David Weaver

I didn't follow the total discussion from below, but in the practical context of woodworking, you are stating which of the following?

a) that a harder steel of the same composition will be worn off less quickly on a stone, or

b) that a harder steel of the same composition will not be worn off less quickly on a stone

Aside from that, I don't see the reason to even discuss - one only has to take two irons that are not similar in hardness but that are the same alloy, count strokes and find out how large the abraded bevel is.

What good is it to read through a metal manufacturers specs when the way metals are tested may not correspond to how we abrade them on a stone?

I think warren said that harder metal wears more slowly on a stone. I agree with him. I need only to take one of the O1 irons I've made at 58 or so hardness and compare it to a hock O1 iron that is much harder.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#3

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistan

Schtoo

Bill,

I've been thinking about this kind of thing recently, and something dawned on me today.

I don't want you to take this the wrong way, and if you're at all offended I apologise in advance.

What I'm seeing, sitting here is that you're very much able to write eloquently, have vast sources of information to draw upon and present to us (as you've done so here) and I must admit, I am envious of your abilities to convey this information. I wish I was able to do so myself, and also wish I didn't have such a short fuse. :\

At the same time, I'm also seeing a lot of theory thrown around like it's law and to go against what the books, tables and big brains dreaming all this up is saying is impossible, and any example of it must be at best misguided, at worst patently wrong.

Here's my take on it, as an amateur materials engineer who's read an awful lot of stuff, finds it very interesting and possessing, I must confess, a particularly nasty habit of having a mind like a steel trap when something is particularly interesting to me, as this stuff is. I've also managed to build up a modest amount of practical experience, which is not as in depth as I would like, but the samples I've been exposed to have been broad and wide ranging.

What the theory says doesn't always pan out as expected. I've seen and experienced things that don't make any sense, but they occur and they repeatedly occur.

I cannot speculate why these unexpected things happen, I have my theories but they have no factual evidence to back them up, so they are relegated to mere opinion, nothing more.

I also suspect that I may have caused the kerfuffle that's happening here, right now, so feel somewhat obliged to say what I think needs to be said, and then I'll leave it all be.

In this case, I believe it was the comment of A2 being relatively easy to abrade, while harder blue steel was more difficult. This, according to all the charts and theory I can find should not be so, but it is. The two materials are, on paper, rather evenly matched giving and taking in a way that depicts they should shape up as very similar in use.

The difference between the two samples I offered is that one is milled from a solid block of A2 steel, heat treated for consistency by computer aided devices and possibly cryogenically treated after the fact. The other is hammer forged, stress relieved and then heat treated by an experienced hand.

(That the fellow who does the heat treat can also forge weld what is in composition, but not name, high speed steel also bucks everything I've ever read on the subject. But yet, they do it with a remarkably high success rate.)

And what dawned on me was this very simple idea.

You tend to see this abrasion of steel in order to sharpen as strictly a cutting/grinding procedure. Naturally, diamonds are the hardest substance we have so they must work the very best in this capacity.

But using a stone (oil or water type, doesn't matter) is NOT a strict cutting/grinding operation. There's more going on than merely grinding away metal. There's fresh and worn abrasive, there's the binder which can freely break down (ablate?) or resist such action, there's abraded metal and there's also the added influence of pressure and speed, instigated by the person doing the work.

One can also vary what's in the mush of abrasive/steel/water/binder if desired.

I have experienced cases where, contrary to all published information, leaving the mush in place adds speed to the process. Alarmingly so in some cases. Most sources state that this mush will break down and slow down the process.

One can 'taint' the process by adding in an alien substance which again varies what will occur.

And one also has variables of pressure and speed, which are universally available, but while their effects are one dimensional in the case of grinding wheels or diamond plates, add additional factors to the equation where the material being worked and abrasive spent is not discarded, but retained in place.

I don't believe you'll take too much notice of what I've written there, since it does not fit into an established theory that I know of. I just hope that you, and anyone else who will take the time to read it can understand what I've written, and perhaps learn something from it they may not have known before.

Now, I will take my leave. I've had quite enough of theory and reality not talking to each other nicely. For what's supposed to be a week where I get some actual work done, I'm not getting anywhere near enough of it actually accomplished!

Good luck with your discussion,

Stu.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#4

More succinctly....

wilbur

"In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice, there is."

-- Yogi Berra/Jan L. A. van de Snepscheut

:D

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#5

What about the other variables?

Bob Hackett

The problem with engineering, science and data is that it is always being applied by humans and humans have a bad habit of not seeing the entire picture. There are too many variables that go into real world applications and those variables are why humans hardly ever get things right the first time around. Knowing the laws of physics and the theory behind how an internal combustion engine works doesn`t ensure you`ll be able to build a successful automobile.

All the science and data in the world can and usually is trumped by real world experience. That`s why the more successful engineers are willing to go out on the floor and ask the "old hands" with that experience for their advise and thoughts before they submit the final draft for a project.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#6

You are a very bad man Wilbur

Bob Hackett

And that is one of my favorite Yogi quotes. :D

I have found engineers absolutely hate it.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#7

Stamping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I read the article. The author is interested in selling steel to tool makers who stamp steel in industrial settings. There is nothing to indicate any familiarity with wood working. Most of us are not interested in stamping. Here we are interested in sophisticated sharpening techniques and sophisticated woodworking techniques. Testing and evaluating the steels and sharpening media requires a great deal of skill, experience, and most important discernment. These are not things that Crucible Industries is interested in.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#8

ASTM wear tests

Larry Williams

Google 'ASTM wear test" and you'll see these tests involve a flat surface rubbing against another flat surface. This may or may not reflect what's going on at the cutting edge of a woodworking tool depending on the situation.

I was pleased to read that Crucible acknowledges that dulling wear to a cutting edge is generally the result of adhesive wear. Unfortunately they seem to use abrasive wear as their frame of reference when rating tool steel for "wear resistance." This badly skews what woodworkers take away from their spec sheets. Adhesive wear and abrasive wear have different causes and different properties. The "wear resistance" ratings in Crucible's spec sheets have very little to do with woodworking cutting edge applications but a lot to do with how difficult a tool is to sharpen.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#9

Reply

Bill Tindall

1. One of the most influential persons in my technical life had a guiding philosophy which I subscribe to,

"Theory guides, experiment decides", I. M. Kolthoff

2. Extensive studies have shown that the amount and composition of the alloying carbides have a major effect on abrasion resistance. That is not to deny that there are other variables affecting abrasion resistance. How important these variables become depend on how much abrasion resistance is imparted by the alloying carbides. Everything I have read suggests that 2% vanadium will dominate abrasion resistance for a typical steel tool hardened to a typical value. It would be easy to see that at 1% or 0.2% vanadium that other variables would become more important as the example you provided illustrates. Or, at 2% chromium some other variable may begin to have influence. When the differences in abrasion resistance become smaller the number of factors affecting these differences become ever greater. Which leads to point 3.

3. Some hand tool enthusiasts, and it would seem the Japanese hand tool enthusiasts in particular, focus a lot of attention on the fine details of the craft. This attention to detail could enable them to detect small, but significant to them, differences in abrasion resistance and cutting speed that I would be oblivious to. I am typically not discussing the differences in the height of hills. M4 is Mt. Everest, M2 is the Matterhorn and the carbon steels are the Appalachians and the alloying carbide composition will predict the huge differences in these abrasion trends. Undeniably, when the differences are smaller other factors come into play. But in my world of woodworking these smaller differences are of no practical significance in choosing a tool or an abrasive.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#10

Ah, elegance nonpareil.


Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#11

To try to put it in a few sentences

John in NM

Choosing the optimum grinding wheel for a give tool steel is trivial, because of all the information and science available. Choosing a waterstone appears not to be so trivial, and Bill is speculating (correctly I believe) that this is due in large part to the anecdotal nature of the information available. That waterstones and other options like oil stones are quite expensive compounds the problem by limiting extensive first hand experience to a select few.

I'll grant you that most any grinding wheel or sharpening stone will work well enough on O1. The same can not be said for some of the more fancy tool steels with high abrasion resistance, and that is where all that theory comes in.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#12

Such is the nature of inquiry

John in NM

It is very common to borrow concepts from other fields of study in order to advance one's own field. All that is required is the patience to read research with which one may not be comfortably familiar, and the interest in one's own field to make a few connections. This is done all the time in virtually every form of scientific research and in industrial applications of research.

To argue that any industrial or scientific research has no application to our everyday lives, including the hobby of woodworking, is just plain silly. Virtually everything you use on a day to day basis was pulled out of the ground and hammered into a useful product, and that we're not still banging rocks together is the direct result of the spirit of inquiry and the making of connections between different fields of research.

Obviously, no one woodworker needs to understand the nature of abrasion wear, but I believe woodworkers on the whole like having a variety of exotic steels from which to choose. That a few are willing to understand the concepts of how to sharpen them and make recommendations is what pushes the hobby as a whole to having more, and some would say better, tool options.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#13

yes, thanks

Bill Tindall

I have just been spending some quality time in the recent LV catalog so that I can take advantage of their free shipping (thank you Mr. Lee for this Christmas present) and have observed that this catalog does contain some useful information to guide water stone selection such as abrasive composition, and a qualitative assessment of bond hardness and quantitative on cutting speed. It would appear from these data that one can spend essentially the same amount of money for these various stones and get huge differences in stone life and cutting speed. On the other hand none of these water stone descriptions is nearly as complete as the data provided for the 3X grinding wheel.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#14

question

Bill Tindall

What real world experience, as you say, do you have that refutes the claim that M4 at Rc 62 is vastly more abrasion resistant than O1 at this hardness, or that the reason for this difference is the nature of the alloying carbides? This is the summary of my post. The main point I was making is that Rc hardness, within the bounds of what is used for a useful tool, is a useless indication of abrasion resistance. If someone thinks that O1 at Rc 62 grinds slower than 3V at Rc 58 you all haven't tried it.

It would seem that some object to my post but no one has offered any data to refute what was actually said in it.

To summarize.....Rc hardness does not correlate with abrasion resistance in the range of hardness used for tools. (obviously annealed steel is less abrasion resistant but this is outside the scope of this discussion) This fact will boop you on the head when the next generation plane irons are introduced and it is presumed that they will grind just as fast because the hardness is not greatly different than what one was used to.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#15

would you clarify.....

Bill Tindall

By that quote I presume you want to convey that your are dismissive of what I wrote. Are you dismissive because you just don't want to deal with the issue, or things that I write? Or, are you dismissive because you have data that renders what I said irrelevant or false. Or what? If there is something wrong or irrelevant about what I wrote it should be corrected and the correction supported with data.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#16

Re: would you clarify.....

David Weaver

I'll speak for stu, not because he wants me to (i'm sure he doesn't), but if I were going to get anything specific to woodworking, it would be a test of woodworking tools on stones.

Not a spec sheet.

I agree with stu's being dismissive of too much information that is not specifically based on woodworking and tests that are practical woodworking type tests.

And, I also agree with what larry's written.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#17

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistan

TomD

"What the theory says doesn't always pan out as expected. I've seen and experienced things that don't make any sense, but they occur and they repeatedly occur."

I think there are differences in mindset. Neither one better than the other. But I have the mindset to look for the exception. While I am not particularly interested in Ye olde, I just noticed early on how often engineers belittle old tech they cannot fully explain, or have not been called upon to equal. Quite unscientifically they often throw out an explanation of some detail being there for religious reasons when they don't understand the actual use. Just something that keeps coming up. I'm sure there are all kinds of engineers, and product specialists out, so one can't generalize.

One of the things about the Japanese steel Vs western steels, is that A2 is not a hand tool steel, and it was not designed to work with any particular hand tool sharpening system. Maybe a lot of hand tool guys don't get this, but the best knife steels in use in the US typically also come from Japan. They just have an interest that we don't in certain boutique steel. For those of you who follow this stuff, you also know that some common steels have their following here also, like D2, and O1. But these tend to come up in survival or primative uses, where they have a good fit. There are also the crucible steels, so it is getting harder to generalize here also.

On the diamonds thing. They not only have to be the hardest, but they have to have the ideal geometry to get the job done, and have the correct density on the surface. Also, who knows what is happening on a plate, maybe a certain amount of shifting about. There is more than hardness to it. I like my diamond paste though. And I doubly like it for carbide.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#18

Re: question

TomD

"The main point I was making is that Rc hardness, within the bounds of what is used for a useful tool, is a useless indication of abrasion resistance. If someone thinks that O1 at Rc 62 grinds slower than 3V at Rc 58 you all haven't tried it."

I have found that tools that claim the same RC have vastly different edge holding. They may or not grind more easily. The steels that people tend to dislike, are the ones that are yucky, and hard to grind, and worse still, do not seem to deliver that much better edge holding. The existence of such steels is responsible for the trend of offering several options. One problem in tools today, is that there are too many ways of sharpening. So you can have a collision between any number of ways of sharpening, and objectives, and steels. If one could be assured that every person buying A2 had a dry grinder, and diamond paste, or whatever appropriate method, things would work out better.

"This fact will boop you on the head when the next generation plane irons are introduced and it is presumed that they will grind just as fast because the hardness is not greatly different than what one was used to."

I have no problem with the idea that RC and abrasion resistance do not correlate highly. My problem is with the idea of how closely abrasion resistance and desirable tool function correlate.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#19

Re: would you clarify.....

Pam Niedermayer

I don't think Wilbur was dismissing what you said; but he was saying that after all is said, something must be done or there will have been no pragmatic point to the saying. And he was emphasizing the primacy of testing for result.

Or, those diamond stones must be tested in sharpening steel. How does formulation of diamond stone A affect its abilities vs formulation B? How sharp are the edges? Etc. And does it even matter given diamond powder?

Pam

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#20

Re: question

Bob Hackett

I am not saying that anything you said was incorrect or false Bill. I am questioning how it may be useful and applicable to most WWers. I find this stuff fascinating and use Crucible Steel`s site all the time I even have it bookmarked, but I am first and foremost a metalworker.

I find when I bring up metalworking and especially metallurgy to my WWing friends their eyes tend to roll back in their heads and they begin making funny sounds unless I keep it real simple and can show them a very good reason why they will personally benefit from paying attention.

Most folks I know who aren`t metalworkers are in the "Why do I need to know this crap when I can call you" camp. I think you`ll find you are preaching to the choir with this one Bill.

You have me in your camp and I believe you know that. Other than baiting the same old bears I am not seeing the sense in going thru all this again. You and the rest of us on this side of the fire will just get slapped around again by the "old school" camp. The only good thing about the last go-round was I managed to salvage some pretty oil stones after they threw them at us and then stalked off. :D

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#21

Re: yes, thanks

Bob Hackett

How many people do you know that actually understand what the numbers on the labels of their grinding wheels mean? I believe Rob Lee`s father put that info out in a very comprehensive and understandable book over a decade ago and yet only a rather small percentage of WWers have put that info to use.

The info is out there, folks just find it far easier to ask their buddy what he uses and do the same.

The fact is there are better abrasives available in a far wider range in belt form. Many folks I know are moving away from grinding wheels and toward belt sanders because they grind faster, cooler, and are far more versatile. Yet we still keep talking about bench grinders and grinding wheels as if they are the only option as a starting point for sharpening.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#22

Re: yes, thanks

TomD

I use a 2x72 grinder for making tools, I still prefer a wheel for sharpening a lot of stuff. It is slower, and it hollow grinds. So it isn't fast, and doesn't leave a flat bevel. :) I consider them compliments not a replacement one for the other. There are a lot of aps where the tool is fine straight from the grinder. Not really for hand tools, but for other stuff around the shop. So it has to be there. So for grinding scrapers, it's slow cut turns a burr. And for a lot of wood turning it cuts sharp enough. For a lot of metal work also. But when making stuff like a new plane blade, the 2x72 will swallow the whole bevel in the time it would take a wheel just to refresh it.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#23

Abrasive v. Adhesive Wear

Steve Elliott

“I was pleased to read that Crucible acknowledges that dulling wear to a cutting edge is generally the result of adhesive wear.”

I was unable to find a passage where Crucible acknowledges this. The two passages mentioning adhesive wear are:

Wear from intimate contact between two relatively smooth surfaces, such as steel on steel, carbide on steel, etc., is called adhesive wear. Adhesive wear may involve actual tearing of the material at points of high pressure contact due to friction.

and

However, in situations generating severe metal-to-metal wear (adhesive wear, or galling), the best solution is to separate the two metal surfaces.

Both references are in the context of metal-on-metal wear and the second specifically equates adhesive wear with galling. These are significant matters for most kinds of machinery or metalworking, but I can see no support for the claim that a steel tool cutting wood produces adhesive wear.

Whatever the type of wear, it can be measured and the claim that a small percentage of very hard carbides in a softer matrix improves edge retention in woodworking tools is well supported.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#24

You can hollow grind with a belt sander

Bob Hackett

All it takes is the appropriate size contact wheel to get whatever hollow grind you want. Knife makers do it all the time.

Re: A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance

#25

Re: Such is the nature of inquiry

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sorry, I am not a hobbyist. I did take a course in metallurgy in engineering school 42 years ago. It was pretty relevant to me because I was heavily involved with edge tools and already had about 30 thousand sharpenings under my belt. I felt that the author of the stamping article had little to offer woodworkers like me.