A discussion of hardness and abrasion resistance
Bill Tindall
Hardness is measured by poking a point into the test material and measuring depth of penetration. In the case of Rockwell hardness the poker is a diamond point, the hardest material known.
Abrasion resistance is measured by rubbing something against the test material and measuring how much material is removed. To be abraded the abrading material has to penetrate the test material so to a first approximation hard material is more abrasion resistant than soft material.
The correlation of hardness to abrasion resistance is good for a pure material. The correlation can fail when the abrasion resistance of a mixture of hard and soft material is measured. If the concentration of hard material is modest, the hardness of the mixture will be largely determined by the hardness of the softer material. In contrast, the abrasion resistance will largely be determined by the abrasion resistance of the hardest material present.
Steel used for woodworking tools is a mixture of iron of various crystal forms and tiny particles of carbides dispersed throughout. The carbon concentration of these steels is small, at most a few percent. Hence, the concentration of carbides is at most modest.
The carbides formed from iron and the alloying elements-vanadium, chromium, tungsten, etc- are harder than the various crystal forms of iron. Chromium carbides are about hardness 65/70 , molybdenum and tungsten carbides are about 75 , and vanadium carbides are 80/85.
When the hardness of the steel is measured by poking the point into it these carbides have little effect on resisting penetration because they are there in small concentration. Hence the hardness of the test specimen will be most dependent on the properties of the iron and not the alloying elements.
However, when tested for abrasion, the hard carbides are present in sufficient concentration to resist abrasion. The harder the carbide and the higher its concentration, the more abrasion resistant the metal will be. Given the hardness of the carbides listed above and their concentration in the steel you will be able to predict how hard it will be to sharpen carbon steel, A2, M2 and M4 with no more information than I have provided.
To be able to abrade these carbides the abrasive needs to be harder than the carbide. Diamond, at hardness 100, abrades anything. But there are other factors than hardness that determines abrasive performance. That is a topic for another day.
If you have any disagreement with this discussion read the following first before replying. If I have summarized it unreliably I would like to know. It contains a nice summary of steel properties relevant to woodworking tools. http://www.crucible.com/eselector/general/generalpart1.html


I consider them compliments not a replacement one for the other. There are a lot of aps where the tool is fine straight from the grinder. Not really for hand tools, but for other stuff around the shop. So it has to be there. So for grinding scrapers, it's slow cut turns a burr. And for a lot of wood turning it cuts sharp enough. For a lot of metal work also. But when making stuff like a new plane blade, the 2x72 will swallow the whole bevel in the time it would take a wheel just to refresh it.


