New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Fitting handles to the military chests

Posts

Fitting handles to the military chests

#1

Fitting handles to the military chests

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The next chapter in the build.


It occurred to me to document how I fitted the handles. This is not terribly difficult, but it is complicated enough to create a pause. I also note that Chris Schwarz has recently taken up the military (or campaign) chest quest on his blog, so there are likely to be others interested in building similar pieces.

The article is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/FittingHandles.html

Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Why didn't you use iron screws?


Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#3

Re: Why didn't you use iron screws?

Bob Hackett

I was wondering why he didn`t fill the holes in front, silver solder bosses on the back and attach them thru the back of the drawer front. That`s the metalworker and yacht builder in me talking though. Sure would have made for a visually cleaner installation though. :)

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#4

Looks damn professional to me....

roger lance

thats a lot of work including all that you had to do to the hardware....you being a hand tool guy that I admire, I'm always smiling when you've been using a router....you're almost done and I know that's a great feeling....great project!!

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#5

Re: Why didn't you use iron screws?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Stephen

That is actually a valid point. As I understand, early screws were only iron, and these were used with brass hinges and handles in contrast to modern times, when we use matching brass screws.

I have been thinking about trying out iron screws - if I can get them - but my one concern has been to avoid making these cabinets "busy". As it is I am not including the straps in this regard.

On a point related to the screws, it was mentioned that the vertical clocking was distracting.

I oriented the screws vertically in the first place as I thought that this would not accentuate the horizontal, which could dominate with this piece.

I asked my wife, and she said "What screw heads?". She could not see either the dome shape nor the orientation of the screw. Go figure.

I managed a little more after work today (Mondays I finish early), and then took a photo of the whole (as at this stage), and zoomed in closer. The aim is to see whether any of this actually matters!




Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#6

A little dilemma ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Today I refined the process a little.

The paper template was only to get the handle positioned to mark the recess.

Each handle is minutely a different size, but enough that I do not want to use a single template for all. I decided to concentrate on two common measurements - the left vertical and the upper horizontal. I applied blue tape, then scored these two lines using two cutting gauges. Then I could place each handle against these lines and score the other two lines.

The blue tape made it easy to see the lines, and routing close freehand was not difficult. Removing the remainder with a chisel was done fairly quickly.

i looked at the handles I did yesterday (using a different method). One is fractionally out-of-square ... by about 1mm (third from the right on the bottom). I can see it. Lynndy can see it now that I have pointed it out. Buggar ... I will have to redo it.


Are the vertical lines as easy to determine as the horizontal? Which are your eyes drawn to? I have a choice of fixes: either I remove the handle and recut the mortice. This will leave gaps around it, which I will have to repair. Or I could file the top to match the horizontal, move it up by 1mm, leave the verticals as is, and then only have a tiny sliver to fill below. Or just leave the handle alone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#7

Re: A little dilemma ..

philip marcou

Derek,

some comments which may be useful:-

that type of handle is "it's own template " and you the only template you need is for the the finger recess- so you just rout these out having marked vertical and horizontal centre lines for each handle which will then align with the same on the template so you can mark the shape of the recess. Then you rout the recess, plonk in the handle, use your square to square one vertical edge of the handle and then mark the edges using the handle as a template. That takes care of any slight dimensional differences etc there may be in each handle. The first handle is then the reference for the one below, and so on.

Re the alignment of screw slots: in theory they are supposed to be with the grain or parallel to the long edges of the handles.

I can also tell you that no matter how precise you may be with positioning and alignment of handles the grain can cause optical illusions so if you tend to become over neurotic about this I suggest you use the round handles :D

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#8

Re: A little dilemma ..

Todd Nebel

Hi Derek,

I thought dilemmas like this only happen to me ;)

My wife will tell me she doesn't see or can't see my concern. I know she is only being nice, at least I tell myself that. So, I usually try and fix it which results in a less than satisfied result. Either way, if I fix it or leave it, I always look at the finished piece and see it. My advice to you is to finish this piece and live with it for a little while. If it bothers you after a while you can always fix it later (unless you are planning a complex finish). Of course if this was a commissioned piece my advice would be different.

The chests look amazing! They are real show pieces.

Todd

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#9

Re: Why didn't you use iron screws?

roger lance

I thought that having two different metals in contact was a no-no....I also thought that you probably used a steel screw in that hard jarrah initially to keep from breaking the soft brass screws....the brass screws look proper to me....the clocking with or against the grain, your choice.

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#10

Re: A little dilemma ..

roger lance

being a perfectionist is a burden....its amazing how the eye of the maker is drawn to the flaw....show us the fix when done.

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#11

Re: A little dilemma ..

Pam Niedermayer

Trying not to be a spoil sport, but I saw it first thing, grabbed my eye; although I still think this is a very fine piece of work.

Pam

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#12

Dissimilar metals...

John in NM

AFAIK, the galvanic reaction is most pronounced with steel+aluminum, I don't think it is of great concern with brass and iron or steel. Just look at all those brass sided dovetailed planes :D

I used to know the gunsmith's phrase for lining up screw heads like that ("bloused" maybe)... funny, it looks good with a couple of vertical screws in a line, like on pistol grips or a buttpad, but I really don't care for it in this case, looks awfully fussy to my eye. I agree though, most viewers will never notice at all (or know either the old term or the new term for it :D ). Easy solution - phillips... :D :D :D

I sometimes pre-thread the hole if I'm using brass screws, or wax the brass if I don't want to fuss with threading first. Some brass screws are terrible, some quite strong. I suspect it depends on if the wire is annealed before becoming a screw - with brass screws, harder is better. I've even gone so far as to test the batch of screws in a scrap if I have spares. I don't recall ever having torqued a head off one that I waxed, though it could have happened.

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#14

Re: Why didn't you use iron screws?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As best I understand it, galvanic corrosion occurs when a battery is created by contact between two sufficiently dissimilar metals in the presence of enough moisture to allow current to flow. The severity of the effect seems driven by two factors: the distance between the two metals on a scale whose name I forget, and the tendency of the less noble (less rust-resistant) metal to rust on its own.

I doubt that Derek will want his furniture to get that wet, although I don't know how high the humidity can get in Perth's humid season. There could be an effect, in a high-humidity environment; but I've seen plenty of old furniture that mixed steel and brass hardware without any apparent problems. And, indeed, I've noticed a mix of steel and brass on some current exterior architectural fittings that seem not to have problems - although I'll confess that, on the exterior light fixture I installed recently, I did go buy some nylon washers to separate the brass nuts holding the fixture on from the steel shell of the fixture.

Now, if he were planning to take these pieces campaigning, then I'd worry.

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#15

Carefully is the operative word

John in NM

I've torqued so many brass screw heads off that when my wife and I were building cabinets and windows for our house, I tried to impress upon her how easy it is to ruin the brass screws that came with all those hinges we bought.

I tried to demonstrate by driving one in a piece of oak using a screw gun and no wax. Darn thing wouldn't break :D

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#16

Leave the flaw...

Jerry Gibbs

and make sure you point it out to everybody. I did that with a canoe until I became the distraction. Nice looking work. Jerry

Re: Fitting handles to the military chests

#17

Re: Leave the flaw...

Patrick Gibbons

On a recent piece of mine I accidentally made one through tenon larger than the rest. Of course it could not be fixed. In your case, the flaw is minor and I believe fixing it will leave a visible flaw of a different nature that will be just as distracting or even more so. I'd leave it and be proud of the "human touch".