bevel angle
Joe Shelton
how do i decide on the angle to grind new chisels? 30 deg? 25 deg?
I intend to chop dovetails in walnut.
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
bevel angle
Joe Shelton
how do i decide on the angle to grind new chisels? 30 deg? 25 deg?
I intend to chop dovetails in walnut.
Joe
Re: bevel angle
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Ultimately, the answer is "you find out what works." The current general thinking seems to be that chopping wants 30 degrees, paring 25; but there are so many variables that this can't be a hard and fast rule: wood being used, kind of steel, quality of chisel, work habits, whether the chisel is dedicated to the purpose or used for multiple processes, and so on and on.
Myself, with walnut (love that wood: mild but so pretty), I'd start with 25 and move up if I got lots of edge failure (chipping and the like). But then, I tend to use chisels for chopping and paring both (as an example of the variables issue).
Re: bevel angle
Brian Greene
Use the bevel they came with (likely 25) as your starting point and grind/hone a steep micro bevel -- upwards of 30 degrees. Walnut won't cause any grief that 30 degrees can't handle.
Re: bevel angle
Pam Niedermayer
Given that you seem to be LV's sharpening guru, that's an interesting recommendation. Do you also recommend this for the Japanese chisels LV sells?
Pam
Re: bevel angle
Brian Greene
I wouldn't call myself "Lee Valley's sharpenin guru". I work for Lee Valley. I do a lot of sharpening. I'm pretty good at it. I teach it. When I venture into public space like this I'm speaking strictly for myself, not the company!
That said, I have never sharpened or used a Japanese chisel.
My woodworking education is far from complete.
Re: bevel angle
TomD
Chopping and paring really aren't the issues I would divide along. I would look at prying and penetrating. If one pries out waste, then a fatter bevel will better support that activity. That is supporting working the edge at a 90, not a 0 to the shaft. Short of hitting gravel in there, I have no problem chopping, and black walnut is really pretty light. I have dovetail chisels that are close to 3 degrees.
This brings us to penetrating. Dovetails, particularly in the lighter stock used in drawers and cases, are a defined depth of cut. The fatter your bevel the less easily you will get to a point where the chip is released. Some very thin chisels for special cases can cut right through a board in one pass from both or one side, without any undercuts. While that is the extreme, it dramatizes what can be done when relying on penetration rather than prying out. If one only cuts, and it is just a procedural thing to get there, and doesn't pry, one can maximize penetration, and never need anything over 25 degrees, for dovetails. Or less.
Mortising chisels are a different game. I've had stretcher mortices that went in 8 inches with a 5/16" chisel. I still try not to pry, but not all chisels are designed with that in mind, so one has to adapt when using them. I use 30 for mortising chisels.
OK, thanks.
Re: bevel angle
philip marcou
Joe, why do you want to grind a new chisel?
Anyway, the trade practice I am familiar with is to "grind at 25° and hone at 30°". I use that on all chisels whatever the timber, and have never had significant edge failure whilst using "usual" chisels like Marples, FootPrint, Stanley, Eskilstuna and others other than Japanes chisels with which I have no experience.
I also use a simple honing guide, because I know how easy it is to , er, maintain a constant angle . 
Wow, Tom
Joe Shelton
I don't think I'm going to try 3 deg. But your point is pretty compelling to me. My approach, at this point, is to chop without prying, and I think I'll try 25 deg as a starting point.
Maybe I'll need some more chisels, too, to have some on hand that are refined enough to drive through from one side, and some that will deal with "gravel".
Thanks for your advice.
Joe
Why grind a new chisel?
Joe Shelton
Simple. Looking over the shoulder of some very impressive folks, from my perspective, a hollow grind is the best way to prepare a chisel. I just lost the bubble on what angle to use to implement that hollow grind.
And I'd never had a new set of chisels until two or three days ago...
Joe
To further muddy the water...
Bob Hackett
You might want to take a chisel that has given you less than satisfactory performance and try grinding and honing a 90 degree bevel on the end of it. It now becomes a very effective scraper that can be used on both wood and softer metals up to and including cast iron. Handy tool to have around for all sorts of fitting or easing tasks where a conventional chisel may be a bit too aggressive or take too big a bite.
Too Painful
roninkokomo
It is too hard to decide. That is precisely why you need at least two sets of chisels. One at 25 and the other at 30.
Ron who has three sets ( one for rough work)
scraper angles?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
are metal scrapers sharpened at at 90°? I've been using a somewhat more acute angle, say 85° or so. Maybe that's my problem.
Man after my own heart
Joe Shelton
Now if we can just get Pam to check back in and convince me that the next set should be Blue Steel dovetail chisels from Japan Woodworker, I'm done...
Re: Man after my own heart
Pam Niedermayer
Nice try, will not do that. I'm strictly a white steel aficionado in metric. I can highly recommend Koyamaichi from Stu, Tasai from Iida, and Fujihiro from Hida.
David Weaver likes his blue steel, so we'll have to wait for him to weigh in.
Pam
Re: scraper angles?
Bob Hackett
90 is what I`ve always used. For harder metals I`ve always just brazed a piece of carbide onto an old dull file and honed that carbide with diamond. 
90° scraper
Pam Niedermayer
The other thing this type tool is good for is tamping down stray fibers at the bottom of mortises.
Pam
Re: scraper angles?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I'll give that a shot. What I've done, not having a real scraper, is take a worn out file, grind off the teeth and grind the end at about 85° or so. It never occurred to me to make it less aggressive.
Is Pandora's box dovetailed?
Joe Shelton
Pam, I didn't know to expect that. Maybe I need to just concentrate on what's at hand for the moment. But thanks for the new horizons, anyway.
Joe
Re: Is Pandora's box dovetailed?
Pam Niedermayer
Nah, Pandora probably used bamboo nails. 
Pam
all my furniture is Pandora's box
Patrick Gibbons
There's always hope left inside that the next project will be better.
Re: Why grind a new chisel?
TomD
Hollow grind is a whole other thing. Because if you have an overall angle of 25 degrees, then the actual effective angle at the tip is less, depends on the diameter of the wheel, and the degree ground back, or micro bevels. But penetration wise it will eventually be limited by the heel. All that said:
1) Drive on! 25 degrees hollow ground just hand sharpened without a jig (you can really feel registration), or with a jig. Good to go, if you don't pry, get 'er done. Don't look back.
2) Unlikely to actually be the best since Hollow grinding is mostly just a production oriented technique, and a lot of money has been spent to develop machines that won't do it. It is there because wheels are round.
3) Great way to learn hand sharpening techniques. Since you can always quickly go back to the wheel to get the hollow back, and since the feel is so good, it makes learning to wet the edge really easy. Most people do not find hand sharpening difficult at first. Problems come later when:
a) they get tired with all the material to be removed
b) round the bevel and can't feel the edge, end up chasing it.
c) Have difficulty sharpening long enough in the zone to get the wire edge and transition to the next grit.
This and a lot of other stuff is solved by having a hollow grind so it is a great way to go!
Re: scraper angles?
TomD
For cast iron, it can be in the 90-100 range, with a lot of people calling out 95. For other materials you get other grinds, and these can be as low as 80. Normall there is radius, to allow the tool to penetrated, and to form the surface texture required to hold oil.