New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

An alternative universe of work and storage

Posts

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#26

white surroundings are very important

Bill Tindall

Any light that doesn't fall on the work area hits something else. If it absorbs it is wasted. Even with 16 x 4' lamps overhead I could not get the necessary 200 foot candles until the surroundings were light colored. This reflected light contributed about 25% of the total illumination.

To give some idea of this amount of illumination I can take pictures in the work area with typical camera settings and no flash.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#28

Re: dovetailing *LINK*

Jim in N. Va

Bill,

I think the Benchcrafted version of the Moxon vise is very slick. Great video too!

Jim


Benchcrafted Moxon vise video

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#29

My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd thought about this for quite a while. It was designed to fulfill several functions:

--it had to fit on the credenza behind my desk at work (I work shifts, and at nights and weekends we're allowed to do stuff like this). That credenza is 40" high.

--it had to basically be a vise of sorts.

--it also had to be able to function as a shooting board and bench hook, so the top is designed for that. The base is integral, and serves to provide ears for clamping and also as a base for the plane to ride on and against.

The screws are standard 3/8" carriage bolts.

It works exceptionally well. Turns out, the wood of the vise clamps other wood pieces extremely tightly. All the construction is baltic birch.

As it also turns out, the whole shebang works very well on my regular bench at home if I am seated. Seeing as how I have lower back problems, I try to do as much as possible seated, including dovetail sawing and fitting.


Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#30

Nice Job

Steve Elliott

Bruce,

That’s a great solution to your needs—well thought out, simple but effective, versatile, and easy enough to build that you can get on with dovetailing instead of building fixtures.

In discussions of jigs the focus is often on whether to buy a jig or learn a hand skill. The ability to build your own jig for a particular purpose is itself a skill, and a very useful one. Yours is an excellent example.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#31

Thank you, Steve.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It didn't come easily. I'd struggled with a couple iterations, but the final product has been worth the effort.

One thing I've learned in my decrepitude is that it's sometimes worth it to make trial runs. I used to believe that if I thought hard enough, that first effort would be the only one necessary. Not so.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#32

You know how fond I am of multitaskers

Bill Tindall

Nothing beats a multitasker solution. I like it.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#33

Re: My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Pam Niedermayer

Masterful, great stuff. What kind of work do you do that allows woodworking?

Pam

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#34

Re: My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Power system operator at a public utility. I monitor the electric and gas distribution systems for a small city. It's almost entirely computer driven, so there are a half-dozen monitoring systems to keep track of. At night, the main objective is to keep alert, and what better way than to keep moving!

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#35

Re: My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Pam Niedermayer

Ah ha, and what do you do for dust collection? :)

Pam

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#36

Re: You know how fond I am of multitaskers

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Bill. It has to fulfill several different woodworking functions plus it has to be portable. It occupies a spot in my pickup a lot.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#37

Re: My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Bruce, a MN Galoot

There's a really good vacuum cleaner we keep in the room. :D

I don't do anything with power tools ever, and also I never do anything I can't drop at a moment's notice. I wouldn't want to be in the middle of a glue-up when something serious happened. Last month, on night shift, half our town of 14,000 lost power, and I had the whole shebang put back together in a little over a minute.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#38

Re: My version of a dovetail holder thingie

Pam Niedermayer

Last month, on night shift, half our town of 14,000 lost power, and I had the whole shebang put back together in a little over a minute.

I love it when Austin Energy does that.

Pam

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#39

Irony

James Watriss

Yeah, that entire basement was either old stone foundation, or old brown roughsawn pine. Very dark, and I really didn't like it when I compared to other places that I was working, like school.

Once I moved into my 'real' shop, I thought about keeping a small space to work on things at home, so I gave it a real good cleaning, and painted it white. It looked great, and very inviting, and I couldn't wait to set a little something up down there.

And then I decided to move in with my girlfriend.

Thankfully, the place is now being rented by a friend of mine who uses the basement to do costuming work for theatre, I think. So at least it wasn't wasted.

(Well, except for the quick release vise I left set up down there.)

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#40

Re: PS- two important additional details

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The light issue is ever-important, and increasingly so as our eyes age.

A few years ago I installed fluorescent strips under the cabinets above the bench.

Increasing the reflected light is another reason I must change the existing dark Jarrah bench top for a light Oak top.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#41

Re: the bottom line of it.......

TomD

You talk as though the tradition of benches is something fancy in the pages of Fine Woodworking, not that that would be a bad thing. A real work bench is dead practical, and dead simple. It is fundamentally a beam/top on trestle base (lots of variations) with the workholding maximized. I started out working on the floor in the japanese style, I've made and used simple planing beams. The reality is, that contortions aside, most people in the west do not think those simpler forms are "real benches" either. But they have everything in common with the bench in your shop. A flat thing without all the vices.

Size shape materials are irrelevant if they get you to the same place. But for hand tools, real benches are sturdy, dead flat and maintainable, and have the vises maximized. Otherwise it's a table.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#42

Actually, he doesn't...

John in NM

Paint the traditional bench as something fancy - I think you're imagining that.

Most of Bill's post is doing what he advocates - explaining his work practice and how this arraignment benefits those habits. He's not saying we should all do it, he's not saying what other people do is useless, and he's not saying that anything other than what he does for lesser woodworkers. Even reading between the lines of his posts I don't get those impressions. Bill is by far one of the more analytical and objective people I have come across on the internet.