New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

An alternative universe of work and storage

Posts

An alternative universe of work and storage

#1

An alternative universe of work and storage

Bill Tindall


The picture shows my shop workbench area. Stationary power tools are in the background as well as an open area for assembly and storage of pieces in progress. In this shop I build furniture (over 50 pieces to date), house parts ( cabinetry, trim and doors for this house and parts of daughters) and do maintenance of house and farm equipment.

This bench work area shown in the picture is 9 x 11' and the bench is 3.5 x 7' because that is how the size of the lumber worked out. It is covered with a replaceable sheet of off-white Masonite kind of stuff to provide a light colored durable and cleanable work surface. Two quick release metal vices are mounted on the bench as well as a full sized machinist vice. Overhead are 16 x 4' fluorescent lamps to provide 200 ft candles of illumination at the bench surface. There are unfortunately no windows in this shop(basement). Chisels live in a rack that typically sits on the bench. The bench is large enough that it usually accommodates tools for work in progress.

Three floor to ceiling shelf sections behind the bench (as seen in the picture) provide "at-hand" storage. Starting on the left shelf unit the top is devoted to paper materials and sand paper, next are router bits and drills and below a extensive assortment of nuts bolts and nails sufficient for farm, home and furniture needs.

The next shelf unit mostly contains hanging small hand tools (screw drivers and the like) up top, sharpening stuff, files and the like in the middle and misc. on the bottom. The unit to the far right central to the work area has misc. up top including screws and small bolts and fasteners, measuring tools on next shelf, then marking aids, next are planes and scrapers, then adhesives and tape, and Misc. below. Saws hang from the side of this shelf unit. Clamps are hung from the left wall.

There is a shelf under the bench where corded tools live and a drawer under the bench for small bits of things. Around the corner to the right and out of view is a shelf for finishing materials and house and farm maintenance supplies. It is a long trip to town so I keep on hand more maintenance materials than most.

The whole affair is a product of evolution. But nearly everything I need to work at the bench is within arms reach and I don't need to open anything to get at it.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#2

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

Jerry Gibbs

how do you carry stuff to a remote project?

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#3

Definition of "stuff" is needed.....

Bill Tindall

I am not sure what kind of stuff you are referring to. I don't often carry more than what fits in a 5 gal pail or milk crate anywhere. A common carrying container if I am doing a demo is the milk crate discussed in a posts below, but demos are rare. I carry a cordless drill to fix a farm gate in my pocket or a 5 gal pail. I carried the chop saw to install daughters floor in the back of the truck. Because almost all work is done in the bench area I have never devoted much thought to carrying stuff away from this area. My mechanics tools are in portable tool boxes that I can carry to equipment as I don't have a central place to do this kind of work. I don't like and am not good at mechanics work and hire it done for the most part.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#4

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

TomD

Looks good to me. With your level of productivity, have you not been tempted to build a real bench for the hand tool activities, or even portable power tools?

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#5

"Real" benches

Steve Elliott

Bill's bench is the type I've seen in almost every commercial shop I've worked at in the last thirty-plus years. Of course these have been shops using power equipment where hand tool use is kept to a minumum.

When I was in cabinetmaking school I built a solid maple cabinetmaker's workbench based on plans I bought from Ulmia. Its face vise and tail vise are reversed because I'm left handed. I've sometimes moved it into my space at work but usually it hasn't been much of an improvement over the flimsier back bench the shop already had.

I don't know which type of bench is "real" but both are good and the choice between them depends on style of work.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#6

I'd say that's the point he's been making...

John in NM

For his method of work, that is a real bench.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#7

PS- two important additional details

Bill Tindall

1. The bench has a huge overhang. It enables stuff to be easily clamped to the bench which is how I get by without the usual traditional bench fixtures.

2. Overhead among the multitude of lights are plug drops for corded tools. It is handy to have cords above the work where they are out of the way.

On the subject of lights, the shop was not pleasant to work in compared to my former naturally lighted shop. In fact I could not stand to work in it more than a couple of hours. My brother-in-law, the lighting engineer, diagnosed my problem- too little light, and flicker from the old style ballasts. Apparently I am stressed by flicker. It took a huge number(16) of lamps and a near white bench top to get up to the 200 foot candles he recommended. (Natural outside shade is 500, by comparison. Your shop may only be 50)The result is pleasant and many have commented on the favorable lighting. If you don't like your shop look into the lighting.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#8

Re: I'd say that's the point he's been making...

TomD

I find it hard to believe that a version of that exact bench with some form of face and tail vises, dimensional purity and sustainability, absolute rigidity, and sufficient weight, and a dog system would not be an advantage in any shop Size, surface material etc... aren't fundamental. That's not a real bench for hand work, and this is the hand tools forum. A park bench is also a real bench.

I wouldn't mention any of this if it was in a general forum. Of course maybe he just didn't refer to those features. That's an assembly bench as far as I can see or a utility one. Very useful if one has space. Whenever I am in a commercial space the first thing I build is a 4x8 foot stress skin table, but it isn't real for this kind of work.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#9

Re: PS- two important additional details

TomD

Traditional benches also have overhang, not a replacement for other features. I love building benches, so I would not be able to help myself if I was in need.

The light in my shop is not what it should be. Interesting to hear what you are doing about it. Mine had a ton of fluorescent fixtures when I moved in, but I took them down to drywall and insulate, and I have not replaced them with an adequate system.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#10

Darrell in Oakville

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

Darrell in Oakville

My shop setup is similar to yours, due to my attempts to achieve the elusive Zero Rummage Factor. If the tools are easy to acquire and easy to put away then there is a much greater chance of them being put away when the task is done. I found that every horizontal surface would collect tools until the shop became unusable. Once I set things up so that the tools were spread out over the walls in a thin layer (one tool deep) I found that I could find the tool I needed easily, and more importantly, put it away easily. No more clutter.

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#11

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

Pam Niedermayer

I used a 4'X4' version of this bench for a year in the ACC woodworking shop classes; but we used mostly power, hand held or stationary, very seldom used hand tools. This sounds like your setup.

For my shop this style is more like a stationary assembly table, as Tom said, even though I'd rather have such a table on wheels with a smaller top, and much closer to the floor.

Like your storage setup for its accessibility, although like Darrell, I prefer a single layer of tools on the shop walls for some items.

Pam

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#12

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

I have no doubt that we could make do with just about anything if we are keen enough.

On a recent trip to Bali the local woodworkers worked off the ground. I visited a few shops and did not see one bench in action. I did see a lot of shop made tools ...


It is sobering to see this - certainly driving home the point that woodshops and benches and chests and cabinets are never the critical factor in woodworking. The critical factor is enthusiasm and drive.

In my own shop I work on a bench that is way overdue for replacement in the eyes of many. I built it 18 years ago and it needed to fit among machines in a garage (that was actually used for cars! :D ). It is a little under 5' long. I have planed it down so many times that the dowels I used to align the boards are now showing clearly. Still, I could get by on it - and do - and because I much prefer to build furniture for the house than the shop a new bench gets pushed back down the list ..


A good bench in unnecessary, but it certainly makes woodworking more pleasurable. So a new bench is planned, and it will be special to work on. I have set aside the wood (I managed to uncover a stash of 4x2" European Oak boards (criminal!), enough for a 6'6" long x 22" wide top. I have a terrific wooden screw for a leg vise and the BenchCrafted wagon vise for the other end. I have enough Jarrah rafters to turn into a solid base. Yes, it will be another Roubo - because this will work well in my shop.

I have set up a second, very - very - small bench for dovetailing or mitresawing or shooting ...


.. and, as seen in an above picture, I keep as many tools on the wall above the bench as possible. This gives me a place to rest them when they are not in use, and makes it easier to grab when needed ..

I just could not see myself working out of a chest. Not that this is a bad idea - horses for courses. In fact I had a chest 30 years ago when my wife and I lived in an apartment. Today I just do not have the floor space in a shop which is a double garage and still home to one car.

At the least Chris has created a great deal of self reflection and discussion about the way we work and the work we do. I do not always agree with him, but I certainly have learned something as a result of his writings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#13

I know what you mean about the light...

John in NM

I just moved out of a basement shop in which I could barely stand to spend more than a couple hours. The new building has a lot of natural light and is far more pleasant a space, though smaller and currently just as cold in the winter. I never would have guessed that the lighting alone made such a difference without having experienced it personally.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#14

Re: "Real" benches

Bob Hackett

A bench is something that holds stuff, the first type of holding it does is holding the work at a convenient height that allows the craftsman some comfort and makes it easier for that person to do quality work. My primary WWing bench is a little above waist level because that`s where I am most comfortable doing that kind of work. My anvil is about mid thigh because that`s most comfortable for that type of work. My grinding bench and free standing vice are at chest level to accommodate both my vision and my somewhat diminished upper body strength.

The second thing a bench holds is other holding devices such as a vice or two and acting as an anchor point and base from clamping. Some folks like to have both a WWing and machinist`s vice mounted directly to their bench. Others (myself included) like to build things so one vice will hold another method of clamping. Dogs that drop into or pop up from moveable vice jaws and a machinist vice mounted on a base that my WWing vice can hold securely, as well as soft jaws for my blacksmith`s leg vice are some of my favorites.

When it comes to heavy fab work in metal or wood I find the best approach for me is holdfasts on a stout, flat, work surface.

For me personally, I want something I can WORK on and not be overly concerned about damaging it by screwing things to it ,beating on it, cutting into it, or splashing finishing products on it`s surface.

I have a really nice bench that lives in the residential part of the house. We can sit around it and drink coffee in the morning or if I got up early and felt like doing a little spokeshave work while watching the sunrise thru the sliding glass doors then that was OK too as long as the shavings weren`t tracked anywhere else in the house by the dogs. Unfortunately I am easily distracted and not all the shavings got swept up in a timely manner so that work bench is now a kitchen fixture and off limits to WWing until further notice. :(

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#15

the bottom line of it.......

Bill Tindall

I don't have room for specialized benches. As I stated, this bench must serve to assemble stuff, fix chain saws and prepare dovetails.

Moving into what could become a useful hand tool discussion, how does one use a multitasking bench for hand tool work? To add perspective, my hand tools work does not include dimensioning lumber with hand tools. It does include dovetailing, mortising, and fitting by planing edges and ends and seldom faces, a style more common than the activities of a pure hand tool shop. By hours spent dovetailing is the greater fraction of time, with fitting a distant second.

Given the reality of time spent on these hand tool tasks it becomes most important whether the task can be done reliably and much less important whether it takes a few seconds more to set it up on this less traditional bench. The bottom line is that anything I need to do I can find a reliable means of fastening to enable it to be done reliably. The secret is the large overhang of the bench top from the frame which enables clamping. Something unavailable to the ancients are quickly adjusting "C" clamps. Some of my extensive collection can be seen in the picture, not coincidentally, within an arms length of the bench. A stop clamped to the bench functions just as effectively as a dog in a dog hole, but might take a few seconds longer to install, compensated by the fact that it is infinitely adjustable.

I worked in a professional Period Furniture shop for a bit and upon returning drilled dog holes in front of my quick release vice and purchased (Tools Working Wood) the cheap and effective springy metal devices(whose name I have forgotten) that fit in dog holes . I find this arrangement useful but more than once reverted to two 25# bags of shot on the object to be held (example drawer to plane top edge).

Dovetailing- I don't have any problem quickly and effectively holding parts for dovetailing drawers and cases on this bench. A traditional bench would at most offer a slight improvement in efficiency.

Fitting- A traditional bench would offer some efficiency in effectively holding stuff for planing edges and ends but the inconvenience of the tedious vices on these benches would be a disadvantage for me.


Breaking down lumber- I typically buy lumber in 12' and longer length and step 1 of any project is reducing it to rough cut lengths. The two quick release vices on the same side of the bench is particularly effective for this operation.

In summary I have found ways to use the bench at least nearly as effectively as a traditional bench for the sort of hand tools tasks I do. So I have no motivation to spend time making a traditional bench.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#16

dovetailing

Bill Tindall

Every time you show the picture of your dovetailing holder I move a step closer to making one. I think I am about 1 picture away for getting on with it. I would be zero pictures away if there was a metal acme thread alternative to the wooden screws

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#17

Re: dovetailing

Mark Salomon

...and that acme thread would be found on a screw press, wouldn't it?

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#18

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: the bottom line of it.......

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Bill,

I treat my bench pretty much the same way you do. I use it for just about any project - from woodworking, car & tractor repair, chainsaw sharpening, metal work, or whatever other task may be at hand.


I originally built it for woodworking, so it has some dog holes, and an Emmert-clone vise, but over the years, it's morphed into multi-purpose. I've even embedded a number of brass thread inserts (mostly 5/16 - 18) to use for holding fixtures and tools (Kreg jig, chain sharpener, etc.), but it still gets used mainly for woodworking. At 36½" high, it's a bit high for comfortable handplaning, though (I'm 5'9").

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#19

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: dovetailing

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Bill,

Enco sells Acme threaded rods in three foot lengths, and the matching nuts as well. A ¾" or 1" ought to suit your purposes quite well.

FWIW, I've also been considering one of those DT vises like Derek's.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#20

Re: dovetailing .... improved moxon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I have modified that moxon vise since the picture was taken. I found the handles that Chris Schwarz recommended required too much wrist action ... and they were Slow.

Below is the modified version. This vise works several times faster now ..


Incidentally, the other important factor to keep in mind with a Moxon dovetail vise is that after you set up the vise, you only adjust it thereafter with one handle. It is then very quick to adjust.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/MoxonDovetailVise.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#21

Interesting use of the two vises...

John in NM

I have a spare quick vise I may mount on the half built bench if it ever gets closer to completion (currently the focus is on finishing the new shop building).

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#23

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: dovetailing

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I built one similar to Derek's a few years ago. I needed a way to demo dovetails on a viseless bench at a remote location. I got a used 1" screwbox and tap fairly cheap off ebay(they come up often) and it was a quick learning process.I now have the capability of making wooden screws for all kinds of devices.I got the inspiration from a picture in the workbench book. ---Jack

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#24

wooden vrs metal screws

McKay

I made the vise because my back bothers me so much. I started out with metal screws and did not care for the action. I was able to get two wooden screws made on the Legacy vice. (they did a demo for the states woodworking teachers). Very nice screws and they do the job much nicer than the metal screws.

Re: An alternative universe of work and storage

#25

No Joke

James Watriss

Back when I was still working in my basement, one of the last mods I made to the space was simply to paint the walls white. Added light... even reflected light... makes a world of difference. I hated working down there.