New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

Posts

Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#1

Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

Bill Tindall

When we were in NZ we got the most wonderful pot pies (as well as some sodden ones) but the memory of the the good ones leaves me longing for one on a cold day. No chance of buying one in TN, so will need to fabricate at home. Most needed is the secret to making one that is not sodden.

I also long for the large ginger snaps that were available everywhere. I have never been able to replicate them. I suspect the grease choice is their secret.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#2

in a pot with pastry cover or in pastry case?

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

For pot with pastry cover, I find the key is to cook the inards in a saucepan to the desired consistency (thickness), then transfer to the serving pot and cover the pot with pasty -- into the oven for 10 - 15 mins to cook the pastry. small holes (traditionally made with a fork) for the excess steam to escape

for pastry case, I find it helps if the bottom is blind baked before the inards (at the desired thickness) are added and covered with the pastry lid -- into the oven for 10 - 15 mins to cook the pastry. small holes (traditionally made with a fork) for the excess steam to escape

(I should be in bed)

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#3

That's what I needed

Bill Tindall

The hemispherical source would suggest the revealed "secret" will yield success. It's pies for Tue evening. Now will it be turkey or lamb?

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: That's what I needed

Moses Yoder

My wife has a recipe for pot pie with a biscuit like top that she bakes in I think a 9 x 13 pan. I will post it sometime but probably won't get to it in time for tomorrow night.

My wife has been a cashier at a local Meijers supermarket for about a year now and is shocked at how few people actually use their stove for something besides heating up pizza. She says it's amazing how many people buy twinkies with their food stamp card.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#5

Not amazing if you weigh the customers

Bill Tindall

I believe the reason many are so fat is that they don't cook in a traditional way. They heat up prepared food or go out for food. At 5 PM there are long lines at all the fast food places. Much of the grocery store isles consist of stuff that would never be used to prepare traditional home cooked meals. The prepared frozen dish isles plus the junk food isles may be longer than the meal "raw material" isles. There are numerous isles I never go down for there is no "food" ingredients in them. My curiosity kindled I think I will measure next time.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#7

PS

Bill Tindall

If I am going to float something on a "stew" as opposed to surround it, it will be Yankee dumplings, those light as thistle down affairs that hover atop a pot of stewed pheasant, rabbit or squirrel. If you grew up on Yankee dumplings you would be aghast at what are called dumplings in the south, truly sodden lumps of gelatinous dough sunk to the bottom of otherwise tasty stews.

The pot pie of my dreams is surrounded by flaky crust. The trick is the flaky crust and how to keep it that way.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#8

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

Schtoo

I hate you.

Think I'm going to need to make up some pies or pasties this weekend now.

Probably pasties...

(dry meat and vegetables in a pastry case. Kinda like calzone I suppose.)

(Used to work in a pie shop, can make them in my sleep.)

Stu.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#9

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I was introduced to pasties in N Minneapolis, where a bunch immigrants from northern MN moved after much of the mining declined up nort'. They are wondrous to behold and munch.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#11

Flaky Crust

Steve Elliott

“The trick is the flaky crust and how to keep it that way.”

I’ve never made a pot pie but I’ve been working for a long time on how to make a tender, flaky crust for dessert pies. I’ve found that using cake flour instead of all-purpose flour makes a more tender crust because of the lower gluten content, and that a very hot oven (500 F) for about two minutes will turn the moisture in the crust into steam, creating the flaky layers. After two minutes I open the oven door to release some of the heat, then continue baking at 350 F or a little lower until the filling is done. I like the final crust to be just lightly browned, not enough to create a bitter taste.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#12

Re: What's pasties? *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I was told that it was a meat/veggie pie, usually hand-held, more like a turnover, although my introduction was served with gravy. They were developed for miners who brought their meal in their lunch bucket and were cooked over a stove deep underground. I know they're big in upper Michigan, N. Minn and mining communities in Montana (e.g., Butte). They're a wonderful thing.


Pasties

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#13

Re: PS

Schtoo

I don't know if this is what you're after, but standard pastry layered with shortening or butter will make a puff pastry that's really difficult to make soggy and dead.

I can't tell you any specific recipe for it, since it was a long time ago, and made pies and pasties by the two hundred.

Now, I do it by eye. I'd need to measure after the fact to give you anything like a recipe.

Good luck, it's not rocket science. ;)

Stu.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#14

Re: PS

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My grandmother made the best pie dough in the world. My mother asked her to write down the recipe. It read, in part, "there's this lard..."

Actually, she used 7/8 # of lard and enough flour to make the dough the right consistency, with a little salt thrown in. Who knows how much of each? She did it by feel. She did insist that butter or some substitute (margarine wasn't used for such things 50-60 years ago).

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#15

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

Edward in Vancouver

Yeah,

Take two whole chickens. Bone them out, roast the meat, roast the bones with some onions. Save the drippings, render down all fat and skin in a small pot.

Make a stock with the bones (I have by leaf, rosemary, thyme, and sage growing in my garden).

Save half the fat, heat it, and add enough flour to soak up, keep on low heat and stir until flour is lighly toasted.

In a pot, heat up 50/50 chicken fat and oil, saute diced onions, when soft, add in diced clery and carrots, when soft, add in chopped garlic. Dust with flour. Add in chicken stock,then whisk in your roux (chicken fat & flour), simmer gently. Dice up chicken meat and add in. Season--I like mine pretty simple with just S & P, and fresh herbs.

Now it's just a matter of lining pie pans with pie dough, spooning the filling in, and covering up with more dough.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#17

thanks to all

Bill Tindall

Thanks all....followed Ian's directions and the crust stayed crisp. Inside was just right.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#18

not when it comes to recipies

Bill Tindall

The link is a good example. The details for how to keep the crust crispy that Ian provided were absent in on-line recipe. The problem with the internet as a source of recipes is there is too much information. Search a recipe and one will get a dozen variations, all rated excellent and none may hit the mark.

As another example I know what it takes to get a NY style pizza. I never got there until I has a conversation with Mario the pizza chef and gleaned the details that make it successful. One will find endless variety of pizza recipes and most will not yield a NY style recipe that anyone from NY would recognize.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#19

Yuppier cuisine....not so great....

roger lance

that's just an opinion from a Troll (someone that lives below the Mac Bridge).

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#20

Re: not when it comes to recipies

Schtoo

I find that when looking at recipes, if it looks right, I'll use it as a base to make my own with. Rarely does any recipe work like it should, especially if flour and an oven are involved.

Then again, my wife hates me. I can make a complete mess of something, and yet still save it. Even if it means morphing the mess I have into a new direction. She follows the recipe, and it's a disaster (don't tell her I said that!).

Which information was missing that kept the crust crisp? The vents?

(Used to do them with scissors. 1 for plain meat. 2 for mushroom. 3 for cheese. 2 with sesame for tomato. Round with 1 vent curry. Round with 2 vents chicken. Potato top for Shepherd's pie. Surprised I still remember that...)

Stu.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#21

Re: not when it comes to recipies

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, I consider online recipes kits rather than finished objects. At least they jog my memory about the basic ingredients. Worry a lot less about following their directions.

Pam

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#22

Good to know they worked


Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#23

So, do tell, what was the recipe you used?

James Watriss

Just curious, I'm craving pot pie now...

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#24

here it is

Bill Tindall

Made turkey stew but thicker and added peas. Don't forget to use stock made by boiling the turkey bones. Made pie crust. Followed Ian's instructions for assembly and cooking. Don't over brown the top crust. Crust stayed dry and flaky. I was delighted.

We buy whole turkeys because mass produced chickens have no taste. We render it into parts. Grill the legs and thighs. Bake the breast for sandwiches. Pieces-parts go into pot for stock. I have a recipe for a potato/flour Chibata that is just awesome for poultry sandwiches. The pastry chef from a top Chicago restaurant shared it with me for my NY pizza recipe.

Re: Does anyone have a recipe for Pot Pies

#25

Re: here it is

James Watriss

I still have a quart sized mason jar of turkey broth left over from the post-thanksgiving simmer... sounds like it'll go to a good cause.

So, is your kitchen as production-organized as your shop?