New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Double Edge Saw?

Posts

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#2

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Paul M.

A Ryoba like this is what I use for all my rough cuts anymore. The "fine" side is crosscut with fine teeth with a wider set to handle the crosscut. This is indeed very similar to the tooth pattern on most dozuki's. The other side is filed rip with very little set.

I have two of these. A small cheap disposable 210mm one for bench work in hardwoods, and a larger 270mm one for framing work on larger softwood timbers.

When doing precision small cuts, I still prefer a dozuki because of the additional stiffness the back provides. But all through cuts use the Ryoba.

I fail to see the need for expensive Japanese saws. The cheap ones work just fine for me. The skill of the arm and eye are more important than the tool in this case. And when they inevitably get trashed, the blades are cheap to replace. The user really cannot resharpen these, as it takes more skill and patience than I have to file hardened steel. If the wood has reaction and wants to close on you, then the thin Ryoba wants to kink on the return (up) stroke. After a few such kinks, the blade takes on a new shape and needs work or replacement. An expensive blade is something to cry over. But a cheap trip to Rockler for a stamped out replacement blade is no problem at all.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#3

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Pam Niedermayer

I started out with hand made ryoba of 3 or 4 sizes; but it was that kinking that Paul mentions that drove me to single sided saws. I broke one of them to death, gradually using it down to 1/2, 1/4, 1/8, stub. Not a pretty sight, but it did help teach me how to saw better.

Mitsukawa makes fine saws. I just bought a set of 4 tiny (170 mm) ones to make small things, they're very good and not very expensive (usually about $250 for a set of five plus canvas roll); and I have a super large anahiki for crosscutting logs and timbers that he made that I also like a lot.

I'd say it's worth a try. His quality has been reliable.

Pam

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#4

Re: Double Edge Saw?

david weaver

As paul mentions, there is a solid stiffness with a backed dozuki that is not there with a ryoba, even if the entire saw is hardened (though IME the hardened saw will not flop around like an all factory made soft plated saw with impulse hardened teeth). Pam alludes to what can happen during the learning curve period with a hardened saw.

I don't like any of my ryobas for general dovetail work, partly because of the flop, and partly because the crosscut teeth don't cut as fast as I'd like. I do like them for cutting dovetails quickly in 3/4" material with the rip side of the saw.

I like a rip dozuki better for dovetails in almost anything else, and think LV's rip dozuki (the one that's about a hundred bucks) is a wonderful saw for dovetail and small tenon work. Miles faster than combination dozukis.

I think the hardened saw plate lesson is best learned by breaking some saws and figuring out what not to do . Maybe a cheaper partially handmade saw would be a good way to take a shot at it. It would also let you feel the difference between a hollow ground saw and you could buy a $45 impulse hardened saw to compare. Sometimes the factory made saws are nice, because you can do just about anything with them and get away with it.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#5

I was talking about hand made saws.

Pam Niedermayer

It was a moderately expensive lesson. Unless of course the two that broke were really machine made and the vendors lied.

I haven't tried the LV rip dozuki, Rob sure loves it; but I do love their Japanese Pro Dozuki for dovetails, just as fast and accurate as my Kaneharu rip dovetail. Another that's good is the LN straight handled dovetail.

Pam

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#6

Re: I was talking about hand made saws.

David Weaver

I've never seen that one before. It says it has rakers (!).

I always assumed that the rip dozuki that sells for $100 was the same thing that people refer to as the "professional" dozuki. Guess not.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#7

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have a Mitsukawa dozuki, not one of the crazy priced ones, but one that is partially machine made. I believe it is the same quality as the doube edged saw you are looking at. The blade is hand scraped and if my memory serves me the teeth are machine cut and hand filed(I could be wrong about the teeth) My dozuki is very easy to hold a line with and produces a nearly glass smooth cut. Lately I have been using it to cut the shoulders for tenons and if I do my part the saw will cut a shoulder that needs no clean up.

My dozuki was a $200 saw several years ago so if these double edge saws are of similar quality then I would say they are actually a pretty good price.

Robin

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#8

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Schtoo

Possibly, but no.

To get a 'dozuki' type cut, you'd need to get the 'dozuki-me' saw, which Iida don't list. Their reasoning is that you don't want the economy grade saws, and should always choose the better grade saws.

The 'dozuki-me' from Mitsukawa is 180mm long, is a 'machine' made saw, and isn't expensive. 'Daizo' brand actually.

(I'm just reading off the Mitsukawa price list with my name on it sitting next to me if that might mean anything...)

Anything in the 150-210mm range and better than a Gyokucho will likely have some handwork in it, and should provide a good, clean cut. Once you go above 210mm, you're starting to move away from 'clean' and into 'fast'.

Stu.

(Who really needs to sort out what to do with Mitsukawa and his saws...)

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#9

That LV rip dozuki...

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Can't say enough good about this saw. The product description is no hype:

"This is a superb saw with sawdust finer and speed greater than you expect to see from any dovetail saw"

My experience supports this (and I ran tests).

After about five years of moderate hobbyist use, I bought a second one to see how much sharpness was gone. Well, the old one cut almost as well as the new one...

This is one saw that you can buy with your eyes closed. And no, I'm not paid to endorse it :)

DC

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#10

Re: That LV rip dozuki...

TomD

+1. I find it a little slower than some, but the performance is well above the cost, at least when I bought mine.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#11

Question

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

What saw did you sample that cut faster, and on what wood species? Just curious...

That LV saw cuts faster than my Yataiki rip dozuki, although in all fairness I specified the saw sharpening for hardwoods (maple being the target), and the Yataiki is a tad thicker. The feel is in a different league altogether between the saws, but so is the price :)

DC

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#12

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Gordon Thomas

Schtoo pray tell what is your dilemma with Mitsukawa?

cheers,

Gordon

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#13

Re: Double Edge Saw?

Schtoo

It's this.

When I started listing them, I had to price them at xxxx in order to make enough money on them to be worthwhile. It was a good price, and I was happy to sell as many of them as I could.

I didn't sell many, but I sold enough.

Come November last year, I found myself stuck in Koyamaichi's booth at a large tool show, and he was backed onto Mistukawa's booth. They both know each other well enough, so put 2 and 2 together.

(I get my saws direct from Mistukawa now, not from an agent.)

As a result, I was also given a price list (as alluded to before) and found that my new pricing was quite good. So good that I have great trouble keeping my pricing on the existing saws at the same level. I'd be more comfortable having them at 20% less.

But that also means that those who've already bought saws should see a refund coming, especially since it was those wonderful folks who had faith in me and bought their saws from me in the first place, which allowed me to approach Mr. Mistukawa with a valid offer.

Problem is, I'll have to hunt down all those people, work out how much they should be refunded and get it to them. It's going to be a little expensive, and right now, I don't have enough spare cash to do it. Something for the new year perhaps.

(The store is doing well enough, but still...)

So that is the dilemma.

(Oh, I'll be adding a swathe of stuff in the new year. If I can manage to get it all sorted out!)

Stu.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#14

Re: Question

TomD

I was thinking of stuff like the Independence Dovetail saw, which is really the cuttingest thing around my shop. I bought 3 of them when they came out, so I have not for the most part sampled other premium Western type saws. I have however tried a few others and the Independence outshone them for me. I also have one stock saw from the Mahogany Masterpieces days that was a weird combo tooth, like a riff cutting saw, I bought both the dozuki, and a ryoba, and it's pretty fast. The independence works great for me, but I am sure some would point out that it's aggression is bought at the cost of being a little harder than some saws to start. I prefer it for softwoods, and soft hardwood, south of maple.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#15

Re: Question

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Well, something funny must have happened from Independence to LN, because the LN doesn't cut nearly as fast as you describe the Independence's speed. In fact, my informal test at the time put the LN as twice as slow as the LV-RD...

How's the cut quality with the Independence? Just curious...

DC

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#16

Re: Question

Pam Niedermayer

Don't know anything about the Independence/LN, but the LN straight handled dovetail cuts just as fast as the LV Pro Dozuki (I know, you guys are talking about the Rip Dozuki).

Pam

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#17

Re: Question

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Had the Pro Dozuki, didn't care for it, sold it. It was nowhere close to the Rip Dozuki in terms of speed (to be honest I didn't check the cut quality at the time).

DC

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#18

Re: Question

TomD

Yeah I think the Independence is way better than the LN. I think the story was that at the time I bought, they were all hand sharpened by Tom Law. The Independence is way better than the LV, which I also think is a good saw. The cut is certainly smooth, but it is not the absolute smoothest of smooth. However it is just as it should be if you ask me.

Also, my views about how appropriate it is for really hard woods may reflect the fact that I worry about loosing performance on that account. Still logically the fastest saw should have some hardness limit.

As good as I think the independence is, I do think there is a horses for course element, and that not everyone would agree. Also, Independence was pretty much the first modern saw. There has been a huge amount of stuff discussed and refined over the last ten years. Independence is pre all that. So while it remains my favorite, I think users who dream about saws going to sleep at night, have all kinds of sophisticated preferences, and are going to be hard to please.

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#19

Re: Question

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Tom Law? That would make sense, I tried a few years ago a saw that he sharpened, just an inexpensive gents saw, the type with an orange handle, and boy did it ever cut...

DC

Re: Double Edge Saw?

#20

Re: Question

Pam Niedermayer

Maybe the rip dozuki is superior to the pro; but it's hard to get much faster than 3 strokes per 3/4 dovetail side, same I get with the LN straight handled and Kaneharu rip. One of these days I may give the rip a try, maybe I can get it down to 2.

Pam