New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

The cult of IKEA

Posts

Re: The cult of IKEA

#2

Shop classes...

John in NM

Its an awful shame that shop classes fell by the wayside for the most part. High schools could easily be producing graduates with cnc experience who would be eminently employable in any part of the country. Instead they've passed the buck to community colleges on the basis that guidance counselors should not discourage kids from going to college.

As to the article, I think the author is reaching pretty far to cast IKEA as a cult. Perhaps it's meant to be hyperbolically humorous though :D

Re: The cult of IKEA

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Near perfect marketing....

Jesper, Denmark

It's the application of the old adage: Sell the sizzle, not the steak - or beauty is only skin deep.

Clean Swedish design cobvering over crappy construction underneath. Overtighten one of those Allen head screws by a quarter turn, and it's time to return the item.

On the other hand, things which cannot be hidden by a beautiful surface are of surprizingly good quality - textiles, glass, cooking utensils as examples.

I am not sure what influence IKEA has on WW classes, but I am fairly convinced that in the longer run, the pendulum will swing the other way, and people will look for a more "honest" construction and good WW will increase.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#4

Re: Near perfect marketing....

Pam Niedermayer

On the other hand, things which cannot be hidden by a beautiful surface are of surprisingly good quality - textiles, glass, cooking utensils as examples.

That's really interesting, Jesper, thanks. Having an innate aversion to being surrounded by piles of shoddy stuff, I've never shopped there; but maybe they're worth at least one trip through.

Pam

Re: The cult of IKEA

#5

I bought a wool rug there

Bill Tindall

We were in Orlando killing time when we spied the store. Never been in one so we decided to take a look. The furniture had no appeal either by style or construction (both crude). But when we got to the rug department I found the deep pile wool rug of my dreams for half what it would have cost elsewhere. It is well made. However, a return to the rat maze called Ikea is not likely. I didn't find it a shopping friendly environment. Ditto Best Buy. Both seem to appeal to a demographic that I am well outside of.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#6

Value/quality sweet spot

GolfSteve in Calgary

I'd hesitate the call Ikea products crap....have you taken a look at the prices of "real" furniture in other stores....Slightly better construction at astronomical prices.

I'd say Ikea succeeds because they've hit the sweet-spot in the value/quality continuum. Not bad stuff at a not bad price.

Admittedly they have their share of junky products but if you avoid those there are actually some good products in the store. And you can't beat the 0.75 frozen yoghurt.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#7

Re: I bought a wool rug there

Pam Niedermayer

The rug sounds good; but it's all I can do to not think about the poor maker who most likely had to sell at a price that impoverishes. Maybe. Or maybe it's a middle man who loses big time. No real loss that, unless you're (impersonal) that middle.

I agree with you on the atmosphere. I grew up before style replaced content, and am very resistant to salespeople and advertising. So much so I'd just as soon leave them to their own little worlds, it's tedious being in their presence.

Pam

Re: The cult of IKEA

#8

economic reality

Bill Tindall

If the rug maker could be doing something more profitable he/she would be. Had the rug been more expensive I could have readily lived with out it which would have left the rug maker with his/her next less profitable opportunity to earn a living. For all I know the rug maker is so good at making a product that many will afford that he, or she, lives better than the person making $1000 saws that would seem to have a limited market that would preclude a live of luxury. In either case their situation is not my concern unless I decide to make a charitable contribution instead of a purchase.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#9

Re: Value/quality sweet spot

David Weaver

I would agree. Some of the stuff is permanently serviceable, and if not, makes good functional placeholder furniture.

Not that we have gobs of it here, we have one piece (a steam bent ply framed leather chair), but it's important to think about what it replaces - for the folks with near no means, it is a suitable option to having nothing at all, and from what I gather, it is far better than the particleboard woodgrain-tape covered stuff that walmart and other places sell.

Make that two pieces, we do have a kid's table and chairs for the little miss. It's made of wood, painted with non-toxic paint and it cost far less than what it would've cost for me to get the wood.

Dishes, etc, as mentioned are a good deal for beaters. Basically allows you to replace all of the plastic junk you have around with decent quality low-price stoneware.

I find the ikea ire misguided - especially when it comes from luddites who think everyone should do as trades promoters dictate and throw money at them. People buying lots of furniture from ikea never would've bought high-end furniture to begin with. It serves a need, and as far as I can tell, does so ethically.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#10

Your judgement is subject

CJ in MPLS

The frozen stuff you refer to is clearly where they use left over sawdust. The meatballs are probably the same, but gravy and some lingonberry sauce cover a lot of sins.

CJ

Re: The cult of IKEA

#11

Re: Near perfect marketing....

TomD

Yeah, my current green coffee cup comes from there. I am at peace.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#12

Re: Near perfect marketing....

TomD

Don't buy the jam, if anyone in your family makes jam...

Re: The cult of IKEA

#13

Re: I bought a wool rug there

TomD

Yeah, now if you were into rugs, you would have said the same thing about the rugs as you did the wood. We all have some core competence, but the overall level is pretty much the same.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#14

Re: Value/quality sweet spot

TomD

They also have some stuff a woodworker could buy as a source of materials. Hardware, solid surfacing, Stainless.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#15

Re: economic reality

TomD

That's a bit wordy. And you can only guess about the actual conditions. Let me bottom line it for you:

"I don't care".

:)

Re: The cult of IKEA

#16

I'm with you Pam

Jeff Weaver

About 15 years ago, my wife and I bought a pair of hand-tied wool rugs. Both 8 x 10. Originating from somewhere in the Middle East. On sale for a few hundred dollars each. After the purchase, the salesman explained that a rug that size took two men (or women) six months to complete. That rug represented half a year's wages for two people.

I presumed that even on sale, the store was still making a profit, and not selling at a loss. Yes, the salesman assured me. I then speculated about the number of links in the chain, each selling at a profit, to get back to the maker. The salesman, seeing my wheels turning, said, with a painful look, "I know, sir. Try not to think about it."

We still have those rugs, and I can't help thinking about it.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#17

Re: The cult of IKEA

joel moskowitz

250 years ago furniture made by cabinetmakers was expensive and only the upper middle class had any. Everyone else had joiner's work (read shaker type stuff), hand me down, or they sat on the floor. In general people had far far fewer pieces of furniture than today.

150 years ago furniture made by cabinetmakers was expensive and only the upper middle class had any. The new middle class wanted furniture and in the US even as early as 1850 furniture for the masses was made by mass production in factories using specialized machinery. In England low cost furniture was made by "Garret masters" and sold to distributors known in the trade as "the slaughterers" because of the less than starvation wages they paid. very little of this furniture was built well enough to survive and certainly did not interest your average collector so very little is around today.

By the 20th century Londoners could buy decent midpriced furniture made on the East End, not custom, and more expensive than what the slaughters sold, this model survived until WW2.

Ikea, for all that I hate what they do, is a natural continuation of the mass furniture making tradition. Most people don't care about how well a thing is made, or under what conditions. Price is king. I can't blame them, and certainly the current trend in US government is to make it worse not better. I might not be guilty in the furniture world but like most people all my clothing is made in the third world as is increasing some of the food I buy.

Fortunately on a small local scale I increasingly have access to local food, and lots of local products. And local food from the farmer's market is always our first stop.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#18

Re: economic reality *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Most people concentrate on the bit after the "but," or in this case, the second paragraph. :) The first was commentary on how the big box sellers work their "magic," not any criticism of you or what you bought.

Along these lines, here's an interesting article in the NYTimes Sunday Book Review today on the issue of reselling intellectual property, link below.

Pam


Free Ride by Robert Levin

Re: The cult of IKEA

#19

Re: I'm with you Pam

Pam Niedermayer

Yes, isn't it annoying when these pesky guilt ridden thoughts invade daily. We have so much, for which I'm thankful, but it does seem unfair at times.

Pam

Re: The cult of IKEA

#20

Moses Yoder

Re: The cult of McDonalds

Moses Yoder

Long before Ikea was in the USA, there was McDonalds. Billions of people bought poor quality food because it was cheap and fast. Ikea probably studied the McDonalds business plan and simply followed suit. At least Ikea's furniture won't kill a person, if it is used with common sense.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#21

Moses Yoder

Re: economic reality

Moses Yoder

I care that 18,500 children starve to death every year, I just don't have enough money to feed them all. I honestly wish I had all the answers. I had to put my dog down today, and I care about that too, just nothing I can do about it.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#22

Moses Yoder

Re: I'm with you Pam

Moses Yoder

I think I would be more concerned if I was the rug retailer. To buy a rug and make use of someone's work seems honorable to me.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#23

Sorry to hear that Moses....

roger lance

I had to also do that with my dog....my friend....a golden....I still miss him.

Re: The cult of IKEA

#24

No arguments there, Moses.


Re: The cult of IKEA

#25

Re: The cult of McDonalds

Pam Niedermayer

And to think tax paying citizens of the US subsidize McDonalds. I think the real cost of a crappy meal is something like $200.

Every time we take a road trip I get kind of sick because Jack actually likes their milk shakes; so we're always stopping there and nowhere else. Hah! As if there were any real milk product in that garbage with the nasty after taste.

Pam