Re: Question about Japanese saws
wilbur
Since Yataiki made this particular saw, and since he is no longer making saws, part of the price is certainly due to the name and collector's value.
But here are the things that distinguish any handmade Japanese saw from a home center model. First, the construction is in a large part by hand. You start with a piece of steel, hammer it out to the shape and thickness of a saw, and perform the hardening/tempering to make it ideal for sawing. Then the teeth are cut into the saw, again usually by hand, sharpened and set. Then the blade is scraped so that it simultaneously tapers from the tooth line towards the center, and so that it tapers from the handle end to the other.
What you wind up with is a saw that cuts more smoothly and with less effort than the machine made versions. A photo doesn't do much to show these differences, but if you compare the two side by side in person, you can easily see the difference.
Here's a video that will give you a good idea as how much goes into the process of making a saw:
http://web.mac.com/nami_aru/Daiku/NokoGiri.html
For the machine made versions, a thin piece of steel is cut to the shape of the saw, and the teeth are cut at the same time. The teeth are hardened via an electroimpulse method, which leaves them too hard to sharpen later on. No scraping is done so that the saw blade is the same thickness throughout. This is certainly a lot less labor than making a Japanese saw by hand.
As far as the actual cost of manufacture, I have a handmade 210mm ryoba that is made by a saw maker named Heiji who is still actively making saws the old fashioned way. It cost me about $400, which seemed a bit outrageous at the time, but seems less so now, since it's really $400 for two saws, since I can use it for both rip cuts and crosscuts (in fact, I use my 210mm ryoba in lieu of a pair of backsaws), and these days there are a number of western saw makers who are charging $200 for a single purpose saw, when that wasn't the case a few years ago.