New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Yataiki ryoba

Posts

Yataiki ryoba

#1

Yataiki ryoba

Pam Niedermayer

I got the following email from Tomohito Iida (iida@japantool-iida.com) a couple of days ago:

My wholesaler got a ryoba saw 210mm by Yataiki(Miyano Dai Endo) by chance. A retailer had it. He has kept it in good condition.

Yataiki used white steel #2 which is the best steel for saws.

Price:148,200 JPY(Shipping:Free)($1900+)

Tomohito is reliable and good, but I'm not looking for another ryoba, even a Yataiki. If any of you are and you are still flush, contact Tomohito-san. I promise you that if he finds a dozuki, I'll never tell you about it. :)

Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#2

Re: Yataiki ryoba

Howard Pollack

That would sure be a nice saw to own.... -Howard

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#3

Re: Yataiki ryoba, photo

Pam Niedermayer

Completely forgot to upload a photo, enjoy.


Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#4

Ellis Walentine

Question about Japanese saws

Ellis Walentine

I look at the photos of that ryoba saw and have a difficult time telling it from my $30 beater ryobas just by appearance. Naturally, the white steel isn't something you can readily pick out of a photograph, but what other attributes distinguish a saw of this caliber from less expensive versions?

Ellis

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#5

Re: Question about Japanese saws

wilbur

Since Yataiki made this particular saw, and since he is no longer making saws, part of the price is certainly due to the name and collector's value.

But here are the things that distinguish any handmade Japanese saw from a home center model. First, the construction is in a large part by hand. You start with a piece of steel, hammer it out to the shape and thickness of a saw, and perform the hardening/tempering to make it ideal for sawing. Then the teeth are cut into the saw, again usually by hand, sharpened and set. Then the blade is scraped so that it simultaneously tapers from the tooth line towards the center, and so that it tapers from the handle end to the other.

What you wind up with is a saw that cuts more smoothly and with less effort than the machine made versions. A photo doesn't do much to show these differences, but if you compare the two side by side in person, you can easily see the difference.

Here's a video that will give you a good idea as how much goes into the process of making a saw:

http://web.mac.com/nami_aru/Daiku/NokoGiri.html

For the machine made versions, a thin piece of steel is cut to the shape of the saw, and the teeth are cut at the same time. The teeth are hardened via an electroimpulse method, which leaves them too hard to sharpen later on. No scraping is done so that the saw blade is the same thickness throughout. This is certainly a lot less labor than making a Japanese saw by hand.

As far as the actual cost of manufacture, I have a handmade 210mm ryoba that is made by a saw maker named Heiji who is still actively making saws the old fashioned way. It cost me about $400, which seemed a bit outrageous at the time, but seems less so now, since it's really $400 for two saws, since I can use it for both rip cuts and crosscuts (in fact, I use my 210mm ryoba in lieu of a pair of backsaws), and these days there are a number of western saw makers who are charging $200 for a single purpose saw, when that wasn't the case a few years ago.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#6

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Schtoo

Hi Ellis,

That Yataiki is creme-de-la-creme of Japanese saws, at least of recently modern manufacture. The name 'Yataiki' itself commands a very high price all by itself.

It should have been hammered out from a block of steel, had a wrought iron tang forge welded to the steel then heat treated. Scraped down to thickness, hit with a hammer repeatedly to tension and straighten the blade then burnished to reduce drag. Then the teeth will be cut, hand filed to correct shape, hand set with a hammer (more tensioning than bending, limits the chance of breakage) and sharpened by hand.

It'll then be tested and any adjustments required will be made. Cleaned, packed and ready to go out the door.

It'll cut faster than your beaters, much MUCH faster, possibly up to 100% faster in similar woods, even NA hardwoods. It'll cut cleaner than any saw you've likely used so far in your life, and more likely than not finish ready off the saw, either rip or cross cut.

That's what a very top end saw goes through, but whether this Yataiki saw has gone through all of that, I don't know.

Is it worth it?

I've used saws of that kind of level, and they're lust inducing to say the very least. I don't know that I'd be willing to pay that kind of coin though, since you can get most of that work and performance with a more gentle price tag.

(But compared to what I've got being made up as I write this, that saw is chicken feed. Some chisels and a plane with telephone number price tags. :O )

Stu.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#7

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, what Wilbur and Stu said. I've got two Yataiki saws, much cheaper than this ryoba, both azebiki, one large, one small (panel saws, you can see this type at Hida (http://www.hidatool.com/shop/shop.html), choose Woodworking:Saws, scroll about half way down the page). I've also got a Woodcraft azebiki, purchased very early on. They all work, but starting a mid-panel cut with one of the Yataiki is a pleasure rather than an onerous task.

Same with a Tasai 36mm ultra thin paring chisel. It's a joy to use, makes me feel masterful.

I liken this to furniture making. How much more would you pay for a masterful table made with mortise and tenon joinery, maybe some dovetails thrown in, nicely french polished than for one made with nailed butt joints?

OTOH, I've also got a LV Japanese Pro dozuki, replaceable blade, that cuts dovetails as well as a hand made Kaneharu single side rip and the LN straight handled dovetail saw. So perhaps it's the type of saw that makes a big difference, too.

Pam

PS Oh, yes, and I guess I should mention how much I personally hate Yataiki; but he sure made great saws.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#8

How much more for a handle??


Re: Yataiki ryoba

#9

Seriously??


Re: Yataiki ryoba

#10

OK, Roger, now pull on her other leg...


Re: Yataiki ryoba

#11

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Frank D. in Montreal

Hi Pam,

I have to ask: how does your personal hate for the man relate in any way to this forum? Seeing that you give no specifics (as you shouldn't, which only shows how it has no business even being referred to on a public forum) and that the person being slighted isn't here to defend himself, I'd say that's a very cheap shot. and if you hate him so much, why even waste yout time thinking about him? You hate him but you love his saws? So you don't let your principles get in the way of your principles.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#12

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Pam Niedermayer

Cheap shots deserve cheap shots in reply. He gave me a much larger cheap shot.

Also should have mentioned that I have no skin in this game.

Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#13

Re: Question about Japanese saws

TomD

Or looked at otherwise Frank, if she says his saws are great, it isn't apparently because of her love for the man. So it's relevant as a weighting of the praise for the saws. It really isn't all that negative, since Pam doesn't specify why, and not everyone else always agrees with Pam around here, as she knows, so it isn't really an instant black eye for this guy with the saws. I'd say scrupulously fair, at the level of opinion.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#14

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Pam actually mentioned a while ago the reasons for her feelings towards Yataiki (and Odate at the same time IIRC). I have no other information to support her position or not, so I will not pass any judgment one way or another...

As for the saws, my two dozuki are absolutely fantastic :)

DC

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#15

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Pam Niedermayer

Yes, it's normally my habit to not buy things from people who've done their best to impede me (usually as a woman), don't see any point in helping them make more money. Or, a personal economic boycott.

So Tom is exactly right, it's a major departure for me to buy anything from such miscreants, have to turn my head and hold my nose, so to speak; and yet, I bought two of Yataiki's saws and would have bought another if found. And I sure hope only Kayoko made any money from the sale.

Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#16

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Frank D. in Montreal

"Or looked at otherwise Frank, if she says his saws are great, it isn't apparently because of her love for the man. So it's relevant as a weighting of the praise for the saws. It really isn't all that negative, since Pam doesn't specify why, and not everyone else always agrees with Pam around here, as she knows, so it isn't really an instant black eye for this guy with the saws. I'd say scrupulously fair, at the level of opinion."

thats a more charitable way of looking at it. But I still don't see how it's fair. As a statement of her feelings I can't argue with it on a factual level, but that's what I find improper about it because it serves to point a finger or cast a shadow on someone's character without taking on the responsibility of substantiation. If we were talking about the man's character, sure, but an offhand remark in a discussion about the man's saws is IMO irresponsible. I don't think it has any bearing on the value or validity of her statement about his saws either; whether she loves or hates the man should be beside the point of how good his saws are. Now I'm not defending Yataiki either. I have no idea who he is other than a saw maker and, now, someone who Pam hates. I don't think I've ever seen anyone disagree with Pam's opinions on tools. The conflicts seem to arise when she makes value judgements on people which are uncalled for, as in this case. I probably should have just refrained from commenting, but it's like when you see someone repeatedly dropping peanut shells on the floor: you don't mention it the first few times, but eventually you feel compelled to say that someone else will have to sweep them up.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#17

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Frank D. in Montreal

But Pam, don't you speak as if Yataiki was selling water in the desert? His saws may be the best, but you do have alternatives. Are you not just satisfying a desire by possessing a Yataiki saw, rather than fulfilling a need? It's not that I think you should NOT buy his saws, but if you do, or if you let people know that one of his saws are for sale, then why make the moral statement?

I don't want to argue your values with you, and it's not as if all of us don't have our contradictions, but in this case I think your sense of justice is counterproductive.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#18

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Pam Niedermayer

All I can say is that his panel saws are so far ahead of the regular panel saws that there was no question that my money was well spent. Granted, they were a lot cheaper than this ryoba, but they're also a lot smaller. There are a couple of other saw makers who approach this quality.

I don't want to argue your values with you, and it's not as if all of us don't have our contradictions, but in this case I think your sense of justice is counterproductive.

Hmmm, maybe so, but I'm not selling/trying to sell this saw. A friend has one, and now you all know about its availability. I guess you'd prefer a sales pitch?

Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#19

Re: Question about Japanese saws

Pam Niedermayer

Oh, come on, Frank. You guys always get such a kick picking apart everything I say. As Dean said, I posted the full story a couple or four years ago, and that was that. I have no desire to repeat it, and I won't. Use the search function.

I expect the next words to be "but gee, he has to make a living."

Pam

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#20

Maybe we can stop kicking the can around

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Pam made her statement; there are some disagreements about whether it was usefully legitimate information or gratuitous or even gauche or rude.

But there it is, she said it; and the original point was that there's a hand-made saw out there that Pam thought folks might be interested in. I've been following that part of this thread with some interest. As a lifelong bottom feeder, I'm always intrigued by discussions of tools whose prices make my ears bleed; it's like imagining myself as someone who owns a Maybach sedan. Vicarious pleasures can be pleasures, too.

Maybe, if my sweetheart and I ever get around to our trip back to Memphis (family on her side there), I should try to slip in a side trip to Pam's shop, to try out some of these godlike saws.

Re: Yataiki ryoba

#21

Re: Maybe we can stop kicking the can around

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks, Bill; but you are likely to be disappointed visiting my "shop," which is really a tiny shed, still. The house is tiny, too, a retirement single level in a close in suburb, chosen in 2000 after the crash because we still had barely enough left to pay cash for it (I developed software for a mortgage aggregator, so I saw what was likely to come). And, boy, was I glad to have it after 9/11, which ate our business within 6 months. It got really dicey there for a couple or three years. The rest is history.

As to saws, the most amazing Japanese saw I have is the Pro Dozuki from LV, very cheap as these things go, and even cheaper when I bought it. Oh, yeah, and nobody else uses my hand made Japanese tools. If anybody is going to wreck them, I'd prefer it be me. :)

Pam