New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How many tools do we need again?

Posts

How many tools do we need again?

#1

How many tools do we need again?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm reading a book on Ernest Shackleton's ill-fated attempt to walk across the Antarctic continent in 1914. The ship got caught in the ice before they reached land, and was eventually crushed, with the crew sledging and boating to land (not done yet; please, no one mention what happens next). There's a reference to the ship's carpenter adding freeboard to the ship's boats and repairing broken planking using a saw, hammer, chisel (one, I guess), and adze as his sole and entire kit. Makes me embarrassed by my shop, which is so crammed it spills over, to my bride's frustration.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#2

Re: How many tools do we need again?

Bill Tindall

maybe your life will be better because you have more tools...............just a thought. In any case I am betting on more tools as insurance.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#3

But if he COULD'A had . . .

steve mackay

:D

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#4

That ship's carpenter's life

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I sure wouldn't trade his skills for his experience there. The book refers to an 18 degree (Fahrenheit) day as "warm." Having, so far in life, lived in Minnesota for a year and a half and Michigan (warmer but wetter) for three, I know that was a sincere statement, and that the body does adapt (within limits), but I'm not sure I want my body to be adapting to those temperatures anymore.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

My thoughts exactly


Re: How many tools do we need again?

#6

Re: How many tools do we need again?

Michael Brady

Ah, but Shackleton's carpenter was an anarchist and had his tool chest with him. He could build anything.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#7

Just one more


Re: How many tools do we need again?

#8

Re: That ship's carpenter's life

Bruce, a MN Galoot

"but I'm not sure I want my body to be adapting to those temperatures anymore. "

No you don't :D

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#9

Which of the books are you reading?

Chuck Nickerson

I've read four, and I favor Caroline Alexander's.

Be sure to read one about the support team that was laying supply depots for the second half of the trip.

Everybody forgets them. I'll look up the title if you'd like.

Chuck

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#10

Re: Which of the books are you reading?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Yes, Caroline Alexander's book - I came across it at a garage sale, 50 cents. It's so clean I'm considering talking to the county library to see if they want to add it to their catalog.

Yes, I'd be interested in a book that goes into more detail on the supply depot crew. Alexander makes an offhand reference - clearly, she was feeling the pressure to end the book - but it sounds like they were just as heroic and just as nuts.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: How many tools do we need again?

Moses Yoder

I was at a tool meet one time and picked up a Stanley #3 bench plane but I noticed it had a chip out of the body so I set it back down. I didn't want to spend the $3 just for some more parts. The owner of the plane noticed me looking at it and said he would give it to me, and I politely declined, saying I had no use for it. He then proceeded to walk over and pick up the plane and started walking towards a dumpster. He said "Well, I have no use for it either." I looked at him walking away and said "Now wait a minute, if you're just going to throw that away I'll take it." So now I guess I have one tool that I don't really need.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#12

Re: How many tools do we need again?

TomD

He might have had trouble running molding...

I go to the country shop every year, and there are a lot less tools there. I get about the same amount done or more. Also, every tool in the shop requires work or money to be put in it, sooner or later. That is probably the big cost.

I used to keep a picture of the Shed the Aussi polar expedition had. The part that interested me was their Drumond metal lathe. So you never know what they might have had a hundred years back.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I'm a klutz, so......

Jesper, Denmark

My philosophy on tools is as follows:

If I need to perform some task, I will want to use the best possible tool for the job. That eliminates any blame on the tool, leaving only the operator. I buy the best tool I can afford at the time, even though I may never need to perform exactly that function again.

It gives me a lot of pleasure to have good tools to be available whenever I have to do something. I do also not give a whit that some of these tools may sit there for years without being used. It puts a smile on my face that when I need to do something, I can often go to just the right tool for the job and get it accomplished as efficiently as I am able to.

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#14

You nailed it!

Bob Hackett

Having the right tool for the job expands your capability and your options.

There`s a lot of truth to the old saying "When all you have is a hammer,the world begins to look like a nail".

Not that I have anything against "Percussive maintenance". :)

Re: How many tools do we need again?

#15

I'm not arguing against that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Maybe I'm just displaying my uneasiness about my own hunter-gatherer proclivities, but I do think there's such a thing as overboard. The other day, someone on another forum asked if it's possible to cut dovetails with a regular bench chisel. I guess he'd been watching the debates between the fishtail chisel and skew chisel camps and inferred from what they said that one or the other must be an absolute minimum in tooling for this task.