New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Groz planes?

Posts

Groz planes?

#1

Groz planes?

Clementine

Would you do this to a friend (Seriously)? I have a good friend to whom I would like to give a hand plane. I can't afford the really nice ones and I'm inept at restoring old Stanleys. I see where Woodcraft has Groz planes marked way down, but the reviews are all over the map. My friend piddles in the shop, but he would not be known as a woodworker. I don't want to give him a piece of junk, but would you take a chance on a Groz?

Re: Groz planes?

#2

Re: Groz planes?

Pam Niedermayer

And what's your goal in giving a friend who piddles a plane that may have difficulties? I'd say not to bother, give him something else, probably not woodworking related.

Pam

Re: Groz planes?

#3

Re: Groz planes? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I wouldn't recommend it. There is a reason that these are cheaper than you might commonly find at some garage sales for a 50+ year old plane.

This will sound strange, but Harbor Freight has a plane in that price bracket that's actually gotten some pretty decent reviews. The link below is to a Sawmill Creek conversation about the plane, with the link to the plane itself in the first post.

If he's just messing around in the shop, the first plane he should actually have is a block plane. The Lee Valley apron plane ($85 plus shipping) or Lie-Nielsen small block ($95 plus shipping) are both said to be outstanding planes, but this may be more than your budget can stand.


Look for the link to the plane in the first post

Re: Groz planes?

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Groz planes? *LINK*

Moses Yoder

I would buy him the Veritas P724 plumb bob instead. It is a beautiful tool, very well made, (needs no fiddling to work) and he might actually find a use for it as either an interesting paperweight or perhaps actually installing a door jamb. See link below.


Veritas P724 Plum Bob

Re: Groz planes?

#5

2nd a "block" . . .

steve mackay

If he isn't dedicated to "woodworking" a block plane makes the most sense. It IS used in woodworking and will give him a start in the "plane world"but it is also a universal tool. Remodeling, fixing doors (or anything for that matter). Anywhere he needs to do some "adjusting". If he likes it and finds it usefull, then he thinks "I could use a bigger plane". As to what brand or flavor . . . sounds like youd be better served stoping at Sears or ACE where you could ask questions. I've tried Groz tools and didn't think much of them. About all I got was frustrated with them. Not a good thing with a beginner.

Re: Groz planes?

#6

No - life is too short for bad tools


Re: Groz planes?

#7

HF Plane

Jerry Nicholson

That HF plane looks just like my Stanley SB4. Kind of a bench plane with a spokeshave blade. I never have been able to my SB4 adjusted to suit me but it would probably work just fine on soft wood.

Jerry

Re: Groz planes?

#8

Re: Groz planes?

Clementine

274 Plumb Bob. Perfect suggestion! I ordered it this morning. He does do some carpentry, so he will make good use of it. Also, I once showed him a nice plumb bob I hereited from Dad, and I thought I detected a note of envy from my friend. So the Veritas is perfect.

Thanks everyone. I hear you on the Groz and the HF planes.

Re: Groz planes?

#9

Not to a friend, no.

James Watriss

Back when I worked at Woodcraft, we buried those in the back of the case and only sold them to people we really didn't like. I actually refused to sell them to a few people.

FWW did a review on em a few years back. Even after replacing the iron with a premium, sharpened one, and chip breaker from a Clifton plane, and fussing for a while, they couldn't get it to work well.

I looked for a Groz promotional sticker to apply to the back of the toilet bowl at the store, but couldn't find one.