New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

Posts

Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#1

Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

roger lance

Last night, I received an unexpected package from LV that contained a new SBUS with a note that read that LV had mistakenly placed a small bevel on the rear of the toe of the plane I recently bought. So they sent a completely new plane in exchange to resolve that mistake. This is a "flaw" that was so minor that it was not discovered/discussed in the review below. I was critical about some cosmetics of this plane and to now be fair, this is an exceptional company to make this kind of correction!! I remain a loyal LV customer...for a number of reasons.

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#2

Re: Were you asked to return the first plane?


Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#3

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I had read on another forum of this bevel, and of LV sending a replacement. Like you, that does not surprise me in the least.

I checked mine. It does not have the bevel. So I assume it must have occured with a select number, and those were replaced.

In any event it would not make an iota of difference with a plane that has an included angle of 55-60 degrees and above. In fact, at this angle you could leave the mouth wide open and it would not make any difference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#4

Yes....it's an exchange.


Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#5

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

roger lance

Derek....I really don't want to belabor the point; but, I find this voluntary replacement by LV to be totally unique in my experience. I have been buying tools for a long time and a number of those tools had some major shortcomings in design and/or manufacture. I've never had a manufacturer contact me saying we could have made such and such better...here is a replacement part...thanks for being our customer. The only time I've heard of a product recall/replacement seems to be when a company is caught in violation of some significant law (EPA, OSHA, etc) and can be successfully sued or there is such an uproar by customers over a poor product that a company acts to maintain what is left of their reputation/good will. At best, you may get a redesign on the next generation of that product. This is so unique....a minor hardly noticeable "flaw"....no customer complaint/awareness....totally voluntary by the company. Thanks Lee Valley.

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#6

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

A little while ago LV redesigned/upgraded the depth stop for the Large Router plane. Rather than sell the part as an accessory, they sent all owners the new depth stop. There have been other similar examples.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#7

Information noted

Bill Tindall

Your experience will influence future purchase decisions.

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

#8

Re: Update on Veritas small BU smoother...

North of the Border

All my handplanes (seven of them) and dovetail saws (three) are Veritas products not because I am a Canuck, but because I trust that my purchases are always taken care of during and after the sale. I never think "Buy American Only" or, for that matter, "Buy Canadian Only" is a good purchase policy, because if everybody does that, the merchants or producers won't find any incentive to compete or improve their services. The reality is that those who do go by that buy-locally-only thinking are in the very small minority; the growth of Walmart and discount stores is proof.

Rather, we should support companies which show us that they care about our business, even if it means a temporary negative impact on the financial performance. Lee Valley, as you said, has shown such caring, time and time again.