Veritas Crosscut Carcass Saw
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
I received the subject saw yesterday and thought I'd post my initial thoughts of it. Keep in mind I am not a hard core hand tool guy. I do have other Veritas products and have always been more than happy with them. My BU Smoother is my favorite plane by far.
I wanted to get a 'go-to' crosscut saw; a saw I could grab and use when I needed to make quick and clean crosscuts in smaller pieces. For those times where using the table/cabinet saw doesn't make sense.
I already have an Adria DT saw which I really like and also a Dozuki saw I bought at WoodCraft a number of years ago.
The Dozuki does a great job of crosscutting. It cuts quickly and cleanly. I've just never been able to get used to the handle. I guess I don't care too much for the style of it.
As I recall the cost of the Dozuki was about the same as the Veritas. The Adria is a lot more; around $150 as I recall.
So I opened the box and was disappointed to notice the handle was loose. In addition, the blade has small scratches on it. No big deal there, except I looked at the Dozuki and after several years of use, the blade looks brand new. The Adria, which is even older, is scratch free as well. It's no big deal, and it's not fair to compare the Veritas to the Adria, but it's just something I noticed.
The Veritas has a screw in the handle so you can tighten it and/or remove it and make your own handle. This screw was loose, not even finger tight. I figured tightening that would tighten the handle down, but I called LV anyway. What if I tried to tighten the screw and the handle didn't tighten up? What if I marred the screw with the screw driver, would I be able to return it? So I called and sure enough, the very helpful and courteous person on the phone said to tighten it. Problem solved.
The instruction pamphlet that came with the saw recommends taking a sharpening stone (<1200) and doing one pass on each side of the blade to remove sharpening burs. I didn't do that in case I want to return it.
So I went downstairs to the 'shop' to make some scrap. I did a number of cuts in some scrap poplar with all 3 saws.
First impression? Not too impressed really. Again, I know it's not fair to compare the Veritas saw to the Adria, but maybe it's not unfair to compare it to the Dozuki(?).
The Veritas did cut quickly and with little effort, but so do the other two. Actually, the other two were quicker and with less effort - I suppose that is subjective though.
What I was most interested in though was a crosscut saw that left a clean cut. And that is where I am disappointed. As far as teeth marks left on the surface goes, the Adria (filed rip) was by far the cleanest, then the Dozuki, and last was the Veritas. The Veritas didn't leave a very clean cut compared to the other two saws.
Maybe my expectations where too high? Could very well be. I don't know. But if I was to cut some small molding pieces for the top of a case or something, this saw wouldn't give me the cut I would want. You would need to clean up the saw marks with a block plane or something I suppose. Maybe you would with a high end LN crosscut saw too. With my limited experience, I really don't know.
It might be comparing apples to oranges, but the Dozuki leaves a noticeably cleaner surface.
This weekend I hope to play around some more with it. I want to cut some cherry, maple, and walnut to see how it does. I'm going to make a new saw hook and see how it goes.
Perhaps my expectations were too high - probably.
Maybe my technique stinks - good chance of that.
Maybe the saw cuts exactly how it was designed to cut and my inexperience is expecting too much from it?
Maybe I bought the wrong saw.
The Veritas has a nice feel to it, nice weight and balance too. Maybe I just need to practice and play around with it more. Maybe I'll come to terms with it. I'll let you know.
Don't shoot me. These are just thoughts/impressions from an amateur.
Joe




