New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

liquid hide vrs. hot

Posts

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#26

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

TomD

Truth!

The cold glue is modified with urea, or something to give it open time. There is probably other stuff in there. The end result is cheese spread. But you see it a lot of factories. As I keep saying, they almost always heat the wood. But that doesn't change the chemistry. Understand, the loads on guitars are crazy. But also on some furniture. Maybe stools. It is always hard to know what to do when you become aware of a better method, but it becomes necessary to leave a proven one to adopt it, only to find there was bear trap somewhere in the process.

Titebond old formula is also really good. Other stuff may be as good, but nobody wants to build one hundred guitars and get them all back in the mail under warranty. Or worse, put someone's eye out if a bridge snapped. LMII makes a better white glue, and I would prefer it, but it combines poor shelf life with huge expense to get up to Canada.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#27

Re:There's bugs in there somewhere - video

TomD

Quite a quotable video, fun, on guitars and hide glue. I wouldn't say I agree with all of it. At the end T. says it would be impractical for a factory to use hide glue. But I would say only if they aren't getting paid for it. These days every single material in a guitar is impractical right up to the point of landing you in jail for the rest of your life. But if you are getting paid for it... Maybe.

Also the mater of wood contact is largely how you do it. Rubbed, two step clamping etc... In other words would there be a midpoint along there where you could apply more skill to the process and get equal results. Or part way. Stuff like hide glue throws up a lot of problems and so you have to really think it through, but sometimes there are solutions. The problem is that the vinyl glues are easy, so maybe one doesn't think about it much. Hide glue is another of those myths that gets a hold, and we really don't need more myths, or maybe we do.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6iSvL2McYM

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#28

I've tried a similar technique with veneer...

John in NM

Where you thinly coat both surfaces, let it dry, and then iron it down.

Two specifics I remember, works best with white glue and don't leave it more than a day before ironing.

Though vastly more simple than some of the other veneering methods out there, I did not find the results good enough to keep practicing this method. Having never tried a similar experiment using hide glue, I couldn't say if it would work better. I bet it would though, I wonder why no one has tried iron on hide glue veneer?

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#29

Re: I've tried a similar technique with veneer...

TomD

Maybe because hammer veneering works so well. It is basically an iron on method except the heat is carried in there with the glue, and taken out with the iron/hammer. One can sometimes get hide glued veneers down again with an iron, or an iron and mild moisture.