New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

liquid hide vrs. hot

Posts

liquid hide vrs. hot

#1

liquid hide vrs. hot

McKay

I know that I need to use hot hide glue, but what little gluing I do, I do not feel like the effort is worth using hot hide. My question is, what is the difference in liquid hide in holding strength? I really like old brown glue, but every time I need it to glue one joint, it is gel. (I keep my shop at about 60deg.) Is liquid hide glue from tightbond not as strong in tack strength? It is always liquid and does not go bad when I do not use it that much.

What say ye 'ol knowledgeable ones?

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#2

False premise

Bill Tindall

"I know that I need to use hot hide glue". I disagree with the premise. Given the fact that the vast majority of all factory and custom furniture is successfully assembled with typical white or yellow glue I don't understand the angst over glue selection.

In the context of typical furniture construction quick rub joint assembly is the only application I can imagine where hot hide glue excels. Liquid hide excels with joints that need to be slid together because it lubricates such joints making assembly of too tight joints easier (for example dovetails and M&T), and it has the longest working time of the widely used glues. However, an experienced cabinet maker can get along without these advantages. (Personally, I find them useful)

The convenience of the white and yellow glues, plus their working properties make them the glue of choice for edge and face gluing. Their quick tack makes them good for rub joints too. They are ready to use, have nearly unlimited shelf life, and wide working range of temperature and lumber moisture content. They are reversible by the same techniques as hide glue. They are stronger with joints that are a bit looser than optimum.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

Stephen Shepherd

You can use Franklin/Titebond Liquid Hide Glue and it is still better than any white or yellow glue. It may not be as strong as hot hide glue but the loss of strength is minimal and it is reversible. You get about 20 degrees more latitude with this over Old Brown Glue, but you can warm that up before use and it will work just fine.

Also the Fish Glue that Lee Valley sells is less viscous at lower temperatures and has a high initial tack strength.

And the clamp time for hide glue is greatly over exaggerated, I have worked stuff that was an hour in the clamp and on some rub joints worked in 30 minutes.

Store it at low temperatures [it even stands freezing] at it will last years beyond the expiration date.

Stephen

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#4

Easy small glue pot...

John in NM

I often need just a little at a time, so I use a 1 1/2" copper pipe cap on an electric coffee mug warmer as a small glue pot. Back when copper was cheap, the cap cost a buck or so and the warmer maybe $5 in Walgreens. Now the whole setup might run $15-$20. I tinned the inside of the cap with solder, but that shouldn't really be necessary.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#5

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

GolfSteve in Calgary

I really like the titebond liquid hide glue for general purpose furniture making.

I was planning on using it for an upcoming guitar project, but the "glue gods" in the guitar world don't like the liquid hide glue very much....seems to be related to reduced strength at elevated temperature under high strain, such as might occur when a guitar is left in a hot car (the string excert considerable strain on the guitar, so if the glue weakens bad things can happen).

Anyway, regardless of what the glue gods think about it for luthier work, I still love liquid hide glue for general purpose use.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#6

Bill it depends

roninkokomo

If you are making heirlooms, it is not a question of will it need repair... but when. Hide glus makes that so very much easier.

If you are making kitchen cabinets... doesn't matter.

There are a few glue ups where hot hide glue makes the task a lot easier in a one man shop.

Like many other things in my life.. I am not consistent and use both.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#7

Re: Easy small glue pot...

roninkokomo

I use a small potpourri "Crock pot" kinda thing. Buy them a garage sales for 2 bucks. Works great.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#8

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

roninkokomo

There are lots of 200 year old instruments put together with hot hide glue??

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#9

And, conversely,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

there are a lot of glue-up situations where liquid hide glue is a LOT easier in a one-man shop. Extended assembly time is a real boon to this man-kind.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#10

differences of opinion on repair

Bill Tindall

There are some on this forum that state that hide glue will make repair easier. Indeed that is the conventional wisdom. And there is a local shop run by a Period Furniture maker/repairer with an impressive pedigree that considers it immaterial whether the joint is made with yellow or hide glue. As a test I have disassembled a yellow glue M&T joint and it separated easily using the same technique as would be used with hide glue, just as I was told it would.

All commercial furniture and most custom furniture is being assembled with some variant of yellow glue. (In fact I have never been in a commercial shop that used hide glue, ever.) One can be sure that any shop doing repair 100 years from now will have to be able to handle furniture assembled with yellow type glue. The fraction of pieces the shop will see assembled with hide glue will be minuscule. Given this fact the repair will proceed assuming the assembly was made with yellow glue unless you engrave on your pieces otherwise.

There may be valid reasons to use hide glue but ability to repair 100 years from now does not strike me as a valid concern. If the repair shop can't handle yellow glue then the volume of business for hide glue will be so low that there won't be a shop.

For those undecided, doing what almost every one else does seems a safe bet when it comes to glue.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#11

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

GolfSteve in Calgary

From my readings, they specifically don't like liquid hide glue. Hot hide glue is fine, but plain old original Titebond PVA is liked by many.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#12

Hide Glue v. Yellow Glue

Steve Elliott

In my thirty years in commercial cabinetmaking I've never seen hot hide glue used, but I've mostly worked in shops doing casework or furniture in contemporary styles. (By contemporary I mean designed by high-priced egomaniacs with little sense for the materials used.) Where I live (Seattle, USA) there's not much of a market for period styles.

That said, I've had experiences with yellow glue that make me think it might not be best for heirloom furniture. Although it can be softened with heat, the yellow glue coating the wood surfaces can be difficult to glue to. It's also difficult to remove. The newer, water-resistant types are especially problematic after their molecular cross-linking takes place, which happens in a few days or weeks.

In my retirement I'm planning to make some pieces that may be in my family for quite some time, and I'm thinking of using hide glue when I make them.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#13

Re: differences of opinion on repair

roninkokomo

Bill,

I havw a lot of respect for your views,however, fashion is not synonymous with best practice

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#14

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

Mike Bridger

Give your Old Brown Glue bottle about 15 minutes in hot tap water before use. The glue should flow nicely once warmed up.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#15

Examples of stuff built with PVA glue

Bill Tindall




I could have posted many more examples of Period furniture made with white or yellow type glue. I don't take many pictures of other designs, but I have encountered lots made with these PVA type glues.

One would expect everyone at a Society of American Period Furniture Makers meeting would be using hide glue if this repair of heirloom issue was as important as some claim. However, in fact, the reason I most encounter for using hide glue is Period authenticity, and not all the other reasons claimed.

I have heard that the Krenov school uses some variant of PVA (white/yellow) glue, but I can not confirm this information. I know that at least one of his professional students does.

Now I agree that the "enhanced" PVA glues (Titebonds XXX) have no place in indoor furniture. For the most part these glues prey on the paranoia of persons gluing. Something with a II or even a III must be better for everything. Clever marketing.

The bottom line is if you believe that your furniture made with PVA glue will be discarded because it can't be repaired 100 years from now, persons buying/selling stuff like shown in the pictures don't agree.

Now here is a real worry. The only objection I have to liquid hide glue is that it has a self life with no quantitative way to determine how much of its bond strength has been lost. It is easy to tell when it has become useless, but how does one know when it has lost 25 or 50% of its bond strength? Loss of some bond strength is not so much an issue with a well fitted M&T joint but it can be fatal in a panel. In fact, I was scarred by hide glue early in my wood working career when I was misled on its merits. Apparently the "new" bottle had aged and I had a face joint fail after the piece was assembled and in use. I get reminded of this fact daily when I pass by this open joint. I am confident anything I make with PVA glue can be repaired along with the vast majority of everything else made. I am never confident my hide glue has retained most of its inherent bond strength.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#16

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

Martin from Texas

Please clear something up for me.

I have been using Old Brown Glue since before Titebond came out with a liquid hide glue (or at least before I was aware of it).

It seems in your post that you favor the Titebond Liquid Hide glue over the Old Brown glue.

May I ask why? Is there something about the Titebond product that is better?

I would like to know if I need to switch brands.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#17

Stephen Shepherd

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

Stephen Shepherd

Martin,

'Please clear something up for me.

I have been using Old Brown Glue since before Titebond came out with a liquid hide glue (or at least before I was aware of it).'

Titebond/Franklin was first on the commercial market before Old Brown Glue.

'It seems in your post that you favor the Titebond Liquid Hide glue over the Old Brown glue.'

I don't favor one over the other, my only comment was about the fact that Old Brown Glue is thicker at lower temperatures, I am currently using up a big bottle of Lee Valley Fish Glue.

'May I ask why? Is there something about the Titebond product that is better?'

The reason I use Titebond/Franklin a lot is because a friend with a large commercial cabinetshop and mill uses large quantities [he buys 15 to 20 gallons of the stuff in 5 gallon buckets, once a year when T/F makes the stuff] so I have an unlimited supply for free.

'I would like to know if I need to switch brands.'

No need to switch brands, Old Brown Glue is great stuff, I just don't have a bottle of the stuff right now.

Stephen

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#18

Re: differences of opinion on repair

R. Payne

From every thing I've read (not as much as I'd like), hide glue is easier to repair. If only for the fact that hide glue will stick to old hide glue. I've never seen nor heard of a successful repair using PVA where the glue was stuck to old glue. You have to remove the old PVA glue to make the repair, that is more work.

I've pretty well given up on PVA except for sealing end grain of logs I've cut and want to use at some future date. When my bottle of PVA runs out I doubt I'll buy another. I use hot hide glue.

ron

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#19

Re: Examples of stuff built with PVA glue

wilbur

The bottom line is if you believe that your furniture made with PVA glue will be discarded because it can't be repaired 100 years from now, persons buying/selling stuff like shown in the pictures don't agree.


They also could be wrong, misinformed, or not worried about the prospect of repair in the future.

You have mentioned that PVA glue joints can be reversed with heat and/or moisture, much like hide glue. That's not where hide glue has its greatest advantage, although in the joints that I have had to reverse, hide glue was much easier to reverse than PVA glue joints. The main advantage of hide glue is that it has no problem sticking to old dried hide glue. PVA glues do have issues to sticking to old dried PVA glue. You can get around this by scraping away the old glue first, but that is more work, and I find that between the scraping and the weak PVA-to-old-PVA-glue bond, the joint itself is in worse shape. This is why if you are concerned with future repairs, hide glue is a better choice than PVA. If you are not concerned, then use whatever glue you want.

Now here is a real worry. The only objection I have to liquid hide glue is that it has a self life with no quantitative way to determine how much of its bond strength has been lost. It is easy to tell when it has become useless, but how does one know when it has lost 25 or 50% of its bond strength?

I think that this is a non-issue. If you are really concerned about this issue, and you want to make a project like in the pictures you posted, then you can always buy a new bottle of hide glue. A 16 oz. bottle of Titebond Liquid Hide Glue is about $12. Lee Valley Fish Glue is $11 for 16 oz. Patrick Edward's Old Brown Glue is $21 for 20 oz. You're going to blow away many times that amount of money in scrap wood for a SAPFM-quality project. So to try to save money by using a bottle of liquid hide glue that you are unsure of is a classic example of being pennywise and pound foolish.

Unless, of course, you are not worried about the difficulty of repair for whoever has to deal with that in the future. Then go ahead and use any glue you want.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#20

Testing to follow.....

Bill Tindall

I have heard that PVA glue won't stick to itself, but it is always from someone wedded to hide glue. There is no inherent reason PVA glue will not stick to itself. All that has to happen is for the PVA to soften such that entanglement will occur between the polymer molecules at the interface. The same would be true for hide glue. The heat in hot hide glue will certainly enhance the likelihood for adequate softening. The question to be answered is whether the water and solvents in the new glue will soften the dried glue to enable entanglement in the time scale of the new glue drying. I think I got an answer to the question once before from a chemist at Franklin but I will ask again to be sure. And it may be easy to test. I'll report back when I have data.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#21

Arcane PVA Glue information

Steve Elliott

I've had some experience with what it takes to get two dried/cured PVA surfaces to bond to each other. The application was covering a substrate with parchment. I had good results coating both the parchment and the substrate with white glue, letting the surfaces dry overnight, wetting one surface, then ironing the parchment down. Having a layer of wetness right where the glue surfaces met was necessary to get a good bond.

I've used the same technique with yellow glue to put wood veneer on the curved edges of round tables. That also worked well although the glue line was a little thick. For the tables I was making I applied the edge veneer first, then hot pressed the top and bottom surfaces using urea formaldehyde glue.

My tests with Titebond II were much less successful. It needed higher heat and even then it was more difficult to get a good bond.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#22

Re: differences of opinion on repair

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About 25 years ago my wife's uncle asked if I could sell my business when I retired. I said "in this business you don't really retire, you just get pickier about what you will do." It was a happy day when I was able to be picky enough to turn down requests to repair furniture made with crappy glue. I just say I'm sorry, but that piece wasn't made to be repaired.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#23

makes sense, thanks for the info

Bill Tindall

The Tirtebond II crosslinks and once crosslinked the polymer molecules will not wiggle enough to become entangled at a new interface. It is the entanglement (think Velcro at the molecule level) that bonds two surfaces together.

on the other hand the application of heat and water made that surface mushy, the molecules wigley and a bond to form as the wigley molecules entangled with the new surface.

Actually two requirements are necessary for a good bond. First, as mentioned, the molecules of the two surfaces must entangle. Second, the plastic that forms when the glue dries must be tough so it doesn't fracture under stress and also be rigid so the joint doesn't creep.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#24

Re: Easy small glue pot...

TomD

Great minds think alike. Unfortunately the cup warmers have disappeared around here, or are all USB ROTFWL. I splashed out for this:

http://www.lmii.com/CartTwo/thirdproducts.asp?CategoryName=Specialty+Tools&NameProdHeader=Brass+Glue+Pot

Just the hot plate part.

Re: liquid hide vrs. hot

#25

Re: differences of opinion on repair

TomD

"There are some on this forum that state that hide glue will make repair easier. Indeed that is the conventional wisdom. And there is a local shop run by a Period Furniture maker/repairer with an impressive pedigree that considers it immaterial whether the joint is made with yellow or hide glue. As a test I have disassembled a yellow glue M&T joint and it separated easily using the same technique as would be used with hide glue, just as I was told it would."

Re-assembly is the big issue, not just taking apart. Yellow glue does not stick to yellow glue. And this can be a problem if you just accidentally size the joint with yellow glue going in.

The only yellow glue I use is tightbond original, because it is proven, the rest are scum in a bucket. It all has to be fresh. The glue is cheap and there are great uses for excess glue like sealing lumber, and kid crafts.

"All commercial furniture and most custom furniture is being assembled with some variant of yellow glue. (In fact I have never been in a commercial shop that used hide glue, ever.)"

Yeah, but there are tons, even in the US. The US makes tons of hide glue that gets used for a lot of stuff most of it possibly not wood, but anyhoo. I think this is mostly about your having taken the path of the less travel, to paraphrase. Plus hide glue is growing in use.

" One can be sure that any shop doing repair 100 years from now will have to be able to handle furniture assembled with yellow type glue. The fraction of pieces the shop will see assembled with hide glue will be minuscule. Given this fact the repair will proceed assuming the assembly was made with yellow glue unless you engrave on your pieces otherwise."

+1 And I would wood burn or something your pieces to say they have hide glue in them. The fact is most stuff people make will hit the land fill, sadly. Or end up on a show where someone paid a dime for it. But:

1) If you take every shortcut known to the shops in Whoville, you can guarantee nobody will value your stuff, while it is withing the grasp of anyone here to become the next big name builder if they cared to. I don't follow that path, I like to wander. But I see tons of people pass me by, you can get there, but you have to play the game, and this could be part of the game

2) It is not the case that all these repairs will occur in 100 years. Accidents happen, and some stuff that might last 500 years, needs regular maintenance, say 20-50 years.

3) part of this is just a fantasy, the part marked 99%. People want to think they are doing something that is:

The work of an expert;

Technical whizzbangery;

Part of the herd, so they fit in;

You fantasy Bill, might be that hard nosed business types in your part of the world do it this way, and you will be darned if what you choose isn't as sensible as Wa-mart shoe, until proved otherwise (for which your mind appears to be wide open). Sorry for the fictional personal, doubtless wrong characterization, but my point is, if that were your fantasy, it isn't any more real that the guy who gets kicks doing dovetails in a bunny suit, whatever cranks the switch marked "serotonin".

"There may be valid reasons to use hide glue but ability to repair 100 years from now does not strike me as a valid concern. If the repair shop can't handle yellow glue then the volume of business for hide glue will be so low that there won't be a shop."

Kinda agree, but what is the downside? HIde glue is adaptable to industrial uses. Often what determines an industrial use is a 1 cent saving for a worse process, so it shouldn't concern us. Plus customers are constantly more knowledgeable, they ask for hide glue in some stuff already, so it will be worth the cost.

But the main issues should be:

Will hide glue be less likely to see the shop, and in some cases the answer is yes.

Will it make a repair by a jerk more expensive, or less successful, no.

Will better furniture that gets to a competent shop be better repaired if hide glue, yes

Is it likely there will be more hide glue used and more experience out there, yes.

"For those undecided, doing what almost every one else does seems a safe bet when it comes to glue."

Major factories seem to like the liquid glue applied to heated wood. This seems to be necessary to the real process of it's use. Any time I see the stuff used in a factory it is cold glue used on heated parts.

I particularly agree with you on using what is best practices where there are warrantee or liability issues.