Re: differences of opinion on repair
TomD
"There are some on this forum that state that hide glue will make repair easier. Indeed that is the conventional wisdom. And there is a local shop run by a Period Furniture maker/repairer with an impressive pedigree that considers it immaterial whether the joint is made with yellow or hide glue. As a test I have disassembled a yellow glue M&T joint and it separated easily using the same technique as would be used with hide glue, just as I was told it would."
Re-assembly is the big issue, not just taking apart. Yellow glue does not stick to yellow glue. And this can be a problem if you just accidentally size the joint with yellow glue going in.
The only yellow glue I use is tightbond original, because it is proven, the rest are scum in a bucket. It all has to be fresh. The glue is cheap and there are great uses for excess glue like sealing lumber, and kid crafts.
"All commercial furniture and most custom furniture is being assembled with some variant of yellow glue. (In fact I have never been in a commercial shop that used hide glue, ever.)"
Yeah, but there are tons, even in the US. The US makes tons of hide glue that gets used for a lot of stuff most of it possibly not wood, but anyhoo. I think this is mostly about your having taken the path of the less travel, to paraphrase. Plus hide glue is growing in use.
" One can be sure that any shop doing repair 100 years from now will have to be able to handle furniture assembled with yellow type glue. The fraction of pieces the shop will see assembled with hide glue will be minuscule. Given this fact the repair will proceed assuming the assembly was made with yellow glue unless you engrave on your pieces otherwise."
+1 And I would wood burn or something your pieces to say they have hide glue in them. The fact is most stuff people make will hit the land fill, sadly. Or end up on a show where someone paid a dime for it. But:
1) If you take every shortcut known to the shops in Whoville, you can guarantee nobody will value your stuff, while it is withing the grasp of anyone here to become the next big name builder if they cared to. I don't follow that path, I like to wander. But I see tons of people pass me by, you can get there, but you have to play the game, and this could be part of the game
2) It is not the case that all these repairs will occur in 100 years. Accidents happen, and some stuff that might last 500 years, needs regular maintenance, say 20-50 years.
3) part of this is just a fantasy, the part marked 99%. People want to think they are doing something that is:
The work of an expert;
Technical whizzbangery;
Part of the herd, so they fit in;
You fantasy Bill, might be that hard nosed business types in your part of the world do it this way, and you will be darned if what you choose isn't as sensible as Wa-mart shoe, until proved otherwise (for which your mind appears to be wide open). Sorry for the fictional personal, doubtless wrong characterization, but my point is, if that were your fantasy, it isn't any more real that the guy who gets kicks doing dovetails in a bunny suit, whatever cranks the switch marked "serotonin".
"There may be valid reasons to use hide glue but ability to repair 100 years from now does not strike me as a valid concern. If the repair shop can't handle yellow glue then the volume of business for hide glue will be so low that there won't be a shop."
Kinda agree, but what is the downside? HIde glue is adaptable to industrial uses. Often what determines an industrial use is a 1 cent saving for a worse process, so it shouldn't concern us. Plus customers are constantly more knowledgeable, they ask for hide glue in some stuff already, so it will be worth the cost.
But the main issues should be:
Will hide glue be less likely to see the shop, and in some cases the answer is yes.
Will it make a repair by a jerk more expensive, or less successful, no.
Will better furniture that gets to a competent shop be better repaired if hide glue, yes
Is it likely there will be more hide glue used and more experience out there, yes.
"For those undecided, doing what almost every one else does seems a safe bet when it comes to glue."
Major factories seem to like the liquid glue applied to heated wood. This seems to be necessary to the real process of it's use. Any time I see the stuff used in a factory it is cold glue used on heated parts.
I particularly agree with you on using what is best practices where there are warrantee or liability issues.