New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Bench Conversion

Posts

Bench Conversion

#1

Bench Conversion

Todd Nebel

I mentioned a few months back that I was going to convert my bench from a power tool bench to a hand tool bench. It's almost there. I need to drill more bench dog holes and I'm thinking about adding a rack on the left side back to hold chisels.

I started by flattening the top. This was the first time I ever did this. I recently bought a No. 8, so with the No. 5 and No. 4 1/2, I had the tools. When I built the bench in 2000 I used a belt sander. It was remarkably pretty flat but not flat enough for planning on. My biggest struggle was the hickory wood and I never bothered to match the grain. So, much of the flattening was cross grain as you can tell by the chips on the floor.

Photobucket

Then I needed to reduce the height by seven inches. I took off the legs, cut them down and used the feet as cross members which are mortised and tenoned into the legs. Before I glued it together I drilled three holes in the right front leg for holdfasts. When I attached the top I made sure it was flush with the front legs.

Photobucket

Once the bench was back on its legs. Then I changed the wood on the front vise to a thicker and longer chop and added a couple dog holes. Next, I bought a second vise to use as a tail vise. I made the chop extra thick to support some of the board when the vise is extended. I added leather to the inside of both vises. Should have done this years ago. The last thing I did was add a shelf today so I have a place for the shooting board, other jigs and miter box. I've working at this a little here and there for the past couple months.

Photobucket

I also made a sawbench (need a second one). You can't see it in this photo, but there's just enough bug holes and tracks that I didn't want to use the walnut for furniture.

Photobucket

Next, is a Moxon double-screw vise. The lower bench is great for hand planning but murder on the back for sawing dovetails. I must admit the sawbench has seen more use as a stool than a sawbench.

Todd

Re: Bench Conversion

#2

Hickory bench

Dale Lenz

Built my bench some 28 years ago out of SYP, all that I could afford at the time. Have thought from time to time if I build another bench/top it would be hickory/pecan, but I dread flatting the top due to hickory's tearing problem. Great looking bench!

Re: Bench Conversion

#3

Re: Bench Conversion

Stuart Hough

How tall are you, Todd? Also, what is the height of your bench at the top edge? I'm curious, becaue I'm in the process of building my bench (taking a good long time due to work constraints) and I am at the point where I need to determine the final height. It will be used mainly for hand tool work, though I may build different auxiliary portable (bench-top) work surfaces to raise the work up for when I use the electron-eaters. Any info will be helpful!

Re: Bench Conversion

#4

Re: Bench Conversion

Pam Niedermayer

Love the stuff you've been making lately, great work; but I do question your assumption that the bench top has to be flat for planing. In the case of most joinery, planing is done in clamped position on the bench front. In the case of face planing, it's done above the bench, not on it, given that we're never able to plane between bench and board; and checking flat would be done with various gauges. Granted, it may be somewhat easier to eyeball flat if the bench is flat, but it's hard to make a bench so unflat that eyeballing would be thrust awry.

Pam

Re: Bench Conversion

#5

Re: Bench Conversion

TomD

I would say though that the result of planing a bench is going to be that it is "flat" within the tolerances of the plane, and other factors. So since one has to go out of one's way to make it otherwise, and since it will contribute to the flatness of some pieces planed on it, seems like a good objective. But you are right that various factors lead to getting pieces the way you want them in woodworking, and rarely come from one source.

Re: Bench Conversion

#6

Re: Hickory bench

Todd Nebel

Hi Dale,

Hickory was not my initial choice. It was a barn find (cheap) and I tried to use it for furniture but that didn't work out so I figured a bench was the next best use. I will say though that round holdfasts don't work so good, but that might be me.

Re: Bench Conversion

#7

Re: Bench Conversion

Todd Nebel

Hi Stuart,

There are several ways to determine height. I think Chris Schwarz mentions 3-4 in his books. I used the height from the floor to the bottom of my palm if laid flat on the top of the bench. For me that's 32 1/4" high bench. By accident it matches the height of my power jointer.

Todd

Re: Bench Conversion

#8

Re: Bench Conversion

Todd Nebel

Hi Pam,

Thanks for the kinds words on my work. This is a great place to ask questions and show what one has accomplished.

With each project I strengthen my hand tool woodworking skills and techniques and learn new ones. Right now much of my stock preparation is done using the power jointer and planner. After which I fine tune the board's thickness at the bench. Mostly removing the snipe and unevenness across the width and length of the board. Until recently, before I installed an end vise, I relied on just a bench dog (or a stop) to hold the board while planning. I think the more surface area touching between the board and the bench helps reduce the movement during the planning operation.

Todd

Re: Bench Conversion

#9

Re: Bench Conversion

roger lance

Todd....you appear to be nearing the finish line with the conversion....nice job on the flatting with planes (another rite of passage)....your saw/sitting bench is as attractive as I've seen and way better than the wood box that I'm using to sit on....any thoughts on making an assembly table??....I use one and its good to get parts off the bench, have a place to glue etc and not be concerned about making a mess, plus its another opportunity for storage of tools, jigs, etc.

Re: Bench Conversion

#10

Re: Bench Conversion

Todd Nebel

Hi Roger,

An assembly table would be great. I'm afraid I don't have the room. Right now I cover the table saw and use that.

Re: Bench Conversion

#11

Re: Bench Conversion - height

TomD

Height is a real toughie, and I have never been all that dissatisfied with any of my benches, or convinced that I nailed it. I think that in the modern world adjustable bench height verges on mandatory. It all depends on the thickness of work you do, and the tools you use. The handles on trad jointers are 3-4 inches off the surface being worked. Stanleys are lower, gripped planes like Japanese, or Krenovs, are different, ECE, etc... And worst of all the guy who has a mix of all different styles known to man (me), and that is just planing.

Re: Bench Conversion

#12

Re: Bench Conversion

Pam Niedermayer

Yes, OK, I never use tailed planers or jointers, so I don't experience snipe. This definitely cuts down on the amount of hand planing, depending on whether a board is riven or saw milled.

I agree that a board shouldn't be allowed to wallow around on the bench, but this has never been a problem, again, it's hard to plane a top with gaping concavities or towering convexities. Most of the variation is minor.

Pam

Re: Bench Conversion

#13

Re: Bench Conversion

TomD

I plane a fair bit of stuff that is very limber like battens or parts for guitars. These would be affected by laying into even rather slight contours.

Re: Bench Conversion

#14

Re: Bench Conversion

Pam Niedermayer

In that case, I'd put a planing board between thin piece and the bench, provides a lot of flexibility for pinning and the like.

Pam

Re: Bench Conversion

#15

Re: Bench Conversion

Dominic in Buck's County PA

I'm looking at your bench and what you've done and I'm reminded of mine. Your bench and mine share a lot of features. I like how you increased the length of the shop. That's one of the projects I have in mind for mine as well. I'm also thinking of ditching the Veritas Twin Screw Vise I have at the end of the bench and adding a wagon vise.

But Holy Crap Todd! That saw bench looks great!

Re: Bench Conversion

#16

Re: Bench Conversion

TomD

I don't much like the Wagon vise, but I do like handwheels. MSC has them in all shapes and sized for not too much money.