New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Half blinds revisited

Posts

Half blinds revisited

#1

Half blinds revisited

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When I started the thread "Against the Clock" the intention was to explore efficiency. Looking back I thought the methods used could have been improved, and that doing so would provide the efficiency I sought for the remaining (now eight) drawers left to build.

So here I offer two methods for the removal of waste from half blind dovetail pins. Both work easily and fairly quickly. One is power assisted and the other is 100% handtool.

Interestingly, where the previous drawer was a frantic 4 hour race against the clock, today was a relaxed 3 1/2 hour session.

Starting with a marked, sawn and kerfed pin board ...


Two pins were routed and two were chopped out for comparison. The difference this time is that the boards were placed flat (rather than vertically) for the routing ...


... and only the baseline was cleared (with a 1/16" left to finish with a chisel) ..



That took 8 minutes to complete:


Method #2 involved progressively chopping out a mortice ...


... and then splitting out the waste as the mortice deepened. This is the method I generally use ..


This required a total of 10 minutes ...


The above was repeated with the remaining two pins. Both were completed in a further 10 minutes ..


.. and the pin and tail boards fitted ...


Likes and dislikes: I dislike the noise of a router. Dust is not a problem as the Elu I have is efficient at sucking the dust into a Fein vacuum cleaner. This is a speedier method, but chiseling is very close behind. On the other hand I like that the router has a depth stop and that there is no danger of blowing out or cracking the face of the pin board with an overzealous chisel blow. This is always on my mind as I chop into the hard Jarrah. Routing the initial mortice does remove a great deal of stress from the process.

For the other side of the drawer I decided to use the router alone to gauge the ease/speed more realistically by excluding interruptions, such as photos.



After a casual 35 minutes ...


The rear of the drawer was dovetailed and assembled ..


Progress to date:


Hopefully the next thread on the military chests will be to show the completed drawers.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Half blinds revisited

#2

Looks good, Derek.

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Derek,

Looks good.

As a suggestion to further speed things up, when you mark out your dovetails, use the cutting gauge to mark out a bit of scrap as well at the correct depth of the tail sockets.

Set the router to exactly this distance through trial and error, then plunge-cut your baselines. No paring necessary, one less step to do.

When you do this, plunge the bit in and then push the router anticlockwise, to avoid a rough cut.

Cheers,

AF

Re: Half blinds revisited

#3

Not taking full advantage of the router

Bill Tindall

Why just route the tiny slot near the baseline? The router can be used to promptly remove nearly all the remaining waste which results in two additional advantages 1. the tail depth is precisely established and 2. only paring at the base line to remove the last smidgen of waste is required. All the routeering can be done free hand. I use either a 1/4" or 3/8" bit depending on what is sharp at the time.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#4

Re: Not taking full advantage of the router

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I cannot disagree with you. Using the router is not something I have done much in the last few years (at least). I am cautious still. While I have freehanded the routing of all pins on at least one complete drawer, the fence was added here as a security measure. Frankly it makes sense to rout to the line as well. On the other hand, iIt takes 2 or 3 chisel strokes to remove the end waste, and I am more confident in controlling the accuracy of this with handskill. Perhaps I will take a few more risks as I gain experience when completing the remaining drawers. The point I want to make is that I agree with you, and others should try and follow your lead. My efforts posted are simply a chronical of my learning experience.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Half blinds revisited

#5

A cautious approach is never wrong

Bill Tindall

Especially on a finished drawer front!

When you try routing all the waste use small arcing cuts for best control.


Re: Half blinds revisited

#6

Overcuts speed 1/2 blind chopping

Adam Cherubini

Both of you could pick up speed by over cutting the baseline on the pin side. If you are desirous, you can use the heel of your DT saw to saw almost all the way to the bottom of the pin. Basically, if a normal saw cut has a straight bottom, what I do results in a curved bottom.

The over cuts are a standard 18th c technique, typical on even the finest furniture.

As for time, I always sought to build a drawer in an hour given prepped boards. Depending on the materials I think I MAY have done that but most times it takes me longer. Had fun nailing a drawer together 2 weekends ago. Came out nice and neat. Highly recommended.

Adam

Re: Half blinds revisited

#7

Re: Not taking full advantage of the router

Sgian Dubh

Derek said, "While I have freehanded the routing of all pins on at least one complete drawer, the fence was added here as a security measure."

The fence of course controls the inset distance of the cut, thus accurately defining the shoulder line. However, the fence also acts as a useful pivoting point. By holding one point in the length of the fence firmly against a corner of the drawer front at the beginning of the cut you rotate the router and the cutter into the waste between the pins. Fairly quickly you can nip in and out of the socket between the pins to clear the majority of the waste.

For anyone that's not picked up on the technique, the router base sits on the back face of the drawer front and the router fence runs along the end grain of it. Just thought I ought to mention that. Slainte.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#8

Re: Not taking full advantage of the router

Bob Hackett

Just not getting this "partial router" thing. If you are really interested in time savings to the point of putting on the hearing protection and using a router then why not just "go all in" and set up a dovetail template,router table or other jig to tell your screaming,finger eating,high speed spawn of satan what to do and cut all the drawer`s dovetails using the forked tailed devil machine?

I know we`re talking half blind here but come on guys,the router. Really?!

I hope you folks are happy now,you`ve got me sounding like I`m a member of Warren`s family. The adopted black sheep perhaps? ;)

I only use a router if I absolutely have to and then only on things I hate like MDF, Formica,pressure treated,projects for the MIL or for my annoying neighbors (there`s one neighbor in particular I`d like to use the router on directly).

Re: Half blinds revisited

#9

That will be provocative

Bill Tindall

Indeed, such cuts are to be found on six$ and seven$ figure Period furniture. I was tempted to post a picture of this technique as part of the "dovetail standards" discussion. But it seemed that the consensus was that visually perfect dovetails were as quick to cut as the less than visually perfect dovetails ubiquitously found on Period furniture.

Personally, I am so slow that this cut extension does not save me a significant amount of time, given that I have to pare this area anyway. Two orthogonal chisel slices removes the triangle of waste all the way to the saw kerf. Hence, I don't use it. However, you are correct that the absence of these cuts in not Period Authentic in some cases.

But it does illustrate the point that flaunting drawer dovetails is a modern fashion. A friend has a theory. In "high end" Period furniture (the studio furniture of the day) there was ample opportunity to flaunt one's skills on the exterior features of the piece- the carving, inlay and shaping, etc. Little modern furniture illustrates this level of skill and complexity so the drawer interior has become the quality/fashion statement

Re: Half blinds revisited

#10

Re: Not taking full advantage of the router

Sgian Dubh

Bob, your point of view is fine by me. There are lots of reasons to undertake woodworking tasks, from hobby to professional, and everything in between, and there are probably many ways of accomplishing much the same end result. However, routing waste between dovetail pins and tails can (in certain circumstances) be of benefit in a production environment (and perhaps elsewhere), where the traditional 'hand cut' appearance is required. Okay, so routing is noisier, dustier, and perhaps less pleasant, but getting the job done quicker may be the driving force. Slainte.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#11

Re: Half blinds revisited

roger lance

I am pleasantly surprised that hand tool craftsmen that I've come to really respect for their capability and craftsmanship know so much about the use of power tools in making hand cut dovetails. I know there is a big continuum of styles of working from pure power tool to pure hand tool and I've always figured myself in the middle (my Unisaw is still my main tool)....its nice to see I'm not alone.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#12

An odd thought

Bob Hackett

(Like most of the thoughts I get aren`t odd to most people)

You mentioned that the exterior surfaces of period furniture was where craftsmen chose to flaunt their talents for customers. That got me thinking (can you see the smoke?) that in the shops up here (and I`m sure elsewhere) the opposite was true among the craftsmen themselves.

The chests that most craftsmen stored the the tools that they used to make their living looked like rather plain beat up boxes from the outside,except for the dovetails and the occasional raised panel on top. up here they often added metal (often bronze) trim/reinforcement.

It was the inside of the chest that really showed what the owner was capable of, where all the stops got pulled out and the talent was showcased. Many of these chests were all the recommendation a joiner needed when applying for a job.

Just something to think about as we talk.

BTW-Many of the shipfitters working in the yards today still carry on this tradition when they make up their all metal toolboxes. They may look like a footlocker till you open them and then they speak for themselves. You can`t help but be impressed as you take in the craftsmanship in the many closely fitted compartments, precise welds,polishing,organization, and planning involved in their interior construction.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#13

Re: Half blinds revisited

TomD

This is technically the hand tools forum. I use a lot of hand tools alone, but I also have all the power tools, and a goodly number of the tools to make the power tools. I don't really believe in mixing them, it usually leads to shortcuts, at least after the roughout is done. But there are plenty of task were what passes for hand tools around here will simply not get the job done. The folks here make a relatively small selection of products, one rarely finds an article on making sail plane spars with a Noris plane.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#14

Re: That will be provocative

TomD

"Indeed, such cuts are to be found on six$ and seven$ figure Period furniture."

Let's say a famous maker did this, and his furniture disproportionately fell apart as a result. That would lead to less pieces out there and higher prices. Just kidding, but prices really don't tell us much about quality.

I think the people like Andrew pushing the shortcuts should come up with reasons as to why they make the furniture more durable, like less separation along the glue line. Assume as is normally the case that the primary and secondary woods have different shrinkage maybe the over-cuts reduce stress and lead to longer lasting furniture. At least then I would have a reason for doing it.

The problem is that otherwise we live in a world where the main people who like this stuff currently hold the view that finishing the piece comprehensively makes sense. In the day, the customer was someone who for the most part was interested in the exterior. Today the main customer is the person who makes the stuff and is actually in many cases more interested in the internals than the externals, and does not want to jackass them up. In addition they have many labour saving devices.

Also, I am not convinced the best furniture used these shortcuts. American furniture in say Boston was hardly the best furniture, that was being made in europe and is in some cases still in palaces. Personally I have not had a chance to inspect it. My cousin got an OBE from the Queen, and the ceremony was videoed. There was a piece of furniture in the waiting room the quality and ornateness of which I have never seen, and it may well have had saw tracks all over it, but I don't feel confident about it either way.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#15

Re: An odd thought

TomD

Fascinating, any pictures of that kind of thing?

I made a similar point about what we are proud of, though the other part of it is that craftsmen's boxes may get a little knocked about.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#16

Re: An odd thought

Bob Hackett

Pics of the older chests can be found pretty easily by doing a search on old toolboxes or joiner`s chests.

As for the newer versions I have no pics as the ones I came in contact with were in Navy yards and they didn`t allow any cameras inside the gates other than the one the company photographers carried. When cell phones started including cameras that created a real problem. Post 9-11 things really tightened up and anyone evidence of picture taking would bring a visit to your home from the government boys.

If you`re interested in seeing a modern toolbox the one personal box I retained after I left the yard is buried under the steps in the shop. When I get some time to dig it out I`ll email some pics to you. I have tried and failed at posting pics a number of times here. I have no idea how to resize an image in order to make it acceptable.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#17

Would like to see pictures of the nailedd

roger lance

together drawer....I suppose the more formal/traditional amongst us would only approve of cut nails....and would reject outright the use of wire nails....a blasphemy against tradition no doubt....and hammers to drive the nails....another potential hot bed of disagreement :D

Re: Half blinds revisited

#18

Re: Would like to see pictures of the nailedd

Patrick Gibbons

For some drawers I made for shop furniture I screwed them together. Not much different from using nails, I suppose.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#19

To bob and others

McKay

Bob, a free and very powerful program is called infraview. This program will easily allow you to manipulate your pics.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#20

Do you mean Irfanview?

Bill Tindall

It is what I used. I don't understand most of it but a photographer friend showed me how to crop, sharpen and adjust contrast as well as resize and that all goes quickly and easily.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#21

Example of Overcuts 

Bill Tindall


Shown is an example of "overcuts" in the drawer for a Period Authentic slant top desk of PA/VA origin. It sold for something in the neighborhood of $15,000.

Personally, they don't buy me any significant improvement in efficiency. I don't much like them even if they did.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#22

Re: An odd thought

TomD

I'd be interested Bob, you can email me at proaconstrictor yahoo.ca. Thanks.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#23

Re: An odd thought

anotherBob

If Irfan doen't click for you... there's FastStone Image Viewer - http://www.faststone.org/

Tips page - http://www.imagingtips.com/faststone/batch/0100batch.shtml

Tutorial page - http://www.faststone.org/FSIVTutorial.htm

or you can host them at http://imageshack.us/, and it gives you an option of resizing if you want. After the image is hosted there or elsewhere, you just click the picture icon up above where you post messages here on this board. Click the picture icon then paste the URL into the box.

Re: Half blinds revisited

#24

Irfanview

Steve Elliott

For making a small jpeg image file (say under 40k or 100k for internet posting) Irfanview does a great job. I wasn't able to get nearly the image quality using Photoshop, so I now adjust images in Photoshop, export them as TIFF files to Irfanview and create the jpegs with it.