New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

Posts

Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#1

Michael Donaldson

Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

Michael Donaldson

So, I have my dad's Lie Nielson #3 tuned up, sharp, and making perfect shavings. Well long story short...I love hand planes. I would like to get some more, specifically a low angle block plane to clean up end grain, and a #6 bench plane for surface smoothing and jointing. Cash is short, so I have been looking at either woodriver planes from Woodcraft, or used planes. Checking ebay, I found a lot of old Stanley planes for really cheap. Are these a 'get what you pay for' kind of thing, or are the old Stanley planes good? Additionally, what would be involved in restoring one of these planes? I have added a link to an example from ebay.


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Stanley-Bailey-No-6-Smooth-hand-Plane-Good-Woodworking-Chisel-/250902888053?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3a6afa3e75#ht_500wt_1167

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#2

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Michael

I'm fond of the vintage Stanley planes. They sometimes require a bit of work tuning them up but depending on what interests you, that can be fun too.

The link is to a site with links to plenty of information on restoring and using hand planes as well as lot of other hand tools.

Bob in NJ


http://www.cianperez.com/Wood/WoodDocs/Wood_How_To/INDEX_How_To.htm

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#3

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A lot of the vintage Stanley planes are good to great tools; some of them are dogs.

You can somewhat, but not entirely, look at the year range of production, which requires learning what are called the "types." Several people have assembled the clues that will tell you roughly when a plane was made. The general consensus is that planes up to World War II can generally be trusted; many people like the World War II planes also. Myself, I'm skeptical of the planes prior to 1902, because the frog (where the cutting iron rests) is not well supported at the mouth.

The problem with buying online is that you can't look at the plane. Even a plane of a good year can have problems - a warped sole, for instance - that will make it not a good plane. A reputable dealer will have vetted the plane for you, and this might be a more reliable approach than buying from eBay.

The eBay auction to which you linked shows what is probably a World War II plane. The clue? The non-metal adjusting wheel.

Until recent years, all my planes were vintage planes. I had some mad money from consulting work, and picked up a few new planes from Lee Valley, but the bulk of my planes, including the ones I turn to most often, are vintage. They serve me well.


http://www.rexmill.com/

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#4

dealer caution

Bill Tindall

Dealers deal with both woodworkers and collectors and the demands of these customers could not be more different. I would suggest only buying a plane form someone that uses one. A reputable dealer may be clueless as to the utility of the tool, while being an expert on type and condition of the finish.

I bought two #5 Stanley planes from Bill for my sons in law. These planes are as functionally good as a $350 LN and I knew that would be the case because Bill said they were good planes. I would not have had that confidence with a dealer.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#5

Re: Vintage Hand Planes

Dale Lenz

Hey Mike,

I'm not fond of the plastic depth adjuster, if it ain't brass I turn the other way, thats just me. Brass turns well on metal threads and can be an postive indicator. I wondered if the depth knob was not replaced(?) The other poster talked about during WWII era, he seems to know more about planes that I do.

A quick look and I seen two No. 6 that looks good and currently a decent price:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/120788153202?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649

http://www.ebay.com/itm/250903526447?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649

Look them over carefully, as was said it can be difficult to purchase used equipment over the net. I've done it and came out good and not so good, but I'm probably 90% good. If you purchase a user, tune it up and drive it for a year or so. I've gradually purchased after market irons and chip breakers for most of my non L/N planes, makes a noticable difference.

Good luck

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#6

Depends

Neal in San Jose

What is your hobby? If it is refurbishing old tools, this might be a good subject. If, on the other hand, you want to go to the shop and only work wood, then a Wood River, LN or LV would make more sense. The plastic depth adjusting knob has a metal insert, so it isn't a negative, and these WWII vintage planes had thicker castings and thus more mass, so some users seek them out. It is easy to invest more on "experienced" planes like this one than modestly priced new ones if you decide to upgrade the iron, chip breaker, etc.

I teach classes in hand planes, and always run into the question "what plane should I buy". It is hard to look a hand tool beginner in the eye and recommend a high-end plane like a LN before they are even sure they want to pursue hand tools, and even harder to recommend the old tool route because of the potential pitfalls in refurbishing old iron. I've been pleasantly surprised by the Wood River line, and usually recommend them to my students. HTH Neal

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Vintage Hand Planes

Moses Yoder

I highly recommend figuring in the cost of a new Hock iron when you buy a vintage Stanley. The Stanley irons are usually in pretty bad shape, and they are not very good steel to begin with, not nearly as good as a Hock. Also get David Charlesworth's article on plane tuning and just follow it step by step. If you end up needing a frog or depth adjuster knob or other screw email me, I have quite a collection. Your dad was a good friend.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#8

Michael Donaldson

Re: Depends

Michael Donaldson

My interests are in working wood, but hand planes are still a bit of a mystery to me, so if I had one that I could take apart, tweak, clean, repair, and so on without risking $350, I would understand the tool a lot better, and understand what works for me and what does not. That is how I learn, so I think I am willing to spend $40 on that kind of education. Plus, it may turn out to be a great plane. Thanks for the info and insight. I feel a lot more confident going into this.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#9

Michael Donaldson

Re: Vintage Hand Planes

Michael Donaldson

Thank you. I will let you know if I need help.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#10

Michael Donaldson

Re: Vintage Hand Planes

Michael Donaldson

Those both look really good, Dale. I think I will try to get one of them (if the bidding stays reasonable). If I have any trouble after I get it, I will be back asking for help.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#11

Michael Donaldson

Re: Vintage Hand Planes

Michael Donaldson

The website you posted was fantastic. I will have to spend some time reading through the whole thing. So much to learn, far too little time.

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#12

scott grandstaff

Re: Depends

scott grandstaff

Practical hard love.

Its an old question. Do you want to work wood or learn tools?

Well too bad. You can't work wood worth a crap in the long run, if you don't learn tools.

You have to learn not just how to drive, but how to make the car go in the first place.

If you don't learn, even if you buy a new Ferrarri, the day is coming soon when it won't go anymore and then you have to learn anyway, or give up and stop.

Most people I see trying to buy their way in have already decided its going to be easy. Guess what? Its not easy. Most of them give up and run away when they figure it out.

People who fight their way in, tend to stick around longer.

I recommend you buy some old used tools to learn on, and learn.

Work you way up through the grades of tools until your skill grows as your tool arsenal grows.

When you hit the top you design your own projects and build your own tools when you want.

And, there is room at the top, my friend.

Oh yes, there is always room at the top.

yours Scott

Re: Vintage Hand Planes *LINK*

#13

Hey guys,Scott`s back!

Bob Hackett

We missed ya buddy! We also very much missed your sage and common sense posts like the one I`m replying to here.

Let me set up a chair for ya over by the stove, pour a cup of coffee for ya and you can tell us all where ya been for so long.

Did I tell you we missed you buddy? :D