New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

Posts

Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#1

Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

Bill Tindall


When we left this discussion I remained bewildered as to the possible benefit of driving a card scraper/chisel into the saw kerf. Being in the midst of over 100 of these operation on the current set of drawers I had opportunity to see for myself.

Referring to the picture, the pins will be numbered from right to left 1,2,3.

The right pin has just been sawed (inaccurately ,but safely to the left of the line as you can see) and it is this offending piece of triangular waste that needs to be removed as efficiently as possible.

Referring to pin 3 this triangular piece of waste was attacked with a chisel with the blade parallel to the pin face and with one paring cut starting in the saw kerf all that remains of the triangular waste is the thin piece the thickness of the saw kerf. Its edge can be plainly seen in the photo. It is this material that presumably would be removed by bashing something into the saw kerf to deepen the kerf. I submit that it is not an onerous task to pare away this remaining material.

On the other hand........For pin 2 I drove a card scraper into the saw kerf, deepening it to the bottom of the tail socket baseline. What you see is what was left, almost nothing. The triangular piece sheared off at the baseline and was gone. I would probably do one paring cut to clean up this face, but someone in a hurry probably would not need to.

Conclusion: In this example driving a card scraper into the half blind/lapped dovetail saw kerf made short work of removing the triangular waste.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#2

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I told you so ... I told you so ... I told you so ... so there! :D

Nicely done Bill.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#3

Something tells me , there is going to be

roger lance

a run on stainless steel trowels.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#4

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Schtoo

Interesting. I knew it worked since I've done it before.

Now, I just use a chisel to get into that little corner.

Actually, I use two chisels. Once to hack out the bulk of the waste, another to tidy up the corners.


Yes, it's very deliberately blurry because it's the only one on the planet and I don't want to give too much away just yet.

Perhaps Derek has an idea of what it is? ;)

Stu.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#5

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Removing the little corner is a trivial operation with a chisel, probably faster than mashing in the kerf. Much was made about dovetailing Jarrah a few days ago. I had never dovetailed jarrah before, so this morning I gave it a try. I cut out three sockets (like on a drawer front) in 6 minutes and 5 seconds. For comparison, I did the same work in black walnut (Juglans nigra) in 5 minutes 40 seconds, and white pine (Pinus strobus) in 4 minutes 30 seconds. The jarrah is definitely more work because you have to take smaller bites, but it is not really difficult. It is similar in texture to some of our local hickories.

Except for the mallet (1979), the tools I used were all over 80 years old and readily available in flea markets. Unnecessary tools include fishtail, skew, and trowel chisels, card scraper, A-2, CPMVXXX, and probably more that I have forgotten.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Stephen Shepherd

Also if you cut below your base line an inch or so on the inside back of the drawer front, the issue goes away. The kerf is trivial.

Stephen

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#7

News flash...Warren and I finally agree

Bill Tindall

You stated...."Removing the little corner is a trivial operation with a chisel". That is what I thought based upon a few dozen drawers of experience, and still think so too. I'm comforted someone agrees. Most didn't and that suggested room for improvement, or at least a trial to see for myself.

The card scraper certainly worked, better than I had imagined. But, it is hard to improve on something that isn't significant to begin with. Nor, have I ever seen a need for a skew chisel. However, when I went to 14 degrees on dovetails those last few fibers in the corner became more problematic to disengage. The marking knife severed them handily, thereby making it a multitasker. But I am returning to 10 degrees so that issue becomes irrelevant.

For those that employ a card scraper or equivalent, I think a putty knife would be the tool of choice as it comes with a handle. I was imagining that eventually I could get a nasty cut off the card scraper whilst whacking it.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#8

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yes, it's very deliberately blurry because it's the only one on the planet and I don't want to give too much away just yet.

Perhaps Derek has an idea of what it is?

Of course I know, Stu. But am I allowed to say ... ?

I have a fishtail I made from an old chisel.


I also have a rather pretty one from Blue Spruce.


Both work really well at cleaning out the corners, and I prefer these to skew chisels.

The other "tool" that is exceptional for this task is the marking knife by Chris Vesper. This is a true "multitasking" knife.


It is a very heavy duty marking knife, and the ends have what amounts to a double skew for working into the corners of dovetails ...


Chris now has an undated model with a shortened handle. I have tried this and prefer it for balance. It snuggles into the palm and is very comfortable and controllable ...


Look out for Chris at WIA.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#9

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

Schtoo

Well, they're dovetail chisels. Bachi-nomi. Just no mention of who made them. Please.

(That's gotta be the worst secret known to mankind, but as long as no names are mentioned, it's not official, right?)

You might find one in your mail box for evaluation soon. ;)

Just not that one. I'm vain enough that I want to be able to say "I own the originals".

They're nice to use. Maybe no faster, but certainly less fatiguing and do a cleaner job of it. A few particular little details is all that there is in it.

Of course, they're not for everyone.

But I like them.

Stu.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#10

WHAT?!

Bob Hackett

No bronze or stone chisels left in your inventory Warren? :D

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#11

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

TomD

"Removing the little corner is a trivial operation with a chisel,"

First, since a lot of people identify this operation with Frid, I think the majority of people probably agree with you, if he is the "only one" traditionally doing it.

That said, I never thought is was about getting the triangle out with paring cuts, but about making it easier to get the main waste out. One doesn't hear many people suggesting the whole through dovetail business would go a lot faster if one didn't bother to saw all the way throught, made one diagonal cut as in the half blind. And half blinds are a toofer, the side is half connected (as would be the case with the throughs in my joking example) and to boot the back surface is connected.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#12

I use a 1/16" chisel

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Warren.

I pare out most of the waste, and use a 1/16" chisel (aka skewer) to get the corners.

Having said that, I've heard the card scraper being hammered in the kerf a while ago, just don't have a spare scraper that I was willing to destroy.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#13

ps: using the trimmer

Andrew F in Australia

... .... ... As you alluded to elsewhere, gallery work commonly uses the trimmer with a fence/router with a fence, as a far quicker option than any hand tool to clean out the pin and tail sockets, but routing end grain is always a scary proposition.

I find for one or two drawers, the setup time in getting the fence set accurately far exceeds the time it takes to do the job by hand.

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#14

Re: I use a 1/16" chisel

TomD

I have used a drywall or plasterer type knife. It comes from the factory in correct form, similar in function to the chisel that started this thread. No significant damage occurs to the tool in using it in this role.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#15

Re: ps: using the trimmer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... .... ... As you alluded to elsewhere, gallery work commonly uses the trimmer with a fence/router with a fence, as a far quicker option than any hand tool to clean out the pin and tail sockets, but routing end grain is always a scary proposition.

I find for one or two drawers, the setup time in getting the fence set accurately far exceeds the time it takes to do the job by hand.

Hi Eddie

About a year ago Neil Erasmus showed me how to do this. I have a 1/8" carbide bit for the job. I decided to try it out on the third drawer - just enough to remove the bulk of the pin waste, and then finish with chisels. Worked like a charm! I will post pictures from the next drawer, which I will get to tomorrow.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#16

Tried a 1/16" chisel....I like it

Bill Tindall

For these 14 degree perky dovetails the corner is more a problem than with the less angle affairs I normally use. Indeed, the tiny chisel severs that pesky tuft of fibers that often remains in the corner.

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revisited

#17

Re: Half Blind/Lapped dovetail waste removal revis

TomD

Derk. For that kind of cut I often use a shortened saw blade. I have a few small segments I use as rulers, rasps, and corner extractors.