New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

Posts

Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#1

Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

Bill Tindall

As previously reported my drawers have been drifting across the Atlantic in terms of construction. For the most part I am retreating back to Colonial America. Depending on drawer size for a chest of drawers (not a spice box) something in the range of 7/16 to 1/2" looks about right and seems sufficiently robust for poplar, a conclusion reached about 300 years ago in America. 3/8" looks too frail in a softwood, and I expect it will turn out to be over time for a large drawer.

As far as dovetail size I tried something approaching traditional English size and I am retreating back to more typical American sizes. Skinny pins just seem too weak and a nuisance to deal with. They are hard to mark and inconvenient to apply glue to and for my patience too much care needs to be used to keep from shearing them off while removing waste in half blinds. I can imagine that disassembling a piece for repair with skinny pins is also problematic. I don't strive to make a fashion statement inside a drawer so their perky looks is not advantageous in my case, while I can appreciate this advantage in studio furniture.

They are forgiving. No matter the fit, skinny pins act like nails driven into the tails. No doubt this was an advantage in production shops. But, I will muddle on with larger ones.

I still think slips have merit on a large drawer and making them by the yard and installing them (Ian) as others have suggested is convenient.

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

Moses Yoder

I vote Bill Tindall for President based on this post alone. It is the most common sense I have ever seen contained in one post.

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#3

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

roger lance

Bill....one aspect of the discussions that we were having with Derek and others regarding London dovetails and very thin sides to drawers/slips that was not discussed....and, in my mind, very important....is that drawers with super thin pins and very thin sides are only appropriate on certain specific types of furniture and would be completely inappropriate on other pieces....such construction would be correct for Queen Ann (et al), but would be wrong for Shaker or Arts & Crafts....such design elements do not have universal application....the furniture styles and types that evolved in the colonies are as valid as any other....whether they appeal to certain arbiters of taste or not.

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#4

building philosophy

Bill Tindall

"super thin pins and very thin sides are only appropriate "...by this statement I presume you to mean that this style was the fashion for a period and that this or that style of dovetails would look most appropriate in this or that period. That is to say the dovetail is dictated by fashion and not some other factor.?.

I do appreciate that some builders strive for period authenticity, something I admire but don't subscribe to. It is not an arrogant "I don't give a damn" about fashion sort of thing with me. It simply doesn't cross my mind while building. For example, I put a Krenov catch in a Federal cabinet because I wanted to try one and I thought it had the potential of working better for the application than an authentic period alternative. Once I get inside a piece where it doesn't readily show I strive for durability, tempered by my building skills, and sometimes by my curiosity to try something new. When I finally settle on a dovetail size it will be found in every drawer I make from then on. (Well probably not as I seem driven to keep trying something new, as I did skinny dovetails)

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#6

Re: building philosophy

roger lance

what I meant is what I said....very thin pins work on certain pieces but are not universal in their application as Derek has noted by going to a wider pin for his campaign/military chests as these chests lived a life in sometimes harsh conditions and more rugged construction (thicker/wider pins) seemed appropriate....etc...etc.

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#7

Re: building philosophy

TomD

Something other than fashion is just a fashion also, to state the obvious. I think it's good to design your own way, and make your own judgements. That said the field of design was well developed, and I don't like just being ignorant of the issues involved, though for the most part that's where I am when it comes to classical proportions, etc...

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#8

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

bugbear

As far as dovetail size I tried something approaching traditional English size

I think your main post is about (what we call) London dovetails, the ones with only a saw kerf size at their apex.

England is perfectly well supplied with dovetails larger than this. London dovetails are unusual, and mainly seen in high end, mahogany pieces.

BugBear

Re: Skinny dovetails.....rejected.

#9

thanks for clarification

Bill Tindall

The only English furniture I get to see is what is in two shops that import it. It is either well made mahogany/white oak "old" furniture or reproductions of old pieces. Apparently there are still shops or small factories there that are turning out reproductions of Period styles for sale in US shops, and I suppose elsewhere. The quality of the new furniture is outstanding.