Skinny dovetails.....rejected.
Bill Tindall
As previously reported my drawers have been drifting across the Atlantic in terms of construction. For the most part I am retreating back to Colonial America. Depending on drawer size for a chest of drawers (not a spice box) something in the range of 7/16 to 1/2" looks about right and seems sufficiently robust for poplar, a conclusion reached about 300 years ago in America. 3/8" looks too frail in a softwood, and I expect it will turn out to be over time for a large drawer.
As far as dovetail size I tried something approaching traditional English size and I am retreating back to more typical American sizes. Skinny pins just seem too weak and a nuisance to deal with. They are hard to mark and inconvenient to apply glue to and for my patience too much care needs to be used to keep from shearing them off while removing waste in half blinds. I can imagine that disassembling a piece for repair with skinny pins is also problematic. I don't strive to make a fashion statement inside a drawer so their perky looks is not advantageous in my case, while I can appreciate this advantage in studio furniture.
They are forgiving. No matter the fit, skinny pins act like nails driven into the tails. No doubt this was an advantage in production shops. But, I will muddle on with larger ones.
I still think slips have merit on a large drawer and making them by the yard and installing them (Ian) as others have suggested is convenient.



