New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

Posts

dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#1

dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

roger lance

In a recent thread, the subject of using dust panels in a multi-level drawer chest was raised....the idea being that dust panels are a sign of quality and should be used by a forum member (who already makes very high quality items). In the past, I've installed dust panels below the bottom drawer only as I saw this location to be the most likely place for dust to enter the case as the bottom of the case is close to the floor where dust can accumulate especially under a chest. Also, I was reluctant to place dust panels between drawers as access to those drawers was then limited and if a drawer became stuck or drawer contents somehow became wedged, the only recourse would be to remove the back of the case and try to fix the problem that way. So, I'm asking for your opinion/insights on the use of dust panels through out the piece...between every drawer or not...so what say you ??

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#2

waste of lumber and time

Bill Tindall

and they just add weight to an already heavy piece and serve no useful function. A chest of drawers weighs a ton anyway if made from solid wood.

In the day, drawers had locks. The dust panel prevented access to a locked drawer from the drawer above it. Hardly a useful feature now days. But if Period authenticity is desired then their addition could be justified.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#3

Well, I was always a little puzzled by

roger lance

the need to encapsulate each drawer to fight dust (but I was never the housekeeper of the year either)....so they are historically more a "security" panel than a dust panel...interesting...well, I'm really just developing my own style of furniture making as opposed to rigid reproduction of classics...so I'll continue to enclose the case on the bottom with a dust panel and maintain the ability to get at the other drawers (except the top drawer) from above...thanks for the reply Bill.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#4

Re: Well, I was always a little puzzled by

Charles

Central heating and air conditioning which help filter dust, carpet that holds dust, vacuums and dust mops that do a better job of picking up dust, not heating with coal, coke, or wood - lots of things have obviated the need for dust panels these days. Make no mistake, though, there was a time when they were a necessity from a cleanliness standpoint and the aforementioned security standpoint when one wasn't always sure about the honesty of household staff. Pieces with the 'full treatment' - dust panels and other niceties were found in fine homes and estates when clothing and table linen were valuable items subject to theft.

Most robbers these days wouldn't dream of stealing the fine linen tablecloths.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#5

How.....

Bill Tindall

would a "dust panel" prevent dust from entering the drawer and settling upon its contents? Gravity is going to more or less seal the bottom edge of the drawer to the drawer blade such that entry there is minimal compared to the crack at the top of the drawer where the "dust panel" has no effect. Hence, I would think that the major amount of dust intrusion will be through the top crack and down upon what lies within, unencumbered by the panel above or below.?.

While we call these things "dust panels" I don't think they have anything to do with dust prevention. If someone has a piece with dust panels pull out a drawer and report if there is a large accumulation of dust settled upon it.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#6

Functional to a degree

Charles

I believe they were functional. The dust, dirt, and grime came from m'lady sweeping (or the help sweeping) and from generally moving about. Dust settled on runners, kickers, etc. and the panels do help keep it off the clothing. We're not talking being hermetically sealed, but helped. It's a matter of degrees I think.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#7

Re: How.....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've seen some on dust panels, probably from wear on the drawer runners.

Although it prevents you from opening a drawer that's got something caught in it, a dust panel also prevents a piece of clothing from sticking up and getting between the drawer and runner above it. not sure how big a problem this is.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Dust Panels

Stephen Shepherd

The contents of the drawers, usually cloth, wool, linen, silk, or cotton will create a certain amount of flotsam on their own. And opening and closing the drawers create vacuum pressure that sucks dust and dirt in and share it freely in all drawers unless there is something preventing its movement. Much dustier, dirtier and more grimy back than, so anything they could do would make life better.

Stephen.

Re: dust panels...to be, or not to be...that is the to

#9

Re: Well, I was always a little puzzled by

charlie belden

Let's not forget "critters" and "vermin". Where there are humans, there will be rodents and bugs. Think multiple layers of security.