New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

More questions than answers

Posts

More questions than answers

#1

More questions than answers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Another update on the Military Chests ...

I am still working on preparing the drawer parts preparatory to dovetailing and assembly. It feels like I will never get there. 12 drawers at one time is more than I've done together before (6 was my previous record, and then the construction was Shaker).

Over the weekend I completed the slips, cut the drawer sides to length, and completed the drawer backs. The slips ...



All the parts are now done with the exception of the drawer bottoms. I have decided to make and fit these last. Usually I would fit them immediately after dovetailing the 4 sides, as it is a way of squaring the drawer. In this case, I am concerned about having too many planed boards lying around and their potential to cup. I have a jig that will ensure that the drawer is square as the glue dries. Comment?

All the parts ...


The second of three questions I throw open to the forum is about the next stage in the drawer build. Before I dovetail the drawers I need to fit the drawer handles. These are to be recessed into the drawer front, so I plan to complete the mortices first, dovetail the drawers, then attach the handles.

I researched these handles quite a bit, discovering that they were now all made in India - even the ones said to be made in the UK. I was fortunate to discover that one of the local Perth stores that specialised in brass had a few of the different versions in stock. Philip Marcou gave me some tips on what to look out for. All of these handles are cast brass, which then requires finishing. It appears that some companies flattened the tops with a belt sander, with the result that the plate were not flat but curved. There would be signoficant difficulties recessing curved plates into flat drawer fronts. Indeed, all but one of the brass handles I looked at were rounded over. I ended with this ...


However, almost all the handles are slightly wavy at the edges ...



Here is the question: Do I leave them as is, or do I straighten them (on my disk sander)? Straightening them makes it easier to fit in the drawer front, but this may alter some of the "handmade look". Opinion?

The third question relates to the dovetail design. I ran up a couple of mock fronts. I shall mention my own preferences, but it hearing yours would be helpful in firming up the best design. And, of course, you may suggest something else.

The first was simply to create an even set. I like this, but it is my second choice ...


My preference goes to a simpler, less cluttered look ...


The third version did not come out as I intended - the dovetails look a little too skinny. I thought the centre two dovetails from the second example should have been closer, but then also I made them even slimmer. I think that was a mistake. However, let me know what you think of the spacing ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: More questions than answers

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: More questions than answers

Stephen Shepherd

All of the hardware of this type that I have seen in older pieces were squared up from the castings. All edges draw-filed and some slightly back beveled [the only time I ever use this technique is on hardware] to make for a snug fit.

Stephen

Re: More questions than answers

#3

Re: More questions than answers

roger lance

Derek....First, I might try to build a drawer a night (don't know your speed or time available to you after work)....this gets it over in two weeks....might even finish one cabinet after six drawers and move it into the house to give yourself some room and preserve your sanity. Second, I would not be a happy camper with the hardware....perhaps a marine store in Perth would have hardware similar to what you are showing as it can be found on boats....I would square up the edges at least....with all the effort you are making to achieve perfection in wood, it would be nice if some company was trying to reach a high standard in metal/brass. Third, I vote for 1 or 2....not 3 (too dainty....unless you have recently become aware of an unresolved latent envy complex....sorry mate, can't help with that.

Re: More questions than answers

#4

Re: More questions than answers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

You are quite correct about the hardware. It is poor standard now that I have looked at sites that previously I was unaware of.

It is interesting that one (I!) only notices some of the subtle (not so subtle!) details when you get two alongside one another. Something about the design of the ones I have did not look right. Now I see it as the flush lift in the recess. I did not think much about this before now as the smaller nautical types are like this. However, looking at my model more closely, and at the picture below, which are forged and not cast-and-ground-flat, the pull section is quite different (i.e. rounded).


Cross posting from the Aussie website, where this comment was made:

The entire surfaces of military chests were sanded – handles, (steel) screws and all – prior to being polished. This was to ensure the furniture slid smoothly into their respective tight-fitting transport cases without snagging. The brasses exhibit quite coarse but uniform scratches from being sanded (I'm guessing 120 grit in modern parlance). I've seen them sanded to the degree where the screw slots have all but disappeared, making removal extremely difficult.

Original brasses should retain their oil/shellac varnished surfaces. Polished fittings are normally the result of exuberant housewives/maids prettying them up.

With regard the dovetails, I am returning to A, with thoughts of a very slightly thinner profile, but still substantial. I have not seen original, vintage military chests in the flesh, nor photos of the dovetails. I keep imagining slim "London" dovetails (as some refer to them), but this may be out-of-keeping.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: More questions than answers

#5

Derek....look at Lee Valley for recessed...

roger lance

pull hardware....see 00S30.21, 00S30.22, and 00S30.23.....these are stainless steel and intended for marine use originally....I think that marine store thing might work for finding brass pulls and the LV look very high quality (no surprise that)....if I stumble over any possibility, I'll forward.

Re: More questions than answers

#6

Derek....better yet go to LV and see....

roger lance

00A19.03....brass recessed pulls....high quality....you'll just have to raise your rates or not buy another plane for a time (slim chance....raise the rates)....regards from Michigan.

Re: More questions than answers

#7

Re: Derek... more choices at LV by.....

roger lance

going to hardware index, handles & pulls, chest handles, then inset handles.

Re: More questions than answers

#8

Chandlers? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Although it's hard for me to believe you couldn't find a local source - I mean, Oz IS surrounded by water - I've had great, though limited, success with Green Boat Works. Great folks, very friendly and determined to provide good service. They list only one pull of the type you're seeking - and, at that, not quite the same - but their quality seems good, based on the limited purchases I've made.

No affiliation except a satisfied customer.


http://www.greenboatstuff.com/seadogbrreha.html

Re: More questions than answers

#9

Re: Derek... more choices at LV by.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Roger

This handle issue has been a non-stop saga. Every where I have looked the quality seems to be crappy. Ironically, the ones I ended up buying appeared better finished - across the face - but the non-rounded pull section slipped under the radar. Now they will not be used as is.

A while back I received a link to a retailer in Sydney. I looked at the handles there, they looked like every version I had seen before. The price was good, but I decided against them because, on the basis of the picture, the brass appeared dubbed from sanding.


Today I looked at the same version on a UK site and ... well, you tell me if you see a difference ...


Australian price: $11.95

UK price: £12.62 (and still to add the more costly postage).

One more UK offering:


Price: £10.58

None of these made me say "I WANT it!" They are all so bloody mediocre. All exactly the same (or use the same photo).

Since I have a bunch already, I may work on them and get the look I want. Here is another from the USA that looks good at first ... I like the antique finish ... however on closer inspection they look like the ones I have, but with some rounding of the pulls ..


Price: $17.16

I looked at the Lee Valley offering. The quality looked better in the pictures ..


... but the price was too high: $39.90 (before shipping). Multiply these by 18 to get the total I need - $718 (without shipping)!

I don't want to have to spend more, but I will if I have to to get a decent quality handle. It looks like I may have to rework what I have. Any other recommendations? Anyone?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: More questions than answers

#10

Re: Derek..check that LV price again....

roger lance

I think that $39.90 price is for a pair (pr.) of pulls....so that cuts your cost in half.

Re: More questions than answers

#11

Re: Derek..check that LV price again....

GolfSteve in Calgary

Restoration House in Rockhampton was always a great place to find stuff like this. That store is worth a visit to Rockhampton ;-)

http://www.restorationhouse.com.au/products/furniture-fittings/chest-fittings1/flush-pull-polished-brass/

Doesn't appear to be great quality, but at least they use a different picture.

Re: More questions than answers

#12

Re: Chandlers?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I think that I mentioned this in an early thread - one of the limiting factors is size (length rather than width). Most of these handles are about 75mm plus in length, and this is overpowering on the small drawers. The handles chosen are 65mm long, and this is a good size for overall proportions.

I suspect that the quality of the hardware is the much the same the world over, that is, it probably comes from the same Indian factory. I know that higher quality hardware exists - for example, Philip Marcou - who now makes handplanes - used to specialise in Military furniture and told me that he used hardware made in Italy. Unfortunately, that contact has passed into time.

Before I buy from another source, I will try and refinish the handles I have. Sanding them flush is the first step. Straightening the edges/perimeter is another (as they need to sit flush with the drawer fronts). The third step will be to add a chamfer to the edges of the pulls - rounding them is too difficult, and an even bevel can look attractive. I need to make the pulls usable. In their present state they are uncomfortable to hold. The edges are sharp. None of this is difficult - just one more task before I start dovetailing.

Regards from Perth

Derek