New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

First stages in drawer building.

Posts

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#26

For drawers made by hand

Ian_N

I think I may have introduced a little bit of confusion here

My starting point was that we're primarily discussing hand tool techniques and hand tool construction methods. Not how to build a drawer using machine tools -- just to clarify, I've nothing against the grooves in the drawer front and slip being cut with a router

When you build a set of drawers by hand you should expect some small variations to creep in and plan accordingly. One way to handle variations in the location of the drawer back relative to the groove in the drawer front is to allow the slip to extend a little way below the drawer side, that way the slip can be fitted to hold the drawer base at a height that puts the upper surface of the base flush with the underside of the drawer back -- the photo Derek posted for me should show this

Then when the final fitting of the drawer is done, the slip and drawer side are guaranteed to finish up flush.

If the slip is dimenesioned first, there's some risk that when fitted the slip is not flush with the drawer bottom.

There's one other consideration -- but I'm not sure I've ever seen it -- the drawer sides could deliberately be cut short so that when completed, the drawer runs on the slip rather than the slip and side

regards from Sydney

Ian

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#27

Re: the story on cedar drawer parts

Bob Hackett

This is a story that keeps repeating itself. Eastern White Pine used to the the New England equivalent to Sequoias on the West coast till the lumber companies got to them. Try to find the once abundant White Oak of any reasonable size for timber near any NE river or coastal town.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#28

That suggestion will be employed shortly, thanks

Bill Tindall

"One way to handle variations in the location of the drawer back relative to the groove in the drawer front is to allow the slip to extend a little way below the drawer side, that way the slip can be fitted to hold the drawer base at a height that puts the upper surface of the base flush with the underside of the drawer back" ........... In fact this may be as good an argument to use slips as all the others. The "small variations" Ian speaks of certainly creep into my drawers and a back that sags even 1/32 below the side groove won't let the bottom slip in.

This morning I am starting on the 7 drawers for a chest of drawers. Life is complicated by the fact my drawers are somewhere "midAtlantic" between American and England. I'm not ready to risk a 3/8" softwood drawer side.

The tenon on the Richard version of a slip certainly solves the alignment problem at the front but at the "expense" of making the tenon. I am not fond of making tenons, maybe because I don't have an efficient and reliable way to do it. As an alternative I will just temporarily slip a small square of wood the thickness of the drawer bottom into each front corner to align the slip with the front groove whilst gluing the slip.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#29

Re: That suggestion will be employed shortly, than

Ian_N

The tenon on the Richard version of a slip certainly solves the alignment problem at the front but at the "expense" of making the tenon. I am not fond of making tenons, maybe because I don't have an efficient and reliable way to do it. As an alternative I will just temporarily slip a small square of wood the thickness of the drawer bottom into each front corner to align the slip with the front groove whilst gluing the slip.

Bill, that's how I aligned the slips in the drawer that Derek that posted a picture of for me

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#30

Re: for the screw

wilbur

Got it, thanks. Do you have two screws holding the bottom of that drawer? From the picture, the notch seems pretty close to the side, or the drawer is narrower than I think.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#31

Re: for the screw

Ian in Sydney

There's two screws

after drilling the clearance hole, and counter sinking for the screw head, I cut the slot and used a chisel to champher the edges

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#32

Re: I have the result , yet......

Sgian Dubh

Bill, it's not the case that all British made drawers of the 18th and 19th century used oak for the sides and back. I've seen many a drawer of that era where, for example, pine was used, but this tended to be in lesser pieces rather than the top notch stuff. Slainte.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#33

Question

Bill Tindall

Our antique dealers that troll your country side for merchandise must be leaving the pine behind.

When pine is used for a drawer side will it be made any thicker than if oak had been used?

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#34

Re: Question

Sgian Dubh

Ah, there's one of those yes and no answers on that Bill. For a typically sized chest of drawers knocked out in one of the many somewhat lesser cabinet shops of that period, and as far as I can tell (anecdotally only therefore) most of the pine drawer material was around 10 mm (3/8") thick, but some was a little thicker, and some a little thinner. In most cases a groove was worked in the side to carry the drawer bottom, as is customary in the US.

Usually, as I recall, the drawer side bottom edges were reinforced with a slip of sorts. This 'slip' was usually a bit of wood glued in the corner (rebate) formed between the bottom of the side and underside of the drawer bottom.

Moving on slightly from the topic, and pertaining to nothing relevant really, I have some images on file of a chest of drawers reputed to have some historical significance-- I can't recall what now. Anyway, it was really (in my opinion) a piece of poorly made junk and we eventually put it in the skip (dumpster) a couple of years ago. I got some close ups of the drawer construction which was 4th quality mahogany sides 3/8" thick, rough looking oak backs, mahogany veneered pine fronts with 'slips' as I described above, and pine boards for the drawer bottom; and the carcase of pine with through corner dovetails veneered with mahogany, inlays, ovals, and the like.

I think my point is that there was a lot of lesser quality and rubbish furniture produced in the UK in those busy little sweatshops we used to have back in the 1800s and before. I admire the construction of high quality furniture of any period from any geographical location, but it seems to me there's always been a lot of iffy stuff put together for a low price, stuff best forgotten, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#35

Re: Question on side thickness

Charles

Certainly economy of stock if one re-saws to make thinner sides. Certainly not economical if thicker stock is planed down leaving a quarter inch or more on the shop floor as shavings.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#36

On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

Using thinner sides to save wood is only economical if there is not a subsequent labour cost penalty.

On the other hand ... I was conversing on the Australian forum with an ex-UK furniture restorer who knows his period construction. He made the comment that slips were from the "machine age". "First and foremost, slips are downright ugly (as are muntins), they're synonymous with cheap work (as are muntins), they're unnecessary and they encroach on drawer space.... With the homogenisation of furniture during the industrial revolution, drawer slips simply made it easier to construct drawers – the sides required no further work than dovetailing. The slips could be made by the yard from virtual waste and sapwood and drawer bottoms could be slipped into them with no handwork required".

"I dovetail the drawer sides on. The drawer bottoms are nailed into rebates in the drawer sides and then the runners are glued to the underside of the bottoms/sides .... That was the standard method in England too until about 1695 when the first runners appeared".

I hope Richard sees post this to comment.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#37

Re: On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Pam Niedermayer

So, how were drawers made before 1695? And muntins are ugly? What was used instead?

Pam

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#38

Re: On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

Drawer bottoms of 1/4" thickness are considered sufficient to forego a muntin. 3/8" thick bottoms are seen to be overkill. Unless rebated, muntins break up a flat surface and use up available space.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#39

OK, thanks.


Re: First stages in drawer building.

#40

Re: On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Sgian Dubh

I believe your Oz based correspondent is largely correct, although I think he might be about 70 or 80 years early regarding the first appearance of slips: I think they really started to appear about 1770 or 1780, and once they'd appeared on the scene the method became the norm in better work. The slips were a response to the fashion of slimmer sides because earlier practice had generally been a thicker side (possibly 3/8"- 1/2") with a bottom rebate into which the drawer bottom was nailed and a wider fillet glued below as your man describes. Slimmer drawer sides (1/4" or 5/16") didn't leave much room for either a groove or a rebate into which the bottom could be fixed, and with the by then common practice of running the long grain of the drawer bottom side to side the makers had begun to realise that some allowance was needed for expansion and contraction, hence a groove in either the drawer side (if thick enough) or a slip with a groove.

What he may have forgotten to mention is that (if I remember it right) it was also quite common even up to about 1730'ish to run the grain of the drawer bottom front to back, although by that time I think most drawer bottoms had the long grain running side to side. I've seen quite a few drawers from the Walnut period with front to back splits in the drawer bottom because being nailed in at either side restricted their ability to move. On the other hand it's remarkable that quite a few survived unsplit up to modern times, but generally the glued in fillets are shot, the heads of the nails holding the drawer bottom in place are exposed, and there are deep grooves from the nail heads in the carcase runners, as well as all sorts of wear and grooves on the underside of the drawer bottom. In my earlier days I used to fix a few of these things, and sometimes there was a lot of work and a lot of replacement wood scabbed in all over the damn place, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#41

Re: On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Sgian Dubh

I perhaps should have mentioned that instead of fixing the drawer bottom into a rebate with nails, it was also quite common to see drawer bottoms nailed directly to the bottom edges of the drawer sides, ie, with no rebate, even up to the late 1600s and early 1700s. It was quite normal up to about this point for drawer bottom long grain to run front to back. (If I remember it right, up to about 1650 or so, it was the norm for the grain direction to run this way.) Adding a fillet glued on under the drawer bottom didn't cause problems in terms of cross grain mis-matches because the grain direction was the same. What you saw when looking at the drawer side was two glue lines; one between the drawer bottom and the drawer side, and one btween the drawer bottom and the fillet. Slainte.

Re: First stages in drawer building.

#42

Re: On side thickness ... and a little more ...

Charles

Half inch material would have been available during the time period you're considering.