Not trying to beat a dead horse
North of the Border
but I am always suspicious when people generalize that statistics are lies or not trustworthy whenever they see one that is not consistent with their beliefs.
I finally tracked down the article that Pam quoted about the % of Made in China thing. After reading the original article (http://articles.latimes.com/2011/aug/13/business/la-fi-made-in-china-20110813), I am more convinced that the statistics have not been distorted or misquoted by NYT because the explanations are very clear and simple and I quote: "One word: services. Services, which account for about two-thirds of spending, are mainly produced locally. Your dry cleaner, accountant, mechanic and manicurist most likely are right in your neighborhood."
Those who think the 2.7% figure doesn't seem right are evaluating the % based on their perceptions and that's normal. As consumers, we form our views and conclusions based on what we can see, hear and touch. All the service data are less obvious to us than the clothes we put on or the tools (Made in China) we hold in our hands.
The report concludes:"On average, of every dollar spent on an item labeled 'Made in China,' 55 cents goes for services produced in the United States."
Anyone who wants to dispute this report or the data quoted there should present their arguments with facts or another published set of statistics, but not a general statement or accusation like " The author has some hidden agenda," or "They've done it before," or "All papers do that."
I had done and published research and academic reports based on the use of statistics and sound methodology. When people simply brush off any statistics they see but don't like as distortions or so, I invite them to prove their case so we can set the record and author(s) straight. In my belief, when those accusations are left unchallenged, sometimes they can be taken as accepted facts.And an unjust may have been done -- in this case to NYT. (Note: I am not a subscriber or a regular reader of NYT.)