New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Stark Contrast

Posts

Re: Stark Contrast

#26

Re: Stark Contrast

Phil Joines

That's as it may be but I look at the country of origin for just about everything I buy and about half says China. Have you looked at processed food lately? A lot of it's from China and India. Clothing is mostly from China and Indonesia. I don't want to run this any farther but it really burns me up.

Re: Stark Contrast

#27

Re: Stark Contrast

Pam Niedermayer

That's as it may be but I look at the country of origin for just about everything I buy and about half says China. Have you looked at processed food lately? A lot of it's from China and India. Clothing is mostly from China and Indonesia.

Not really, but the only processed food I buy is organic, the only clothes are cotton and wool from Lands End on sale (these often come from other countries, usually South America or the middle east). I refuse to eat Frankenfoods, even if it does cost us more than we can afford. We just have to give up other things.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#28

Re: Devil's advocate

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, except the NYTimes is not just a favorite home town paper, it's a paper of record with a huge staff of excellent business writers. Now they could have made a mistake or two, thus my gift of double, but still.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#29

Moses Yoder

Re: Devil's advocate

Moses Yoder

You said." b At another forum, most of the users who responded to a question about the products seemed to be happy about what they had bought from Harbor Freight "

I would propose that there are several reasons for this. One is that most of the people posting on internet forums are less than 35 years old and don't really know the difference between a good tool and a bad tool. Reason #2 is that noone wants to admit they spent money foolishly, so of course they are going to talk about how great their tool is and how little it cost. Next I suppose someone is going to say you can buy a cheap Asian bench plane knock off for $15 and it is just as good as a hand made in Canada Sauer & Stiener infill plane. If they do, do you think I will believe them?

Re: Stark Contrast

#30

A further point

John in NM

The rare tool I purchase at Harbor Fill has lower expectations in my mind, so it is a bit easier to end up being pleasantly surprised that the thing lasts through the job for which it was purchased and perhaps a few more. From what I've seen, the Chinese will make good stuff if you pay them to do so. My beef with places like HF is that they seem to ascribe to the PT Barnum school of marketing.

Re: Stark Contrast

#31

Re:HF review list

North of the Border

I can't find any info. that supports or refutes your guess that those who go on the Internet Forum are under 35. My bet is the average age of the people on a particular forum would depend on the type and nature of the forum as well as the topic of the discussion. On the forum thread that I mentioned, those who do show their pictures all appear to be in their 50s and 60s. Of course those may not be their portraits and even if they're, it's not statistically enough because the majority do not reveal their appearances.

But just as I wouldn't say NYT uses distorted statistics unless I see or find data to the contrary, I can't say if any of the reasons you have given are indeed the reasons why those respondents reported their happiness with their purchases at HF. Your guess is just as good as mine or any other person's.

There's a site (or there may be more) that shares info. on HF goods: http://hfreviews.com/reviews.php and anyone who thinks HF sells junk goods only may be missing something that many of its customers don't.

As I said in my last post, for most products, it's really product-dependent rather than origin-dependent when it comes to whether a deal is good or bad. Even Lee Valley Tools reputed for its service and products has its (much smaller) share of dissatisfied customers, at last, based on one service quality monitoring/review site. No companies can please all customers.

I am not a keen customer of HF (partly because it doesn't have any store in Canada) but I hold an open mind (and wallet) on this company. The fact that it's attracting so many new customers can't be brushed off by a broad stroke that its customers can't tell a bad tool from a good one.

As for telling an Asian plane from a collector's kind of plane, I think no informed drivers climbing into a new Kia would tell people that they have got a Mercedes Benz baby for just 1/5 of its price. Most people still have common sense in their genes.

I fully understand why some people advocate and insist on buying Made In [fill in the names of the origins] only goods. They have their good reasons and it's their money. As a general point, I do think those who do so should not offer the impression that any other way of buying would necessarily result in getting inferior products.

Re: Stark Contrast

#32

Perspective is everything

Bob Hackett

I would suggest that anyone who feels that HF offers quality tools has no idea what a quality tool really is.

IMO that would be like saying Wal-mart furniture made from chipboard is quality furniture. It may be entirely appropriate furniture for someone intending to live someplace for a couple of months and then leave all their furniture behind or maybe to furnish an apartment you plan to rent to a pack of party animals but it is FAR from QUALITY anything unless you are speaking about LOW quality disposable goods.

There is a long list of reasons not to buy goods from China beginning with the use of inapproriate and often even toxic materials and ending with the simple fact that every dollar spent on Chinese goods supports a repressive Communist regime that is openly focused on wiping democracy (and our way of life) from the face of the earth. Just two glaring yet simple reasons that people seem to be in denial about both here and everywhere else they go to get information or goods. Think about what your dollars support once they leave your hand folks.

That is as far as I`m going to skate out into thin ice for today.

Re: Stark Contrast

#33

Re: Perspective is everything - nothing

North of the Border

new in the reasons you offer ("There is a long list of reasons not to buy goods from China...") and many before you have listed them -- many times in various forums. (For a similar reasoning or so, some Americans don't want "dirty" oil from Canada even though the very same Americans don't say much about the oil imported from brutal or dictatorship regimes -- in places where women may not be allowed to show their faces or even drive. Do they enjoy democracy as we know it? I doubt it.)

I wouldn't say you're wrong on that because that's your perspective. All buyers are free to have their take and spend money as and where they like.

Re: Stark Contrast

#34

Re:HF review list - not impressed...

John in NM

As I said before, one has a lower expectation when buying stuff that is so obviously really, really cheap - and thus the reviews are chock full of phrases like "Good bang for the buck for occasional use" or my favorite "It did the job and even though it sounds like a coffee can full of rocks".

One of my favorite HF tools was a cast iron sledge hammer. Yes, cast iron. The mind boggles.

The other reason these reviews don't carry a lot of weight with me is that people write those reviews when they've just bought some cheap junky tool at HF for a single use application and write a glowing review, flush with the pleasant surprise that their crummy grinder actually survived the workout of a day or two's project. If they write the same review after a year of those workouts I might consider taking their impressions seriously. I have a HF concrete mixer that is in this category - bought for a single use and still going, but definitely not worth more than the $200 it cost.

I think HF is fine for people to buy tools that they will use maybe once a year for a few minutes (cast iron hammers most definitely excluded). They might get a lifetime's use under these circumstances, and then it would be an ok deal if you ignore the irritation of using crappy tools (that sound like a coffee can full of rocks). If you have to buy more than a few replacements though, it is a false economy. I would rather pay 5 to 10 times the price if I know the tool will last 5 to 10 times longer, and though there are exceptions, in many cases this is true or even a conservative estimation.

Add in the truly useless junk that HF sells, like the cast iron hammer, or any of their casters, and the equation shifts drastically into the realm of a really bad place to shop. Look beyond the excitement of how really amazingly cheap this crap is, and you may learn to see it as crap that someone is actually suggesting you fork over hard earned cash for. I can sell you crap even cheaper than HF does, but mine won't come with the illusion of being useful - only genuinely pure, unadulterated crap is available here :D (perhaps this post is a free sample :D )

Re: Stark Contrast

#35

Re:HF review list - not impressed...

TomD

I Only visited HF once, but I was pretty happy with the stuff I got. One thing I sold at a profit, a milling machine, and another, a piner, I still haven`t taken out of the box. I don`t think I am likely to have another go at HF because the quality and confidence I have in HF is higher than the border services. What I find noteworthy about HF is how variable their stuff is. Like some of their machine tools are useable, There is a blog about a real machinist who bought one of their combo machines and worked with it and made some alterations, he seemed to get a lot of value out of it. One telling coment he made about it is that every motorcylce repair shop in asia has one of these things in the back. Another product I have heard good things about is the inverter stick welder they sell. There is a guy on youtube who has dozens of videos about that tool. Souded like a useful product. I have serious welders, but I wouldn`t mind a unit like that stashed at the cottage. But there is also lots of stuff that just falls appart on unpacking or after a few uses, or where the stuff they copied is the wrong stuff, at least according to me. Maybe one comon thread it that at least the metal guys can fix some of the stuff. To them a screw or handle here or there that blows, is no problem, so long as they can get what they need out of the machine.

Re: Stark Contrast

#36

Re: Devil's advocate

TomD

I`d have to agree that the NYT is probably not the first paper to pick appart over low standards. The newspaper of record thing seems a suitably vague kind of accolade. But it comes down to the same thing in the end, if they are really reporting they are getting the stats from somewhere, and most stats these days are being managed by someone. Though as you say it may not change the outcome in this case.

Re: Stark Contrast

#37

Not trying to beat a dead horse

North of the Border

but I am always suspicious when people generalize that statistics are lies or not trustworthy whenever they see one that is not consistent with their beliefs.

I finally tracked down the article that Pam quoted about the % of Made in China thing. After reading the original article (http://articles.latimes.com/2011/aug/13/business/la-fi-made-in-china-20110813), I am more convinced that the statistics have not been distorted or misquoted by NYT because the explanations are very clear and simple and I quote: "One word: services. Services, which account for about two-thirds of spending, are mainly produced locally. Your dry cleaner, accountant, mechanic and manicurist most likely are right in your neighborhood."

Those who think the 2.7% figure doesn't seem right are evaluating the % based on their perceptions and that's normal. As consumers, we form our views and conclusions based on what we can see, hear and touch. All the service data are less obvious to us than the clothes we put on or the tools (Made in China) we hold in our hands.

The report concludes:"On average, of every dollar spent on an item labeled 'Made in China,' 55 cents goes for services produced in the United States."

Anyone who wants to dispute this report or the data quoted there should present their arguments with facts or another published set of statistics, but not a general statement or accusation like " The author has some hidden agenda," or "They've done it before," or "All papers do that."

I had done and published research and academic reports based on the use of statistics and sound methodology. When people simply brush off any statistics they see but don't like as distortions or so, I invite them to prove their case so we can set the record and author(s) straight. In my belief, when those accusations are left unchallenged, sometimes they can be taken as accepted facts.And an unjust may have been done -- in this case to NYT. (Note: I am not a subscriber or a regular reader of NYT.)

Re: Stark Contrast

#38

Moses Yoder

Re:HF review list - not impressed...

Moses Yoder

I have horse manure, aged, that I will sell for a dollar for every ten pounds, plus shipping. Doesn't that sound like it beats Harbor Freight prices?

Re: Stark Contrast

#39

Re: Not trying to beat a dead horse

TomD

Services, in one word would be sorta the kind of thing I am thinking of. Selecting a set that includes stuff nobody expects to be part of the China trade figures, like the "value" of at home work by mothers and caregivers, why don't we throw that in, must cost out at trillions and make the china numbers look better to boot. That services quote is a classic, sure the massive services industry is Bob the barber. Nobody ever offshored a service, like got your chest x-ray read in India. Did NYT just cut that out, or did they dig deep enough to find out how much of the stuff in services is sent offshore.

I would also point out that you start out with a straw man yourself. You start out talking about people who call stats lies, a word only you used in the thread. But if you want to go there, I would draw your attention to numerous scandals involving deceit. Enron accounting; the change in the research departments at dealers was a huge scandal when people understood their role in the tech bubble; the ratings agencies in the whole CDO thing. And these are the people with professional and legal responsibilities. Let alone those who have only themselves to live with. Keep in mind that all the papers of record ran these people's stories and numbers for decades. They penetrated a lot more than the newspapers. Their completely fictional worlds heavily influenced government policy.

I actually share your preference to believe the best of people. My default position is to assume I am being told the truth. A truth is though, that smart people can sell their numbers and sleep well at night. It is stupid people who are dishonest. They simply lack the imagination to take the argument where it needs to go, while smart people can navigate into deeper waters.

Re: Stark Contrast

#40

Zombie horse

Bob Hackett

Looks like you`re attempting to ride yet another dead horse Thom. Keep this up and we`ll stop inviting you to the wakes of our equestrian companions.

Put the saddle back in the barn now.This one`s long gone,nothing to see here,move along folks. :)

Re: Stark Contrast

#41

May be a dead horse but it deserves to be defended

North of the Border

"Lies, damned lies, and statistics," that was what I referred to in my earlier post. I didn't and do not say or consider anything in the quoted NYT article a lie.

Your reference to the Enron scandal etc. is exactly what I've pointed out: any generalizations based on past incidents in and of themselves are not sufficient justifications for saying or concluding that NYT's article offers anything that is not in order. Statistics or data have been and will continue to be abused or misused but it doesn't mean every statistic we see (and don't like) is necessarily the result of manipulations.

Re: Stark Contrast

#42

Defending the honor of dead horses

Bob Hackett

You Canadians are such gentlemen.

I doff my chapeau (with a gallant flourish) to you all. :)

Re: Stark Contrast

#43

Re: Zombie horse

TomD

I suspect it's till the same horse you are defending, any chance the name is Diamond? :)